BCOM vs LUCOM vs Caribbean

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

BCOM, LUCOM, Carib


  • Total voters
    222
BCOM > Caribbean >>>>>>>>>> LUCOM
As anti-Caribbean as I am, I think I might actually agree with you...

The president of Liberty University is endorsing Trump. I don't know how much worse you can get than a university with a president who endorses a racist misogynist.
 
I personally would not choose any of those programs. Reapply and get a better DO school that has federal loans and graduates. Then go live your dream of being a doctor.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
 
I personally would not choose any of those programs. Reapply and get a better DO school that has federal loans and graduates. Then go live your dream of being a doctor.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
you came back just to bash bcom in 3 seperate threads? get a life
 
you came back just to bash bcom in 3 seperate threads? get a life
None of that was bashing it's solid advice anyone would give to someone picking schools. BCOM messed up the emails which was funny and sad for applicants. Second they have no loans or graduates, and that's risky. I had just got back on the app and started commenting on threads I participated in. Do not take everything personally. If you are attesting BCOM good for you, congrats. You do not see me getting flustered over people saying DO doctors are incompetent to MD and will not get residencies. That's one argument that gets me, but I do not say go get a life to someone. People have opinions, and mine is rooted in facts. Thanks for your suggestion of getting a life and expression of your character.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
 
None of that was bashing it's solid advice anyone would give to someone picking schools. BCOM messed up the emails which was funny and sad for applicants. Second they have no loans or graduates, and that's risky. I had just got back on the app and started commenting on threads I participated in. Do not take everything personally. If you are attesting BCOM good for you, congrats. You do not see me getting flustered over people saying DO doctors are incompetent to MD and will not get residencies. That's one argument that gets me, but I do not say go get a life to someone. People have opinions, and mine is rooted in facts. Thanks for your suggestion of getting a life and expression of your character.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
A couple of students have already gotten approved for loans on the Facebook page.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile app
 
A couple of students have already gotten approved for loans on the Facebook page.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile app
Federal loans, of course anyone can go out and get a regular loan. The school is new therefore you have to take out one from a bank instead of the government.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
 
Federal loans, of course anyone can go out and get a regular loan. The school is new therefore you have to take out one from a bank instead of the government.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
Yes definitely. It's been talked about a lot. The pros and cons of it all are out there for people. Best of luck at your program


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile app
 
I personally would not choose any of those programs. Reapply and get a better DO school that has federal loans and graduates. Then go live your dream of being a doctor.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile

While I agree with your sentiment unfortunately if someone was accepted to BCOM and LUCOM and turned those acceptances down their chances of another DO acceptance again is probably close to 0. It would be best to only apply to these schools in a second cycle after not having any luck in the first cycle with better DO schools. If they had these acceptances it would be the far better choice to go to BCOM then reject them and reapply.
 
While I agree with your sentiment unfortunately if someone was accepted to BCOM and LUCOM and turned those acceptances down their chances of another DO acceptance again is probably close to 0. It would be best to only apply to these schools in a second cycle after not having any luck in the first cycle with better DO schools. If they had these acceptances it would be the far better choice to go to BCOM then reject them and reapply.

Makes sense. Lesser of two evils.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
 
Makes sense. Lesser of two evils.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile

two evils? You have got to be kidding. It's a new school, has created GME, has launched a research institute, have mostly ward based rotations, and is partnered with a State university. What else do you want? that is already better than quite alot of DO schools

I can't understand your obsession with BCOM you literally post against it in every single thread you are in
 
two evils? You have got to be kidding. It's a new school, has created GME, has launched a research institute, have mostly ward based rotations, and is partnered with a State university. What else do you want? that is already better than quite alot of DO schools

I can't understand your obsession with BCOM you literally post against it in every single thread you are in


Dude or woman I am openly against BCOM, until they are proven I would not recommend it. If you would like to be openly against VCOM where I am going by all means you are entitled to that. The lesser of two evils comment was not directed toward you clearly. I have my opinion and I was discussing with the other poster as they had a good point. The OP should accept BCOM if that was their only choices. Why get so defensive. Let's just leave it at this, or private message me where this belongs.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
 
two evils? You have got to be kidding. It's a new school, has created GME, has launched a research institute, have mostly ward based rotations, and is partnered with a State university. What else do you want? that is already better than quite alot of DO schools

I can't understand your obsession with BCOM you literally post against it in every single thread you are in

Easy Dusty. Yes it is definitely the lesser of two evils. A new school should always be questioned until it is proven. When it gets government grants for quality research I'll believe the bit about research, when the 3rd year students all have ward based rotations, I'll believe that as well (I am straight up calling BS by the way that they will have mostly ward based rotations), when all of their proposed GME gets ACGME accredited I will believe all of that as well. And it's "association" with NMSU is not a partnership. They let them use some facilities.

Sorry but until BCOM graduates its first class and outs its money where it's mouth is then it should be questioned. And I will most definitely go there if it is my only acceptance next year but I will still be skeptical until they prove themselves. They haven't even matriculated a class yet, I don't know why you are so defensive that it is questioned.
 
