WW: Mysterious Planet Official Game Thread

[Katie8]

---

Members do not see this ad.

I can't believe JMJ actually turned out to be a wolf after that clusterf#$k.

Good job to those who kept their vote!!

 

[Trematode]

Not completely. 😛 it's easy to bandwagon.

How many wolves bandwagon 100% of the time and early on some of the lynches 😛

 

[Minnerbelle]

I just didn't want everyone to completely ignore the possibility of someone else on that list being a wolf.

ok... so let me get this straight. we have 2 lists. each has at least 1 wolf in it supposedly. we got 1 wolf already in the first list. and you want us to keep our attention on that first list and away from the other list that you are on. interesting... you're really not helping yourself here imo.

 

[Varz]

ok... so let me get this straight. we have 2 lists. each has at least 1 wolf in it supposedly. we got 1 wolf already in the first list. and you want us to keep our attention on that first list and away from the other list that you are on. interesting... you're really not helping yourself here imo.

If PP really wanted to secure her survival, and assuming she is a wolf, wouldn't it be a smart move to move attention away from the fox? Perhaps the Fox is one of the users in the group she is in? Something to think about anyway.

 

[Minnerbelle]

If PP really wanted to secure her survival, and assuming she is a wolf, wouldn't it be a smart move to move attention away from the fox? Perhaps the Fox is one of the users in the group she is in? Something to think about anyway.

when did she say anything about the fox? and what does the fox have anything to do with the "list" she's talking about which included WTF, Orca, wildcat and ftb?

 

[Lissarae06]

when did she say anything about the fox? and what does the fox have anything to do with the "list" she's talking about which included WTF, Orca, wildcat and ftb?

DVM's write up said her soul was in a fox or something like that. I need to go back and reread it. We were thinking there was a fox out there that needed to die in order for PP to die or something crazy like that.

 

[Varz]

when did she say anything about the fox? and what does the fox have anything to do with the "list" she's talking about which included WTF, Orca, wildcat and ftb?

Sorry perhaps I am getting my information mixed up, I thought PP couldn't be attacked / killed or whatever while the fox character still lived. I will have to go back and read this massive thread.

 

[Emiloo4]

DVM's write up said her soul was in a fox or something like that. I need to go back and reread it. We were thinking there was a fox out there that needed to die in order for PP to die or something crazy like that.

Foxhunter is playing now!! 😱 Help us hunt the fox down, Foxhunter!

 

[Lissarae06]

It is a beautiful day here in this hot, scorching desert (the mod would know as she lives in one IRL and is sweating bullets while sitting inside with the AC.) The creatures of Halldóra gather around trying to decide who should be responsible next for the attacks of their friends... Soon the crowd gathers around PetPony. Mrs. Krist even speaks up on behalf of Krist saying, "I know Krist used a plant to keep PetPony from doing her nightly action and this is what silenced PetPony and this is why there were no deaths." PetPony claims, "No I was silenced on Night 3 by a deer/rabbit hybrid." We shall say this much about this... No deaths happened on Night 4 and it is currently Day 5. Did someone lie? Did someone not pay attention and has their facts wrong? Either way someone will pay for this...

The creatures gather around PetPony. Each creature attacking her, beating her. Again and again they attack, but PetPony does not die. It appears as though PetPony's soul resides in the heart of a fox. Until a fox dies, PetPony's soul remains alive.

Also during this scorching desert day, another creature is working hard... Suddenly, LIS appears, healed, and able to talk (well kind of).

35 players remain...

Night ends at 9PM PST.

35 players remain...

Here it is.

 

[Lissarae06]

But it was a daytime write up and DVM told us not to take those seriously so I don't know. It being in bold makes me think we are supposed to take it seriously though.

 

[Minnerbelle]

DVM's write up said her soul was in a fox or something like that. I need to go back and reread it. We were thinking there was a fox out there that needed to die in order for PP to die or something crazy like that.

Yeah I got that, and I actually have a theory about that as well. But I don't understand how that has anything to do with PP drawing attention to that second list. Sorry I'm slow.

 

[Lissarae06]

Yeah I got that, and I actually have a theory about that as well. But I don't understand how that has anything to do with PP drawing attention to that second list. Sorry I'm slow.

Someone said that they thought maybe PP was trying to direct our attention away from that list because the fox might be in it I think.

 

[Emiloo4]

Ok going to bed guys. If I die tonight, you should know who to lynch 🙄
I told everything I know to two people just in case. Won't be around probably at all tomorrow so good luck everyone.

 

[nohika]

I just got home from a nasty day at work, so give me some time to catch up on the bajillion (10+) pages of posting you guys did while I was gone.

 

[Minnerbelle]

Someone said that they thought maybe PP was trying to direct our attention away from that list because the fox might be in it I think.

