There's a WW in Michigan Game Thread

[cowgirl92]

---

Members do not see this ad.

Super SEERious Biz Tracker

Paws (2) - AM,Lyra
Lyra (1) - SP
AM (2) - SP, Mixey

Ok, I will roll the dice on these. Pretty sure I'll be redirected or dead anyways so is probably a moot point, but oh well haha

If I’m not too late, I’ll vote AM
Edit to say I was too late.

 

[finnickthedog]

Dead is @PippyPony - North Manitou Island, a villager who could attempt to seer a player each night

It is now Day 6. 16 players remain. Lynch deadline is 10 pm EST.

Upper Peninsula “The Yoopers”
4. @MixedAnimals77
7. @mmmdreamerz
9. @vetmedhead
10. @johnnaboo

Mackinac Bridge “Mighty Mac”
11. @DVMDream
14. @cowgirl92
16. @SportPonies

Lower Peninsula “The Trolls”
18. @Jilary
19. @Animal Midwife
21. @katashark
23. @SnowshoeDog143
24. @kcoughli
26. @TheGirlWithTheFernTattoo
27. @StayingPositive2017

Out of Service
6. @Coopah
28. @LyraGardenia

Hell, Michigan
17. greeneyegal92 - Buckeyes
22. allieh8607 - Lake Erie
5. Teepster87 - The Henry Ford
8. dyachei - Construction
15. Crayola227 - Bronner's Christmas Wonderland
1. genny - Tart Cherry
2. fromthebox - Lake Superior
20. Karabiner13 - American Robin
12. Melchizedek - Lake Ontario
25. staff_wielder - Motown
3. SoFloGryffindor - Presque Isle Park
13. PippyPony - North Manitou Island (formerly Lake Michigan)

 

[PippyPony]

**********
And a hush falls over the lake

Good luck village 🙂
**********

 

[Skimble]

Just got home, I’m still on page 43, but skimmed ahead and saw mel was a wolf. Thank freaking goodness!! I knew something wasn’t right with him. Ok, I’ve got to get some sleep now, I’ll catch up on the 7 pages I missed tomorrow.

 

[TheGirlWithTheFernTattoo]

I have quite a few thoughts about what went down after I left for work today, but alas it is midnight and I work in 5 hours. So those thoughts will be unsaid as I currently choose to sleep instead.

 

[Coopah]

Ok landed a little bit ago, I don't know whether to be happier mel's dead or staff lol.

N00blet I miss you...

So either AM or paws. Anybody wanna go for a tie?! 😀

 

[TheGirlWithTheFernTattoo]

Ok landed a little bit ago, I don't know whether to be happier mel's dead or staff lol.

N00blet I miss you...

So either AM or paws. Anybody wanna go for a tie?! 😀

Seriously, knock it off about Staff. He was participating in PM with me and was avoiding thread because he didn't want to get ripped apart. No need to be a dick.

 

[Coopah]

Also ya did good pip. I think we need a three way ... tie

 

[Coopah]

Seriously, knock it off about Staff. He was participating in PM with me and was avoiding thread because he didn't want to get ripped apart. No need to be a dick.

I'm sorry I don't mean to be a dick, probs shouldn't be rage posting. You're right I'd hate it if I were a noob and someone was ripping me apart. I'll try to be better. Staff for future games I know being a target can be frustrating but try to use logic. I apologize

 

[SnowshoeDog143]

Well I'm willing to go the dvmd route and test pippy's theory. Though the likelyhood of two unseerable wolves is probably low. But she is claiming vanilla I could see her as a convert...

I used the map on lyra and it said it returns the result as an error because it can't pinpoint her location. Based on that lake ontario wasn't in michigan and was a wolf and posting restriction can be a wolf ability I want to test out this canada is a wolf theory.

lynch lyra

 

[mmmdreamerz]

I could go for either DVMD or Lyra. Pippy's results definitely implied something with Mel, though I do wonder about the likelihood of two unseerable wolves.

Anyone know how Michigans feel about Canada? Lol. It's not Michigan so given their dislike of a lake that isn't there's I'm inclined to think more wolfy-feels from that.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Anyone know how Michigans feel about Canada? Lol. It's not Michigan so given their dislike of a lake that isn't there's I'm inclined to think more wolfy-feels from that.

I'm saying chaos at most.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Ok landed a little bit ago, I don't know whether to be happier mel's dead or staff lol.

N00blet I miss you...

So either AM or paws. Anybody wanna go for a tie?! 😀

This is ridiculous Coop. It's pretty obvious who it is.

 

[SportPonies]

Can someone explain to me why Paws is sketchy? I think I missed that somewhere.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Can someone explain to me why Paws is sketchy? I think I missed that somewhere.

