WWicked WWild HalloWWeen Interest/ Sign ups/Game thread

[Animal Midwife]

---

Members don't see this ad.

Lynch Coffee?

for now

 

[Animal Midwife]

I have to vote before work (PST and all) so for now I’m gonna go with my OG vote for dolphin

.....sorry

lynch dolphin

Why dolphin?

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

I have to vote before work (PST and all) so for now I’m gonna go with my OG vote for dolphin
.....sorry

lynch dolphin


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk[/B]

Has Mutt said or done something to make you believe her village self-claim more?

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Dark Horse @SportPonies any thoughts today?

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Lynch Coffee?

for now

For now.

Until you're caffeinated.

 

[grebes4lyfe]

Has Mutt said or done something to make you believe her village self-claim more?

No... but I didn’t want to gang up. So I figured I would go for dolphin who was my original random vote yesterday since I’m still not super sure how this works.

I’m happy to change it.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Was @allieh8607 the only non-voter? Is she around today?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Was @allieh8607 the only non-voter? Is she around today?

allie was the only non-poster. shelter also didn't vote.

 

[Animal Midwife]

No... but I didn’t want to gang up. So I figured I would go for dolphin who was my original random vote yesterday since I’m still not super sure how this works.

I’m happy to change it.

We have more information now that people have died, so we're using that to figure out who was wolfy yesterday. Do you think dolphin is wolfy?

 

[grebes4lyfe]

We have more information now that people have died, so we're using that to figure out who was wolfy yesterday. Do you think dolphin is wolfy?

Not particularly. Still think mutt is wolfier

I’ll change it
unlynch dolphin

Lynch mutt

Excuse the n00b

I’m at work now so might be MIA for a few hours


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Animal Midwife]

Not particularly. Still think mutt is wolfier

I’ll change it
unlynch dolphin

Lynch mutt

Excuse the n00b

I’m at work now so might be MIA for a few hours

Why do you think mutt is wolfy?

 

[SARdoghandler]

Lynch Coffee?

for now

What is it about coffee that has you keeping your vote there for today?

 

[muttmanager]

Nothing solid. With nothing else to go on, I’ve just decided on someone who voted after half of the people already did, hasn’t been overly vocal to draw attention, and was comfortable being the 2nd vote on someone thereby contributing to a further tie.

Nothing substantial and not anything I would swear by. Just wanted to make sure I got a vote in!

Something about this makes my skin crawl, but the logic is sound.

How is that sound logic? Seems wolfy

Dead is @JaysmmmBT who never knew their role....and maybe you never will either.

Will we ever find out what Jays was? Can we know which team at least ?

No... but I didn’t want to gang up. So I figured I would go for dolphin who was my original random vote yesterday since I’m still not super sure how this works.

I’m happy to change it.

Not particularly. Still think mutt is wolfier

I’ll change it
unlynch dolphin

Lynch mutt

Voting one way to not "gang up" then flip flopping votes with no explaination is sketchy.

@grebes4lyfe @Melchizedek @Dandelion18 are on my list

 

[Animal Midwife]

What is it about coffee that has you keeping your vote there for today?

I'm waiting to see improvement from yesterday.

 

[Stagg737]

I consider it a little bit of karma 😉

*******
.......
*******

 

[Animal Midwife]

How is that sound logic? Seems wolfy



Will we ever find out what Jays was? Can we know which team at least ?





Voting one way to not "gang up" then flip flopping votes with no explaination is sketchy.

@grebes4lyfe @Melchizedek @Dandelion18 are on my list

Do you think Mel, Dandelion, and grebes could all be on the same wolf team together?

 

[muttmanager]

Do you think Mel, Dandelion, and grebes could all be on the same wolf team together?

Definitely. I think their strategy it to have Grebes play up being new

Mutts and Dandelion.

@johnnaboo @muttmanager how do you feel about staying on my vote at this point?

Then Mel calls me and dandelion out as sketch but, has me and jonnaboo on his vote.

Why wasn't dandelion on your vote @Melchizedek ?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Then Mel calls me and dandelion out as sketch but, has me and jonnaboo on his vote.

Can you explain more of what this means? Do you think he should've called out jboo?

 

[muttmanager]

Can you explain more of what this means? Do you think he should've called out jboo?

I assume he called her out since she voted for him and then disappeared but, why remove dandelion from his list unless he already knows she's a wolf

 

[Animal Midwife]

I assume he called her out since she voted for him and then disappeared but, why remove dandelion from his list unless he already knows she's a wolf

Can you show me where he removed Dandelion from the list? Do you feel okay with jboo?

 

[SportPonies]

Mel adding me to his list feels retalitory.
Details = context clues, weeding out the truth in posts since we dont have many clues to go off of

This is almost too smart for a noob. Frankly would be impressed if a first time player pulled a post like this without coaching.

