The WWalking Dead-Game Thread

[genny]

---

Members do not see this ad.

Mods, can I get a couple BOXES of bullets, please?

I'd like to take a couple shots.

Did that work for you? Because asking for a bunch didn't work for me as I had hoped it would.

 

[genny]

What the heck. I want six bullets.

Why six?

 

[Skimble]

Chaos is not wolves. Mostly they are supposed to be irrelevant to the game. I know some people have gone down the rabbit hole of chaos winning over villagers, But I have been independent chaos many many times.

Chaos is for killing at night,
Wolves are for lynching,
That is my strong opinion.

Currently I’m unaware of a method to kill them at night though, unless you believe the wolves are going to be so kind as to do that for us.

 

[genny]

I'm not down to lynch KC because she hasn't done anything to set off alarm bells for me. I'm still not sure lynching a zombie would be helpful. Does it work? We don't know. Are zombies automatically chaos? No idea. So I don't have much to go off of and the fact that she hasn't weirded me out makes a tough sell for me.

With Snowy revealed as chaos and also a supposed zombie though, I'm ok voting here. We kill a non-villager with the plus of finding out what happens when a zombie is lynched. Then we can move forward and get on with our lives.

You don't want to off KC just because she's probably a zombie, but you're OK with lynching Snowy because she's probably a zombie? Am I understanding that right?

 

[jaboo]

Please explain what you would like to see from me beyond what i have already provided, which includes:
- post analysis
- night kill/event theories
- unique info contributions regarding my night results and role
- questioning many other players to get them to engage in discussion
- voting for who I think is most wolfy, with multiple explanations provided for each vote

Seriously, you are claiming I'm the person who has not contributed enough strategy to move this game forward?

...Really?

Bolded the bit that's important. That's the main reason I'm not suspecting you hardcore (yet). You know that I like discussion.

Maybe it's my my lack of experience, but you've been more aggressively questioning people this game. I remember my impression of you in MMichigan pretty well. You added to discussion, pressured people pretty casually, and were more laid back over all. You seem more... jumpy this game.

 

[genny]

Chaos is not wolves. Mostly they are supposed to be irrelevant to the game. I know some people have gone down the rabbit hole of chaos winning over villagers, But I have been independent chaos many many times.

Chaos is for killing at night,
Wolves are for lynching,
That is my strong opinion.

If the zombies are biting people and making more chaos, or more non-survivors at least, then I think we need to do something about them. I would hope that there is some chaos leader we can take out and then not have to worry about it anymore. Unless the zombies are just a ticking time bomb in the game, and we lose when they overwhelm us.

 

[genny]

lynch cray

Most feels in her direction for wolfiness right now.

 

[JustPaws]

Unless the zombies are just a ticking time bomb in the game, and we lose when they overwhelm us.

Every zombie apocalypse

 

[Animal Midwife]

Unlynch genny
Lynch Cray

 

[jaboo]

You don't want to off KC just because she's probably a zombie, but you're OK with lynching Snowy because she's probably a zombie? Am I understanding that right?

Nonononono. Let me rephrase.

Snowy was confirmed chaos. THAT alone makes me want to vote there. The added bonus to voting there is we find out what happens when we try to lynch a zombie (since everyone is so curious about that).

If we had confirmation that KC was chaos, then I'd vote there instead. Take zombie out of the equation. Snowy is the obvious choice.

 

[genny]

Every zombie apocalypse

Except TWD. If the people didn't have other people trying to kill them, they'd be just fine once they learned how to kill zombies.

 

[PippyPony]

Maybe it's my my lack of experience, but you've been more aggressively questioning people this game. I remember my impression of you in MMichigan pretty well. You added to discussion, pressured people pretty casually, and were more laid back over all. You seem more... jumpy this game.

Yes, because questioning people is the most wolfy thing ever 🙄

I will admit I'm being a little more sassy than usual right now, but that's because people are pushing my buttons a bit and I have limited time to dedicate to this because I do not have a ton of time to relax IRL.

But regardless, I think it's a real stretch to say I haven't added to discussion. If you think I haven't contributed any information or prompted any discussion, I would ask that you maybe go back and read my posts.

 

[PippyPony]

Unlynch genny
Lynch Cray

Fast swap here. What am I missing

 

[JustPaws]

Except TWD. If the people didn't have other people trying to kill them, they'd be just fine once they learned how to kill zombies.

