- Joined
- Jan 5, 2017
- Messages
- 2,912
- Reaction score
- 5,454
- Points
- 3,546
- Veterinarian
@jenjen2020 you didn’t put in a lynch vote on D2 did you? If you had, who would it have been?
What about Cubs, who is also voting for Alissa?The fact that you’re on my sketch list but you are also weirded out by alissa creeps me out
Okay my lovely citizens, my reads:
Village
Leaning Village
Cubs
Wondering
AM
Pippy
Mel 🙂eek🙂
3m
Unknown/Neutral
BBC
Barks/Kras
BC/Lawps
Doggo
Genny
Alissa
Mayo
Snowy
Leaning Sketch
Jenjen
Zepp
Jboo (I love you!!!)
Wolfy
Dolphin
These are in no particular order within the category because mostly people are on the same plane.
Also...has sdn been preventing y'all from typing fast? It keeps deleting random letters and changing others...
These reads look a little different from yesterday. What made you move Pippy to Neutral from village leaning and Jenjen and jboo into Neutral/unknown from leaning sketch? I don't remember you talking about Doggo's style being sketch before thisI just don't agree with the way you're justifying why you so blatantly said Dolphin isn't a wolf.
Village Pile
AM, 3m, JenJen, Mel, Wonder
AM has been a bit quiet but she sounds like normal.
3m has been decently active and has been pointing out a lot of stuff that I agree with (I know that doesn't make her inherently village) but I've been liking her play
JenJen sounds like noob village to me
Mel...how do I begin to describe Mel? He's a MarshMELowhe's been acting like a good villager
Wonder has potentially pocketed me in PM but I like how she's posting
Neutral/Unknown
Pippy, Jboo, Cubs, Mayo, Lawpy, Alissa, Barks
Sketch/Wolfy
DOLPHINO, Snowy, FTF, Zepp
Dolphin I have a really strong feeling about. It's my wolf radar going off and I have justified my views for my vote before.
Snowy - I'm just kinda confused about a lot of stuff concerning snowy. Her analysis seems fine but I'm suspicious
FTF - I wasn't thrilled with Doggo's play style and posts. Doggo = sketch, therefore FTF = sketch
Zepp - nooby wolf behavior with the lack of posting and the fluff content
After consulting the vote tracker, I have not great feelings about alissa, 3m, and cubs.
Lynch cubs
I still don't understand why it's a problem. Do you think I'm wolfy?
And if not, do you think I might have had a strategic reason to make a statement like that?
So I don't see why we are harping on it, especially considering that I'm not stopping anyone from voting for her.
If you haven’t ever noticed pretty sure she just plays the game like that. Lots of people do that if they don’t want a player lynched, I don’t see why it’s rubbing you the wrong way. Except for the fact that you were so fixed on me being a wolf, which spoiler alert I won’t be.
Yesterday:
Today:
These reads look a little different from yesterday. What made you move Pippy to Neutral from village leaning and Jenjen and jboo into Neutral/unknown from leaning sketch? I don't remember you talking about Doggo's style being sketch before this
Lynch Moose
Why?
Just stirring the pot
Thanks!
I have no idea what happened today and looked at the last tally and thought let’s have some fun with this
Si ce jeu en cours de victoire dépend du fait que je sois ou non en messagerie privée avec exactement deux joueurs, alors ce village manque de respect à l'utilité du fil de jeu et ne joue pas correctement. Je rejette donc toute étiquette de perte basée sur des fonctionnalités optionnelles.@Animal Midwife I really wish you had been speaking with your PM partners.
Later on, I am going to blame a village loss on those of you who are not trying to work with the existing system in this game.
What about Cubs, who is also voting for Alissa?
Geez, there’s that echo again!Why me over alissa?
It doesn't. It literally just means you have been given an additional tool and instead are throwing it in the dirt.Si ce jeu en cours de victoire dépend du fait que je sois ou non en messagerie privée avec exactement deux joueurs, alors ce village manque de respect à l'utilité du fil de jeu et ne joue pas correctement. Je rejette donc toute étiquette de perte basée sur des fonctionnalités optionnelles.
Wondering. I contingency voted them after D2 lynch.@jenjen2020 you didn’t put in a lynch vote on D2 did you? If you had, who would it have been?
I don't think you can call something an echo when you're quoting different people each time and they are just asking you follow up questions like "why."Geez, there’s that echo again!
Tbh, I’m not set on my vote as it is. Cubs, I’ve been reading you pretty village but your vote tracker didn’t look super great imo. I could easily switch to 3m or alissa. Also might clump jenjen in there as well.
I got an identical result during night two, I still don't know how to interpret it
please don't attack me with the mechanics
[/ SPOILER] [/ SPOILER] [/ SPOILER] [/ SPOILER] [/ SPOILER] [/ SPOILER] [/ SPOILER] [/ SPOILER] [/ SPOILER] [/ SPOILER]
[/ Spoiler] [/ spoiler] [/ spoiler] [/ spoiler] [/ spoiler] [/ spoiler] [/ spoiler] [/ spoiler] [/ spoiler] [/ spoiler]
La dernière fois que j'ai utilisé une messagerie privée pour un bloc de village réussi, c'était Smash pour le contexte. Depuis lors, un seul m'a perdu le jeu, donc non, je ne suis pas intéressé par eux, sauf avec quelques personnes spécifiques.It doesn't. It literally just means you have been given an additional tool and instead are throwing it in the dirt.
I've seen you use PMs before to build a village bloc, so honestly this makes me lean your attitude this game as either wolfy or offensive to fellow players.