And it's "association" with NMSU is not a partnership. They let them use some facilities.
I'm gonna have to correct you on this one. The relationship between BCOM and NMSU is definitely a partnership. BCOM has already announced that they have worked out a deal with NMSU for the medical students to get MBA's through NMSU and access to the MPH program is in the works. BCOM has invested quite a bit of money into a pipeline scholarship program with NMSU to get in-state residents to pursue medicine. And then the dean himself told me that there are future plans (once BCOM gains New Mexico state accreditation) to have cross enrollment between BCOM and NMSU so BCOM students can take advantage of NSMU courses and NMSU students can take classes taught by BCOM faculty. Lastly, BCOM students are encouraged to participate in the research the NMSU faculty are doing.
 
I'm gonna have to correct you on this one. The relationship between BCOM and NMSU is definitely a partnership. BCOM has already announced that they have worked out a deal with NMSU for the medical students to get MBA's through NMSU and access to the MPH program is in the works. BCOM has invested quite a bit of money into a pipeline scholarship program with NMSU to get in-state residents to pursue medicine. And then the dean himself told me that there are future plans (once BCOM gains New Mexico state accreditation) to have cross enrollment between BCOM and NMSU so BCOM students can take advantage of NSMU courses and NMSU students can take classes taught by BCOM faculty. Lastly, BCOM students are encouraged to participate in the research the NMSU faculty are doing.

It's like I said earlier though, when everything is in place and running I will believe it. People can say a lot of things but until everything is finalized then it doesn't mean much. If everything will run as you say how come it isn't just a state school? Don't get me wrong I actually believe BCOM will be a good school in the long run, but I think a few people have christened it the best thing to happen to osteopathic medicine since AT Still without them even matriculating a single class.
 
It's like I said earlier though, when everything is in place and running I will believe it. People can say a lot of things but until everything is finalized then it doesn't mean much. If everything will run as you say how come it isn't just a state school? Don't get me wrong I actually believe BCOM will be a good school in the long run, but I think a few people have christened it the best thing to happen to osteopathic medicine since AT Still without them even matriculating a single class.

The only reason the school is BCOM and not NMSU-COM is that New Mexico is a very poor state and can't afford to support a 2nd medical school. That's it. Part of what makes BCOM such a promising program is that it was designed and planned as a state school, and pretty much is in all but name.

I think BCOM has been getting a lot of flak because people see the for profit status, make a lot of assumptions, and don't look any further. When you really research the details, you start to realize that BCOM is a very put together program, more so than many other new schools were at this stage. People are entitled to their skepticism, but it just seems unnecessarily pessimistic to assume that BCOM won't be able to follow through on their plans. Are their going to be growing pains? Sure, but I think it's pessimism for the sake of pessimism to sit around waiting (or wishing as some people seem to be doing) for this new program to fail.
 
The only reason the school is BCOM and not NMSU-COM is that New Mexico is a very poor state and can't afford to support a 2nd medical school. That's it. Part of what makes BCOM such a promising program is that it was designed and planned as a state school, and pretty much is in all but name.

I think BCOM has been getting a lot of flak because people see the for profit status, make a lot of assumptions, and don't look any further. When you really research the details, you start to realize that BCOM is a very put together program, more so than many other new schools were at this stage. People are entitled to their skepticism, but it just seems unnecessarily pessimistic to assume that BCOM won't be able to follow through on their plans. Are their going to be growing pains? Sure, but I think it's pessimism for the sake of pessimism to sit around waiting (or wishing as some people seem to be doing) for this new program to fail.

Makes sense. Finally some educated discussion. Thanks for the info.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
 
This whole idea that BCOM and NMSU is launching a research facility is hogwash. NMSU has a single R01 funded investigator and has a single collab project with fred hutch. The research inst BCOM has created is a health policy research program, not a true biomedical research inst. So if students are going there for "the research" they are going to go to be quite surprised that all that hype wasnt true.
 
This whole idea that BCOM and NMSU is launching a research facility is hogwash. NMSU has a single R01 funded investigator and has a single collab project with fred hutch. The research inst BCOM has created is a health policy research program, not a true biomedical research inst. So if students are going there for "the research" they are going to go to be quite surprised that all that hype wasnt true.

Yeah, it isn't like NMSU has "world-class" biomedical research. To get that, you'll need to stick with pharma research-driven areas, like the Northeast (especially Boston, Philly, NYC, Chicagoland, California, Texas.)
 
The only reason the school is BCOM and not NMSU-COM is that New Mexico is a very poor state and can't afford to support a 2nd medical school. That's it. Part of what makes BCOM such a promising program is that it was designed and planned as a state school, and pretty much is in all but name.

I think BCOM has been getting a lot of flak because people see the for profit status, make a lot of assumptions, and don't look any further. When you really research the details, you start to realize that BCOM is a very put together program, more so than many other new schools were at this stage. People are entitled to their skepticism, but it just seems unnecessarily pessimistic to assume that BCOM won't be able to follow through on their plans. Are their going to be growing pains? Sure, but I think it's pessimism for the sake of pessimism to sit around waiting (or wishing as some people seem to be doing) for this new program to fail.