Except when zombie hoards ran them out of perfectly good settlements. For example the farm.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Fast swap here. What am I missing

I liked genny's post.

 

[PippyPony]

Did that work for you? Because asking for a bunch didn't work for me as I had hoped it would.

I'm not sure I feel much like sharing anymore 😛

 

[bryndiana.jones]

Official Day 4 Lynch Tally: When the Dead Come Knocking
SOV (1) - Pippy
Snowy (6) - Mel, Skimble, Paws, dpmd, Jboo, Cray
KC (1) - Snowy
Skimble (1) - SOV
Cray (2) - Genny, AM

11/13

Roll call: @kcoughli and @SportPonies

Little pig, little pig. . .

lynch closes in ~3.25 hours

 

[jaboo]

Yes, because questioning people is the most wolfy thing ever 🙄

Fair point, but also I know you're a good player and I wouldn't be surprised if you used that tactic to your advantage as a wolf.

But regardless, I think it's a real stretch to say I haven't added to discussion. If you think I haven't contributed any information or prompted any discussion, I would ask that you maybe go back and read my posts.

I never said you hadn't added to discussion. I said that usually you have more insight at this point. Now that I think about it...

Pause please.

Yep, you were the seer in Michigan. I think my impression of you also includes the fact that you were seer. So maybe subtract that part about having more insight from my original read of you. I was wondering why I was thinking of you as the "all-knowing" guide to WW. That explains my stupid gut reaction about you acting off.

Backing off now.

 

[StartingoverVet]

Why six?

I got me a six shooter. Don’t want to waste ammo. That shiz is precious.

 

[Animal Midwife]

@johnnaboo You remember you've played with Pippy outside of Michigan, right?

 

[jaboo]

@johnnaboo You remember you've played with Pippy outside of Michigan, right?

Yes, but that was my first ever game and I played until almost the very end. So it sticks with me the most.

 

[StartingoverVet]

Currently I’m unaware of a method to kill them at night though, unless you believe the wolves are going to be so kind as to do that for us.

I thought we could shoot them at night. Or use the katana that HAS to be in this game or something,
I like the comment I read just before,,,”we just have to figure out HOW to kill them”.
Lynching a zombie just gets you a zombie hanging on a rope.

Ultimately the bad guys are the human baddie wolves,

 

[StartingoverVet]

Just got kicks and giggles,,

Can I get the katana oh magical item karma deliverer?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Yes, but that was my first ever game and I played until almost the very end. So it sticks with me the most.

Okay, but if you want to get a more well-rounded evaluation of Pippy's play, it's helpful to review other game interactions with her as well.

 

[genny]

I'm not sure I feel much like sharing anymore 😛

Suit yourself. 😛

 

[genny]

Just got kicks and giggles,,

Can I get the katana oh magical item karma deliverer?

If you're someone who wields a six shooter, I don't think you're capable of handling a katana.

Maybe we should all ask for knives?

 

[genny]

I just burned my pasta rereading this thread.

 

[JustPaws]

If you're someone who wields a six shooter, I don't think you're capable of handling a katana.

Maybe we should all ask for knives?

Or if someone is Michonne, THEY should ask for a katana

 

[genny]

Or if someone is Michonne, THEY should ask for a katana

That's kind of outing a role though.

 

[kaydubs]

I just burned my pasta rereading this thread.

That’s sad 🙁

 

[Skimble]

That's kind of outing a role though.

As was asking for arrows. Assuming mods told us the truth, role does not relate to affiliation.

 

[JustPaws]

That's kind of outing a role though.

True. I've been asking for my stuff in pm, though it hasn't worked for me yet.

 

[Lawpy]

I just burned my pasta rereading this thread.

*******

I'll see myself out

*******

 

[dpmd]

If you're someone who wields a six shooter, I don't think you're capable of handling a katana.

Maybe we should all ask for knives?

Worth a try. May i please have a machete?

 

[StartingoverVet]

If you're someone who wields a six shooter, I don't think you're capable of handling a katana.

Maybe we should all ask for knives?

Wasn’t sure if what you asked for had to be related to who you are. Just trying to figure out how this works.

 

[JustPaws]

Wasn’t sure if what you asked for had to be related to who you are. Just trying to figure out how this works.

Well if we all ask for several things at once, no one will know what we get!

 

[StartingoverVet]

As was asking for arrows. Assuming mods told us the truth, role does not relate to affiliation.

