Pirates of the Caribbean WW Official Game Thread

[Philliab]

Advertisement - Members don't see this ad

Wait, so SnS wasn't a villager?
oooo, who was lying to whom?

Great game mods...
You really had us going at the end. 🙂

She was...mostly. She counted as a villager, but had her own win condition too.

 

[StartingoverVet]

She was...mostly. She counted as a villager, but had her own win condition too.

sneaky thimble...

if we lynched her again would she have lived?

 

[Philliab]

I didn't think Devyn and I had a chance with all the items around (we only converted EC near the very end)...
That damn spyglass and necklace were particularly annoying for us.

Well...I did let you smash the spyglass so the end. 😉

But I thought it would be really fun to go back toward the basics with roles and add in lots of items. Dyachei had to talk me down from the billions of items I wanted to have, and I'm glad she did! But that way those without roles had the chance to gather information so they could participate more. 🙂

 

[StartingoverVet]

And @jdh71 claimed he couldn't be killed while I was alive, was that a lie?

 

[shortnsweet]

Yes...I couldn't be lynched.

And I was playing for the villagers...so I wasn't lying. Evil wolf

 

[Philliab]

sneaky thimble...

if we lynched her again would she have lived?

Yup...she could not be lynched.

I figured the wolves were angry they'd kept her around so long when you couldn't kill her 2 nights ago.

 

[StartingoverVet]

Well...I did let you smash the spyglass so the end. 😉

But I thought it would be really fun to go back toward the basics with roles and add in lots of items. Dyachei had to talk me down from the billions of items I wanted to have, and I'm glad she did! But that way those without roles had the chance to gather information so they could participate more. 🙂

Kind of funny I had one of the few "active" roles, protecting, but never got to use it....

 

[Philliab]

And @jdh71 claimed he couldn't be killed while I was alive, was that a lie?

Actually no, but I realized later why he might think that. His life was tied to that of Davy Jones, his true captain, so he couldn't be killed by wolves while devyn was alive.

 

[shortnsweet]

At least I went clutching my beautiful jar of dirt.

 

[Philliab]

At least I went clutching my beautiful jar of dirt.

Thought you would appreciate that. 😀

 

[StartingoverVet]

Yes...I couldn't be lynched.

And I was playing for the villagers...so I wasn't lying. Evil wolf

You withheld a "little" info... I withheld a little info....
No difference.. savvy?

 

[StartingoverVet]

Yup...she could not be lynched.

I figured the wolves were angry they'd kept her around so long when you couldn't kill her 2 nights ago.

we were more angry that the game was still going on AND we couldn't kill her when we thought we had won when there were 3 villagers and 3 wolves left and all those dead around...

 

[shortnsweet]

Grumble. I can't believe people believed you over me...and when I was on a plane.

 

[StartingoverVet]

So did DVMD and Lupin know anything, or was a paranoid that Lupins turtles mean a wolf in tortuga, and dvmd's growling meant I was a wolf?

 

[Philliab]

we were more angry that the game was still going on AND we couldn't kill her when we thought we had won when there were 3 villagers and 3 wolves left and all those dead around...

My evil plan worked.

 

[StartingoverVet]

Grumble. I can't believe people believed you over me...and when I was on a plane.

mostly it was just fellow wolves....

cmon.. transatlantic flights are very wolvie.

 

[shortnsweet]

we were more angry that the game was still going on AND we couldn't kill her when we thought we had won when there were 3 villagers and 3 wolves left and all those dead around...

Like Sparrow wouldn't go down without a good fight....

 

[shortnsweet]

mostly it was just fellow wolves....

cmon.. transatlantic flights are very wolvie.

Lol ask DVM....I was fuming when you said that and I found out this morning.

 

[Philliab]

So did DVMD and Lupin know anything, or was a paranoid that Lupins turtles mean a wolf in tortuga, and dvmd's growling meant I was a wolf?

They knew nothing and were not allowed to post any strategy at all. So....you were paranoid. I did tell them that they were giving you a heart attack when they voted for you and almost begged them to change their vote. They wouldn't listen to me.

 

[StartingoverVet]

Actually no, but I realized later why he might think that. His life was tied to that of Davy Jones, his true captain, so he couldn't be killed by wolves while devyn was alive.

