Supernatural: Villains WW Game Thread

[bluestoat]

---

Members do not see this ad.

I have never been in a game with unlimited vigs and wasn't going to vote you but then I was an idiot

 

[bluestoat]

Deciding who to resurrect-- or to yeet if they come back to life-- is the only one that comes to mind.

So that tin foil you had earlier has come back to my mind in a big way

 

[AceHydro]

I'm wondering if there's a detail we haven't gotten to of why the affiliations/roles aren't revealed in a cannibal shot. but I'm thinking we either have multiple rezzers or someone with unlimited rezzes to go with Alley's unlimited shots.

 

[vetschoolsletmeinplease]

Ok vision is.... kinda back and time to figure out what the heck went down after 2:50 today

 

[bluestoat]

"Dead! Haha! Oh shoot that was a good one. Um, quick, revive!"

Actually that might be a lot but it's the kind of a lot you love to see. I'm here for it.

God ducking darnit Ace just reacted to this and reminded me of it.

That would have been a thing of chaotic beauty and I am so irate with myself

 

[vetschoolsletmeinplease]

I feel like im at the scene of a crime
if this gets too long I'll spoiler it

Day 1: Trouble at the Bunker Vote Tally (#282)

alley (1) - AM

so as of like 4:30 PM was the only vote on alley so I'm really curious to see how this progresses. RN the only other people who i think are suspicious of her are z and samac?
*EDITED BC i don't know how to read a time

Can you get some details from Pleasey because I literally just waffled about the Ace thing and if Zenge, Samac, AND Please are awkward about Ace then I'ma wanna listen.

sorry about that yall it was rough
on my ace vote, it was p201 that felt like a summary of what I and stoat had just said in an essay way (like a put it in your own words way) and it rubbed me wrong. but unfortunately that was literally all it was, i just wanted to put something down bc i couldn't remember if no-voting had consequences and i didn't wanna walk time through looking for that

There's some inconsistencies between posts that I'm not liking.

this feels easy enough to just say, curious to see if PSV can back it up w specifics

hi tim, can you ask for an expansion on this? we've got this:

a yeet because my attempt at a joke didn't get the vibe of everyone, and now you not giving much. I'd love to defend myself, but out of two votes all i can say is sorry it was a joke..

it wasn't that and i also forgot this was your second game. my b. see reasoning above

Well I was expecting much more of a dramatic response to my vote on Samac and got almost nothing. Makes me want to stick with my vote for this cycle.

is this saying you don't think wolf!Samac fights back as hard as village?

Reads so far just from skimming. Will have to do a deep dive tomorrow.

Zenge: Hard claims seer. Claims he’s lock clear because of this. Seers are tricky because wolves have claimed this before. This does not land him in my village pile. Why pull that card so early in the game? Lol at him saying we need to read 11 players instead of 12 now. Also we aren’t supposed to role reveal. Blunder on his part maybe? After much tinfoil, something is definitely up with Zenge’s reveal. So he copy pasted from MU.


Kdswg: Weird reaction to toat thinking zenge is some chaotic 3p. Wolf looking for an easy yeet? Confused newbie? Something up with them and toat regarding previous D1 yeets idk.

AM: Has an ok first response to Zenge’s post. HEr questioning seems solid

Samac: Suggesting that AM yeet me. I get it, but also sideye it. Yeets Ace saying their post asking wolves to reveal themselves feels weird. Searching for a good yeet perhaps? Feels weird throwing zenge in the village pile when we don’t know what we’re dealing with yet. Keeps @Ing me. Misses me or just itching for a nice yeet vote?

Bluestoat: Newbie! Thinks Kdwsg is looking for an easy yeet. Understandably thinks kdswg’s yeet on them is weak. Thinks kdwsg is salt voting them.

PSVet: Another newbie! Pinged by Samac. Not really sure why. Filling up the thread with supernatural stuff instead of game stuff so far. Might be that old wolf trick of making sure you talk the most on the thread.

Alley: Reads kinda meh so far. Provides good analysis and reads. I would have never thought to check MU for zenge’s post. Kinda gives me sus vibes.