She dodged Kara's questions or gave late answers up until her death.

 

[MixedAnimals77]

Pssst. Lake Ontario is still part of Michigan. More so than Canada is.

If Ontario is actually an issue, then you need to lynch Canada first.

When looking at the game map on pg.1 Canada is more closely an option than Lake Ontario. Not saying she was wrong as completing the lakes makes sense. However, I have less inclination to lynch Canada since everyone in Canada is "friendly." Not discounting the discrepancy, but not who I think we should be concerned with currently.

I thought Jil might be interested in voting with me today, since she's also unsure about Paws. But it seems Mel is still the main tunnel.

This feels odd. Why try and recruit someone when Mel was clearly going down? An attempt to flip the vote and ride the waffle train?

I just really want us to actually net a wolf today.

Really just wants to net an actual wolf, but did not celebrate persay when we lynched Mel, still on the Paws train.

Why are you on Mel then?

Questioning others to hopefully push them off the Mel lynch.

Also, I will state I am in this to win. Not to lynch as many people as possible.

This sounds wolfy. Obviously everyone is in this to win it, so why state it. There are strengths in numbers as villagers of wolves so of course no one wants to lynch as many people as possible for no reason.

How is AM the only one catching on to the inconsistencies coming out of Staff's mouth?

Mel is coming to defend AM (he became more defensive the more people pressured him). Obviously Staff was having a hard time, but was most definitely village we discovered.

I'm sorry. I didn't want it to be true.

Now apologizing for leading us astray? Sounds more purposeful to me than by accident. Also "didn't want it to be true" the fact Mel was a wolf and he was going down?

*squints*

No. I'm squinting because you're wolfy.

Still strongly after Paws even after Mel flipped wolf. Not saying Paws isn't wolf, but AM is so die hard on Paws I feel like they are trying a bit to hard to direct everyone here.

I guess my like was missed. There is no protector.

Based on things happening to Pippy.

That's weird to me.

I guess we'll see tonight then.

All of these are in reference to a protector. Maybe I missed the source of why AM claims no protector? Guessing there's no protector based on things happening to Pippy who was rezzed village this screams sketch, especially since nothing had happened to Pippy yet. Also I find what DVMD said about protectors to make sense. Isn't AM a seasoned player? Why does DVMD's description of a protector seem weird then? The last statement eludes to the fact that she knows what's going down and Pippy was going to die at night.

I'm saying chaos at most.

Previously wanted to lynch Lyra first as Canada over Mel, now she's just chaos at most? Contradictory and sketch.

This is ridiculous Coop. It's pretty obvious who it is.

Becoming defensive like Mel.
Therefore for now, unless I see enough evidence to swade me another way.
Lynch AM

 

[SportPonies]

She dodged Kara's questions or gave late answers up until her death.

@StayingPositive2017
Do you have a response to this?

 

[JustPaws]

She dodged Kara's questions or gave late answers up until her death.

That's not true, I answered some of Kara's questions almost immediately, had to go to bed and told her I would give her reads in the morning. Then couldn't get out of appointments at work until lunch time where I timely gave reads
Edit: happy holidays!

 

[JustPaws]

I'm saying chaos at most.

Still worth lynching
Editing for clarity, saying chaos is still worth lynching, not sure why you wouldn't want to Lynch a chaos player
Edit: Merry Christmas!

 

[WildZoo]

Gentle reminder to everyone to check for roster movement before continuing with PMs today

 

[WildZoo]

Day 6 When Did It Get So Quiet Lynch Tally

lyra (1) - snowy
AM (1) - Mixy

2/16 votes
Lynch deadline 10pm EST (about 11.25 hours)

 

[JustPaws]

Day 6 When Did It Get So Quiet Lynch Tally

lyra (1) - snowy
AM (1) - Mixy

2/16 votes
Lynch deadline 10pm EST (about 11.25 hours)

View attachment 226914

I think you missed some contingency lynches, I think both am and I stand by them still based on today's posts lol
Edit Happy Kwanzaa!

 

[fromthebox]

****

Day 6 When Did It Get So Quiet Lynch Tally

lyra (1) - snowy
AM (1) - Mixy

2/16 votes
Lynch deadline 10pm EST (about 11.25 hours)

View attachment 226914

Because talking gets you killed.

********



Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile

 

[Animal Midwife]

When looking at the game map on pg.1 Canada is more closely an option than Lake Ontario. Not saying she was wrong as completing the lakes makes sense. However, I have less inclination to lynch Canada since everyone in Canada is "friendly." Not discounting the discrepancy, but not who I think we should be concerned with currently.

Did I say to lynch Canada?

This feels odd. Why try and recruit someone when Mel was clearly going down? An attempt to flip the vote and ride the waffle train?

