There's a WW in Michigan Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
**********
The Dead's D12 Lynch Tally

mixy (1) - sporty
vmh () -
Sporty (1) - Mixy

:heckyeah: A Tie! :heckyeah:

2/4

Deadline in 8.5 hours

@Karabiner13
dempsey-celebrates.w1120.h624.gif

**********
 
Last edited:
I have to admit I feel like mixy and sporty are misunderstanding each other. On the other hand, someone has to be the wolf.

The timing of Sporty’s question/answer is a little odd, but I’m not sure what the significance of that is, if any.

Mixy, I have to admit I didn’t understand a lot of your reasoning at the end of that post. In all honesty, pretty much everything you posted last night was super sketchy, or at least really odd, and I’d have been voting for you today if I could figure out any way BBC going down would benefit you as a wolf. But I can’t, lol, so I’m still going to wait and see what VMH has to say before I decide what to do.
 
The reason I got the answer from the travel guide was because the mods neglected to send out the items that day until very late at night. I had already went to bed, and they said they were giving us an extension on items that day for that reason.

The fact Mixy's not been questioning me all game and is now retaliatory voting against me, despite questioning vmh earlier... bit ridiculous.
 
I'm gonna guess that mixy voted for BBC to buy credit as a villager. It's relatively low risk at end game like this, in my opinion. Bus a wolf, no one will question you (hopefully), and then you can make it to the end of the game just by killing a few more people under the radar.
 
The fact Mixy's not been questioning me all game and is now retaliatory voting against me, despite questioning vmh earlier... bit ridiculous.
Promise it's not a retaliatory vote.Given enough info I'd vote for someone else. Also you've been on my radar a few times, yesterday included. You've been relatively flying under everyone's radar.
 
I'm gonna guess that mixy voted for BBC to buy credit as a villager. It's relatively low risk at end game like this, in my opinion. Bus a wolf, no one will question you (hopefully), and then you can make it to the end of the game just by killing a few more people under the radar.
I've voted BBC at least once before last night. Again if I was wolf I think it's pretty neglect to leave the supposed tracker alive when you're the only one left.
 
I've voted BBC at least once before last night. Again if I was wolf I think it's pretty neglect to leave the supposed tracker alive when you're the only one left.
Then why did you switch to Sporty? By this you are implying that you suspect VMH?
 
Then why did you switch to Sporty? By this you are implying that you suspect VMH?
Only suspect of VMH because why would the last wolf leave the tracker alive? Maybe they just happened to live (see reason KC killed) or maybe they're lying about their role. Depending on what VMH says when they get on depends on if they stay unlynched. Switched to Sporty because why would you kill KC and not VMH unless you wanted the one person gone who was throwing shade on you the day before.
 
Only suspect of VMH because why would the last wolf leave the tracker alive? Maybe they just happened to live (see reason KC killed) or maybe they're lying about their role. Depending on what VMH says when they get on depends on if they stay unlynched. Switched to Sporty because why would you kill KC and not VMH unless you wanted the one person gone who was throwing shade on you the day before.
Wtf is this defense
 
giphy.gif

First of all, I honest to god can't believe I'm still alive. I didn't even check my mod PM until just now because I was so sure I was going to be killed last night because it's completely ridiculous to leave me alive at this stage in the game.

And, that being said, it was a huge mistake for the wolves to leave me alive. I'm sure you're hoping to generate enough heat on me to get me lynched tonight, mixy, but I saw the little rendezvous you had with KC last night and I have to say... it's not looking pretty for you right now.

Lynch mixy

Also buckle your seatbelts, kids, I've got a lot of things to respond to here.
 
giphy.gif

First of all, I honest to god can't believe I'm still alive. I didn't even check my mod PM until just now because I was so sure I was going to be killed last night because it's completely ridiculous to leave me alive at this stage in the game.

And, that being said, it was a huge mistake for the wolves to leave me alive. I'm sure you're hoping to generate enough heat on me to get me lynched tonight, mixy, but I saw the little rendezvous you had with KC last night and I have to say... it's not looking pretty for you right now.

Lynch mixy

Also buckle your seatbelts, kids, I've got a lot of things to respond to here.
I don't trust you either, for the record haha
 
I swear I should just get an RNG to vote. I have no idea what to do.
 