I also believe that the exhoribitant nonrefundable deposit of $3000 for BCOM and accepting students extremely early left a bad taste. They only had 30 days to decide, well before other schools have even offered admission. They sent out interview invites starting in June!

I, for one, saw through how terrible 'for-profit' status has done for applicants who were accepted early. You can easily see through how $$$ driven they are. It is NM, where cost of living is cheap compared elsewhere. BCOM could have easily taken their time, picked more quality applicants instead of rushing to fill their class ASAP before October...they wanted to maximize profits hoping people would drop out so they could keep the $3000.

I would've said the same for any school that forced students into $3000 deposits. At least refund half if you decide to go elsewhere! PCOM and Rowan only offer $250 and $200 deposits....
 
Last edited:
I also believe that the exhoribitant nonrefundable deposit of $3000 for BCOM and accepting students extremely early left a bad taste. They only had 30 days to decide, well before other schools have even offered admission. They sent out interview invites starting in June!

I, for one, saw through how terrible 'for-profit' status has done for applicants who were accepted early. You can easily see through how $$$ driven they are. It is NM, where cost of living is cheap compared elsewhere. BCOM could have easily taken their time, picked more quality applicants instead of rushing to fill their class ASAP before October...they wanted to maximize profits hoping people would drop out so they could keep the $3000.

I would've said the same for any school that forced students into $3000 deposits. At least refund half if you decide to go elsewhere! PCOM and Rowan only offer $250 and $200 deposits....


Bcom isn't the only school that has a 3K deposit. If they were about money their tuition would be much higher. And there is nothing more ignorant than thinking policy research isn't important @AlteredScale really disappointed in hearing that from you

You will all find a way to complain about anything, atleast there is some conscious effort to do research. Alot of DO schools don't even make that attempt.

And none of you are being reasonable, rather than accurately saying the jury is out you are assuming the worst outcomes in the future
 
Bcom isn't the only school that has a 3K deposit. If they were about money their tuition would be much higher. And there is nothing more ignorant than thinking policy research isn't important @AlteredScale really disappointed in hearing that from you

You will all find a way to complain about anything, atleast there is some conscious effort to do research. Alot of DO schools don't even make that attempt.

And none of you are being reasonable, rather than accurately saying the jury is out you are assuming the worst outcomes in the future

I know...that's why I said "I would've said the same for any school that forced students into $3000 deposits." BCOM isn't the only one to do this. Also, for a school in NM, where property taxes and standard of living costs are very cheap, I would expect the tuition to be even lower than what it is now. If they want good students, and they're a new school, they should do what they can. CUSOM gave out $10k and $20k scholarships PER year to students in hopes of recruiting them.

Look, we have to be reasonable here. I feel that it is feasibly impossible to have a school like BCOM give out this many "promises" in the time they were allotted. It feels like they're just racing to get everything done, but did not think that sometimes, more time is needed to get things done right.

You can't just build a research building and then say that the research you're doing is amazing. You can't say that a new medical school is amazing from the get go. Harvard took over 200 years to get the reputation it deserves today. It takes many many years to make partnerships, relationships with hospitals, and to get its reputation to where the school stands today. Research takes years sometimes to even publish a paper.

Yes, BCOM is promising, and they're doing all they can do establish itself as a good new school. However, they don't really seem to be handling things in a more "humbling" manner. They are acting like they're the new kid on the block and they're better than everybody else. Perhaps it is because of its accepted students are acting like they're super impressed with how amazing it is but are really naïve.

Also, I can't help but think (and I'm not trying to be mean here,) that a for-profit school being in one of the poorest states in the nation is a good combination (especially charging students $3000 just to get a seat.) It just leaves a bad taste, that's all. It just feels like corporate greed is trying to take advantage of NM's "poor status." University of Phoenix is for-profit and we all know how that turned out...

But I will say this...almost everyone will bash a new school. It isn't just unique to BCOM. I'm sure CUSOM had the same "bashing" a couple years back.
 
Last edited:
And there is nothing more ignorant than thinking policy research isn't important @AlteredScale really disappointed in hearing that from you

And it is also fairly ignorant to think that policy research will help all that much come residency application time. If I wanted to study policy I would go get a masters in public health. It's a joke really, people go to medical school to, you know, study medicine and most want to do research in its different fields. It's not that policy research isn't important, it's that it shouldn't be the type of research done by the majority of medical students. Especially the ones trying to do research in their field of interest. BCOM should do better, especially if they are going to advertise thier "research opportunities" to applicants.
 
I also believe that the exhoribitant nonrefundable deposit of $3000 for BCOM and accepting students extremely early left a bad taste. They only had 30 days to decide, well before other schools have even offered admission. They sent out interview invites starting in June!