Exactly. Ouch 🙁Depuis lors, un seul m'a perdu le jeu, donc non, je ne suis pas intéressé par eux, sauf avec quelques personnes spécifiques.
C'est comme ça que ça doit être. Très peu comprennent mon style de messagerie privée. Plus souvent qu'autrement, cela me rend plus sommaire et la toute dernière fois que je l'ai fait, chacun de mes partenaires de messagerie privés m'a non seulement égaré, mais a perdu tout le jeu en un balayage. Passe si difficile.Exactly. Ouch 🙁
What are your alternative thoughts on what visited you N1?
@Miranda Senft are you ready to stake your life on that read?
Edit: the dolphin one in all caps, I mean
?Goddammit
Posted this literally a minute after this:lynch alissa
was trying to give alissa the benefit of the doubt due to IRL things but not sure that can continue much longer
working on reads now. 3M I saw your post and I promise im just really busy. My mom now has a cold and were hoping thats all it is...
Yeah, I feel better about this
Unlynch cubs
lynch alissa
was trying to give alissa the benefit of the doubt due to IRL things but not sure that can continue much longer
Yeah that wolfy guilt is rough sometimes, huhI‘m just conflicted is all
Also, since genny is dead now, my question to her (that dolphin delayed passing on until the moment had passed) that was mentioned on thread yesterday was to try to get some more information about what she thought the hissing was on N2 +/- if she had been attacked.
Odd sounds in Canada:
Goose = a chance of being protector/stopping an attack, although it very well could have been the attack
- goose hissing
- the Windsor Hum
Windsor Hum = probably would be a wolf because it's troubling and disruptive, but I had a village tinfoil about genny's role that has now been proven incorrect.
So I was cryptically trying to get her to provide more info about her night results, since she was 1 PM partner away from me and I didn't really trust dolphin all that much at the time to pass on a direct question.
Not really important line of discussion anymore (or ever, tbh), so I'm only saying this now because I thought people might be amused to see me failing @ playing PM telephone lol
Son ignorance de mes messages menant à la lecture d'un de mes plus longs, ce qui l'a fait changer de vote pour des raisons encore inconnues. Ensuite, je cherchais les messages à lire, en sautant complètement celui où je lui demandais ses interprétations des autres joueurs/chariots.
If she was a wolf or chaos why would she straight up say she was trying to stir things upDoggo's actions last night seem very chaotic
So you’re reading cubs as village but are lynching him entirely on votes? Can villagers not have a bad voting record?Geez, there’s that echo again!
Tbh, I’m not set on my vote as it is. Cubs, I’ve been reading you pretty village but your vote tracker didn’t look super great imo. I could easily switch to 3m or alissa. Also might clump jenjen in there as well.
How are you guys reading Zeppy?
Official D4 - "The Heartland Province" Lynch Tally
Zeppy (1) - Pippy
I was reading cubs more village. Now I’m not so sure. I put more reliability on vote count analysis than feels because I’ve caught far more wolves with VCA than feelsSo you’re reading cubs as village but are lynching him entirely on votes? Can villagers not have a bad voting record?
L'absence de discussion sur de nouveaux contre-chariots me dérangeait, car il ne semblait pas vraiment avoir de problème avec Fern. J'aimerais toujours voir une liste complète d'interprétation à un moment donné afin que je puisse voir ce qu'il fait.Oh yeah that is super wierd. But besides his interaction with you, what makes you think he's a wolf? I just don't see it. He is posting insightful, new thoughts, and critically looking at things. All those scream village to me.
Neutre, glissant dans le loup.How are you guys reading Zeppy?
I didnt think that, I asked a speculatory reads question to Mel. I would be voting for you if I thought you were. I have nothing to hide in the PM. Just trying to game solve, hence my specific questions to certain people.
So just a small question to everyone here, how are you reading Wondy and alissa?
Because i'm also wary of being potentially pocketed which can happen a lot more easily in PMs. Like i said, i'm fine with people PMing me and sharing thoughts and concerns. I just feel wary opening PMs with people and getting potentially misled since it's easier to get manipulated in private conversations.
Choosing not to open PMs with people because of pocketing concerns or feeling the thread provides more useful information that can't be easily misled otherwise in PMs is fine and it's not alignment indicative. If anything it's a matter of personal preference.
It's not to MSP. It's in general. I'm just saying i can talk to anyone if they PM me but i'm really hesitant in opening PMs because of getting pocketed, mislead, manipulated etc. I have kept this stance before as village.
How am i handicapping village? I'm not in total isolation and people did reach out to me by PM which i responded to them.
Why does it matter who opens the PM, if youre going to talk to them if they open the PM? Why wouldnt you just ignore it all if your fear is pocketing? In other words, fear of pocketing is there regardless of who opens the PM, so why would you talk one way but not the other?
I actually posted some of my reads last night about an hour before the lynch. Which included Genny as one of my strong village reads (unfortunately). Pip also gives me strong village vibes.
The goal of being a good wolf is to play like you would as a villager, if you do crazy **** like that and people say "A wolf wouldn't do that", then of course you have to actually consider it as a good wolf moveIf she was a wolf or chaos why would she straight up say she was trying to stir things up
So you’re reading cubs as village but are lynching him entirely on votes? Can villagers not have a bad voting record?
I have to comment on this.I'm reading wonder as sketch and alissa is neutral, but I don't like that she keeps popping in saying she'll get reads and then doesn't have them. Alissa also said she was important and village doesn't want to lynch her early on this game. Bold move for a newer wolf.