The WWalking Dead-Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
PippyPony said:
As an aside, I'm not crazy about lynching chaos at the expense of wolves, but that may also be because I don't particularly mind chaos :laugh:
Click to expand...
Ehhhhhhhh, it's better than killing villagers. But going forward I think we should focus on wolves and keep an eye on how many walkers there may be.

StayingPositive2017 said:
So now that we know zombies=chaos, how many wolves do we think we started with? 16 original players, 3-4 original wolves?
Click to expand...

PippyPony said:
4 would be very wolf heavy in my opinion given that chaos is a thing
Click to expand...
Yeah, my guess would be 2-3 at the beginning, so 1-2 wolves left now.
 
I was paranoid of Mel since in the original write-up when it said Snowy was not chaos. I was thinking he might have bussed allieh and then led us down the trail of killing zoms to distract us. There goes that theory.
 
Day 1 Lynch Tally
SOV () -
Sporty (1) - AM
Greeny (1) - Paws
DPMD (1) - Cray
Pippy (1) - KC
Allie (1) - dpmd
Skimble (2) - Pippy, Genny
Weim (3) - sobsob, Allie, Skimble
Cray (1) - Weim
Genny () -
AM (1) - WZ

12/16
Missing: Mel, greeney, Snowy, Sporty

Day 2 Lynch Tally
SOV (1) - Pippy
allie (9) - Melby, Paws, WZ, kc, Skim, Sporty, Snowy, dpmd, Weim
Melby (2) - Cray, allie
greeney (2) - AM, SOV

14/16
Missing: greeney, genny

Day 3 Lynch Tally
Cray () -
greeney (5) - KC, Pippy, dpmd, Cray, AM
Sporty () -
Mel () -
kc (5) - Paws, Skim, Mel, genny, WZ
genny (2) - SOV, Snowy
Paws () -
Skim (1) - Jboo
WZ (1) - Sporty
Snowy () -
dpmd () -

14/15
Missing: greeney

Day 4 Lynch Tally
SOV (1) - Pippy
Snowy (6) - Mel, Skimble, Paws, dpmd, Jboo, Cray
KC (1) - Snowy
Skimble (1) - SOV
genny () -
Cray (4) - Genny, AM, SportPonies, KC

13/13
 
PippyPony said:
Actually, turns out AM has been late with a good many votes this game. Which is weird. Paws is also pinging my radar again, despite the clearing earlier in the game (right? did that happen?). Should probably re-read, but...

I'm going in to 10 hours of testing IRL, so...

Contingency lynch AM
Click to expand...

Also, I don't like you sitting on an easy vote when you know you'll be gone for almost the entire day.
 
Skimble said:
Because I’m pretty good at reading her and she sounds like village cray. It’s not something I can really pinpoint.
Click to expand...

I was hoping it was something more concrete because I'm still getting feels from her direction.
 
lynch Cray
for small feels after a re-read of her day one interactions and because I've felt like she is village the entire game, yet always tunnel her for a wolf, so thinking her play feels more like wolf cray from Shuffling WW...
 
Official Day 5 Lynch Tally: Welcome to the Tombs
AM (2)- Pippy, Skimble
Sporty (1)- Jboo
Cray (2)- AM, Paws

5/10

lynch closes in ~8.5 hours
 
I’m torn. I don’t feel the same way about cray that skimble does, and I am starting to get suspicious of AM. The way she switched off me into Cray raised a flag for me. I could go either way.
 
Skimble said:
I'd really prefer you guys didn't lynch cray. I know I'm just following my gut, but I'm pretty sure it's right.
Click to expand...

genny said:
I’m torn. I don’t feel the same way about cray that skimble does, and I am starting to get suspicious of AM. The way she switched off me into Cray raised a flag for me. I could go either way.
Click to expand...

How do you guys feel about SOV, dpmd, or sporty? I have never played or read a game with SOV or dpmd so feeling very lost on them. dpmd felt village yesterday, and SOV i'm back and forth on...
 
StayingPositive2017 said:
How do you guys feel about SOV, dpmd, or sporty? I have never played or read a game with SOV or dpmd so feeling very lost on them. dpmd felt village yesterday, and SOV i'm back and forth on...
Click to expand...
I'm a little sketched by Dpmd and SOV, and admit I'm not sure what to think about sporty at this point.
 