I, for one, saw through how terrible 'for-profit' status has done for applicants who were accepted early. You can easily see through how $$$ driven they are. It is NM, where cost of living is cheap compared elsewhere. BCOM could have easily taken their time, picked more quality applicants instead of rushing to fill their class ASAP before October...they wanted to maximize profits hoping people would drop out so they could keep the $3000.

I would've said the same for any school that forced students into $3000 deposits. At least refund half if you decide to go elsewhere! PCOM and Rowan only offer $250 and $200 deposits....

I'm not sure what the cost of living in New Mexico has to do with the deposit. Would you care to elaborate on that point?

I know you've had this discussion with multiple people, so I won't beleaguer the point too much. The two main points are that BCOM was trying to avoid being taken advantage of by students with no intention of attending, and they are implementing pre-matriculation coursework. BCOM has ended up being significantly more popular then anyone (BCOM included) anticipated. In hindsight, such a high deposit probably wasn't necessary, but as a new school that cannot give out more acceptances than they have seats, BCOM was trying to avoid a situation where they had a large percentage of squatters with no intention of attending putting down deposits and sitting on their seats until spring. Also, we now know that BCOM was planning (and has now implemented) pre-matriculation coursework. Every accepted student has received a package of books and instructions for faculty moderated discussions and essays. I suspect that the high price of the deposit was at least in part intended to cover the materials and faculty pay for these courses.
 
I'm not sure what the cost of living in New Mexico has to do with the deposit. Would you care to elaborate on that point?

I know you've had this discussion with multiple people, so I won't beleaguer the point too much. The two main points are that BCOM was trying to avoid being taken advantage of by students with no intention of attending, and they are implementing pre-matriculation coursework. BCOM has ended up being significantly more popular then anyone (BCOM included) anticipated. In hindsight, such a high deposit probably wasn't necessary, but as a new school that cannot give out more acceptances than they have seats, BCOM was trying to avoid a situation where they had a large percentage of squatters with no intention of attending putting down deposits and sitting on their seats until spring. Also, we now know that BCOM was planning (and has now implemented) pre-matriculation coursework. Every accepted student has received a package of books and instructions for faculty moderated discussions and essays. I suspect that the high price of the deposit was at least in part intended to cover the materials and faculty pay for these courses.
Dang you have work before Med school even starts? Interesting.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
 
I'm not sure what the cost of living in New Mexico has to do with the deposit. Would you care to elaborate on that point?

I know you've had this discussion with multiple people, so I won't beleaguer the point too much. The two main points are that BCOM was trying to avoid being taken advantage of by students with no intention of attending, and they are implementing pre-matriculation coursework. BCOM has ended up being significantly more popular then anyone (BCOM included) anticipated. In hindsight, such a high deposit probably wasn't necessary, but as a new school that cannot give out more acceptances than they have seats, BCOM was trying to avoid a situation where they had a large percentage of squatters with no intention of attending putting down deposits and sitting on their seats until spring. Also, we now know that BCOM was planning (and has now implemented) pre-matriculation coursework. Every accepted student has received a package of books and instructions for faculty moderated discussions and essays. I suspect that the high price of the deposit was at least in part intended to cover the materials and faculty pay for these courses.

What I'm trying to say is that the costs of running a school in NM is probably a lot less than running a school in Philadelphia, or running a school in Chicago. Plus, coupled that with the fact that most students who are attending medical school do not have that much money, it is kind of a slap to the face (for me at least,) that they unnecessarily charged $3000 to take advantage of students wanting to become a physician. BCOM doesn't need that much money, but I feel that the for-profit status caused them to charge that much.

I know this isn't going to be a fair comparison, but there are schools like RowanSOM which offers a FREE pre-matriculation program with only a $200 deposit to their school, for ALL accepted students. They just have to be responsible for living costs, which is expected.
 
Never said policy research was not important. Of course it is. putting words in my mouth is the scape goat to get out of the fact that I simply spoke the truth . We should make an HONEST assesment of the school and provide TRUTHFUL evidence that BCOM has not made a push toward biomedical sciences research because they know full well that no investigator is running to Las Cruces due to their potential growth as a research hub. Where are they going? UNM

Instead of spouting off about the "amazing research" bcom will have why not be straight up about it so that potential matriculants dont get sucked into this idea that theyll perhaps win an NSF, Sarnoff, HHMI student research fellowship if the go to bcom for their research?







Sent from my iPad using SDN mobile app
 
Also, we now know that BCOM was planning (and has now implemented) pre-matriculation coursework. Every accepted student has received a package of books and instructions for faculty moderated discussions and essays.

This is ridiculous. BCOM just came off of my list of schools to apply to. Why on earth would a student need to write essays before school even starts. The summer before medical school should be for relaxing, moving, and spending time gearing up for the rigor to come, not for writing useless essays and discussion among people who have yet to even take a medical school class yet.
 
This is ridiculous. BCOM just came off of my list of schools to apply to. Why on earth would a student need to write essays before school even starts. The summer before medical school should be for relaxing, moving, and spending time gearing up for the rigor to come, not for writing useless essays and discussion among people who have yet to even take a medical school class yet.