Ace: Why ask about conditions for rezzing someone so early in the game? Especially since no-one had died yet.

Just: There’s a sense of innocence in them believing zenge. Willing to believe it’s more newbie village than coached wolf.

hmmmm where do i fall?

Zenge is definitely not village.

interesting take

Unyeet stoat
Yeet alley

why

ok that wasn't too long

i leave it feeling the worst about kdswg and psv

 

[AceHydro]

sorry about that yall it was rough
on my ace vote, it was p201 that felt like a summary of what I and stoat had just said in an essay way (like a put it in your own words way) and it rubbed me wrong. but unfortunately that was literally all it was, i just wanted to put something down bc i couldn't remember if no-voting had consequences and i didn't wanna walk time through looking for that

it wasn't that and i also forgot this was your second game. my b. see reasoning above

Thanks for your explanation. No hard feelings

 

[samac]

I feel like im at the scene of a crime
if this gets too long I'll spoiler it

so as of like 4:30 PM was the only vote on alley so I'm really curious to see how this progresses. RN the only other people who i think are suspicious of her are z and samac?
*EDITED BC i don't know how to read a time


sorry about that yall it was rough
on my ace vote, it was p201 that felt like a summary of what I and stoat had just said in an essay way (like a put it in your own words way) and it rubbed me wrong. but unfortunately that was literally all it was, i just wanted to put something down bc i couldn't remember if no-voting had consequences and i didn't wanna walk time through looking for that


this feels easy enough to just say, curious to see if PSV can back it up w specifics


it wasn't that and i also forgot this was your second game. my b. see reasoning above


is this saying you don't think wolf!Samac fights back as hard as village?


hmmmm where do i fall?

interesting take

why

ok that wasn't too long

i leave it feeling the worst about kdswg and psv

I wasn’t into the alley vote until it came down to self prez and her role reveal making my eye twitch.

Weren’t you suspicious of alley earlier today? Or am I crazy?

 

[vetschoolsletmeinplease]

I wasn’t into the alley vote until it came down to self prez and her role reveal making my eye twitch.

Weren’t you suspicious of alley earlier today? Or am I crazy?

Lightly suspicious of her take on me but not enough to wolf lean her, just raise an eyebrow

 

[kaydubs]

night one closed​

 

[WildZoo]

Y'all I am d r a g g i n g this morning

 

[kaydubs]

Y'all I am d r a g g i n g this morning

quadruple shot espresso - unless that’s too much! (I don’t drink coffee, I don’t know!)

 

[Zenge142]

quadruple shot espresso - unless that’s too much! (I don’t drink coffee, I don’t know!)

That’s not too much! That’s my daily!

 

[WildZoo]

That’s not too much! That’s my daily!

My heart would explode and y'all would never get a writeup

 

[Truenamer]

That’s not too much! That’s my daily!

As an absolute caffeine addict, I think that might be too much all at once 😂

 

[WildZoo]

Night 1

He drove with the windows down, the bite of the cold air keeping him awake through the night. It was rare for him to be behind the wheel, especially alone, but Dean had wanted to keep an eye on Crowley himself, so Sam had taken Baby. He was headed to meet an old friend who had delivered strange news over the phone. Impossible news, really. He gripped the steering wheel a little bit harder and flicked his gaze to the rearview mirror. He nearly drove off the road when he saw the figure in a trenchcoat slumped in the back seat.

"Cas? What the hell!"

~~~~~

Dean paced outside the bunker, rage and grief coming off him in waves.

"You didn't have to kill him!" he yelled, pointing a finger in Crowley's smug face.

"He was about to kill you, or did you think he was showing his teeth as part of a mating ritual?" he smirked, but only for a moment before Dean's fist connected with his face. Crowley staggered back and touched the corner of his mouth.

"I SAVED your LIFE, you flannel-wrapped IDIOT!" He moved towards Dean, stopping when he saw Dean had pulled a knife.

Rowena watched their scuffle from the treeline, just beyond the bunker's proximity sensors. She shook her head. Men were so predictable.

~~~~~

As the sun rose, Bobby awoke to several of his phones ringing. He answered the closest one.

"What in the hell are you doing calling me this early?"