Ohhhhhhh gotcha gotcha. That makes sense now.

 

[zanydogz]

Ohhhhhhh gotcha gotcha. That makes sense now.

Does PP know who the fox is? If she does, then I see where y'all are going with this. Otherwise, idk...

 

[Minnerbelle]

Does PP know who the fox is? If she does, then I see where y'all are going with this. Otherwise, idk...

She claims to have noooo clue about hte fox, just like she had noooo clue about why people are saying she was out on night 3 or something.

 

[Lissarae06]

Since netflix doesn't want me to finish my show, I'm going to sleep. See you guys in the morning.

 

[zanydogz]

She claims to have noooo clue about hte fox, just like she had noooo clue about why people are saying she was out on night 3 or something.

Okay I don't remember if this was ever settled but is PP a villager or a wolf?

 

[orca2011]

Okay I don't remember if this was ever settled but is PP a villager or a wolf?

Don't think we actually know.

And I need to go to bed. I need to be at work in 7 hours.

 

[TigerWillow]

Okay I don't remember if this was ever settled but is PP a villager or a wolf?

now see, I thought someone woulda been smart enough to go check her out for sure last night....

sigh

 

[ksmi117]

Waiting on a few more PMs. You've got 20 minutes and then I RNG them. The RNG does include using an item, so if you don't want to use something, please let me and DVMDream know. 🙂

 

[Minnerbelle]

In case I die tonight I wanted to get all my thoughts out there (well the light at the end of the tunnel is that you won't have to see nearly as much of my annoying posts after tonight since I won't really be around either way). I've entrusted Orca with sensitive information that I don't want to have out just in case I'm not killed. She can divulge after I die. She knows my role and some other stuffs.

Both PP and SOV are strongly strongly suspicious to me right now. Why? because they're pulling the classic wolf move of NOT addressing any of the major points I think they would have addressed if they were actually innocent. Like when someone makes and accusation or comes up with reasoning that they think is sound for lynching, if you're innocent you would pick up on it and vehemently defend. Or if the reasoning isn't sound, point it out. Or at least deny it even if they can't come up with a good way to prove it. Instead, PP and SOV just let those comments slide and didn't address them.

1.) PP being monopod aka Dufflepuds from Narnia. More roles have come back and they are all from folklore from somewhere around the world it seems like. (some may be made up by DVM I guess ,but either way, not some character from Narnia). I mean something like a gremlin I can buy, but some obscure character from Narnia??? Really??? And yes, squirrels was linked to final fantasy, but it's more like final fantasy has a ton of characters from classical myths (at least from what I can remember from like 15 years ago with FFVII). Plus, squirrels is probably bad bad bad too. Rather than address that, PP just shut down and moseyed on along and threw a fit about how no one's listening to her so she's not even gonna try. Well I was listening... you just weren't talking. You were ignoring what I brought up. And apparently according to wiki, monopods are from some greek myths... but Dufflepuds? Totally just Narnia. No one else has come forward to say that they had book/movie references to their roles.

Also, after she didn't die during the lynch she was all "I told you so!" But told us what??? Totally non-sequitur. I don't get it. Me and a few others have pointed out that being unlynchable doesn't prove anything. *crickets.* And there were quite a few other things that people asked that she never really addressed. It was all "I don't know what you're talking about."

2.) I've said TWICE now how lynching SOV was the only way to see if he's telling the truth (unless we wait 3 more full cycles until the forest comes back). It wasn't even my idea. It was heylodeb's, but I made sure to elaborate a couple times to see if he would respond. Win-win situation because if he's lying, we have us a wolf. If he's not lying (and we don't have any other obvious lynch choices) we will know we can trust him, and no villagers will be killed inadvertently.

I do agree with him that it doesn't make sense to just lynch him every time we're not sure, because each night cycle we will lose people. But when all we have is his words and assurance from others that he's shared his role (doesn't mean that's what he really is), it IS advantageous to know for sure. How many times has he pulled that crap?

Plus how convenient. He has some role that camouflages and can't be investigated for the next 3 nights. In that time he can make up whatever the heck he wants his role to be. A role that can't be lynched or attacked AND can resurrect other players? Really? I find that hard to believe. That's much greedy a role methinks for a villager. I would like to see it in action. A wolf that can resurrect once in the game, and can only be investigated on their day sounds more reasonable. And phoenix... in the forest? I mean, it could be true everything he's saying. But it raises both my eyebrows.

