There's a WW in Michigan Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
I'm no expert, but in the Sega game Jilary did something similar, claiming to be Knuckles, which was the perfect mix between something the mods would probably not have used bc it's not a main player and something that would cause doubt for some people. I feel the same about Lake Erie.

I could be wrong, but that's my two cents there.

ETA: Jil was a wolf in that case.
Umm, Knuckles is not really a minor character at all! I know nothing about most video games, and even I know knuckles.
The issue I have with this is that Lake Erie is a risky role claim to make. She already knew there were other lakes in play, so the chances of someone else having the role is higher than the chance of someone having Knuckles.

Still possible the mods gave it to her as a cover role, and I've not played a finn game before (I don't think), and apparently that's something she's done in the past. So that I can believe. I don't find it as likely that she just downright pulled the role out of her butt and hoped no one else had it.
But what if it's not a cover role at all and it's just a wolfy role?
Little Lake Erie is the smallest Great Lake in depth and only beats Lake Ontario in surface area... but it is the 11th largest in the world. You are a vanillager.
I have a hard time believing this is your entire role pm.
 
Not cool to sit there not saying anything and then pull that stunt with a "trust me" type of move 5 minutes before close.
I wasn't trying to make it last minute! She JUST gave us the wording of her role which makes me believe her v.s. getting it second hand what her role was from someone else.
 
Allieh, if you flip wolf, here's a hint for the future. I would have done something like:

Little Lake Erie is the smallest Great Lake in depth and only beats Lake Ontario in surface area... but it is the 11th largest in the world. [... more boring stuff]

... and left people to draw their own conclusions.

So, are you a wolf?
I guess you'll have to wait and see!


I set aside my difference in opinion on the "greatness" of Michigan for this game but I just have to say, Go Buckeyes! It's 9:57pm and *ichigan still sucks 😛
 
I guess you'll have to wait and see!


I set aside my difference in opinion on the "greatness" of Michigan for this game but I just have to say, Go Buckeyes! It's 9:57pm and *ichigan still sucks 😛
It was 9:59 when you posted. I see Ohio schools are still not teaching you how to read a clock.
 
Umm, Knuckles is not really a minor character at all! I know nothing about most video games, and even I know knuckles.

But what if it's not a cover roll at all and it's just a wolfy role?

Definitely a possibility, just didn't think it was necessarily the most likely of all the options. Didn't really expect Michigan to have a very strong opinion about a lake.


You know this actually happened in telenova... different mods wrote different roles and included different info so the roles looked different
I just feel like all the wording of all the lake roles would be the same, ya know?
 
Well, it’s nice to know I’m not the only one that has no idea what is going on?!?
 
I'm sorry but there are three mods. None of you were willing to do a lynch tally? Is this a rule thing I don't know? That mods don't have to tally if they don't want to?
Dude, it's not their job to produce updated tallies at our whim, check yourself
 
I'm sorry but there are three mods. None of you were willing to do a lynch tally? Is this a rule thing I don't know? That mods don't have to tally if they don't want to?
Uh pretty sure I don't have to do anything if I don't want to.

Can't expect me to keep up with a wafflefest on my phone. Sorry not sorry.
 
Wasn't it also a rule to not post between lynch close and write-up like, not that long ago?
Man, things are falling apart these days...

No, actually. That's more a newer thing. And even then it's more often been "don't post strategy" between close / write-up.

But historically, that rule hasn't really been a thing.
 
Top