"Bobby," said the voice on the other line, "We think someone was killed. But...the body is gone. There's a lot of blood though. So much blood."

Bobby rubbed a hand over his face. Balls he thought. I'm getting too old for this.

~~~

Spoiler: Dead is

@Animal Midwife, whose body could not be found

 

[WildZoo]

It is now Day 2. Deadline is TOMORROW at 10pm EDT.

10 players remain

2. @justafluff
3. @vetschoolsletmeinplease
4. @samac
5. @potentialsheltervet
6. @AceHydro
7. @Zenge142
8. @kdswg
12. @bluestoat
14. @Ms Procrastinator
15. @cubsrule4e

Dead:
9. @alleycat03 - Benny Lafitte - village cannibal vigilante
1. @Animal Midwife - ???​

 

[Zenge142]

I don’t think Think I’ve seen Midwife be the N1 NK since Basics.

Although they tried N1 NK her in Casino.

 

[WildZoo]

I don’t think Think I’ve seen Midwife be the N1 NK since Basics.

That was a double tragedy

 

[bluestoat]

Rezzer should bring back AM please 🥺

 

[WildZoo]

That was a double tragedy

Why are you hmming me Zenges?? I died n1 that game too!

 

[WildZoo]

😡

 

[Zenge142]

Rezzer should bring back AM please 🥺

I assume it’s a night action so I’m a little surprised Alley isn’t back.

 

[bluestoat]

I assume it’s a night action so I’m a little surprised Alley isn’t back.

Dude that's a really good point

 

[cubsrule4e]

I assume it’s a night action so I’m a little surprised Alley isn’t back.

Per the rules write I think it says certain circumstances must be met. Maybe it’s an even night kind of thing or certain other players have to die to trigger it.

 

[cubsrule4e]

Special Game Mechanics - READ CAREFULLY​

Despite the motto "what is dead should stay dead", this is rarely the case in Supernatural. As such, there are multiple opportunities for resurrection. These opportunities are contingent on particular requirements being met.

As an additional note: There are consequences in place for relying on role reveals this game, both as a game-solving method and as a crutch for defending yourself. You won't be mod-killed if you do it, but you will probably regret it. However, I love this show and am happy to talk about your characters in your role PMs as much as you like. Consider me your personal Supernatural wiki.​

 

[Zenge142]

Why did you quote the role reveal part? Are you saying that because she role revealed, she wasn't eligible for resurrection?!

 

[bluestoat]

Why did you quote the role reveal part? Are you saying that because she role revealed, she wasn't eligible for resurrection?!

Eh seems tinfoiley since her death ALSO role revealed her

 

[justafluff]

Eh seems tinfoiley since her death ALSO role revealed her

Yeah you “role revealed” too, but I doubt that speaking about your potential role on thread would prevent you from being rezzed…

 

[justafluff]

Eh seems tinfoiley since her death ALSO role revealed her

But maybe AM is a candidate for resurrection since we don’t know her role!

 

[Zenge142]

Yeah you “role revealed” too, but I doubt that speaking about your potential role on thread would prevent you from being rezzed…

Just for clarification, when I say not to use role reveals, I mean the character part of your role, not ability claims. Of course, anyone who knows me as a mod knows that ability claims are fraught with terrors as well. But for the purposes of clear interpretation, I was talking about characters.

Character.

 

[justafluff]

Character.

Oww good point.

 

[samac]

This cannibal **** makes my eye twitch

 

[bluestoat]

This cannibal **** makes my eye twitch

My question is... Was this a wolf action or another party's action? We have only one dead player, consistent with a night kill. Is it possible that all the roles, regardless of alignment, have a cannibal modifier ? Could yeeting be the only public confirmation of affiliation?

 

[justafluff]

I believe it’s a wolf action. Cannibals aren’t a different faction and our vigilante just died. There’s not that many players to have double roles.. I totally believe there’s a wolf cannibal out there.

 

[Zenge142]

My question is... Was this a wolf action or another party's action? We have only one dead player, consistent with a night kill. Is it possible that all the roles, regardless of alignment, have a cannibal modifier ? Could yeeting be the only public confirmation of affiliation?