3.) Okay, so now for the super conspiracy theory. This is mostly for amusement. DOn't take it too seriously. When I heard fox creature, the first thing that came to mind was a Kitsune, which is fox in Japanese. They hold tremendous mythological importance in Japanese folklore. In fact, if you google "mythical creature fox" that's the first wiki page that comes up. They go hand in hand with Tankuki. Kitsune generally have this cunning malevolence to them (though in some folklore they can be nice). Kitsune can shapeshift (though usually into a human, but maybe loosely consider that camouflaging?). They also live in the forest. And, what do you know, they can possess people. Maybe that also loosely can be applied to carrying someone's soul? hmmm??? hmmmm?????? hmmmmmmmmm???????? i know i know, that's a stretch. just wanted to put that out there.

Anyhoos minnerbelle, out. I work 7 days a week throughout the summer and commute like over an hour each way, AND all this 4th of july celebration shiz is happening, so whatever happens I promise I'll be out of y'all's hair after this outrageously long post. Last time I did this sort of thing, my intuition was dead wrong, but I'm optimistic that this time I'll have better results 😛.

 

[ksmi117]

Night is closed. Results pending.

DVMDream isn't back since her movie started late, so give me some time to figure this all out. Your patience is greatly appreciated.

 

[krist]

How come we are fully believing those lists anyways? Yea, there have been right things but we still shouldn't just count everyone else on there as innocent now that we got a wolf! There could still be more!

PP are you serious?? I've brought several wolves out basically on a platter and you STILL don't believe my list?? Wow...can't wait till we kill that fox.

and wow it just took me 30+ minutes to catch up, I was at magic mike (with DVMdream?😛) and i can't believe all the waffling but thank you all for trusting my hunch and going with JMJ. And now night is over I am still alive. Not sure what to think about the whole SOV/emiloo thing will have to re-read again tomorrow when I am sober (love that they serve alcohol athe movies!!!) an dmrore awake. I wokr 8-4 cst tomorrow but will rty to keep up on my phone as best as possible. I'll send in a contigency vote after night results are posted. Way to go villagers! I'm on fire!!

 

[ksmi117]

After patting themselves on the back for yet another wolf lynch, the creatures of Halldora head to sleep. However, many choose to venture out in the night for good and for evil deeds. In different areas of the forest, two plants claim two victims. Both victims escape alive but will need time to heal.

In yet another area of the forest, a third attack by a strange looking deer with a poisonous barb at its tail. Again, the victim is also only injured and will heal eventually.

Unfortunately, the final attack is deadly. The Back-in-Time Bird is seen leaving her house for a leisurely midnight stroll. On her trek, she encounters a beautiful color-shifting creature whom she can't resist touching. The creature's skin is poisonous and the Back-in-Time Bird, also know as abbercadaver, slumps over dead. The creatures will certainly mourn the loss of abbercadaver, the Back-in-Time Bird, neutral character and shuffler of items.

As the sun rises, the mysterious planet turns into a frigid tundra. The mysterious planet will remain a tundra for the next day/night cycle. Hope you remembered your parka!

Lynch deadline is 9 AM PST.

29 players remain...

The Locke Forest:
1. Packen
2. kakurubird-Kulshedra The Dragon- malevolent
3. krist
4. Mrs. Krist/Foxhunter
5. Mrs. SOV-Selki-benevolent

The Montego Forest:
1. squirrels-?????
2. Ivorypolarbear- The White Stag- benevolent
3. Abbercadaver- Back-in-Time Bird- neutral
4. Philliab
5. TimeWarner

The Zora Tundra:
1. nohika
2. katie8
3. wildcatj
4. SnS
5. EquineConstant
6. Katie8sMate

The Neva Tundra:
1. Orca2011
2. Wolfspeaker- Water Leaper-malevolent
3. holdonhope
4. Minnerbelle
5. Saltz

The Keb Desert:
1. Trematode
2. Devyn-Singa-benevolent
3. SOV
4. PetPony
5. lissarae06

The Makani Desert:
1. Cuit- Con Tram Nu O'c
2. Jamrockin
3. heylodeb
4. FTB
5. Emiloo4

The Misty Swamp:
1. zanydogz
2. nyanko
3. Jemappellejane-Roperite-malevolent
4. varz

The Raviv Swamp:
1. sheepdog
2. dyachei
3. Abney-The Marine Lion-neutral
4. LIS-Egyptian Sphinx-benevolent
5. WTF-Whirling Whimpus-malevolent

 

[TigerWillow]

Nooooooooo!!!

Abber!!!!!!

Why the eff are people killing off my forest?!?! 😡

 

[TigerWillow]

And I just noticed sheep and I have t least amount of people in our group.


Looks like someone wants to trash our planetary leadership conference lines.

 

[DVMDream]

I am home!! Movie was sold out so we had to go to a later one..

A big THANK YOU to ksmi!! That is a lot to do alone and she did an amazing job!! I still have to catch up on what happened.

 

[zanydogz]

Nooo Abber!!!!!

And, on top of that, I counted about 3 people silenced for the day so that doesn't help either.

