WW: X-Men Official Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Well, I've had no part in lynching the innocent people either.

At that point I had no reason to trust or distrust the people who started that bandwagon (or any other until this one). So I didn't take part in the discussion or vote. However, I've now spent a day in their group, and consider them fairly trustworthy. Plus that vote gave me usable info. So here I am, now, voting.

If you do lynch me, you'll want to look hard at krist and ksmi next. Krist in particular has been itching to lynch me since day 1, and both are in the voting section I'd consider fairly suspicious.

I mean, I guess that's fair enough ,but I don't really understand the whole not voting just because you have no idea and don't really know enough about anyone to vote. I feel like that's been used against me and others before. I feel like I honestly never know enough about anyone and even those I do trust, I don't trust fully due to conversions and whatnot. To use that as a reason to not vote just doesn't seem productive. Sure, you might not be responsible for lynching any villagers, but you're also not contributing to lynching wolves either.
 
Oh, i have more transgressions.
I mixed up orcagirl and orca2011 in Lissarae's first game (ancient history) and almost outed all the wolves there as well.

I am not good with names. Not IRL either.

Haha. I remember that. If I could recall who else was all included on that PM I could have really destroyed that game. Luckily for you, I didn't pay that much attention.
 
********************

I'm not either. I triple check every message or post that I make.

Same. I am always so worried that I'm going to accidentally PM my group all my wolfie strategy when I'm a wolf. I will check and recheck the names on the PM I'm sending even though 99% of the time I'm hitting reply or reply all.

Also, 🙁 I got lynched going in to the weekend. Do me proud remaining wolves!

********************
 
Sorry I've been MIA today. I have spent my day driving to and from the Atlanta airport and back to Tennessee.

Not silenced, obviously.

I'm suspicious of Samoa because of the character confusion and lack of voting. But when you look at what happened with Zany, that makes me hesitant to vote for her based on those 2 things alone.

I'm going to go with dyachei on this one because she is the leader.

lynch nyanko

Sent from my DROID RAZR using SDN Mobile
 
I'm going to vote to lynch Samoa.

Yes, this is partially to save myself**, but that's not the only reason. Putting aside the lack of lynch votes until now, the Kitty Pryde thing is just not making any sense to me. We have proof there was a Shadowcat--wolfspeaker, who was the first person lynched. All the names that I know about so far have been their X-Men code names. LIS was Professor X, not Charles Xavier; zany was Cyclops, not Scott Summers; etc. The only member of the X-Men team who I think doesn't have a code name is Jean Grey.

Okay, yes, since Shadowcat and Kitty Pryde are canonically the same person, it would seem to fit with what the write-ups have implied about Samoa's movements between groups. But:
a) We only have Samoa's word that she is Kitty Pryde.
b) According to DVM's public comments about her role name/ability (Havok/avoiding lynching), as well as other knowledge I have, role names and abilities in this game don't always line up together so neatly.
c) Q: Since there was a publicly declared Shadowcat, claiming to be Kitty Pryde would be a stupid move and we all know it, so why would someone do this? A: Because we all know that it would be a stupid move, we're predisposed to believe that no one would do this, especially if we don't think they're normally stupid. The line of thinking seems to be that claiming something so out-there would be an incredibly dumb wolfy move, so no smart wolf would do it. Unless they're a smart wolf who realizes that we'll think exactly that and is manipulating us based on that belief.
d) I believe it was in the History game (courtesy of SOV--our current co-mod 🙄), that one of the wolves (I want to say Emiloo?) had the ability to move between groups, which the wolves used to their advantage.
e) With so many characters to choose from, why would the mods create two roles that were the same person? (Devyn even claims that no alcohol was involved in the making of this game. 😛)

So yeah, this Samoa = Kitty Pryde thing is incredibly suspicious to me. That's in addition to the lack of lynch votes and not really bringing anything to the thread, either.

**All anyone's said when voting for me is they have vague suspicions. Please, investigate me if you can and let's get this cleared up!
 
Sorry I have been quiet just wanted to check in, I have been at a dogfishhead brewery event drinking free beer all day and just got home but am about to keep drinking. I have no idea what is happening and do not feel like reading through so I dont want to vote and kill someone without knowing what is going on. I will be back to normal ww mode tomorrow.
 
lynch votes

IPB 3 (DVMD, lissa, Samoa)
Samoa 3 (krist, orca2011, IPB)
Nyanko 2 (Dyachei, jamrock)
Philliab 1 (FTB)
krist 1 (ksmi)



1.5 hours to deadline of 0200 Dublin time.