Final Day 1 Lynch Tally
kc (2) - Cray, jboo
DVMD (1) - Sporty
Coop (1) - SoFlo
greeney (3) - Fern, Kara, KC
Fern (2) - vmh, genny
Pippy
(1) - FTB
3m
(1) - Snowy
Jil () -
Teep (1) - allie
SoFlo
(1) - kata
dy (1) - staff
allie
(1) - lyra
Cray
(1) - cowgirl
Sporty (1) - 3m
FTB
(2) - Pippy, Paws
Snowy (1) - Mel, DVMD
staff (3) - dy, AM, Coop

FINAL D2 Lynch Tally
Snowy () -
allie (8) - kc, Paws, jboo, Lyra, Jil, LeTits, DVMD, Sporty
cowgirl (1) - Teep
Mel (2) - cowgirl, SoFlo
Cray
(2) - Kara, Snowy
Coop
(1) - dy
staff (7) - genny, Coop, vmh, allie, Mel, AM, FTB
SoFlo
(2) - Fern, kata
dy (1) – staff

Final Day 3 Lynch Tally

staff () -
SoFlo (3) - Lyra, kata, Fern
Mel (2) - Sporty, Jil
Cray (9) - Kara, Coop, Pippy, jboo, Paws, 3m, DVMD, Snowy, Cray
Pippy
() -
genny (2) - kc, vmh
kc (1) - FTB
Coop
(1) - SoFlo
FTB
(2) - cowgirl, genny
Snowy
(2) - Mel, AM

LUNCH OVER, DESSERT MENU PENDING
Final Tally D4

SoFlo (5) - Mel, Fern, Lyra, Mixed, Jil
Paws (2) - Kara, AM
FTB (8) - Paws, jboo, kc, cowgirl, Pippy, vmh, Coop, DVMD
cowgirl () -
Lyra () -
Sporty (2) - kata, 3m
kata
(1) – Snowy

Unofficial Day 5 Remember the Robin Lynch Tally
Paws (4) - AM, kata, Pip, snowy
CheezyD (11) - Mixed, Sporty, Jil, Coop, BBC, Paws, kc, meats, jboo, 3m, staff
staff
(1) - Cheez
SoFlo (2) - Lyra, cowgirl

Lynch Closed. Sults Pending.
Final Tally D6

Paws (2) - AM, DVMD
AM (9) - kc, Paws, Mixed, Lyra, jboo, Coop, Jil, vmh, Sporty
Lyra (5) - Snowy, Fern, kata, 3m, cowgirl

Unofficial Finn-doesn't-wanna-go-back-a-page Lynch Tally D7
Paws (7) -
Sporty, kata, Lyra, jboo, DVMD, vmh, Fern, jil
DVMD
() -
jboo (1) - Coop
Lyra
(4) - Mixy, kc, cowgirl, 3m
vmh (1) -
SP () -
Cowgirl (1) – paws

The Dead's Day 8 Lynch Tally
Jil (1) - DVMD
Coop (8) - jboo, kata, Fern, Lyra, cowgirl, Sporty, kc, Mixy
cowgirl () -
jboo (1) - Coop
vmh (1) – Jil

Offishul D9 Lynch Tally Merry Christmas!
jboo (3) - DVMD, 3m, kcough
bbc/fern (3) - jil, mixy, Lyra
Lyra (5) - sporty, jboo, cowgirl, bbc, vmh

The Dead's D10 Lynch Tally
jboo (2) - sporty, 3m
BBC (3) - jil, mixy, cowgirl
Cowgirl ()
KCough () -
3m (4) - kc, jboo, vmh, bbc
jil () -

The Dead's D11 Lynch Tally
jboo (3)
- vmh, kcough, cowgirl
Bbc (3) - sporty, jboo, mixy

I left BBC as orange since they were convert. One wolf remains. Believe me or not I am village rezzed the same as in death.

Do we know if BBC was the convert? I read it as original? I’m confused???

Pretty sure that means villager wolf...why you ask me? I'm new too 🙄
I have a suspicion BBC wasn't the convert and I have another suspicion that this is exactly why you're suddenly so adamant she was

Also, again with the suggestive color coding here. Do you know how hard this makes it to analyze your own votes since you colored them all green?

My head feels like it's gonna explode from sinus pressure, but basically, I don't see anything that indicates BBC was the convert. I think mixy gave up more than she should know.
I agree here but for different reasons. I think mixy is claiming BBC as the convert to mask herself as the actual convert. Get village to look for an original that doesn't actually exist, you know?
 
I thought vanilla meant she was once village b/c vanillager. Then cowgirl pointed out vanilla also means no roles. Hence blind leading blind.