Skimble said:
For the sake of conversation, can you pinpoint anything about cray that makes you think she’s wolfy?
Click to expand...

She's never said anything about other players until I asked her about her reads. Where's the paranoia about Pippy and me conspiring? What about WZ being too village to be true? Why is it all mechanics? Nothing even about mixing Paws and Snowy.
 
lynch cray
I have been thinking a lot about her initial post after almost being lynched and the subsequent overreaction after being called on having no real reaction to it at first. Just feels off to me.
 
StayingPositive2017 said:
How do you guys feel about SOV, dpmd, or sporty? I have never played or read a game with SOV or dpmd so feeling very lost on them. dpmd felt village yesterday, and SOV i'm back and forth on...
Click to expand...
Would also like to hear from these three people.

My guess is that wolves have been skating by so far by staying under the radar and letting us get distracted with game mechanics and worrying about zombies. I'm going to go back later tonight and try and iso people who were actively encouraging those convos.

More ammo would also be nice!
 
johnnaboo said:
Would also like to hear from these three people.

My guess is that wolves have been skating by so far by staying under the radar and letting us get distracted with game mechanics and worrying about zombies. I'm going to go back later tonight and try and iso people who were actively encouraging those convos.

More ammo would also be nice!
Click to expand...
You realize dpmd commented directly above you, right?
 
Official Day 5 Lynch Tally: Welcome to the Tombs
AM (2)- Pippy, Skimble
Sporty (1)- Jboo
Cray (3)- AM, Paws, dpmd
dpmd (1)- SOV

7/10

giphy.gif


lynch closes in ~6 hours
 
lynch AM

seems like she's been no-so-subtly trying to drive my lynch, and not to be retaliatory, but the last time she did that without good reason she was wolf and got me lynched to win the game

I can't fathom why she would vote me over Snowy when the village seer put his ass on the line and found us chaos

I get not wanting to chaos-hunt over wolf hunting, but when you *know* 3rd party better than a wolf, 9/10 lynch 3rd party

plus now that I finally know more about the game (like I keep saying) I have a bit more theories as to not only what is happening, but how that relates to players

I think that the leader of the zombies, KC, was sending walkers to attack PRs or wolves at night to bite and infect and convert them

others they thought might be lowly villagers it would make sense the chaos zombie faction would just try to get lynched

it's better for 3rd party'ers to be on the lynch of wolves or lower level villagers for the flip, and to deal with PRs villagers in some other way (obviously you wouldn't expect chaos to be better at wolf or PR hunting without abilities/items/intel than anyone else, still, I think that would be their goal)

all of this is just a theory for why I haven't been loving what's going on with AM, her play, her attack, and her vote
 
the comment about chaos and not me accumulating idiotic votes? I was in a ****ing movie theater literally getting elbowed (it hurt!) by my friend

I'm seriously pissed that I'm getting criticized for making the comment I not only had time for, but I thought would be helpful

I didn't think I'd catch flak for not taking that as the moment to open the can of worms that is, WTF is wrong with you people

that, and a lot of other things this game seriously make me regret trying to be as active and contributory as I can

you guys have a serious problem of tunneling more active players
 
Crayola227 said:
lynch AM

seems like she's been no-so-subtly trying to drive my lynch, and not to be retaliatory, but the last time she did that without good reason she was wolf and got me lynched to win the game

I can't fathom why she would vote me over Snowy when the village seer put his ass on the line and found us chaos

I get not wanting to chaos-hunt over wolf hunting, but when you *know* 3rd party better than a wolf, 9/10 lynch 3rd party

plus now that I finally know more about the game (like I keep saying) I have a bit more theories as to not only what is happening, but how that relates to players

I think that the leader of the zombies, KC, was sending walkers to attack PRs or wolves at night to bite and infect and convert them

others they thought might be lowly villagers it would make sense the chaos zombie faction would just try to get lynched

it's better for 3rd party'ers to be on the lynch of wolves or lower level villagers for the flip, and to deal with PRs villagers in some other way (obviously you wouldn't expect chaos to be better at wolf or PR hunting without abilities/items/intel than anyone else, still, I think that would be their goal)

all of this is just a theory for why I haven't been loving what's going on with AM, her play, her attack, and her vote
Click to expand...