Definitely. I think their strategy it to have Grebes play up being new

Then Mel calls me and dandelion out as sketch but, has me and jonnaboo on his vote.

Why wasn't dandelion on your vote @Melchizedek ?

And this.

I also don’t like coffee?’s play on D1 but it’ll take me a bit to dig out why since I’m still computerless.

 

[SportPonies]

Understand which part? I think the new players are going to have strategies or be posting things that will be harder to make sense of, and for someone else would be sketchy, but for a new player is just a new player But they haven't said much so this hasnt been true, I just anticipate it, and 3/15 players means this is true for 20%, which is a lot.

No, I meant leading D1 in general is getting old.

Not something I noticed yesterday, and very tin foil, but I can see coffee mis-counting noobs if she’s a wolf and a noob is a wolf (thus missing the noob wolf in the count)

She also offered nothing while leading the lynch, which in and of itself isn’t that wolfy because I’ve certainly done it as villager, but she did keep trying to draw attention to other players without any real conviction.

I like coffee and mutt as wolves right now.

 

[SportPonies]

Lynch mutt

Because I have incrementally more feels that way, but I think it would be useful to see either of them go today.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Not something I noticed yesterday, and very tin foil, but I can see coffee mis-counting noobs if she’s a wolf and a noob is a wolf (thus missing the noob wolf in the count)

She also offered nothing while leading the lynch, which in and of itself isn’t that wolfy because I’ve certainly done it as villager, but she did keep trying to draw attention to other players without any real conviction.

I like coffee and mutt as wolves right now.

Why were you still sitting on me at that point?

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Not something I noticed yesterday, and very tin foil, but I can see coffee mis-counting noobs if she’s a wolf and a noob is a wolf (thus missing the noob wolf in the count)

She also offered nothing while leading the lynch, which in and of itself isn’t that wolfy because I’ve certainly done it as villager, but she did keep trying to draw attention to other players without any real conviction.

I like coffee and mutt as wolves right now.

Except I went back and Jays was not labeled as noob in sign ups so this is where 3 came from

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Not something I noticed yesterday, and very tin foil, but I can see coffee mis-counting noobs if she’s a wolf and a noob is a wolf (thus missing the noob wolf in the count)

She also offered nothing while leading the lynch, which in and of itself isn’t that wolfy because I’ve certainly done it as villager, but she did keep trying to draw attention to other players without any real conviction.

I like coffee and mutt as wolves right now.

Who did I try to draw attention to without conviction?
AM asked my thoughts, I noticed that you threw down a joke vote, then left for the day, but were still on SDN. I also know in Baking you tried to stay quiet. Now you're pouncing on the first person to call you out for it.

 

[Melchizedek]

Adorably sketchy with an underlying innocence kinda describes me irl

but thats my thing

Mel adding me to his list feels retalitory.
Details = context clues, weeding out the truth in posts since we dont have many clues to go off of

I gave you sketch points because you pre-emptively proclaimed yourself villager with no pressure besides a random vote. I could see a noob wolf being startled into feeling like they have to respond to the first vote cast in their direction.
Take into account I was on Stagg's case for making a retaliatory vote and then backing off, and now you're accusing me of being retaliatory. Would a wolf do the same thing that they're drawing attention to from another person?

Also wanted to see how Mutts would react to a vote since axolotl was the only noob who'd checked in at that point.

I know Stagg can't respond, but who is he referring to as axolotl in this post?

Nothing solid. With nothing else to go on, I’ve just decided on someone who voted after half of the people already did, hasn’t been overly vocal to draw attention, and was comfortable being the 2nd vote on someone thereby contributing to a further tie.

Nothing substantial and not anything I would swear by. Just wanted to make sure I got a vote in!

How is that sound logic? Seems wolfy

@grebes4lyfe @Melchizedek @Dandelion18 are on my list

I said its sound logic because everything Dandy pointed out makes sense for how a wolf plays, the part that bothers me is that its a VERY spot on analysis for a first vote out of a new player. How do you feel about one of your suspicious players thinking another one of your suspicious players is sketchy? How do you feel about SAR?

Definitely. I think their strategy it to have Grebes play up being new




Then Mel calls me and dandelion out as sketch but, has me and jonnaboo on his vote.

Why wasn't dandelion on your vote @Melchizedek ?

I think you're confused what I meant about "being on my vote"
Let me clarify, I meant the people who were voting for me at the time (You and Jboo) I asked you both how you feel staying on my vote because it was close to lynch close and you both had voted for me without much reasoning. I wanted to see if you had re-evaluated me after seeing some of my thoughts. There was also the threat of a tie lingering, which never end well for village.
If you mean why wasn't dandelion on my sketchy list, they still are.

