I have been accepted to both schools, and although both have EXCELLENT facilities, great reputations, and a really happy student body, I have chosen Jefferson for the following reasons.
1. Location- Jeff is located in Center City, a great great location in Philadelphia. I've lived in around philly for undergrad and have always wanted to live in Center City. It's fun, not VERY expensive, and Jeff offers on campus housing if you so desire. I live with my fiance, so we will be looking for an off-campus apartment, but the on-campus ones are quite nice!
2. Grading system- Jeff is Honors/Pass/Fail. I'm really looking for a relaxed and supportive environment. I love that I won't have to worry about a traditional grading system at Jeff. It also has all the notes already given to you in the beginning of each module, which is pretty sweet.
3. Happiness of Students- Both Jeff and Temple students seem extremely happy. I have close friends at both, and they all LOVE their respective schools. This one is a tie I suppose then- lucky us!
4. Jeff Hope Clinic- I am very interested in serving the community while in medical school, especially in my first and second year when I do not have clinicals. This clinic allows first and fouth years to pair up and serve in pediatric, ob/gyn, and homeless male clinic. I think this is a great, great experience to gain early.
5. Money- I KNOW you said that for the sake of argument, assume both cost the same, but for others who may be looking at this thread, I figured I would address this point. For out-of-staters at Temple, the tuition/fees is $51,078. For all students at Jeff, the tuition/fees are $44,547. Although it is only a differnce of $6531, over the course of 4 years, this is more than $26,000. For those of us looking at LOTS of undergrad debt and who have no financial help for medical school, this is a substantial difference.
Both are great schools, and you should be proud to go to either. I know I will be! Hope this is helpful- Good luck in your decision 👍