I don’t believe that. Too coincidental that the wolf was an obvious bad guy in the show.
Although my paranoia kicks in and then I think maybe the wolves bussed the only wolfy sounding role among them. That is going down the rabbit hole though,

 

[bryndiana.jones]

Official Day 4 Lynch Tally: When the Dead Come Knocking
SOV (1) - Pippy
Snowy (6) - Mel, Skimble, Paws, dpmd, Jboo, Cray
KC (1) - Snowy
Skimble (1) - SOV
Cray (2) - Genny, AM

11/13

Roll call: @kcoughli and @SportPonies

Little pig, little pig. . .

lynch closes in ~2 hours

 

[SportPonies]

I’m all for wolf hunting, but right now we have a confirmed chaos. Why wouldn’t you want to kill a confirmed chaos?

Did I miss something? How do we know it's confirmed chaos?

I really don't see that lynching a zombie today is the right move. However, I don't really know who else I want to lynch instead. I've been reading from mobile to and from my doc appt today, and I feel like there's been a lot of fair points everywhere, but I know someone has to be lying through their teeth.

 

[SportPonies]

Hmph.

Don't like the snowy vote, and I can maybe go for a cray vote. Her play style has seemed a little different than normal.

I really hate the idea of this lynch going to waste if zombies are unlynchable like I feel they are.

****lynch Cray****

 

[SportPonies]

To all those ammo gods, may I have some bullets?

 

[WildZoo]

***********
Hell, can I have some bullets? Everyone and their mother is asking for them, I feel like the dead deserve some ammo. Not...for an uprising or anything. Just for fun.
***********

 

[PippyPony]

@genny are these like...small, medium, or large wolfy feels?

 

[PippyPony]

I was wondering why I was thinking of you as the "all-knowing" guide to WW.

Well, because obviously I am 😎

 

[genny]

@genny are these like...small, medium, or large wolfy feels?

Small. I'd be a lot more adamant if there was anything substantial to it.

 

[KCgophervet]

Hello all. Just got caught up, get ready for quote city!

N3
Those inside the compound felt relatively safe. The holey holy bible was thrown again at its’ previous target. However, what good does a holey bible do? So, the thrower decided to launch this lovely scottish highlander cow at the intended party, thinking the extra protection would be appreciated (look at that face, who doesn’t need that!?)

More people left the compound during the night despite what happened to the last group of poor decision-makers....

A guard saw a familiar figure walking outside the compound, but it appeared her mouth was agape and she was moving with a slight limp.

Just beyond in the tree line was...wait! What was Gabriel doing outside at this hour?? The guard’s sight, not so 20/20, took aim, and missed the first shot. Their shot veered to the left, striking Gabriel in the back, ripping through his heart! They took aim again, using his last shot only to make sure Gabriel wouldn’t be turned.

The walkers frenzied toward Gabriel's near lifeless body, the first devouring the heart served in skewer form, barely clotted blood spewing, while another gnawed on his arm. If only he had his bible...Dead is @WildZoo the village protector!

In the midst of it all, @StayingPositive2017 had cleared the compound walls, rushing to the Hilltop, but she was attacked by 4 walkers along the way.

At this point I think weim could have been turned...why hasn't a village rezzer claimed?(unless they have more rezzes?) It's clearly not automatic after lynches as we were afraid.

Agreed, dislike rezzers holding back that info. But doesn't necessarily mean wolf-rez, see AM in a game that happened sometime before this game.

Uhhh so I just read the write up more closely

@kcoughli afaik you're the only one stockpiling things that could skewer people

Time for some 'splaining, I think

Yes, you caught me, I definitely wasted the only thing that might be keeping people from murdering me at night to randomly attack someone. 🙄

At the risk of people whining about this being a stereotypically sketchy request...

I might suggest seering me at some point in the near future, and frankly am somewhat confused as to why that has not happened. I've said multiple times on the thread that I have the means to protect myself from attacks at this time, so it would probably be like...helpful or something...to have a confirmed villager who can't be successfully night killed or infected (for the time being, at least).

Just like, a suggestion.

Me too. But, like, for me though.

Speaking of seering -- @Skimble has anyone looked into you? Going back to D1 you were confused as to why KC had been seered and you hadn't, iirc. Any updates on that that you would like to share?

KC has not been seered yet (that she knows of).

I would like it if someone gave me a bullet please, because Snowy and KC are chaos.

