CHOOSE YOUR OWWN III - Game Thread

[Animal Midwife]

---

Members do not see this ad.

Day 1 Yeet Tally
Stagg () -
mkg () -
O2 () -
genny (2) - dubz, alissa
True (2) - shorty, Vis
dubz (1) - Lumi
Chaos (5) - Lawpy, Zenge, True, O2, PSV
Lumi (3) - Wonder, Chaos, alley
mkg () -
Lawpy (1) - mkg

14/16
@Chaostrodon is in the lead!
Missing: @genny @Stagg737
yeet close in ~2 hours

 

[supershorty]

Scrambling kindergartener.

I don't appreciate this characterization of me even if I am the size of one 😡

 

[potentialsheltervet]

I don't appreciate this characterization of me even if I am the size of one 😡

Oh no. I wasn't talking about you 😢
I was thinking about scrambled eggs and foreign languages and wound up with that.

 

[WildZoo]

Scrambling kindergartener.

Sassy kangaroo

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Sassy kangaroo

Skeleton karma!

 

[WildZoo]

Skeleton karma!

Spooky scary skeletons send shivers down your spine

 

[alleycat03]

The fact that duplicate roles aren't possible is something that really really really really really really needs to be included in the sign-up post's OP. You've all played this setup before, so you knew that already, but no one bothered to tell me that... or include it in the sign-ups for the game...

Read the first letter of each word of my first post. Black goo claim was to try to get scum to not visit me because they'd get converted to cult - like a bulletproof that doesn't fear strongmen kills.

The fact that it caught Chaos lying unintentionally was hilarious.

@supershorty @Viscernable this is the post I was referring to

ETA: the second paragraph specifically

 

[alissa14]

SK?

Sassy Karen

 

[supershorty]

@supershorty @Viscernable this is the post I was referring to

ETA: the second paragraph specifically

Yeah, I know, but I can see a town perspective for doing that just as easily as I can see a scum one.

 

[alleycat03]

Work absolutely sucked today, so now I’m hydrated!alley

After 2 cocktails, it’s a world record

 

[Lawpy]

I don't appreciate this characterization of me even if I am the size of one 😡

unlikely pls

 

[Lawpy]

Work absolutely sucked today, so now I’m hydrated!alley

After 2 cocktails, it’s a world record

Engaged

 

[alleycat03]

Yeah, I know, but I can see a town perspective for doing that just as easily as I can see a scum one.

I was saying that lying is crappy, and while they could do it as scum or as village, I didn’t like that they lied in the first place. Hence my vote for them

 

[Lawpy]

Day 1 Yeet Tally
Stagg () -
mkg () -
O2 () -
genny (2) - dubz, alissa
True (2) - shorty, Vis
dubz (1) - Lumi
Chaos (5) - Lawpy, Zenge, True, O2, PSV
Lumi (3) - Wonder, Chaos, alley
mkg () -
Lawpy (1) - mkg

14/16
@Chaostrodon is in the lead!
Missing: @genny @Stagg737
yeet close in ~2 hours

I guess Staggs isn’t going to be on 🙁

 

[alleycat03]

Engaged

Don’t worry, Cam is driving us home because I didn’t expect 2 drinks to knock me to the ground 😂

 

[alissa14]

Work absolutely sucked today, so now I’m hydrated!alley

After 2 cocktails, it’s a world record

Wishing SDN had an “OHO” reaction like our discord server does

 

[Lawpy]

Don’t worry, Cam is driving us home because I didn’t expect 2 drinks to knock me to the ground 😂

Pleased!

 

[Viscernable]

Research, huh? Was it a field study conducted from shorty and Zenge's bushes?

Dubz pls he lives in Z’s computer, this would not be necessary

 

[Viscernable]

Well I’m willing to let go of my jester theory and all since I’ve finally looked at the role list. So I’m willing to believe wonder for now. Honestly I realize I go for Genny a lot on D1 when we play together so I might try this instead for now

Unyeet chaos
Yeet lawpy

What changed your mind on lumi?

 

[alissa14]

Any examples?

For me it’s that I can tell she’s present, but maybe not entirely caught up. I just expect a bit more active village play from genny. Idk I sussed cubs last game and I’m pretty sure he did flip scum after my misyeet so I’m trusting my gut feels right now. Lumi I’m gonna give another cycle to settle in. Feeling a wee bit better about MK but she’s still in my scum leans, bordering neutral. And I personally don’t want to touch chaos right now with a 10 ft stick and want that to be future!alissa’s problem

 

[Viscernable]

If people are actually willing to yeet Lumi I’m also open to going there, but I do realize it’s kinda a dick move since this is their first game on SDN

Ah. Is there more to it or just not wanting to go there D1?

 

[Lawpy]

@WorthlessOxygen did you post your reads somewhere and I missed it?

 

[Viscernable]

I get that this is because voting him would switch him to scum, but how is that worse than say, waiting for a vig shot? Would at least be confirmed scum at that point, right? And the alternative is believing him after being caught in a lie.

2 village shots vs 1.

 

[alissa14]

I don't remember all the games they've played together, but from a quick search of the ones I do remember:

She made no attempt to read him in the SDN game, from what I can tell, there are only 2 mentions of him at all in her ISO.

In England, she initially read him incorrectly and voted him, but then eventually came around to the correct read on him after he posted a reads list.

It appears she did not read him as wolfy in Bioshock.

She correctly read him immediately in GGoats.

I know they played Worst Idea together, but they were both scum (of different factions) and I'm pretty sure alissa went down D1 so I'm not sure that game would be that helpful to look at.

@alissa14 are there more recent games you've played with Zenge than the ones I listed here? I feel like I'm missing some.

