The Good PWWace - GAME THREAD

[_rae_]

---

Members do not see this ad.

my issue is I’m not quite sure what we need to accomplish yet but I think affiliations aren’t flipping because they don’t actually matter.

Interesting.... so do you think we're solving for a coordination of actions as a team? What's your thought on our current NK (vig shot vs mod kill vs other)

 

[Animal Midwife]

...............I'm going to try something.




Yeet @Zenge142
@supershorty @kaydubs @SARdoghandler

What are you trying?

 

[WildZoo]

Tbh I'm not sure it would have made a difference strategically but it would have felt nice

 

[finnickthedog]

I think affiliations aren’t flipping because they don’t actually matter.

They said they'll get flipped at a specific point in game.

I think they aren't flipping because we still think we're in the good place.

It was. I assumed "I read AM wolf most times and most times I'm wrong" means "I'm reading AM as wolf so she's probably village"

Nope. I gut read AM wolf pretty much all the time and its usually wrong because that's just statistically how it goes. People will be village more often than they are wolves.

So I advised we ignore my gut entirely in regards to AM. It means neither likely wolf nor probably village.

 

[_rae_]

What are you trying?

I wanna see how zenge responds. Especially since he hasn't voted and that pushes him back into a tie (if I'm doing my math right)

 

[samac]

Day 1



There was a sense of unease in the air, even though it was The Good Place. Surely, everyone belonged here! Everyone was good! Surely, this being The Good Place meant that everyone was good ... right? Or maybe there were some who would benefit from the removal of others, but not everyone?



She somehow found herself back at her house that night, safely tucked in despite having to navigate the ledge that seemed like it should be stairs but wasn't. As she drifted off to sleep, she mumbled to herself "The Good Place is good, but not all good is good? Some good is bad? Incompatible?"

If she had a headache the next morning - a hangover in The Good Place - she was going to be FORKING annoyed.

​

Night 1





A chill trickled down the backs of the residents (you could feel chills in The Good Place?). Someone complained of a stomachache. They just wished they figure out the key to more information... to understanding what "not all good is good" meant...​

Just noted this combination here

 

[samac]

Interesting.... so do you think we're solving for a coordination of actions as a team? What's your thought on our current NK (vig shot vs mod kill vs other)

I don’t think it’s a mod kill. I think it’s a big shot or some factional ability of some sort but I don’t think the factional bit is necessarily anything with a bad wincon if that makes sense?

 

[samac]

Tbh I'm not sure it would have made a difference strategically but it would have felt nice

I don’t know how to handle this strategically either tbh

 

[samac]

They said they'll get flipped at a specific point in game.

I think they aren't flipping because we still think we're in the good place.



Nope. I gut read AM wolf pretty much all the time and its usually wrong because that's just statistically how it goes. People will be village more often than they are wolves.

So I advised we ignore my gut entirely in regards to AM. It means neither likely wolf nor probably village.

I think we have to do something to trigger the flip.
I don’t know what. Or if it actually matters

 

[GoSpursGo]

I don’t think it’s a mod kill. I think it’s a big shot or some factional ability of some sort but I don’t think the factional bit is necessarily anything with a bad wincon if that makes sense?

... how is a faction with an NK anything other than a wolf, or at least functionally a wolf?

 

[screamqueenbee]

I think we have to do something to trigger the flip.
I don’t know what. Or if it actually matters

It could be how many people there are in the deadchat. That's what it was for SPN

 

[Animal Midwife]

It could be how many people there are in the deadchat. That's what it was for SPN

Didn't people fully flip in that game right from the start?

 

[WildZoo]

... how is a faction with an NK anything other than a wolf, or at least functionally a wolf?

Well, wolves are more than just a faction with an NK. they have a very specific win condition - village elimination. If that's not the wincon, that's not a wolf pack.

A vigilante isn't a serial killer just because they can kill at night.

 

[samac]

It could be how many people there are in the deadchat. That's what it was for SPN

That was just to start the dead chat game, not trigger anything else

 

[WildZoo]

Anyway none of this helps me know how to approach this strategically lol

 

[samac]

Does anyone else have any tinfoil? I’m spinning my wheels I need someone to riff off and my pm partner someone gave me has made exactly 3 posts. I did not win her over lol

 

[GoSpursGo]

Well, wolves are more than just a faction with an NK. they have a very specific win condition - village elimination. If that's not the wincon, that's not a wolf pack.

A vigilante isn't a serial killer just because they can kill at night.

Well yes, I can understand that. But if there is a faction trying to NK us, then regardless of whether their wincon is village elimination or elimination of some specific magic formula of players... aren't they still the baddies?

I just don't see how strategically this changes how we approach votes.

 

[WildZoo]

This tin was already my foil fam

 

[_rae_]

Does anyone else have any tinfoil? I’m spinning my wheels I need someone to riff off and my pm partner someone gave me has made exactly 3 posts. I did not win her over lol

I’m still curious to see how soulmates worked out.

…………I’ve been flip flopping about talking about nights but I don’t want to go fishing and I don’t know how much we can share……

 

[samac]

Anyway none of this helps me know how to approach this strategically lol

THATS MY PROBLEM
MY HUSBAND IS LAUGHING AT ME

I’ve considered that maybe there is one person to take out and it’s Shawn or the judge.
But I don’t know. I don’t know what to do with this but this also explains why I feel like there’s not a wolfy agenda on thread. I don’t feel like anyone seems to be working with anyone and it all feels weird.

 

[WildZoo]

Well yes, I can understand that. But if there is a faction trying to NK us, then regardless of whether their wincon is village elimination or elimination of some specific magic formula of players... aren't they still the baddies?