This is almost too smart for a noob. Frankly would be impressed if a first time player pulled a post like this without coaching.

I had a similar thought, but more along the lines of "noob wolf saw the AM/Stagg interchange about retaliatory votes being wolfy, and decided to fake wolf hunt by applying the same logic elsewhere."

Timing mostly.

Can you elaborate? I went back last night after seeing this response, and didn't see anything myself. Same thing when I looked again this morning, but I'd like to hear your thoughts.

Edit: fixing quotes

 

[muttmanager]

Can you show me where he removed Dandelion from the list? Do you feel okay with jboo?

See below. I don't have any feels towards jboo.

Lynch Stagg

Getting a vote in for now because I’m test driving cars. Feels between him and two of the noobs and I will be the first to say I’m bad at reading noobs.

Which two?

Mutts and Dandelion.

@johnnaboo @muttmanager how do you feel about staying on my vote at this point?
@Stagg737 are you home yet?

 

[muttmanager]

This is almost too smart for a noob. Frankly would be impressed if a first time player pulled a post like this without coaching.

First time player, but I read through old games.

 

[Animal Midwife]

I know Stagg can't respond, but who is he referring to as axolotl in this post?

He's referring to mutts.

See below. I don't have any feels towards jboo.

I guess I don't see where Dandelion was removed seeing she's mentioned as being sketchy to him in the quotes.

 

[Stagg737]

I know Stagg can't respond, but who is he referring to as axolotl in this post?

**********
Was nothing strategy related. Was jokingly referring to mutts as axolotl since I don't know her/his gender. Although if we start calling mutts axolotl then they'll really be taking all your things
***********

 

[muttmanager]

Would a wolf do the same thing that they're drawing attention to from another person?

I don't know that a wolf wouldn't do the same thing they're accusing someone else of. But its sketchy.

I said its sound logic because everything Dandy pointed out makes sense for how a wolf plays, the part that bothers me is that its a VERY spot on analysis for a first vote out of a new player. How do you feel about one of your suspicious players thinking another one of your suspicious players is sketchy? How do you feel about SAR?

So why, is her noob logic sound and mine suspicious?

I think dandy is definitely a wolf and should ve suspicious to everyone. I think you agreeing is smart but, i feel like you know more than your letting on.

I think you're confused what I meant about "being on my vote"
Let me clarify, I meant the people who were voting for me at the time (You and Jboo) I asked you both how you feel staying on my vote because it was close to lynch close and you both had voted for me without much reasoning. I wanted to see if you had re-evaluated me after seeing some of my thoughts. There was also the threat of a tie lingering, which never end well for village.
If you mean why wasn't dandelion on my sketchy list, they still are.

Definitely misunderstood that, my mistake.

I had a similar thought, but more along the lines of "noob wolf saw the AM/Stagg interchange about retaliatory votes being wolfy, and decided to fake wolf hunt by applying the same logic elsewhere."

It felt retalitory because the reasoning was bc I stated I'm village too soon. To clarify, that was out of confidence, not fear.

I can think clearly as a noob bc I'm not guilty of being a wolf.

 

[muttmanager]

He's referring to mutts.



I guess I don't see where Dandelion was removed seeing she's mentioned as being sketchy to him in the quotes.

I misunderstood what he was saying.

 

[muttmanager]

**********
Was nothing strategy related. Was jokingly referring to mutts as axolotl since I don't know her/his gender. Although if we start calling mutts axolotl then they'll really be taking all your things
***********

I'm a girl. She/her pronouns will do.
Axolotls creep me out

 

[SportPonies]

Why were you still sitting on me at that point?

Was studying and didn’t really read/evaluate posts beyond skimming until after lynch close.

Who did I try to draw attention to without conviction?
AM asked my thoughts, I noticed that you threw down a joke vote, then left for the day, but were still on SDN. I also know in Baking you tried to stay quiet. Now you're pouncing on the first person to call you out for it.

Me, mutts, and Mel I believe was the third.

I’m far from pouncing on you 😵 you’re acting like I’m all up in arms or calling you a wolf just because you “called me out”. I’m almost always quiet during WW and someone almost always mentions it; it’s not like it’s new to me. But it IS an easy thing people can and do try to twist as wolfy, and your play as a whole has not sat right with me so far.

 

[muttmanager]

Lynch Dandy

 

[muttmanager]

How do you feel about SAR?

Not enough to vote off of.

 

[Melchizedek]

So why, is her noob logic sound and mine suspicious?

I think dandy is definitely a wolf and should ve suspicious to everyone. I think you agreeing is smart but, i feel like you know more than your letting on.

Her logic is sound because it actually fits this situation whereas you tried to copy paste a retaliation claim onto something that wasn't so.
Retaliation is when A votes for B and B votes for A because A voted for B.
AM voted for Stagg, Stagg voted for AM after - retaliation.
You voted for me, I gave you sketch points for something entirely unrelated. - not retaliation.