Interesting. I really thought he just said that to gain my trust, but he was being truthful as far as he knew.
Funny how things work out.

 

[Philliab]

Interesting. I really thought he just said that to gain my trust, but he was being truthful as far as he knew.
Funny how things work out.

Or he could have just read his role PM a little more carefully. 😛

 

[StartingoverVet]

They knew nothing and were not allowed to post any strategy at all. So....you were paranoid. I did tell them that they were giving you a heart attack when they voted for you and almost begged them to change their vote. They wouldn't listen to me.

I was so sure that turtles was about tortuga..
So did they have a posting restriction, or they just made that stuff up themselves.. It was pretty fun (even if it triggered my paranoid schizophrenia).

 

[dyachei]

you guys had it in the bag for the last 5 nights. So your complaining had no effect on us

 

[DVMDream]

So did DVMD and Lupin know anything, or was a paranoid that Lupins turtles mean a wolf in tortuga, and dvmd's growling meant I was a wolf?

I was not told anything, you had made yourself an obvious wolf in my mind. Wasn't surprised with devyn either. EC I wasn't expecting because figured game would have been over had there been 3 wolves.

The growling meant nothing, we were told to bring some chaos into the game. So we did. Our vote, we kept attempting to intentionally tie the highest vote getters...

 

[StartingoverVet]

you guys had it in the bag for the last 5 nights. So your complaining had no effect on us

I was sure someone would keep voodoo-ing me to change my vote, and no one ever did....
not sure how i kept escaping.

It was funny (not at the time) it went no kill... no lynch... no kill... no lynch the previous 2 cycles.. That is pretty rare.. Devyn was more frustrated than me...

 

[Philliab]

you guys had it in the bag for the last 5 nights. So your complaining had no effect on us

Or since FFM got out of being lynched early in the game. 🙄 Still would have loved to be a fly on the wall....

 

[StartingoverVet]

I was not told anything, you had made yourself an obvious wolf in my mind. Wasn't surprised with devyn either. EC I wasn't expecting because figured game would have been over had there been 3 wolves.

The growling meant nothing, we were told to bring some chaos into the game. So we did. Our vote, we kept attempting to intentionally tie the highest vote getters...

LOL... well done.

 

[Chillbo Baggins]

I guess I got recruited to the winning team, and I'm immortal, so yeah!

 

[Philliab]

I was so sure that turtles was about tortuga..
So did they have a posting restriction, or they just made that stuff up themselves.. It was pretty fun (even if it triggered my paranoid schizophrenia).

Posting restriction....They had to post as their animal.

DVMD= Prison Dog
Lupin = Sea turtles

Escalla then Lupin could actually talk to the people in World 's End to decide their vote.

 

[StartingoverVet]

Or since FFM got out of being lynched early in the game. 🙄 Still would have loved to be a fly on the wall....

after i got converted and FFM and lissarae were both goners... it was touch and go....
we were constantly worried devyn would be lynched and we would lose the last conversion.

We lucked out a bit in so many distractions....

 

[Lupin21]

My turtles were all posted in relation to what was being said in the thread. Except I did post my crying turtles in response to jdh's lynch votes. That made me sad. And Tortuga actually translates into Turtle, SOV. 😉

 

[StartingoverVet]

My turtles were all posted in relation to what was being said in the thread. Except I did post my crying turtles in response to jdh's lynch votes. That made me sad. And Tortuga actually translates into Turtle, SOV. 😉

I know.. that's why I thought you were hinting there was a wolf in Tortuga bay.

 

[StartingoverVet]

Oh, DVMD... i totally didn't want you to be killed. I was enjoying the parrot communication, but Devyn said you were going to ask lissarae with the liar's dice about that davey jones thing, and that would uncover her.... that's why you were killed.

 

[DVMDream]

So exactly how paranoid did lupin and I make SOV be? I'd love to see that convo... 😉

 

[DVMDream]

Oh, DVMD... i totally didn't want you to be killed. I was enjoying the parrot communication, but Devyn said you were going to ask lissarae with the liar's dice about that davey jones thing, and that would uncover her.... that's why you were killed.

I figured that, but it would have revealed lissa not devyn.... Oh well

 

[Lupin21]

I know.. that's why I thought you were hinting there was a wolf in Tortuga bay.