This is still just more mechanics. It's a waste of a day for everyone to bandwagon on chaos and pat themselves on the back. You're solely voting for me because I'm voting for you. You haven't brought me up once prior to this. Remember when the tally was between greeney and kc and you chose greeney? Do you also remember when the seer outted allie and you chose to continue lynching him? But yes, you can't fanthom why I didn't vote for Snowy.
 
I feel I basically got lynched for sticking to my Pippy paranoia last game, so I backed down on my Mel tinfoil hat and feelz

seriously, one of my top suspects was the village seer who took down a wolf d2 or whatever, and *that's* not paranoid Cray enough for you people? can you even hear yourselves?

not to mention the Pippy paranoia I still ended up going down the rabbit hole with this game, yeah I flopped off

no one gets that my Wolf play is much much more coherent, it's much easier for me to tell a story and stick to it as a wolf, as a villager since I am *actually* trying to wolf hunt, I'm more prone to bizarre and wish washy behavior, and that is my gorram right

I am more concerned with figuring things out than how I look, that's the difference between village and wolf play on a fundamental level

as far as WZ, actually, she didn't seem too village to be true this game, and I'm not surprised if she felt a touch "off" to me this game, seeing as she was protector, this happened in some other game too

I haven't had the time or technical ability to register every last twinge or fart I've felt this game
 
Animal Midwife said:
This is still just more mechanics. It's a waste of a day for everyone to bandwagon on chaos and pat themselves on the back. You're solely voting for me because I'm voting for you. You haven't brought me up once prior to this. Remember when the tally was between greeney and kc and you chose greeney? Do you also remember when the seer outted allie and you chose to continue lynching him? But yes, you can't fanthom why I didn't vote for Snowy.
Click to expand...

one, you're acting like this is the first time I've gotten hung up on mechanics to the point of finding it hard to come up with reads, and two

I also don't see how it's a waste of time to get chaos, especially when it looks like they had a conversion mechanism and could overrun the village

no, I still can't fathom why you didn't vote for snowy

and yeah, everything you said doesn't really look good for me, does it? guess when Cray looks like an idiot? When I'm village. Guess when my game seems "good"? When I'm wolf. It's not hard to see why.
 
Animal Midwife said:
This is still just more mechanics. It's a waste of a day for everyone to bandwagon on chaos and pat themselves on the back. You're solely voting for me because I'm voting for you. You haven't brought me up once prior to this. Remember when the tally was between greeney and kc and you chose greeney? Do you also remember when the seer outted allie and you chose to continue lynching him? But yes, you can't fanthom why I didn't vote for Snowy.
Click to expand...

I haven't brought up a lot of people in this game because I had not a clue what was going on. Surprise surprise, this last write up where we learn more abut chaos, who was the village seer in addition to protector, things are coming more clearly into focus for me
 
Crayola227 said:
one, you're acting like this is the first time I've gotten hung up on mechanics to the point of finding it hard to come up with reads, and two

I also don't see how it's a waste of time to get chaos, especially when it looks like they had a conversion mechanism and could overrun the village

no, I still can't fathom why you didn't vote for snowy

and yeah, everything you said doesn't really look good for me, does it? guess when Cray looks like an idiot? When I'm village. Guess when my game seems "good"? When I'm wolf. It's not hard to see why.
Click to expand...
This is so inconsistent with your usual statements about yourself. Weren’t you the village redirector that took out like half a wolf pack on your own? I’m not buying this poor dumb villager speech.
 
usually I play with a PbPa (post by post analysis) where I reply to every post that gives me a reaction, rather than gleaning a thread meta

it's annoying to others as frak, and according to some mafia wiki tends to not be very effective

I think it's where a lot of where my trademark hare-brained ideas come from, and I just can't do it this game

it makes me feel a bit lost, especially this game

I have given my thoughts on players this game, but I'm not on the chandeliers about it

deal with it
 
genny said:
This is so inconsistent with your usual statements about yourself. Weren’t you the village redirector that took out like half a wolf pack on your own? I’m not buying this poor dumb villager speech.
Click to expand...

One, I think it was AM who took me to the mat on that one, or maybe KC, and just totally gutted what a cool game that was for me.

My speech is usually something to the point that *I* don't think my contributions to the game are stupid, you're twisting what I'm saying here which is that I might often *appear* stupid or out in the weeds, I don't think I am. But I think it can look that way.