This seems right. He was scum when I modded WWizards but that’s not helpful. I really have not consistently played in the last year and a half, which is the majority of the games the noob class of 2020-2021 has played

 

[Lawpy]

Because starting off with a fake claim about being goo is highly suspicious and then following it up with judas, the ideal fakeclaim, is even more suspicious.
I find it more likely scum!Chaos didn't think anyone would be black goo and then had to come up with another fakeclaim.
I also think Lumi is scum, but my bet would be on SK.

Engaged

 

[alissa14]

Because starting off with a fake claim about being goo is highly suspicious and then following it up with judas, the ideal fakeclaim, is even more suspicious.
I find it more likely scum!Chaos didn't think anyone would be black goo and then had to come up with another fakeclaim.
I also think Lumi is scum, but my bet would be on SK.

Oh no the tinfoil!!

 

[Lawpy]

The probability of it happening however many times is quite similar whether it happened to them or not. For example, probability of it happening at least 7 times is 1.53%, and the conditional probability of that (>=7) happening once you know it’s happened at least once is 3.87%

@LuminousLag thoughts pls

Also we need a stats WW game too

 

[Viscernable]

I am not entirely sure with how Judas works if he can use any abilities pre-conversion. My assumption is no, but I could be wrong

The abilities shouldn’t be tied to aff change for any reason that I can think of.

 

[WorthlessOxygen]

@WorthlessOxygen did you post your reads somewhere and I missed it?

Haven't posted a full reads because so many of y'all are true neutrals that it's really not helpful. I'm fairly determined to vote a goonie today so it's pretty much between lumi and chaos since I feel somewhat more comfortable with wonder

 

[supershorty]

Haven't posted a full reads because so many of y'all are true neutrals that it's really not helpful. I'm fairly determined to vote a goonie today so it's pretty much between lumi and chaos since I feel somewhat more comfortable with wonder

Posting any reads is more helpful than not posting them.

 

[bluestoat]

Trapped Lawpy is trapped in MN departure airport but will check in soon with thoughts pls once leaving

***
SIR.
***

 

[Truenamer]

Haven't posted a full reads because so many of y'all are true neutrals that it's really not helpful. I'm fairly determined to vote a goonie today so it's pretty much between lumi and chaos since I feel somewhat more comfortable with wonder

I get it, but I left like four or five people in the "idk" list on mine. I feel like it's still helpful for other people to know who your tops and bottoms are.

 

[WildZoo]

who your tops and bottoms are.

giggles

 

[potentialsheltervet]

***
SIR.
***

SPECTATORS MUST NOT POST ON THE THREAD 😡

 

[potentialsheltervet]

I get it, but I left like four or five people in the "idk" list on mine. I feel like it's still helpful for other people to know who your tops and bottoms are.

 

[alleycat03]

giggles

 

[mkg323]

What changed your mind on lumi?

My opinion of lumi hasn’t changed, I still think they aren’t village.

 

[mkg323]

For me it’s that I can tell she’s present, but maybe not entirely caught up. I just expect a bit more active village play from genny. Idk I sussed cubs last game and I’m pretty sure he did flip scum after my misyeet so I’m trusting my gut feels right now. Lumi I’m gonna give another cycle to settle in. Feeling a wee bit better about MK but she’s still in my scum leans, bordering neutral. And I personally don’t want to touch chaos right now with a 10 ft stick and want that to be future!alissa’s problem

I know you don’t want to touch chaos but hear me out - tie?

 

[mkg323]

Don’t angery me shorty we could get 2 goos with 1 yeet!

 

[alleycat03]

Don’t angery me shorty we could get 2 goos with 1 yeet!

Wait. How do you know the tie mechanics?

 

[WorthlessOxygen]

Posting any reads is more helpful than not posting them.

Rough, only ordered where there are obvious spaces

Village lean:
shorty
lawpy
PSV

Zenge

True neutrals:
Alley
Genny
True
WZ
Alissa
mkg

POE: some variation of Wonder, lumi, chaos

Missing:
Me - for obvious reasons but I stand by my bulletproof townie affiliation claim
Stagg - no posts

 

[genny]

is it voting time yet?
yeet chaos

 

[mkg323]

Wait. How do you know the tie mechanics?

I don’t, that’s what makes it fun

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 1 Yeet Tally
Stagg () -
mkg () -
O2 () -
genny (2) - dubz, alissa
True (2) - shorty, Vis
dubz (1) - Lumi
Chaos (6) - Lawpy, Zenge, True, O2, PSV, genny
Lumi (3) - Wonder, Chaos, alley
mkg () -
Lawpy (1) - mkg

15/16
Chaos is in the lead!
Missing: Stagg
yeet close in ~48 minutes

 

[supershorty]

Don’t angery me shorty we could get 2 goos with 1 yeet!

You don't know that. If this setup uses the tie mechanic the games I played on MU had, it would just RNG between the tied players.

 

[Truenamer]

I don’t, that’s what makes it fun

I have been given the impression that KayDubs carries a big, sharp sword to be used in the case of ties

 

[mkg323]

You don't know that. If this setup uses the tie mechanic the games I played on MU had, it would just RNG between the tied players.

Yeah that probably wouldn’t be that fun
Unyeet lawpy
Yeet Chaos

back to the wagon I go

 

[supershorty]

How come y'all are only excited to make ties outside of my games 😡

 

[mkg323]

How come y'all are only excited to make ties outside of my games 😡

How about this, I promise I will do my best to make a tie in your next game?

 

[WildZoo]

How come y'all are only excited to make ties outside of my games 😡

I'm still upset about last game tbh