There’s no evidence anywhere of a 3p. Until we get some sort of evidence we shouldn’t delve down that rabbit hole, lest Midwife starts spinning in her grave fast enough to yeet the entire planet out of rotation.

I see no reason why a cannibal modifier wouldn’t be put onto both the village vig and a wolf.

I would imagine that only a select wolf is a cannibal, and they did the kill. Yeeting the cannibal wolf would cause other, non-cannibal wolves to do the kill, making the flips public.

 

[samac]

There’s no evidence anywhere of a 3p. Until we get some sort of evidence we shouldn’t delve down that rabbit hole, lest Midwife starts spinning in her grave fast enough to yeet the entire planet out of rotation.

I see no reason why a cannibal modifier wouldn’t be put onto both the village vig and a wolf.

I would imagine that only a select wolf is a cannibal, and they did the kill. Yeeting the cannibal wolf would cause other, non-cannibal wolves to do the kill, making the flips public.

Hey if we go into tinfoil mechanics territory fast enough maybe she’ll come back to life to lecture us

 

[WildZoo]

Day 2 The Family Business Vote Tally

...

0/10 votes
Winning: no one
Missing: all
Deadline: tomorrow (3/16) 10pm eastern/9pm central/8pm mountain/7pm fantasyland

 

[bluestoat]

Oh, I meant "another party" as "anyone other than wolf" @Zenge142

 

[AceHydro]

I believe it’s a wolf action. Cannibals aren’t a different faction and our vigilante just died. There’s not that many players to have double roles.. I totally believe there’s a wolf cannibal out there.

My mind was going towards two village cannibals, but I’m liking what you’re thinking more

 

[bluestoat]

Did anyone get to open a PM with AM? Who was her partner?

 

[Zenge142]

Did anyone get to open a PM with AM? Who was her partner?

The person Ms.P knows the best in this game is AM, and it wouldn't surprise me if AM put Ms.P high on her list, knowing she wouldn't be around, just as a way to avoid having a real PM.

 

[samac]

Yeet fluff

I went back through people discussing the zenge copy pasta and her reactions felt like pressure and backpedaling in a way that she did similarly when she got flack when she was a wolf.
I’m having strongggg flashbacks and for anyone who has her as a top village read I don’t understand why.

 

[cubsrule4e]

Why did you quote the role reveal part? Are you saying that because she role revealed, she wasn't eligible for resurrection?!

No I deleted everything above it so it’d be the first thing to read. And on the phone it’s a pain to try to get those stupid brackets around what you want to bold or whatever.

 

[justafluff]

Yeet fluff

I went back through people discussing the zenge copy pasta and her reactions felt like pressure and backpedaling in a way that she did similarly when she got flack when she was a wolf.
I’m having strongggg flashbacks and for anyone who has her as a top village read I don’t understand why.

I’m not a wolf samac, this is counter productive.

 

[cubsrule4e]

Yeet fluff

I went back through people discussing the zenge copy pasta and her reactions felt like pressure and backpedaling in a way that she did similarly when she got flack when she was a wolf.
I’m having strongggg flashbacks and for anyone who has her as a top village read I don’t understand why.

What does a wolf gain by coming out with the dialogue she started? It’s easy enough to say nothing and scheme behind the scenes and let village struggle with it.

 

[bluestoat]

What does a wolf gain by coming out with the dialogue she started? It’s easy enough to say nothing and scheme behind the scenes and let village struggle with it.

@cubsrule4e ya got a reads list?

 

[samac]

What does a wolf gain by coming out with the dialogue she started? It’s easy enough to say nothing and scheme behind the scenes and let village struggle with it.

I completely disagree with this.
It’s a weird post that would be easy for a wolf to drum up sus with.

 

[Zenge142]

What does a wolf gain by coming out with the dialogue she started? It’s easy enough to say nothing and scheme behind the scenes and let village struggle with it.

Which dialogue are you referring to specifically? Just so we’re clear.

 

[bluestoat]

I completely disagree with this.
It’s a weird post that would be easy for a wolf to drum up sus with.

I don't think Fluff is that crafty or prone to that kind of out-of-gate behavior