I just don't see how strategically this changes how we approach votes.

That entirely depends on what their wincon actually is.

 

[samac]

I’m still curious to see how soulmates worked out.

…………I’ve been flip flopping about talking about nights but I don’t want to go fishing and I don’t know how much we can share……

I don’t know if soulmates are anything, really they aren’t in the show either.

 

[_rae_]

I’ve considered that maybe there is one person to take out and it’s Shawn or the judge.

This thought is intetesting

 

[WildZoo]

Which we don't know

Like I can't assume from the death of one PSV that there's a faction of baddies trying to take me out and eliminating them is my goal

 

[WildZoo]

Maybe there's a faction trying to eliminate chefs. I'm not a chef.

I'm being facetious but hopefully it's helping explain my point lol

 

[samac]

Maybe there's a faction trying to eliminate chefs. I'm not a chef.

I'm being facetious but hopefully it's helping explain my point lol

I don’t know what to do or how to go about this. Im hoping someone else has information or thoughts that can click things into place. I feel like we’re missing something staring us in the face.

 

[WildZoo]

I don’t know what to do or how to go about this. Im hoping someone else has information or thoughts that can click things into place. I feel like we’re missing something staring us in the face.

Ummmmm

Idk I'm still waiting to see if Zenge is a jester! If he is then BOOM, that's one wincon down!

 

[supershorty]

You would know if someone was modkilled, it would be announced in the announcements PM just like in the kayDubz game.

 

[samac]

Ummmmm

Idk I'm still waiting to see if Zenge is a jester! If he is then BOOM, that's one wincon down!

Yeah I mean
If he is a jester at least I’m teaching him how to deal with em
Yeet em and let em win

 

[WildZoo]

Me rn

 

[WildZoo]

Tbh it's more like

 

[samac]

Me rn

My husband literally said “you look like the Charlie conspiracy meme”

 

[samac]

I don’t know what to do with this.
I don’t know how to play this game.
Wheeeeeeee

 

[GoSpursGo]

Unofficial tally (@supershorty of course does a great job, I'm just taking stock as I'm about to head home and life is about to get hectic)

screamqueenbee ()
CeeGee ()
genny (1) - fruit
samac (2) - kitzuna, Clem
Zenge (3) - Dubz, samac, rae
Clem (3) - Spurs, finn, AM
fruit ()
rae (1) - Barky

@Clem J and @Zenge142 are tied and in the lead if you call 3 votes to 2 the lead

10/14 voting
Missing: @screamqueenbee @genny @CeeGee14 @Zenge142

Vote closes today, 12/2, at 9 PM EST (~4 hours).

 

[GoSpursGo]

life is about to get hectic

which, uh, is unfortunate given... *gestures wildly everywhere*

 

[kitzsuna]

THATS MY PROBLEM
MY HUSBAND IS LAUGHING AT ME

I’ve considered that maybe there is one person to take out and it’s Shawn or the judge.
But I don’t know. I don’t know what to do with this but this also explains why I feel like there’s not a wolfy agenda on thread. I don’t feel like anyone seems to be working with anyone and it all feels weird.

Who is Shawn?

 

[samac]

Who is Shawn?

Leader of the bad place. Bad guy through most of the show.

 

[supershorty]

Unofficial tally (@supershorty of course does a great job, I'm just taking stock as I'm about to head home and life is about to get hectic)

screamqueenbee ()
CeeGee ()
genny (1) - fruit
samac (2) - kitzuna, Clem
Zenge (3) - Dubz, samac, rae
Clem (3) - Spurs, finn, AM
fruit ()
rae (1) - Barky

@Clem J and @Zenge142 are tied and in the lead if you call 3 votes to 2 the lead

10/14 voting
Missing: @screamqueenbee @genny @CeeGee14 @Zenge142

Vote closes today, 12/2, at 9 PM EST (~4 hours).

You forgot to take out my snark aimed at you.

 

[kitzsuna]

Leader of the bad place. Bad guy through most of the show.

Oh i thought michael was the guy

 

[screamqueenbee]

Didn't people fully flip in that game right from the start?

It triggered a mechanic shift

 

[WildZoo]

I think probably the trigger for affiliation flips will be based on show timeline in some way

 

[Animal Midwife]

It triggered a mechanic shift

What was that?

 

[samac]

Oh i thought michael was the guy

Michael is the architect but he has a boss

 

[samac]

I think probably the trigger for affiliation flips will be based on show timeline in some way

I think we’ll have to trigger it but I guess we’ll see

 

[GoSpursGo]

You forgot to take out my snark aimed at you.

I actually updated it but left it so if would be there if you wanted to update from this list next time

Alright folks heading home. Don't put any of your tinfoil in microwaves, or anything else I wouldn't do...

 

[samac]

It triggered a mechanic shift

So it just made some additional mechanics available to dead chat but wasn’t a mechanical shift

 

[WildZoo]

Leader of the bad place. Bad guy through most of the show.

Maybe we do just need to find him or something but we have the other wincons so that's not the only thing we need to do

 

[WildZoo]

I actually updated it but left it so if would be there if you wanted to update from this list next time

Alright folks heading home. Don't put any of your tinfoil in microwaves, or anything else I wouldn't do...

I'm putting mine straight in the microwave, sorry

 

[samac]

Maybe we do just need to find him or something but we have the other wincons so that's not the only thing we need to do

This is true.
I understand why we can’t go “this is my wincon let’s do this” but I wish we could.
Hopefully Zenges is getting yeeted

 

[WildZoo]

Alright! Who wants to admit to being Shawn 🧐