 

[fromthebox]

I am not silenced. But I am also home and starting my weekend. Likely won't be around until an hour before deadline in the AM.

 

[nyanko]

Likewise - I am glad the deadline is 9 am instead of 8 tomorrow morning, no way I'd wake up for 8 am on Saturday especially.

 

[TigerWillow]

Likewise - I am glad the deadline is 9 am instead of 8 tomorrow morning, no way I'd wake up for 8 am on Saturday especially.

Yeaaaahhh I'll be up at 6. And will be gone 8-2.


Sucks to be me.

 

[DVMDream]

I currently have over 500PMs in my inbox...

I am really quite tired so I am going to skip on catching up tonight with everything you all posted...

Going to bed....😴

Lynch deadline is 9AM PST.

Happy Lynching!! 🙂

 

[nyanko]

I currently have over 500PMs in my inbox...

😱 she's a wolf, get her

 

[Lissarae06]

Boo. Anyone have any leads? I hope someone comes out with some good info soon.

 

[Jamr0ckin]

Boo. Anyone have any leads? I hope someone comes out with some good info soon.

Are we just discounting the discrepancies in SOVs story and the one given by the mods?

Also, he needs to be investigated on a non forest night, so that perhaps he can't be camouflaged. If the seer gets the same message then I would wager SOV is a wolf that can evade detection by adapting to whatever terrain three planet is currently in.

Sent from my DROID RAZR using SDN Mobile

 

[wildcatj]

I really have no good ideas right now and I have to run to work. I will attempt to pop on on my phone, but I doubt that's going to happen so I'll probably miss the lynch.

 

[equineconstant]

I'm inclined to agree with whoever was saying we should lynch SOV regardless. If he's a wolf we get him, if he's what he says he is we don't lose him. Only if we don't have any other leads, of course.

 

[dyachei]

since I am about to go to work:
lynch SOV

 

[Packen]

I will admit I was drinking a wee bit of whiskey while trying to pack and move my stuff last night - couldn't let it go to waste So I didn't really follow the whole SOV/Emiloo thing very well.

Do I have this right: SOV evaded investigation by being camouflaged, Emiloo was suspicious, they then tried to lynch each other, leading to probably one of the quietest, dark-horse-like wolf lynches ever?? Seriously did not see that coming.

I don't know where that leaves us now though. I read through minner's monologue, and feel like she has some really valid points. Nice research into fox myths and legends btw 🙂

There is time before the lynch. I am going to run some errands and check back in a bit.

 

[Trematode]

Since SOV and PP are on the top of everyone's suspect list:

lynch SOV.

We have to find that fox so PP can GO. .

 

[Lissarae06]

Are we just discounting the discrepancies in SOVs story and the one given by the mods?

Also, he needs to be investigated on a non forest night, so that perhaps he can't be camouflaged. If the seer gets the same message then I would wager SOV is a wolf that can evade detection by adapting to whatever terrain three planet is currently in.

Sent from my DROID RAZR using SDN Mobile

Um, what story was given by the mods? Are you talking about emiloo's story?

 

[equineconstant]

lynch SOV

Making it official. I'm very willing to change my vote if we get more information, though.

 

[Lissarae06]

I'm going to wait until more people wake up before casting my vote. I want to wait a little while to see if anyone has any solid info.

 

[Jamr0ckin]

Um, what story was given by the mods? Are you talking about emiloo's story?

SOV appeared to be a forest creature, and since investigated in a forest terrain, was camouflaged and therefore the investigation didn't yield any results.

Sent from my DROID RAZR using SDN Mobile

 

[Lissarae06]

SOV appeared to be a forest creature, and since investigated in a forest terrain, was camouflaged and therefore the investigation didn't yield any results.

Sent from my DROID RAZR using SDN Mobile

Keep in mind that the only person that knows for sure if that was from the mods or not was the person who got the message from the mods. The rest of us have to take you at your word. For all we know you are making it up. I think you are telling the truth but I'm just pointing out that no one trusts anyone in these games and it would be really easily to falsify info. I still don't know what discrepancies you were talking about. Didn't the stories line up?

 

[Lissarae06]

The whole thing was really confusing.

 

[Jamr0ckin]

The whole thing was really confusing.

Oh, I agree it is confusing. But he should know that he could evade investigation, and everyone agrees that a Phoenix doesn't really fit with forest.

I'm not necessarily pushing for a lynch, but rather an investigation of him by a seer in another terrain.

And not that this counts for anything, but I am being honest about the results.

Sent from my DROID RAZR using SDN Mobile

 

[Katie8]

I am going to be driving for the next 3-4 hours so I don't know if I'll be able to check in after this, but I'm going to go ahead and lynch SOV

I also will be at the beach (sun, sand, drink aahh im so excited!) for the next week sooo I will be posting a bit less.