Waffle-o-meter: 3
 
Last edited:
Sure, let's all play pick on the asst-moderator.
You will ALL pay when I am back as full moderator.
Everytime you rag on me, I go think up a new way to torture you all. 😛
 
Sure, let's all play pick on the asst-moderator.
You will ALL pay when I am back as full moderator.
Everytime you rag on me, I go think up a new way to torture you all. 😛
Fair enough. I bugged TW about her tallying skills in SW; she completely played me in HP. I bug you about your tallying skills in X-Men; something new and unexpected happens to me in your next game. It's all good. :laugh:
 
My phone probably won't make it to the deadline...

I may be gullible because I haven't had much time this game, but right now I believe samoa. She has been honest about moving and lissa sort of backed her up earlier in the thread.
 
lynch votes

IPB 3 (DVMD, lissa, Samoa)
Samoa 3 (krist, orca2011, IPB)
Nyanko 2 (Dyachei, jamrock)
Philliab 1 (FTB)
krist 1 (ksmi)



<1 hour to deadline of 0200 Dublin time.

Waffle-o-meter: 3

Still missing a few votes. Everyone counts when I can't count.
Deadline is 0200. Votes received after that time will not count. I am off to eat, may not tally it until later (unless Devyn notices the time herself).
 
Unless Lissa comes out with more info, lynch nyanko. When everyone was voting to lynch kakuru she questioned why were were lynching her and not zany.

Still can't work out the Kitty Pryde=Shadowcat thing. Since no one has come forward to say they have a human name, I just don't believe it, but then again, I have no reason to suspect Samoa. And it seems to me that a wolf would be sure to vote every lynching.
 
Fine. Nyanko has been checked out. I'm not saying how. Believe me or not. I really don't care that much.

Ok, I'm inclined to believe you, and my suspicions are higher with Samoa anyhow...

unlynch nyanko

Lynch Samoa


Sent from my DROID RAZR using SDN Mobile
 
Fine. unlynch nyanko

Going to think about it for a minute....
 
lynch votes

Samoa 4 (krist, orca2011, IPB, jamrock)
IPB 3 (DVMD, lissa, Samoa)
krist 2(ksmi, dyachei)
Philliab 1 (FTB)
Nyanko 0( )



10 minutes to deadline of 0200 Dublin time.

Waffle-o-meter: 6

Still missing a few votes. Everyone counts when I can't count.
Deadline is 0200. Votes received after that time will not count. I am off to eat, may not tally it until later (unless Devyn notices the time herself)
 
lynch IPB

I trust DVMD's gut, and I'm not convinved that Samoa should be lynched, yet.
 
Gah I really don't know who to vote for I would like to switch my vote to philliab but for self preservation I'm not going to
 
lynch votes

IPB 4 (DVMD, lissa, Samoa, phillab)
Samoa 3 (krist, IPB, jamrock)
krist 3 (ksmi, dyachei, orca)
Philliab 1 (FTB)




5 minutes to deadline of 0200 Dublin time.

Waffle-o-meter: 7

Still missing a few votes. Everyone counts when I can't count.
Deadline is 0200. Votes received after that time will not count. I am off to eat, may not tally it until later (unless Devyn notices the time herself)
 
Woah don't lynch me! I am Darwin, the evolver!
 
Gah I really don't know who to vote for I would like to switch my vote to philliab but for self preservation I'm not going to

FWIW I didn't vote for you. Wouldn't you switch your vote to IPB for self preservation? 😕
 
lynch votes

krist 4 (ksmi, dyachei, orca, nyanko)
IPB 4 (DVMD, lissa, Samoa, phillab)
Samoa 3 (krist, IPB, jamrock)
Philliab 1 (FTB)




Deadline reached

Waffle-o-meter: 7

Still missing a few votes. Everyone counts when I can't count.
Deadline is 0200. Votes received after that time will not count. I am off to eat, may not tally it until later (unless Devyn notices the time herself)[/QUOTE]
 
lynch votes

IPB 4 (DVMD, lissa, Samoa, phillab)
Samoa 3 (krist, IPB, jamrock)
krist 4 (ksmi, dyachei, orca, nyanko)
Philliab 1 (FTB)




Deadline reached

Waffle-o-meter: 7

Still missing a few votes. Everyone counts when I can't count.
Deadline is 0200. Votes received after that time will not count. I am off to eat, may not tally it until later (unless Devyn notices the time herself)
[/QUOTE]

do I get to tie-break?
 
Top