The only one I thought would really set you off was my suspicious turtle, but it was because you said it in a sentence twice. 😀

 

[Chillbo Baggins]

And Tortuga actually translates into Turtle, SOV. 😉

Oh man, this makes me think of Breaking Bad! (Btw, has there been a BrBa WW??)

 

[StartingoverVet]

1) So first Lupin's posts of a turtle made me think she was saying a wolf was in Tortuga bay.
2) They your first GIF was of that poodle growling at a dog that looked like an IG to me... so i thought you were saying I was a wolf. Then every GIF that had a growling dog made me think you were trying to reinforce the message..

so pretty paranoid.

 

[StartingoverVet]

I figured that, but it would have revealed lissa not devyn.... Oh well

No.. actually devyn was davey jones...
she thought you were going to ask who was davey jones.

Unless it was just a yes or no question...

 

[Philliab]

I guess I got recruited to the winning team, and I'm immortal, so yeah!

Actually...I was really sad when The Auctioneer was killed. I enjoyed your posts.

 

[DVMDream]

1) So first Lupin's posts of a turtle made me think she was saying a wolf was in Tortuga bay.
2) They your first GIF was of that poodle growling at a dog that looked like an IG to me... so i thought you were saying I was a wolf. Then every GIF that had a growling dog made me think you were trying to reinforce the message..

so pretty paranoid.

😆 I also posted a growling dog at devyn

 

[StartingoverVet]

😆 I also posted a growling dog at devyn

yeah, that didn't help.

 

[Lupin21]

1) So first Lupin's posts of a turtle made me think she was saying a wolf was in Tortuga bay.
2) They your first GIF was of that poodle growling at a dog that looked like an IG to me... so i thought you were saying I was a wolf. Then every GIF that had a growling dog made me think you were trying to reinforce the message..

so pretty paranoid.

So what did you make of our message to you about look for clues in Davey Jones' Locker and the bit about not trusting World's End people?

 

[Philliab]

So exactly how paranoid did lupin and I make SOV be? I'd love to see that convo... 😉

1) So first Lupin's posts of a turtle made me think she was saying a wolf was in Tortuga bay.
2) They your first GIF was of that poodle growling at a dog that looked like an IG to me... so i thought you were saying I was a wolf. Then every GIF that had a growling dog made me think you were trying to reinforce the message..

so pretty paranoid.

So...since you didn't known SnS' other win condition, is that why you were so worried about the dead? Is they why you thought we we still playing?

 

[Lupin21]

yeah, that didn't help.

I almost started posting turtles eating corn when you made that list of who everyone was. I really wish I would have now.

 

[Chillbo Baggins]

Actually...I was really say when The Auctioneer was killed. I enjoyed your posts.

It's probably good that I got killed off; I ended up being waaay busier those first few days than I thought.

 

[StartingoverVet]

Let's be honest.. that late in the game, you know I have to figure I am on borrowed time...
I'm going to be paranoid no matter what anyone says..

I kind of laughed at how easy it was to eliminate JDH and DocE in lynches. That 2 votes thing is really useful as a wolf.
I don't think JDH was gonna let me stay around too much longer.

 

[DVMDream]

No.. actually devyn was davey jones...
she thought you were going to ask who was davey jones.

Unless it was just a yes or no question...

Devyn fails here, I told her you can't ask about role/name/alliance.

I was going to ask Lissa if she knew who Davy Jones was, her answer would have been yes, buti didn't even ask lissa, I switched to SnS and even told devyn that....

 

[StartingoverVet]

So what did you make of our message to you about look for clues in Davey Jones' Locker and the bit about not trusting World's End people?

I was confused...
I didn;t know you sent it.
I thought someone knew that you guys knew who the wolves were but the sender of the message didn't know themselves and thought I was a villager.

I was like "yeah, they know I'm a wolf" to myself.
"Thanks for the useless advice. "

 

[Philliab]

Let's be honest.. that late in the game, you know I have to figure I am on borrowed time...
I'm going to be paranoid no matter what anyone says..

I kind of laughed at how easy it was to eliminate JDH and DocE in lynches. That 2 votes thing is really useful as a wolf. I don't think JDH was gonna let me stay around too much longer.

I think hedgie was the only one that brought up that you would have been a great convention target. Thought the villagers would jump on that quickly, but alas...