The essays are like one page reflections on books that describe NM healthcare and culture. Relax.

And noone is heralding BCOM as the greatest program in history. Don't understand why you think anyone views it that way. It's an exciting new program that's all.


If you let an internet forum dictate your application strategy rather than independent objective research I hope you stay far away from my program (atsusoma) because that is just ridiculous
 
The essays are like one page reflections on books that describe NM healthcare and culture. Relax.

And noone is heralding BCOM as the greatest program in history. Don't understand why you think anyone views it that way. It's an exciting new program that's all.


If you let an internet forum dictate your application strategy rather than independent objective research I hope you stay far away from my program (atsusoma) because that is just ridiculous

Have you decided on atsu soma? I thought you were set on BCOM.
 
Yeah those pre-matriculation assignments are like 3 one page book reports on some cultural and historical aspects of New Mexico. I'd be shocked if it took anyone more than a week to do all of it. And that's if you're being casual about it.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
The essays are like one page reflections on books that describe NM healthcare and culture. Relax.

And noone is heralding BCOM as the greatest program in history. Don't understand why you think anyone views it that way. It's an exciting new program that's all.


If you let an internet forum dictate your application strategy rather than independent objective research I hope you stay far away from my program (atsusoma) because that is just ridiculous

First, nice that you respond emotionally to one thing I said and not respond to any of my other criticisms in previous posts. Way to criticize me because I don't want to write essays the summer before medical school and would rather spend time with my wife and kids. Admittedly I was a little dramatic and will have to look into how much pre-work you have to do before I officially cross it off. ATSU-SOMA is still on the list because the CHC model actually appeals to me a bit.

Instead of reacting to other people's posts strictly on emotion maybe you should cut the emotions out and look at the facts. I'm not saying BCOM is a bad school, but to not admit and seriously scrutinize their deficiencies is slightly ignorant. Talk about the bad along with the good.
 
Yeah those pre-matriculation assignments are like 3 one page book reports on some cultural and historical aspects of New Mexico. I'd be shocked if it took anyone more than a week to do all of it. And that's if you're being casual about it.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Admittedly I was dramatic. That really isn't too bad at all.
 
Admittedly I was dramatic. That really isn't too bad at all.

I would not cross it off if I were you based on that alone. They're trying to be a mission oriented school so it makes sense that they want they're students to have some general ideas about the history of the region they're signing up to serve.

Of all my interviews, I liked BCOM the most. I'm not going to be attending but I loved the whole experience. I think people are excited because it's awesome to see a new school at least trying to be something great right out of the gate. I interviewed at CUSOM and ACOM and was pretty underwhelmed with them. It felt like their presentations were pretty much "If you go here, you get to be a doctor. Wouldn't that be neat?"

If it weren't for the private loans, I'd say BCOM is the "best" new school because they just seem to be making an effort a lot of more established schools still haven't gotten around to making.
 
I would not cross it off if I were you based on that alone. They're trying to be a mission oriented school so it makes sense that they want they're students to have some general ideas about the history of the region they're signing up to serve.

Of all my interviews, I liked BCOM the most. I'm not going to be attending but I loved the whole experience. I think people are excited because it's awesome to see a new school at least trying to be something great right out of the gate. I interviewed at CUSOM and ACOM and was pretty underwhelmed with them. It felt like their presentations were pretty much "If you go here, you get to be a doctor. Wouldn't that be neat?"

If it weren't for the private loans, I'd say BCOM is the "best" new school because they just seem to be making an effort a lot of more established schools still haven't gotten around to making.

We'll see how that pans out in the next couple of years. Generally speaking, the newer schools have to impress the applicants. They are already at a disadvantage. They need to promote their school, and what better way to promote their school than impressing those who are interviewing there and can spread the word? (Like on SDN) Nobody has actually graduated there so of course there is a lot of skepticism going on here.

Older schools don't care about you because they can easily get more applicants to fill your spot. Supply and demand.
 
Last edited:
We'll see how that pans out in the next couple of years. Generally speaking, the newer schools have to impress the applicants. They are already at a disadvantage. They need to promote their school, and what better way to promote their school than impressing those who are interviewing there and can spread the word? (Like on SDN) Nobody has actually graduated there so of course there is a lot of skepticism going on here.

Older schools don't care about you because they can easily get more applicants to fill your spot. Supply and demand.

I absolutely agree. But BCOM obviously had a lot more going on than any of the new schools I saw. One shouldn't give up one of the "top" DO programs for it or any other new school. But if someone had the options OP has and through in vcom-auburn, ACOM , and cusom; I could see how one would pick BCOM based on what I've seen of the program. ( if you weren't concerned about federal loans).
 
So, I've been away from SDN for... a while. Came back and noticed this thread was stilllll treanding lol.

Just wanted to add that everything is wayyyyyyy exaggerated on SDN. There is some kind of a warped universe in here. lol
Here's the reality: a DO school is a DO school; unless if LUCOM.
Sure there are pros and cons to each, but unless you're shooting for rad onc (or something like that), they're purely experiential and negligible in result.