Lynch Pippy

I need a sign from above re who was seered last night

See "sign" above. PS it wasn't me. (I may have given up on subtlety #sorrynotsorry)

Major "WTF" on this one. You last minute switched a vote to a villager from chaos.
You're on my short-list for whoever might be controlling/turning the zombies. Yes I know you got attacked/infected, but if you are getting better at being sneaky, I can easily see a scenario where you'd do that to clear yourself.

As far as I knew last night, KC was saying that the arrows/bullets could be used for killing or self-protection, and people asking for items were being given items. If someone was intent on protecting themselves, they could have been asking for items, not bullets.

(Yes, now knowing that Dubz was a protector who gave me the bible the second night, I understand that the bible theory was off)

I thought AM was saving her vote to avoid the tie. Which I, for one, appreciated immensely.

@Skimble did you or did you not receive a bullet yesterday after asking?

Would also like to know the answer to this since no one seems to corroborate my story that request=receiving.

Have we confirmed requesting items actually gets you them, seemed just like a wild theory to me, If so, give me my sidearm. I will start poking holes in infected people. We gotta get rid of them.

They started showing up after weimmama was resurrected, so my theory with no evidence is she is the one making the dead army.

Gotta lynch wolves and shoot the dead IMO.

Not sure who to lynch yet....got a whole snow day to read through this and figure it out,,,but first tax time!

Agreed, this game feels off track. Also, when I requested an arrow I got one. Twice (counting the first day).

7 minutes to deadline is juuuuuuust close enough that it might not get switched back, but you can call yourself not wolfy.
Why am I bent on getting rid of non-village players? Hmmm.....
Note that I want wolves lynched, chaos night killed with the bullets.
Lol my bad I’ve been doing this all game, getting Snowy and Paws mixed up in my head.

Weim is also on that short-list for OG zombie/zombie controller.

Side note: going to be at work from 3-11 so I’ll try to check in as I can, but don’t get your hopes up.

Like, I sort of see your point with the timing of the vote, but WZ did it waaaay closer to make the tie and flipped village so... not getting the point.

I was confused why Mel would seer allieh and not me N1, since he was voicing suspicion of me on thread. I still find that weird, but he sort of explained his reason. But no, no one has looked into me yet, which is quite annoying since my name has been brought up for lynch every single day so far.


Why are you lynching pip if you know KC and snowy are chaos?

Lynch KC again


I'm inclined to believe pip did not shoot you, for reasons (I also think she's village fwiw). Also, if pip was a wolf and knew WZ was the protector, she'd know wz would likely protect you N2, so it would make no sense to go after you and not wz that night. I'm actually surprised wolves went after you at all that night since you were so likely to be protected.

I did get ammo yesterday (I spelled it amo yesterday for reasons.)

Rude, but thanks for the confirmation of my info-share yesterday.

1. I didn't say I was the only one. Just the only one who was ready to (which apparently SOV is ready to as well)
2.Because I did not understand the mechanic, but now I do.



Unlynch Pippy

Okay "for reasons" was what I was looking for. I know what your "for reasons" are.
Lynching Pippy cuz I thought she was a wolf and because up until now I thought that Zombies/chaos could only be killed by bullets.
I know Snowy is chaos and am extrapolating that KC is. I'd rather see Snowy go first.

Lynch Snowy

Snowy and I are not the same person. Don't lump us. I have no idea why you chose to seer her over me, unless you were assuming someone would shoot me (which in retrospect is fair because I thought the same thing).

Ok, FINE! But I'd like to see KC go too.

Um, still rude.

Wrong, afaik.

Dubz's protection -- to my knowledge -- was not the Bible. My night results were suggestive of a heavenly presence watching over me, and it was quite obvious that it was not item-based.

Doesn't it say right in the write up that it was the Bible? IDK Pipsqueak, sounds sketch. Or maaaaybe the mods were still getting their **** together N1 and a lot of results from that night don't make a lot of sense?! 🙄

Testing a theory based on a conversation I had with mods earlier.
May I have more ammo please?

Hasn't this been discussed ad nauseum?

Do you know how confusing this write up is? I chose to live not turn, but I'm not mentioned anywhere here. Also, wondering about Kc not dying? Lynch avoidance? I mean it could just be RNG too.

Allie was probably trying to take mel out before he took her out. That was my guess.

... Now do we think that kc can be killed? Because I think we should try without a tie. I'd be down for genny if we think lynching won't work on her.