First of all it'd be stupid to nail the only other wolf then leave the supposed tracker alive. Which concerns me why they didn't die. If I was the only wolf left I'd want the tracker dead. So for tonight
Lynch VMH
ETA: Could also go for SP, because the wolf killed KC who was suspicious of them and would be following the pattern of killing Jill who was onto Fern. Will decide for sure tomorrow dependent on VMH tracking answer and more discussion.
This is an incredibly easy set up to make, although a risky one that backfired hugely for you here. Of course everyone is suspicious of the tracker who's been around way too long - but that's the idea, isn't it? I'm sure you were hoping that even if I do come onto thread with results tracking you doing the kill that you could generate enough doubt about me beforehand to lead the village to a bad lynch in a lylo situation. Especially with all of the hedgey "If I were a wolf I definitely would have done X instead of Y, so obviously I'm not a wolf or there'd be different decision making here". This is compounded by the backup hedging that you could just vote SP instead (pending my tracking results and whether they were good for you or not) because the KC kill set it up.

Seems village with the questions, but from my experience the travel guide only gave answers at night. SP had travel guide in am and got answers 2 hours later, still in the morning...this seems fishy unless someone else has experience with the travel guide working differently?

Sounds like an innocent villager statement, but could be paranoid wolf with only 2 left.

Is talking about Fern.

Dislikes where vote is because fellow wolf will be going down but doesn't move it out of suspicion?

Previously suggests BBC was convert, but subtly hints here that they know more than they're letting on by projecting onto me.

I know I seem sketch and a great wolf option, but village will lose if I go down (although I'm totally willing to go down in a tie if it means getting the last wolf). I am also 100% noob with my statement about BBC determining with cowgirl if they were original or convert. I think I somewhat figured out wolf end game which is partly why I'm still alive at the end. With one wolf left they killed KC who was most suspicious of them yesterday keeping in the pattern of killing Jil who was suspicious of Fern and set up jboo by killing DVMD which is why they felt comfortable killing Jil since the frame didn't work the first time. However, during yesterday's lynch VMH suggested me. This is why VMH is still alive because they figured with enough doubt thrown on me VMH would be busy tracking me and therefore didn't have to worry about being tracked. This is also why I was called wolf voting for BBC in an "attempt to save a wolf." Then when BBC flipped wolf they retracted their statement only to throw shade on me again after being nooby about BBC. Also if VMH did track me and clears me then that leaves SP and cowgirl to choose from making it a 50/50 shot they will win the game. Hope to hear from VMH soon. Although if they say they tracked me and I came up dirty consider yourselves warned you should lynch VMH at that point. However this was all bugging me last night so sorry for the word vomit this morning. Also not considering cowgirl because I believe SP thinks she's noob village and she hasn't really done anything to set off suspicion at all.
With all that said until I hear from VMH otherwise:
unlynch VMH, lynch Sporty
I think you're failing to acknowledge that you tied things up with, like, two minutes left in lynch. A lot of this suspicion generation of sporty is reaching at best and really, you're trying awfully hard here. You're even flipping sporty's own accusations against you around so they somehow make sporty suspicious instead of you.

I also like the offer of going down in a tie. Many games have been won by wolves who switched votes in a tie at the stroke of midnight and I'm not surprised at all that you'd be willing to "go down in a tie". I think it's not your intention at all to let the lynch close that way.

And, of course, I love the bolded here. Hedging your bets against the possibility I saw some dirty deeds last night?
 
I have to admit I feel like mixy and sporty are misunderstanding each other. On the other hand, someone has to be the wolf.

The timing of Sporty’s question/answer is a little odd, but I’m not sure what the significance of that is, if any.

Mixy, I have to admit I didn’t understand a lot of your reasoning at the end of that post. In all honesty, pretty much everything you posted last night was super sketchy, or at least really odd, and I’d have been voting for you today if I could figure out any way BBC going down would benefit you as a wolf. But I can’t, lol, so I’m still going to wait and see what VMH has to say before I decide what to do.
I've been trying to work that out too and I have to wonder if it was some sort of attempt to get credit for wolf lynching. Previous ties in this game I think were resolved with RNG so mixy may have been hoping to either generate village goodwill if jboo went down ("look, I tried to tie it because I just knew she was village!") or if bbc went down ("look, I'm the one who tied it on that wolf!"). Either way, buys mixy enough time to take us to lylo - and, of course, doesn't hurt that even with the "kill everyone" approach to ties it still brought wolves to lylo. It's really a win/win situation here.
I'm gonna guess that mixy voted for BBC to buy credit as a villager. It's relatively low risk at end game like this, in my opinion. Bus a wolf, no one will question you (hopefully), and then you can make it to the end of the game just by killing a few more people under the radar.
^^^
 
I've voted BBC at least once before last night. Again if I was wolf I think it's pretty neglect to leave the supposed tracker alive when you're the only one left.
And? I'm pretty sure every wolf in this game has voted for at least one other wolf before this point. Honestly I would almost feel like you were more village if you had never voted for a wolf than if you had, it's simply decent wolf strategy to vote for teammates so voting records don't look horrible in end game.
Only suspect of VMH because why would the last wolf leave the tracker alive? Maybe they just happened to live (see reason KC killed) or maybe they're lying about their role. Depending on what VMH says when they get on depends on if they stay unlynched. Switched to Sporty because why would you kill KC and not VMH unless you wanted the one person gone who was throwing shade on you the day before.
Again, feels like lots of shade generation here.
 