Trust me, most MD PDs won't know the difference between PCOM and BCOM. lol. They'll just see that you're a DO, and that's that.
 
This whole idea that BCOM and NMSU is launching a research facility is hogwash. NMSU has a single R01 funded investigator and has a single collab project with fred hutch. The research inst BCOM has created is a health policy research program, not a true biomedical research inst. So if students are going there for "the research" they are going to go to be quite surprised that all that hype wasnt true.
Would you mind PMing me on how to find out if an institution has an R01 funded investigator or not?
 
I disagree with the DO is a DO argument PCOM has been around 100 years its known across the country and especially the eastcoast over many MD and other DO programs.
 
Federal loans, of course anyone can go out and get a regular loan. The school is new therefore you have to take out one from a bank instead of the government.

Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
Regular student loans cap at $250 for medical school before you have to use the Graduate Plus Student Loans. Regular federal student loans have an interest of 5.8% and Graduate Plus are rated at 6.8%. So far, the private loans BCOM students have been offered based on credit reports and background checks hover around the top end of 7% and bottom end around 3.5% interest rates. I don't think private loans are at a disadvantage if you know how to use them and apply for the ones that fit your needs.

Dude or woman I am openly against BCOM, until they are proven I would not recommend it. If you would like to be openly against VCOM where I am going by all means you are entitled to that. The lesser of two evils comment was not directed toward you clearly. I have my opinion and I was discussing with the other poster as they had a good point. The OP should accept BCOM if that was their only choices. Why get so defensive. Let's just leave it at this, or private message me where this belongs.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
BCOM has nothing to prove to those who have no intention of attending their medical school. I actually turned down VCOM for BCOM, but I may or may not still attend BCOM depending on my state school's decision here in a few weeks.

Easy Dusty. Yes it is definitely the lesser of two evils. A new school should always be questioned until it is proven. When it gets government grants for quality research I'll believe the bit about research, when the 3rd year students all have ward based rotations, I'll believe that as well (I am straight up calling BS by the way that they will have mostly ward based rotations), when all of their proposed GME gets ACGME accredited I will believe all of that as well. And it's "association" with NMSU is not a partnership. They let them use some facilities.

Sorry but until BCOM graduates its first class and outs its money where it's mouth is then it should be questioned. And I will most definitely go there if it is my only acceptance next year but I will still be skeptical until they prove themselves. They haven't even matriculated a class yet, I don't know why you are so defensive that it is questioned.
To each their own, but of all of the DO schools in this country I can easily say WITHOUT A DOUBT BCOM is far from my last choice if I had to choose between other schools and BCOM.

I also believe that the exhoribitant nonrefundable deposit of $3000 for BCOM and accepting students extremely early left a bad taste. They only had 30 days to decide, well before other schools have even offered admission. They sent out interview invites starting in June!

I, for one, saw through how terrible 'for-profit' status has done for applicants who were accepted early. You can easily see through how $$$ driven they are. It is NM, where cost of living is cheap compared elsewhere. BCOM could have easily taken their time, picked more quality applicants instead of rushing to fill their class ASAP before October...they wanted to maximize profits hoping people would drop out so they could keep the $3000.

I would've said the same for any school that forced students into $3000 deposits. At least refund half if you decide to go elsewhere! PCOM and Rowan only offer $250 and $200 deposits....
A new list was released showing the top 10 cheapest private medical schools in the United States, both MD and DO schools combined. BCOM isn't on the list due to them not being federally accredited, but their tuition falls between 7-8th place on the list of cheapest private medical schools...Where is the scam in that? No one is forcing your hand into going to BCOM for medical school. So what if they only gave you 30 days to decide if you want to pay the $3,000 or not - everyone has to pay that amount and when you have to pay it plays no part in how they are conducting their admissions procedures. If you don't want to go to BCOM then simply don't pay. Someone else mentioned this earlier, but BCOM is not federally accredited, yet, therefore they cannot give out more acceptances than seats which means that they have to be on their toes when people withdraw acceptances or decline their acceptance all together. Furthermore, BCOM is doing a lot of pre-matriculation activities to prepare students and get them acclimated to the region and the rich history that is preserved over there. BCOM wants their students to be knowledgeable and engaged with the general public of Lac Cruses, New Mexico..not just some student who is passing by to earn their degree without giving anything back to the community.
I know...that's why I said "I would've said the same for any school that forced students into $3000 deposits." BCOM isn't the only one to do this. Also, for a school in NM, where property taxes and standard of living costs are very cheap, I would expect the tuition to be even lower than what it is now. If they want good students, and they're a new school, they should do what they can. CUSOM gave out $10k and $20k scholarships PER year to students in hopes of recruiting them.

Look, we have to be reasonable here. I feel that it is feasibly impossibe

You can't just build a research building and then say that the research you're doing is amazing. You can't say that a new medical school is amazing from the get go. Harvard took over 200 years to get the reputation it deserves today. It takes many many years to make partnerships, relationships with hospitals, and to get its reputation to where the school stands today. Research takes years sometimes to even publish a paper.