Yeah ok sure. Now I have lynch avoidance. Or maybe the tie decider was a series of questions Rick famously asks people in the show and greeny wasn't even on to answer them so I won by default. Of course I can be killed, that fact hasn't changed from the get-go. I'd just prefer not to be because I'd rather, idk, hunt wolves?

Don't know how I missed this today in write up and this post by pippy.

@kcoughli have you responded to this?

I had not yet at the time, but now I have!

Okay not going to be around the rest of the game to defend myself. Lynch me if you need to, it won't help village numbers. But if you need to test out all the infected persons are zombies theory, I would rather see kc lynched because she's the infected one that nothing makes sense (mod error, then was healed, WZ skewered).

That being said.

Lynch kc

You make no sense. But chaos isn't my priority.

So taxes took all freaking day, old grumpy man is grumpy, no time to re read whole thread.
I have read today’s discussion,

Stop lynching the dead/infected. They do not count as players it appears. Shoot the crap out of them overnight. Or ignore them (but I think that is a mistake),

Let’s lynch wolves. Some people trying to distract us with lynch8ng the dead are probably wolves.

Therefore...

Lynch Skimble

I don't remember why I quoted this. I think I meant to "like" it.

I can get behind that i suppose since they apparently lied about their choice
Lynch snowy

Who lied about what choice??

Mods, can I get a couple BOXES of bullets, please?

I'd like to take a couple shots.

My quiver full of arrows request was denied (I got a single arrow).

What the heck. I want six bullets.

See above.

I'm not sure I feel much like sharing anymore 😛

Hah, me again.

Just got kicks and giggles,,

Can I get the katana oh magical item karma deliverer?

Oooo I also would like a katana!

As was asking for arrows. Assuming mods told us the truth, role does not relate to affiliation.

Daryl is a villager. (and is also me). And my bold move did not pay out so well for me in the end so I don't blame people for not going that route.

 

[PippyPony]

Doesn't it say right in the write up that it was the Bible? IDK Pipsqueak, sounds sketch. Or maaaaybe the mods were still getting their **** together N1 and a lot of results from that night don't make a lot of sense?! 🙄

I wasn't disputing the bible claim in terms of it existing -- I'm just saying that I know for a fact that was not the style of protection I received on N1, and I am about 98% certain Dubz protected me. So, I am just saying that as far as my limited knowledge goes, the Bible did not come from Dubz.

No one else has stepped up to say they were protected the way I was, though, so perhaps the mechanism of Dubz's role changed somehow between N1 & N2.

I'm not sure exactly how relevant it is, though, unless we think Mel is sketchball.

And on that front, I can tell you that if he doesn't get attacked again at some point soon, I will likely be taking a harder look there again.

 

[PippyPony]

FWIW, I do find it interesting that KC and maybe a few others (SOV, I think...?) are claiming that ammo can be used offensively.

I asked mods this evening if I could use my weapon to attack, and they said no.

Not necessarily even suggesting it's wolfy -- maybe it varies based on character or something. I can say that from what I have glanced at online about my character while I've been procrastinating, attacking proactively might not be a good fit.

 

[genny]

FWIW, I do find it interesting that KC and maybe a few others (SOV, I think...?) are claiming that ammo can be used offensively.

I asked mods this evening if I could use my weapon to attack, and they said no.

Not necessarily even suggesting it's wolfy -- maybe it varies based on character or something. I can say that from what I have glanced at online about my character while I've been procrastinating, attacking proactively might not be a good fit.

One of the first things I asked. It's part of why I said I believed you when you said you didn't shoot at Mel. Not sure it varies based on character.

 

[KCgophervet]

I suppose I should vote for someone here. Of the people on the board:
SOV - Not going to vote here, he's at least trying to wolf hunt
Snowy - I could vote here, it's probably where I'll land as a known chaos, but it bothers me the lack of wolf hunting that is happening so part of me wants to not on principle. Of course, her voting for me makes me want to...
KC - super village read, like I can't even right now
Skimblary - I could vote here, she seems kind of aggressive and willfully ignoring things on thread/being oddly cryptic. Also don't like that her "for reasons" was apparently enough information for Mel when my "for reasons" was not. Annoying, though not necessarily wolfy.
Cray - the fact that Cray has been off my radar is weirdly concerning to me. As far as who on this list is most wolfy, I'd say Cray just because she's not screaming wolf to me (because she always does when she's a villager...)