Because there's another wolf and my blinders were on.

Really just wants to net an actual wolf, but did not celebrate persay when we lynched Mel, still on the Paws train.

I won't celebrate until Paws is gone.

Questioning others to hopefully push them off the Mel lynch.

Yeah I was.

This sounds wolfy. Obviously everyone is in this to win it, so why state it. There are strengths in numbers as villagers of wolves so of course no one wants to lynch as many people as possible for no reason.

I was getting very frustrated.

Now apologizing for leading us astray? Sounds more purposeful to me than by accident. Also "didn't want it to be true" the fact Mel was a wolf and he was going down?

Didn't you just say yesterday that people can be wrong sometimes?

Still strongly after Paws even after Mel flipped wolf. Not saying Paws isn't wolf, but AM is so die hard on Paws I feel like they are trying a bit to hard to direct everyone here.

Mel's flip doesn't clear Paws in any shape or form.

All of these are in reference to a protector. Maybe I missed the source of why AM claims no protector? Guessing there's no protector based on things happening to Pippy who was rezzed village this screams sketch, especially since nothing had happened to Pippy yet. Also I find what DVMD said about protectors to make sense. Isn't AM a seasoned player? Why does DVMD's description of a protector seem weird then? The last statement eludes to the fact that she knows what's going down and Pippy was going to die at night.

Probably because Pippy died twice with no one to catch her. I assumed protection stopped all actions on a player, not just death.

Previously wanted to lynch Lyra first as Canada over Mel, now she's just chaos at most? Contradictory and sketch.

When did I want to lynch Lyra? I was trying to make a point

 

[WildZoo]

Someone else can search through the night talk to find the contingency lynches. I've got stuff to do.

 

[Animal Midwife]

That's not true, I answered some of Kara's questions almost immediately, had to go to bed and told her I would give her reads in the morning. Then couldn't get out of appointments at work until lunch time where I timely gave reads

This is a real life answer. I mean it the context of the game.

Still worth lynching
Editing for clarity, saying chaos is still worth lynching, not sure why you wouldn't want to Lynch a chaos player

Never said she was chaos. Am making a point.

 

[JustPaws]

This is a real life answer. I mean it the context of the game.



Never said she was chaos. Am making a point.

I am fully aware, that Village or wolf, we all have lives. But that can't possibly be the only reason you think I'm will be. I have a life, and you just can't always respond immediately to somebody, just because they think you're being suspicious

Happy Hanukkah

 

[SkiOtter]

Day 6 When Did It Get So Quiet Lynch Tally

When @PippyPony died

 

[Skimble]

I'm hoping it's this. I agree, 6 seems like a lot. Obviously we won't know until we get them all, but yeah.

I have a hard time believing wolves would have converted that early unless they had to. With dy as a wolf, she would have certainly told them to hold off on converting as long as possible.

I'm saying chaos at most.

Per the tour map, there is no chaos.

This is ridiculous Coop. It's pretty obvious who it is.

This is a rather bold statement. I don’t feel like it’s “pretty obvious.”

 

[Animal Midwife]

I am fully aware, that Village or wolf, we all have lives. But that can't possibly be the only reason you think I'm will be. I have a life, and you just can't always respond immediately to somebody, just because they think you're being suspicious

Happy Hanukkah

That's why I'm saying that can't clear you. Happy Hanukkah and Merry Christmas.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Per the tour map, there is no chaos.

Okay. Then I don't want Lyra lynched at all if she's Canada.

This is a rather bold statement. I don’t feel like it’s “pretty obvious.”

Sorry, it's just after three days, I start getting frustrated.

 

[jaboo]

Just if anyone is curious about cray's theories, I really am not the redirector and I don't know who is. I got a travel guide item yesterday that I could ask one mechanics question and I asked how many nonvillage, nonwolf players there were and got zero as the answer. I don't know how much stock to put in that though, as I have gotten screwed over by items before.

First mention of this for reference for everyone.

Okay. Then I don't want Lyra lynched at all if she's Canada.

That's an awfully quick backing off of Lyra considering you were putting a lot of pressure there.

 

[Animal Midwife]

That's an awfully quick backing off of Lyra considering you were putting a lot of pressure there.

When did I put pressure there?

 

[cowgirl92]

I see there is a new posting restriction, lol.

That's not true, I answered some of Kara's questions almost immediately, had to go to bed and told her I would give her reads in the morning. Then couldn't get out of appointments at work until lunch time where I timely gave reads
Edit: happy holidays!

Still worth lynching
Editing for clarity, saying chaos is still worth lynching, not sure why you wouldn't want to Lynch a chaos player
Edit: Merry Christmas!

I think you missed some contingency lynches, I think both am and I stand by them still based on today's posts lol
Edit Happy Kwanzaa!