Yes, BCOM is promising, and they're doing all they can do establish itself as a good new school. However, they don't really seem to be handling things in a more "humbling" manner. They are acting like they're the new kid on the block and they're better than everybody else. Perhaps it is because of its accepted students are acting like they're super impressed with how amazing it is but are really naïve.

Also, I can't help but think (and I'm not trying to be mean here,) that a for-profit school being in one of the poorest states in the nation is a good combination (especially charging students $3000 just to get a seat.) It just leaves a bad taste, that's all. It just feels like corporate greed is trying to take advantage of NM's "poor status." University of Phoenix is for-profit and we all know how that turned out...

But I will say this...almost everyone will bash a new school. It isn't just unique to BCOM. I'm sure CUSOM had the same "bashing" a couple years back.
The research building is being built in a cooperative manner with the backing of the U.S. Government agencies and the Mexican health authorities with more of a focus than just typical health policies. They are going to focus a lot of resource towards epidemiological studies and ways to better prepare for future illness that may occur. I am not sure if you all are thinking of this in the correct manner - BCOM students do not have to engage in research in the Health Policy research center..that is only an option and will be utilized by more than just the BCOM students and faculty. BCOM students are encouraged to team up with ANYONE who is partaking in a feasible and well-directed research project. There are no limits to what kind of research we can partake in - we just have to make sure we do partake in some kind of research for it is a requirement for graduation.

And it is also fairly ignorant to think that policy research will help all that much come residency application time. If I wanted to study policy I would go get a masters in public health. It's a joke really, people go to medical school to, you know, study medicine and most want to do research in its different fields. It's not that policy research isn't important, it's that it shouldn't be the type of research done by the majority of medical students. Especially the ones trying to do research in their field of interest. BCOM should do better, especially if they are going to advertise thier "research opportunities" to applicants.
*sigh* you do realize that you cannot do health policy research without some kind of data or previous research to back your claims with, right? Policies are researched, studied, and written based on what other research shows. In order to study health policy successfully you will either have to engage in those studies yourself or have a very keen and thorough understanding of the topic at hand. Sounds to me like you are killing two birds with one stone. By the way, Health Policy is NOT the only option ope for research, it is jut ONE of the many options.
What I'm trying to say is that the costs of running a school in NM is probably a lot less than running a school in Philadelphia, or running a school in Chicago. Plus, coupled that with the fact that most students who are attending medical school do not have that much money, it is kind of a slap to the face (for me at least,) that they unnecessarily charged $3000 to take advantage of students wanting to become a physician. BCOM doesn't need that much money, but I feel that the for-profit status caused them to charge that much.

I know this isn't going to be a fair comparison, but there are schools like RowanSOM which offers a FREE pre-matriculation program with only a $200 deposit to their school, for ALL accepted students. They just have to be responsible for living costs, which is expected.
Why isn't that a fair comparison? According to you and many others, you cannot compare anything to BCOM until the school has had time to graduate a class and prove or disprove its ability to be successful. Unless you know the ins and outs of starting a medical school, your assumptions are ridiculous at the least.

This is ridiculous. BCOM just came off of my list of schools to apply to. Why on earth would a student need to write essays before school even starts. The summer before medical school should be for relaxing, moving, and spending time gearing up for the rigor to come, not for writing useless essays and discussion among people who have yet to even take a medical school class yet.
This is why BCOM is not the school for you, sir. BCOM is having their students do this required work because they don't want a bunch of hooligans coming into Las Cruces with absolutely no idea about the history of the place or what kind of symbolism is carried on through the region. Las Cruces is culturally rich and people take pride in that down their, so they want student who understand the area. Also, it teaches about accountability and preparedness for medical school. If you can't find time to do these tiny little assignments, then I would question your work ethic when it comes to crunch time.

We'll see how that pans out in the next couple of years. Generally speaking, the newer schools have to impress the applicants. They are already at a disadvantage. They need to promote their school, and what better way to promote their school than impressing those who are interviewing there and can spread the word? (Like on SDN) Nobody has actually graduated there so of course there is a lot of skepticism going on here.

Older schools don't care about you because they can easily get more applicants to fill your spot. Supply and demand.
Now you just sound like you are saying things to please your cognitive dissonance being attributed to this silliness. Every school dishes a sales pitch to potential students, even Harvard (the favorite school to compare everything to, apparently) - it doesn't stop just because you have a good reputation. If a student is being highly sought after by a school, then you better believe they will be on their A game. BCOM has a waiting list that exceedes 300 applicants, so tell me again who can easily get more applicants to fill your spot if you decide to pass it up?


