The Stand WW Game Thread

[LetItSnow]

---

Members don't see this ad.

Sorry about that again. Your purpose was to disseminate information about the various chaos people and to point DocE in the direction of who is appropriate to convert and who should be killed/ not killed. Bc DocE was a highly powered wolf, the game was set up so the first two wolves (you and saya) were at an extreme disadvantage. He needed to get the info somehow, but adding a fourth fully functional wolf into the game would have been too overpowered IMO. But I do apologize for taking away the fun or it for you 🙁

Oh, no apology needed. It is what it is, and there were some cool mechanic ideas in this game. But as 'critique' I'd probably suggest that player fun should usually take priority over game mechanics. So in this case, if you needed weaker roles that are likely to get lynched in order to balance out a more powerful role .... the right adjustment is probably to make the powerful role less so, rather than throw in some weaker roles that are basically doomed from the get-go.

That's just a philosophy thought on game design. It's not a person attack or anything.

I think sometimes we get so enthralled with trying to come up with some cool mechanic that we sorta forget to consider "ok, but is this FUN".

 

[DVMDream]

Hehehe. I can see that point, but you didn't LEAD the lynch on me. I was talking more about the way SOV used it this game where he pretty much led the lynch.

Devyn was sure pressuring me to lead the lynch. Since she was the one that tracked you. Can't remember who actually posted the information, to be honest. But I was stuck, had to vote for you, still got bitched out for it... 😛

 

[lhmhtd]

Well I definitely had fun. Thanks for a great game!

 

[StartingoverVet]

. But as 'critique' I'd probably suggest that player fun should usually take priority over game mechanics..

Eh for me, Mod fun always takes priority. He he he he he.

 

[StartingoverVet]

Who was in charge of the morgue? What determined when info was released?

 

[WildZoo]

Who was in charge of the morgue? What determined when info was released?

Mods 😀 Each death was RNG'd to determine how long the info delay would be.

 

[StartingoverVet]

Was MJ's silenced role really RNG'ed? 🙄

 

[WillowLeaf]

Allieh could send you 1 seer result each night after she died and could still seer after death. The other message came from the massive dead chat.

Ooh. Interesting. I was wondering why allieh wasn't allowed in the dead PM convo.

@allieh8607 - Sorry. I was so convinced you were a wolf. 😳 Good job, wolves, making us believe she was a wolf.

 

[Cyndia]

:-<

Btw, the whole mod error thing was just me screwing up my strategy ... NEVER post as a wolf when you first wake up. NEVER.

Oh my god hahaha, I genuinely thought there was absolutely no way you would have made such an idiotic mistake as a wolf.

I'm an absolute *****. Had no time to really properly read through things or follow along too closely so my apologies for losing that for the villagers. I was starting to get suspicious of SOV, but when the coroners report came out that ksmi was a wolf, I figured there was no way he would have thrown her under the bus since it was unlikely we'd get a coroners report in time anyways. Ah well, well played SOV.

And yes, sorry for lynching you Allie! I was convinced you were a convert, oops.

 

[Flim Flam Man]

Was MJ's silenced role really RNG'ed? 🙄

Was DocE's role rng-ed is what I am wondering.

 

[DocEspana]

Was DocE's role rng-ed is what I am wondering.

I asked the same question. I've been Randall Flagg in numerous games now. It's a thing. Must be JDHs subtle hand in everything. Also won all of those games. Even survived to the end in one.

 

[nohika]

*cough, cough*

Mods said you had one question you could ask the dead. We had tried at least once to inform you that only chaos characters could be converted (through BI). You could have used your question, we could have told you that and you could have won the game.... 😉

Oops. I assumed that was a night thing, not a whenever-I-wanted-to thing.

It's always amusing to me when I survive all the way to the end. Heh. Especially as a villager.

 

[WildZoo]

Was MJ's silenced role really RNG'ed? 🙄

Was DocE's role rng-ed is what I am wondering.

All roles were RNG'd except for Escalla since she requested something minor. MJ getting the Mother Abagail role was hilarious, but I wouldn't have done that to him on purpose 😀

 

[StartingoverVet]

Oh my god hahaha, I genuinely thought there was absolutely no way you would have made such an idiotic mistake as a wolf.

I'm an absolute *****. Had no time to really properly read through things or follow along too closely so my apologies for losing that for the villagers. I was starting to get suspicious of SOV, but when the coroners report came out that ksmi was a wolf, I figured there was no way he would have thrown her under the bus since it was unlikely we'd get a coroners report in time anyways. Ah well, well played SOV.

And yes, sorry for lynching you Allie! I was convinced you were a convert, oops.

I asked the mods to conver you to a Las Vegas showgirl as a reward for being such a faithful wolf companion on the last night if we survived. 😱

 

[WildZoo]

I asked the mods to conver you to a Las Vegas showgirl as a reward for being such a faithful wolf companion on the last night if we survived. 😱

Which would have been... Interesting, considering her role was a guy 😛

 

[SummerTheLynx]

Was DocE's role rng-ed is what I am wondering.

Honestly I imagined the game with DVMD as Flagg, so yes it was RNG

 

[Cyndia]

Which would have been... Interesting, considering her role was a guy 😛

Where there's a will, there's a way!

 

[that redhead]

I'm really not sure why SOV is allowed to live past like night three. He's a great player but unpredictable even when a villager 😛

 

[WildZoo]

I'm really not sure why SOV is allowed to live past like night three. He's a great player but unpredictable even when a villager 😛

But that's what makes it so much fun 😀