CHOOSE YOUR OWWN IV - Game Thread

[GoSpursGo]

---

Members do not see this ad.

@GoSpursGo talk to me about your CG read?

Just felt a little easy to throw shade literally only on players that voted for them, and then defend fruits.

 

[Zenge142]

idk if this is addressed later but what does this post mean, Zenge?

Nothing really. Just memeing about.

 

[SARdoghandler]

That was the exact wording? "Town Seer"?

Yes?

squont

 

[supershorty]

That was the exact wording? "Town Seer"?

@Zenge142 Why did you ask this question?

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Hmmmmm I dislike this. 3 votes is hardly a wagon.

I believe by definition, it is

 

[supershorty]

I really should go do work, but I want to interrogate Zenge.

 

[Zenge142]

I don't buy that his interaction with CeeGee was genuine.

Wait what interaction? I don't remember interacting with CeeGee lol

 

[_rae_]

Hello I’m awake

@beans2020 the only problem with your logic is I showed up hella late. If I truly did use vanilla town as my affiliation (which I did) I’d have zero control over how many potential village roles could be left. Rachel also historically cannot count when she is sloshed. So I’m stuck either lying or making myself look sus by being honest. I dislike Samac’s “you can lie more as village” because I will get caught.

 

[_rae_]

lol I guess you all get to know my full name now whoopsie

 

[apoptosis09]

rae - NV. I have a hard time with rae and historically read her incorrectly. Given that I'm leaning village until otherwise
Clem - N. Clem is clem is clem. IDK. Doesn't seem very wolfy but who knows.
SAR - NV. Feels like village SAR more than wolf SAR, granted I've only seen either once.
CG - N. CG always neutral. I very much believe she would pick non-town given the option, but it's not like she doesn't know that too. Could def see 3p.
genny - N. Nothing broadly villagey or scummy yet.
kitz - NW. Giving a little scummy with the tones of posting and some wording here and there.
Dubz - NW. Not giving anything very villagey and play feels similar to the last game.
samac - N. I can always go either way on samac
beans - V. Villagey beans is villagey.
alissa - NV. Mostly seems sus of fruits and me, which is normal for players new to us. Could be going for low fruit but I think is being genuine.
apop - V. Obvs.
Zenge - W. For above reasons of general tone and a couple things sticking here and there, and just hasn't given town zenge very strongly.
Barks - N. IDK that I read barks well or at all last game, so sitting neutral for now.
PSV - NV. I'm historically not great at reading PSV but I think I got better during Hallowws, and this is giving more villagey PSV.
Spurs - N. IDK, I always think spurs is sus and I'm usually wrong, so I'm going to err on N for now
shorty - NV. Powerwolfing? Doubt. Maybe. Never seen wolf or village shorty, but could totally see 3p. But going to stick village for now.
fruit - NW. Fruits normally sees through my chaotic play style to the village in me, and the one time he didn't he was wolf, so my gut says wolf here, but otherwise his playstyle seems like normal fruit, so not jumping on this one yet.

(10/10) - Bye!

 

[apoptosis09]

lol I guess you all get to know my full name now whoopsie

I assumed Rae was short for Raygun

 

[supershorty]

Wait what interaction? I don't remember interacting with CeeGee lol

It was specifically the "indeed" in response to Spurs in this series of posts:

I chose cop lover for affiliation

... aren't those two roles CG?

Indeed

Eh. That's what my PM said when it came to my choices. I'm assumming the cop here just means the same as villager

Uh... yeet @CeeGee14

@kaydub @Animal Midwife @Dr. ForgotToFlush

Pushing this narrative pretty hard, Fruit...

I'm more inclined to think CG was misunderstanding the exercise than CG was wolf caught

I'm ngl, in my head, I thought you had egged on the sus more than it looks like you actually did, because what I was taking issue with yesterday was that followed by the backing off it when a wagon began to form, but I'm gonna be honest that today!me is less excited by that than yesterday!me, now that I'm looking at it again.