I am fully aware, that Village or wolf, we all have lives. But that can't possibly be the only reason you think I'm will be. I have a life, and you just can't always respond immediately to somebody, just because they think you're being suspicious

Happy Hanukkah

 

[JustPaws]

Okay. Then I don't want Lyra lynched at all if she's Canada.



Sorry, it's just after three days, I start getting frustrated.

Don't be frustrated, I offered to play 20 Questions with you last night
That's my Christmas gift to you!

 

[MixedAnimals77]

Did I say to lynch Canada?

If Ontario is actually an issue, then you need to lynch Canada first.

Here you imply we should lynch Canada first.

Because there's another wolf and my blinders were on.

Of course there are other wolves, but not convinced of blinder's theory. Recruiting votes for Paws was futile at the time.

I won't celebrate until Paws is gone.

I understand this, but you said you just wanted to net a wolf so I would think the fact that we did you would have been slightly more enthused.

Didn't you just say yesterday that people can be wrong sometimes?

I did, because we are. However, you're so adamant about Paws it feels forced to me. Agree with @Jilary it does not seem "pretty obvious"

Mel's flip doesn't clear Paws in any shape or form.

Agreed.

Probably because Pippy died twice with no one to catch her. I assumed protection stopped all actions on a player, not just death.

At the time you made those statements Pippy had only died once which is why this is suspicious.

When did I want to lynch Lyra? I was trying to make a point

See above.

Okay. Then I don't want Lyra lynched at all if she's Canada.

Sorry, it's just after three days, I start getting frustrated.

Agree with @johnnaboo backing off Canada now that we've quoted. I haven't played with you before so maybe it's they type of player you are, but it's just a game, nothing to get flustered over.

 

[jaboo]

Also worth noting. But keep in mind that we have a convert. I agree that we should focus on originals, though.

 

[jaboo]

Side note, do converts typically get their role name changed?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Here you imply we should lynch Canada first.

Note the sense it was used in. I never once moved to Lyra nor did I plan to.

Of course there are other wolves, but not convinced of blinder's theory. Recruiting votes for Paws was futile at the time.

Why was it futile? You can have more than one person being voted for at a time?

I understand this, but you said you just wanted to net a wolf so I would think the fact that we did you would have been slightly more enthused.

I dropped some people off my radar. That's the most I'm doing today.

I did, because we are. However, you're so adamant about Paws it feels forced to me. Agree with @Jilary it does not seem "pretty obvious"

Paws is my egg.

At the time you made those statements Pippy had only died once which is why this is suspicious.

She also continued to be bombarded by actions.

 

[JustPaws]

I see there is a new posting restriction, lol.

Ding ding ding what are holly jolly good time we'll have today!

 

[katashark]

Side note, do converts typically get their role name changed?

I would say not typically. It's usually just an affiliation change.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Side note, do converts typically get their role name changed?

They can, but not always.

 

[SkiOtter]

Don't be frustrated, I offered to play 20 Questions with you last night
That's my Christmas gift to you!

DONT YOU DARE OR I WILL SMITE YOU TOO.

 

[JustPaws]

DONT YOU DARE OR I WILL SMITE YOU TOO.

But, but, but, my wife and I love to play this in the car... Quit crushing my Christmas dreams

 

[SkiOtter]

But, but, but, my wife and I love to play this in the car... Quit crushing my Christmas dreams

We're not playing AM's 20 questions. Nope. Nuh uh.

 

[jaboo]

How many original wolves are we thinking there are left? At least 1, maybe 2, yes?

 

[katashark]

Do we think that both rezzes are village? I can't remember if we established any info on that, but with Pippy popping up confirmed village, it makes me look at mixedanimals a bit more.

Also, paws, retaliatory lynch votes are usually seen as wolfy.

 

[katashark]

How many original wolves are we thinking there are left? At least 1, maybe 2, yes?

I don't think we are sure.

 

[jaboo]

I have a plan to sit and read through the first few days of gameplay again tonight since my SO is leaving me for 10 days for the holidays starting today. 🙁 AKA I will be bored out of my mind without much to do.

ETA: Holy run-on batman

 

[LyraGardenia]

Do y'all really think the posting restrictions I've been giving out seem chaos or wolfy?? I didn't HAVE to come forward and claim credit for them. I don't know why the hand map gave the same result for me as Mel other than we're both in the Out of Service group. I don't know why certain people keep getting moved there, I had a theory since Allie and Mel were lakes that border Canada, but not sure how Gryff fits into that.

Lynch AM based on her posts that Mixy quoted and her weird reversal of opinion on me. I know I said last night I wasn't really feeling AM but well, my gut has been wrong this whole game. Tunneling on Paws just for being slow to answer questions is strange.