This happened in the Lounge game, dpmd, if she's not a wolf, can verify, I absolutely can get lost in gamesolving and mechanics, and in the Lounge game and Rehab this was 100% true.
 
Crayola227 said:
the comment about chaos and not me accumulating idiotic votes? I was in a ****ing movie theater literally getting elbowed (it hurt!) by my friend

I'm seriously pissed that I'm getting criticized for making the comment I not only had time for, but I thought would be helpful

I didn't think I'd catch flak for not taking that as the moment to open the can of worms that is, WTF is wrong with you people

that, and a lot of other things this game seriously make me regret trying to be as active and contributory as I can

you guys have a serious problem of tunneling more active players
Click to expand...

I never said you were inactive. Besides, since when does higher activity exclude people for being questioned?

Crayola227 said:
one, you're acting like this is the first time I've gotten hung up on mechanics to the point of finding it hard to come up with reads, and two

I also don't see how it's a waste of time to get chaos, especially when it looks like they had a conversion mechanism and could overrun the village

no, I still can't fathom why you didn't vote for snowy

and yeah, everything you said doesn't really look good for me, does it? guess when Cray looks like an idiot? When I'm village. Guess when my game seems "good"? When I'm wolf. It's not hard to see why.
Click to expand...

Even when you don't have solidified reads, you still usually share how far you've come along in evaluating.
 
Crayola227 said:
not to mention the Pippy paranoia I still ended up going down the rabbit hole with this game, yeah I flopped off
Click to expand...
Can you explain what you mean by this? I don't think I've heard you mention me at all this game until just now, which is in and of itself highly unusual.

ETA: I think this post is also the first time you are mentioning any feels you had for dubz
 
I've played wolf and won while staying with my friend. I just made a fake reads box and saved myself a lot of time.

I'm not doing that here, because I'm not going to manufacture reads because wolfy people are demanding it as they lack of one they use to try to set me up for mislynch.
 
StayingPositive2017 said:
How do you guys feel about SOV, dpmd, or sporty? I have never played or read a game with SOV or dpmd so feeling very lost on them. dpmd felt village yesterday, and SOV i'm back and forth on...
Click to expand...
They are both good players; SOV used to play a lot (was mostly before my time but he's popped in for a game or two since then) and i understand he was responsible for lots of shenanigans back in the day
 
PippyPony said:
Can you explain what you mean by this? I don't think I've heard you mention me at all this game until just now, which is in and of itself highly unusual.

ETA: I think this post is also the first time you are mentioning any feels you had for dubz
Click to expand...

Unfortunately I haven't been able to record my every thought and twinge like I usually do, and frankly, I think when I don't write them down 2 days later I can't even remember.

WZ just seemed more casual and fluffing, she didn't give off that "too village to be true vibe" and I suspected this was because she was trying to be on the down low without being on the downlow. Now it makes sense that wasn't wolfy.

Your interactions with her seemed too laid back as well.

Your interaction with Mel I thought was off.

I decided all this was "paranoid" because this game I had you as "too village to be true" and Mel as "wolfy but I know he can't really be"
 
PippyPony said:
Can you explain what you mean by this? I don't think I've heard you mention me at all this game until just now, which is in and of itself highly unusual.

ETA: I think this post is also the first time you are mentioning any feels you had for dubz
Click to expand...

Don't take this wrong I tend to avoid casting suspicion on you unless I'm a bit more sure. I need a touch more paranoia, grounds, or a feel of wolf vs ___ to do so now. If I have you on a village lean provoking you with paranoia (yes, I get extra paranoid of village leans, almost like "wolf lean by virtue of sneaky rep or leaning village") just leads to a big distraction and more paranoia. I find it more helpful if i really think I'm going to see some wolf Pippy come out.

I can always talk myself into thinking you're a wolf, so I just try not to go there unless I think it's more warranted. There's more players than just Mel, Pip, WZ to tunnel. Or at least I try to tell myself that.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
55K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
39K
Clem J
Clem J
supershorty
GGoats ThWWee: Here It GGoats Again - GAME THREAD
93 94 95 96 97
Replies
5K
Views
56K
vampyrica
vampyrica
Animal Midwife
Matrix - Game Thread
77 78 79 80 81
Replies
4K
Views
89K
samac
samac
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
PokeWWon: A Wild Kanto Adventure - Champs Season 12 Practice Game Thread
87 88 89 90 91
Replies
5K
Views
60K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
Top