I have a suspicion BBC wasn't the convert and I have another suspicion that this is exactly why you're suddenly so adamant she was

Also, again with the suggestive color coding here. Do you know how hard this makes it to analyze your own votes since you colored them all green?


I agree here but for different reasons. I think mixy is claiming BBC as the convert to mask herself as the actual convert. Get village to look for an original that doesn't actually exist, you know?
Again. Blind noob leading blind. See my post about my noobness that should be forshamed.
ETA: screw my phone. I need my computer.
 
Lynch Mixy
Because there is too much that has been weird for the past few days, lynch votes not withstanding. I've been wrong on this before, but I don't have much else to go on. As a random aside, what is lylo?
 
I still want to know who VMH tracked...I'm ok going down. Can't wait to "Told you so in 45 minutes"
I'm honestly trying to figure out what game you're playing over here. For what it's worth I was actually convinced kcough was the convert so I tracked her and got a message about you visiting her last night. Same message as I got when I tracked Dy killing teep
 
I'm honestly trying to figure out what game you're playing over here. For what it's worth I was actually convinced kcough was the convert so I tracked her and got a message about you visiting her last night. Same message as I got when I tracked Dy killing teep
Ah thanks, although I'm confused as to why you didn't track me directly considering you wanted to lynch me yesterday. Also way to flip on your pm partner like that starting the lynch that got them killed. (Dead be prepared for the gifs to flood in 36 minutes)
Unlynch Sporty, Lynch VMH
 
**********
The Dead's D12 Lynch Tally

mixy (3) - sporty, vmh, cowgirl
vmh (1) - mixy
Sporty ()-

4/4

Deadline in 25 minutes
*********
Edit: dang ninja'd
 
Ah thanks, although I'm confused as to why you didn't track me directly considering you wanted to lynch me yesterday. Also way to flip on your pm partner like that starting the lynch that got them killed. (Dead be prepared for the gifs to flood in 36 minutes)
Unlynch Sporty, Lynch VMH
Dude, PM partners aren't a blood bond or something. It's WW, a game of paranoia, and some things didn't add up that made me suspicious enough of jboo to pursue a lynch there yesterday. Did you never lynch a single one of your PM partners all game?
 
Also why does no one else find VMH being alive still not wierd? Also if I was a wolf why would I have brought this much attention to myself?
I'm just giving you a hard time VMH, because I did lynch coop, but only after it was way gone.
Guess I know how to play wolf now for future reference.
 
Dead is @MixedAnimals77 - South Manitou Island, a villager

Bet you thought this game was over but it is now Night 12. 3 players remain. Deadline for actions is 1 am EST but please get them in ASAP so we can get a wrap on this game that has gone on far too long.

Upper Peninsula “The Yoopers”
9. @vetmedhead

Mackinac Bridge “Mighty Mac”
14. @cowgirl92
16. @SportPonies

Lower Peninsula “The Trolls”
The trolls have moved out

Out of Service
Permanently disconnected

Hell, Michigan
17. greeneyegal92 - Buckeyes
22. allieh8607 - Lake Erie
5. Teepster87 - The Henry Ford
8. dyachei - Construction
15. Crayola227 - Bronner's Christmas Wonderland
1. genny - Tart Cherry
2. fromthebox - Lake Superior
20. Karabiner13 - American Robin
12. Melchizedek - Lake Ontario
25. staff_wielder - Motown
3. SoFloGryffindor - Presque Isle Park
13. PippyPony - North Manitou Island (formerly Lake Michigan)
19. Animal Midwife - Up North
23. SnowshoeDog143 - Michigan Wolverines
27. StayingPositive2017 - Michigan Left
6. Coopah - Apple Blossom
21. katashark - Mackinac Island
28. LyraGardenia - Canada
11. DVMDream - Tahquamenon Falls
7. mmmdreamerz - Michigan State Spartans
18. Jilary - Ann Arbor
10. johnnaboo - White-Tailed Deer
26. TheGirlWithTheFernTattoo - Snow
24. kcoughli - Sleeping Bear Dunes
4. MixedAnimals77 - South Manitou Island (formerly Sault Ste Marie, MI)
 
Top