Not enough to vote off of.

huh. Thats weird seeing as how you've been on my case for agreeing with Dandy's logic, but SAR has done the same and you have no analysis of that? This shows me you're not consistently applying logic to your wolf-hunting and makes me think you're manufacturing your reads.

Lynch Mutts

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Was studying and didn’t really read/evaluate posts beyond skimming until after lynch close.


Me, mutts, and Mel I believe was the third.

I’m far from pouncing on you 😵 you’re acting like I’m all up in arms or calling you a wolf just because you “called me out”. I’m almost always quiet during WW and someone almost always mentions it; it’s not like it’s new to me. But it IS an easy thing people can and do try to twist as wolfy, and your play as a whole has not sat right with me so far.

I was talking about mutts and Mel because I was giving me reason for where I voted to break a 4 way tie

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Was studying and didn’t really read/evaluate posts beyond skimming until after lynch close.


Me, mutts, and Mel I believe was the third.

I’m far from pouncing on you 😵 you’re acting like I’m all up in arms or calling you a wolf just because you “called me out”. I’m almost always quiet during WW and someone almost always mentions it; it’s not like it’s new to me. But it IS an easy thing people can and do try to twist as wolfy, and your play as a whole has not sat right with me so far.

And it is not uncommon for wolves to get squirmy when people call them out. During After Wedding, Paws also got defensive when I pointed out her behavior. So, saying you find my behavior off right after I said you were suspect, yes that does raise more eyebrows.

 

[Dandelion18]

I'm still reeling from the compliments on my noob logic, which makes me hesitant to point out the major flaw in it. If Jays was a wolf, it looks like he/she didn't know it. Re-reading through the thread, mod asked Jays to fix the PM status so they could send a role. Then the write up said Jayss never knew what their role is. Then after the write up the mod asked Jays to fix the PM status again. So although it is really hard to believe it, is anyone else's impression that Jayss voted in the lynch without knowing his/her own role?

 

[Animal Midwife]

I'm still reeling from the compliments on my noob logic, which makes me hesitant to point out the major flaw in it. If Jays was a wolf, it looks like he/she didn't know it. Re-reading through the thread, mod asked Jays to fix the PM status so they could send a role. Then the write up said Jayss never knew what their role is. Then after the write up the mod asked Jays to fix the PM status again. So although it is really hard to believe it, is anyone else's impression that Jayss voted in the lynch without knowing his/her own role?

Absolutely this. In which case, his posts should be read as uniformed (villager) regardless of his affiliation.

 

[muttmanager]

huh. Thats weird seeing as how you've been on my case for agreeing with Dandy's logic, but SAR has done the same and you have no analysis of that? This shows me you're not consistently applying logic to your wolf-hunting and makes me think you're manufacturing your reads.

Lynch Mutts

It wasn't about agreeing with her logic. I was on your case based on the post I misunderstood, that reasoning no longer holds true.

I'm not sure what you mean by manufacturing my reads. I am more focused on posts that mention me directly, which is why SAR has not stood out to me.

Edit: grammar

 

[sheltermed]

allie was the only non-poster. shelter also didn't vote.

shelter has no excuses. shelter had a very long night of hydration.

anyway, just checking in! catching up now.

 

[Animal Midwife]

shelter has no excuses. shelter had a very long night of hydration.

anyway, just checking in! catching up now.

i like this post

 

[Melchizedek]

It wasn't about agreeing with her logic. I was on your case based on the post I misunderstood, that reasoning no longer holds true.

I'm not sure what you mean by manufacturing my reads. I am more focused on posts that mention me directly, which is why SAR has not stood out to me.

Edit: grammar

So why, is her noob logic sound and mine suspicious?

Okay, the bolded above made it sound like you don't like that I agree with her logic. The comment in red is more likely to make you look like a wolf. Putting out theories and making a logical case against someone goes a long way to making you look less sketchy v.s. just responding to the posts against you.

Unlynch Mutts

 

[muttmanager]

Upon further investigating, @SARdoghandler lynched Dandy for her logic.

 

[sheltermed]

does anyone have, like, a list of those who are first-time players in this game? I'd make one myself but I'm about to go order food.

 

[Animal Midwife]

does anyone have, like, a list of those who are first-time players in this game? I'd make one myself but I'm about to go order food.

mutt, grebes, and Dandelion are the ones still alive. Though I'm not sure how this was missed during catching up since they all mentioned being noobs.

 

[sheltermed]

mutt, grebes, and Dandelion are the ones still alive. Though I'm not sure how this was missed during catching up since they all mentioned being noobs.

well you can be a noob without it being your first game, no?