Elaborating further -- curious that you would assume I came back powerless when someone was fishing for info about that.
In my role flair I bring back my two dead kids as islands. I have no idea if you'd come back with or without powers. I mostly was banking on you having results from the night you died (plus being the first villager that died and generally being active and a good player).
How do you know for sure I was only redirected last night?
And I have repeatedly encouraged you all to lynch us after dealing with originals. Don't even have to hunt for converts if you're so certain we are the droids you're looking for.
Literally did not know or care if you came back with or without powers. I somewhat assumed based on mod flair and the fact I got two rezzes to mean you'd come back vanilla.
Mmmk not sure I buy that
Is this directed at me?
I know I'm new, but a wolf is a wolf. If I think you (which I already said I don't) or LIS replacement are wolves I should lynch there. Especially if I'm having trouble figuring out who else is a wolf. How many original wolves do we think are left anyways?
I thought it was pretty obvious from d2 the redirector was a wolf.
Depends on the mod.
You should not lynch rezzes purely off of weak mechanics speculation at the expense of actually looking for wolves via solid wolf hunting tactics like post analysis. Super duper wolfy thing to do, actually. Congratulations, as of this morning you have shot up my sketch list after not even being on it.
Hang on, so in your scenario I'm a wolf, who was told by another wolf that you're powerless, and together we decided to redirect you??
Ooh! I know it! I know it!
This feels so wolfy to me. Can we please Lynch mel now?
Definitely does not count as tunneling yet -- I've only been questioning you for about 30 minutes. Come back to me in 6 hours 😛
I didn't. And I explained why then as well. They were using the same tactics Crayola did in the game she took out or exposed basically the entire wolf pack.
Redirecting people who you suspect of having a power role is kinda stupid imo. You are limiting the function of those roles. Which are, like, important roles. Hence why they are called power roles.
Is it protection? Because I've still seen zero evidence of that existing based off of night results.
Trust me I 110% agree. But I've seen it used that way previously by non wolf noobs to insane effect so...
Nope. I think from my voting pattern, it’s pretty obvious I’ve thought mel was a wolf from d2, just no one else seems to agree.
There is something I am toying around with in my mind, which is that perhaps there is actually no redirector at all and it is just my role mechanic to kick back onto a villager when I seer a wolf.
That he knew pips role and she was hit with two wolf abilities, seems like excess considering on thread it was just known she had an ability. The next day when cowgirl outed that info, he made a big fanfare about not knowing pips ability, it wasn’t until after pip came back that he clarified that he didn’t know her ability until after he posted on thread that she shouldn’t be lynched. And now that last post, the last line about his reads being crap this game just doesn’t feel genuine to me. It feels like a wolf going “golly jeepers guys, I just haven’t been finding wolves well this game.”
I definitely think dy was lying about being redirected.
Here is that info in case anyone can translate it:
This checks out, btw, for anyone who cares. My role name did swap. My night result messaging, however, has remained consistent with the Lake Michigan role.
Is there a scale of reliability on this?? That seems kind of ridiculous. Whats the point of these roles if you can't even trust that they work
Lol
response in different thread cuz its not game related
For all of you, I have a strong suspicion to boot Mel today also after item use yesterday in which results could not be found for Mel. So unless there is strong evidence against....
Could you tell us more about this item? I mean I’m certainly ready to lynch him, but I’d like a little more explanation too.
Sure, the handmap could not detect his location. Per the 2 previous wolves dy was construction which is not a location while greeny was buckeyes which although represents Ohio is not a location.
Didn't like what was going on with Pippy earlier; seemed like tunneling and her insistence on not chasing conversions has started to put me off and make me worried.
True, I forgot they were not locations either. However, Mel was very interested in who had the hand map yesterday for some reason. Somethings are sketch about everything that went on with pippy and such, but FTB before death seemed to think Mel was worth more investigating leaning toward lynching.
We are wrong sometimes, but it just adds to suspicion as clearly before others were all for lynching Mel and some still feel that way.
I'm not sure if this is even still an issue, but I'm not sure why this was such a red flag for you. FWIW, I actually took how you worded that message to mean you were rezzed with powers (although possibly not the same ones). And yes, I realize that's easy to say now in my defense, but its true nevertheless. And my offer to role reveal in our PM still stands, if you have serious concerns about me being a wolf.
Just going to remind you that you really enjoy tunneling me when I am a villager these days. Exhibit A: last game.