Gosh, you know, I realize that after I submit this reply I will probably get bombarded with trash talk and silly rhetoric about how I am on the BCOM bandwagon and how BCOM has yet to prove anything, but my question is why should we even have to defend BCOM at this stage of the game? No one on here, literally no one, can say anything negative about how BCOM is being ran or how their curriculum or what have is set up, because they have YET to be given the chance to prove themselves in a real academic year. So, please, quit with the references of what BCOM doesn't have or can't do and just drop it for now. It does you absolutely no good to argue against a school you have nothing to do with. My goodness, people.
 
I know...that's why I said "I would've said the same for any school that forced students into $3000 deposits." BCOM isn't the only one to do this. Also, for a school in NM, where property taxes and standard of living costs are very cheap, I would expect the tuition to be even lower than what it is now. If they want good students, and they're a new school, they should do what they can. CUSOM gave out $10k and $20k scholarships PER year to students in hopes of recruiting them.

Look, we have to be reasonable here. I feel that it is feasibly impossible to have a school like BCOM give out this many "promises" in the time they were allotted. It feels like they're just racing to get everything done, but did not think that sometimes, more time is needed to get things done right.

You can't just build a research building and then say that the research you're doing is amazing. You can't say that a new medical school is amazing from the get go. Harvard took over 200 years to get the reputation it deserves today. It takes many many years to make partnerships, relationships with hospitals, and to get its reputation to where the school stands today. Research takes years sometimes to even publish a paper.

Yes, BCOM is promising, and they're doing all they can do establish itself as a good new school. However, they don't really seem to be handling things in a more "humbling" manner. They are acting like they're the new kid on the block and they're better than everybody else. Perhaps it is because of its accepted students are acting like they're super impressed with how amazing it is but are really naïve.

Also, I can't help but think (and I'm not trying to be mean here,) that a for-profit school being in one of the poorest states in the nation is a good combination (especially charging students $3000 just to get a seat.) It just leaves a bad taste, that's all. It just feels like corporate greed is trying to take advantage of NM's "poor status." University of Phoenix is for-profit and we all know how that turned out...

But I will say this...almost everyone will bash a new school. It isn't just unique to BCOM. I'm sure CUSOM had the same "bashing" a couple years back.
If it counts for anything, the BCOM research institute is non profit
ImageUploadedBySDN1460281463.442570.jpg



Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile app
 
I disagree with the DO is a DO argument PCOM has been around 100 years its known across the country and especially the eastcoast over many MD and other DO programs.

There may be some MD PDs out there who differentiate between DO schools, but @drsmpc is more correct than you are. The only time I've heard DO "tiers" mentioned in my entire career is on SDN. In my years of experience in allopathic graduate medical education, across my specialty and others, when it comes to applicants, a DO is a DO is a DO. Your enthusiasm is great but you have to be careful not to misinform others if you don't have firsthand experience with what you're talking about.

But. To answer the actual question in this thread, while a nonzero number of programs prefer to take MDs from God knows where over DOs, in my opinion that's no reason to go Caribbean over DO.
 
Last edited:
Now you just sound like you are saying things to please your cognitive dissonance being attributed to this silliness. Every school dishes a sales pitch to potential students, even Harvard (the favorite school to compare everything to, apparently) - it doesn't stop just because you have a good reputation. If a student is being highly sought after by a school, then you better believe they will be on their A game. BCOM has a waiting list that exceedes 300 applicants, so tell me again who can easily get more applicants to fill your spot if you decide to pass it up?


Gosh, you know, I realize that after I submit this reply I will probably get bombarded with trash talk and silly rhetoric about how I am on the BCOM bandwagon and how BCOM has yet to prove anything, but my question is why should we even have to defend BCOM at this stage of the game? No one on here, literally no one, can say anything negative about how BCOM is being ran or how their curriculum or what have is set up, because they have YET to be given the chance to prove themselves in a real academic year. So, please, quit with the references of what BCOM doesn't have or can't do and just drop it for now. It does you absolutely no good to argue against a school you have nothing to do with. My goodness, people.

Look, my point was newer schools need to establish their reputation. Older schools don't need to establish their reputation that much. The name can speak for itself. Looking at the average stat of BCOM, it is still significantly lower than that of the established DO schools. I'm sure the "newness" has some effect on the more competitive applicants. This isn't just unique to BCOM. This happens to LUCOM, CUSOM, ACOM, etc. However, the for-profit status does cause a concern.

BCOM has 300 applicants for the waitlist because they cannot accept more than their class size, unlike all the other schools who accept 2.5 times their incoming class.
 
Last edited:
Look, my point was newer schools need to establish their reputation. Older schools don't need to establish their reputation that much. The name can speak for itself. Looking at the average stat of BCOM, it is still significantly lower than that of the established DO schools. I'm sure the "newness" has some effect on the more competitive applicants. This isn't just unique to BCOM. This happens to LUCOM, CUSOM, ACOM, etc. However, the for-profit status does cause a concern.

BCOM has 300 applicants for the waitlist because they cannot accept more than their class size, unlike all the other schools who accept 2.5 times their incoming class.

I agree with some of your posts lol but you cannot even debate with this person, they are apparently right. I just gave up, not worth the time. In other news we all start Med school soon 🙂


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
 
Top