 

[supershorty]

rae - NV. I have a hard time with rae and historically read her incorrectly. Given that I'm leaning village until otherwise
Clem - N. Clem is clem is clem. IDK. Doesn't seem very wolfy but who knows.
SAR - NV. Feels like village SAR more than wolf SAR, granted I've only seen either once.
CG - N. CG always neutral. I very much believe she would pick non-town given the option, but it's not like she doesn't know that too. Could def see 3p.
genny - N. Nothing broadly villagey or scummy yet.
kitz - NW. Giving a little scummy with the tones of posting and some wording here and there.
Dubz - NW. Not giving anything very villagey and play feels similar to the last game.
samac - N. I can always go either way on samac
beans - V. Villagey beans is villagey.
alissa - NV. Mostly seems sus of fruits and me, which is normal for players new to us. Could be going for low fruit but I think is being genuine.
apop - V. Obvs.
Zenge - W. For above reasons of general tone and a couple things sticking here and there, and just hasn't given town zenge very strongly.
Barks - N. IDK that I read barks well or at all last game, so sitting neutral for now.
PSV - NV. I'm historically not great at reading PSV but I think I got better during Hallowws, and this is giving more villagey PSV.
Spurs - N. IDK, I always think spurs is sus and I'm usually wrong, so I'm going to err on N for now
shorty - NV. Powerwolfing? Doubt. Maybe. Never seen wolf or village shorty, but could totally see 3p. But going to stick village for now.
fruit - NW. Fruits normally sees through my chaotic play style to the village in me, and the one time he didn't he was wolf, so my gut says wolf here, but otherwise his playstyle seems like normal fruit, so not jumping on this one yet.

(10/10) - Bye!

View attachment 412563

This is a huge amount of words to have like ... 2 real reads lol. However, I do appreciate the thought processes laid out.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

The original role only exists as mafia, but you can combine it with other affs.

Ah. I somehow got it into my head that the list of roles also meant you couldn't be offered things that wouldn't result in a combo already on the list.

Oh. Good catch. I missed that she'd only said fruit vendor.

I'm not sure if I think it's wolfy or not that she didn't include an aff in the post originally because I think scum would probably be more likely to pay attention to that detail, but yeah, mafia fruit vendor is on the list.

 

[_rae_]

I assumed Rae was short for Raygun

It’s fine there are three other Rachels in the c/o 2028 at UMN, and at three or four others spread out throughout the other classes. I could be any of them.

 

[supershorty]

This is a huge amount of words to have like ... 2 real reads lol. However, I do appreciate the thought processes laid out.

However, I don't village read the list itself, if that makes sense.

 

[apoptosis09]

This is a huge amount of words to have like ... 2 real reads lol. However, I do appreciate the thought processes laid out.

Hey now less than half are true neutrals, everyone else has at least lean.
Besides, 12 pages of 95% ****posting on D1 is hard to get a read on

 

[supershorty]

Maybe a better way to phrase that is that list, if anything, weakens my town lean on apop.

@Zenge142 can you please answer the question I asked you about why you asked SAR that question?

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Hello I’m awake

@beans2020 the only problem with your logic is I showed up hella late. If I truly did use vanilla town as my affiliation (which I did) I’d have zero control over how many potential village roles could be left. Rachel also historically cannot count when she is sloshed. So I’m stuck either lying or making myself look sus by being honest. I dislike Samac’s “you can lie more as village” because I will get caught.

Did beans call you out specifically? This feels really reactive

rae - NV. I have a hard time with rae and historically read her incorrectly. Given that I'm leaning village until otherwise
Clem - N. Clem is clem is clem. IDK. Doesn't seem very wolfy but who knows.
SAR - NV. Feels like village SAR more than wolf SAR, granted I've only seen either once.
CG - N. CG always neutral. I very much believe she would pick non-town given the option, but it's not like she doesn't know that too. Could def see 3p.
genny - N. Nothing broadly villagey or scummy yet.
kitz - NW. Giving a little scummy with the tones of posting and some wording here and there.
Dubz - NW. Not giving anything very villagey and play feels similar to the last game.
samac - N. I can always go either way on samac
beans - V. Villagey beans is villagey.
alissa - NV. Mostly seems sus of fruits and me, which is normal for players new to us. Could be going for low fruit but I think is being genuine.
apop - V. Obvs.
Zenge - W. For above reasons of general tone and a couple things sticking here and there, and just hasn't given town zenge very strongly.
Barks - N. IDK that I read barks well or at all last game, so sitting neutral for now.
PSV - NV. I'm historically not great at reading PSV but I think I got better during Hallowws, and this is giving more villagey PSV.
Spurs - N. IDK, I always think spurs is sus and I'm usually wrong, so I'm going to err on N for now
shorty - NV. Powerwolfing? Doubt. Maybe. Never seen wolf or village shorty, but could totally see 3p. But going to stick village for now.
fruit - NW. Fruits normally sees through my chaotic play style to the village in me, and the one time he didn't he was wolf, so my gut says wolf here, but otherwise his playstyle seems like normal fruit, so not jumping on this one yet.

(10/10) - Bye!

View attachment 412563

So in summary: Zenge is wolfy, beans is villagey, and everyone else is some shade of neutral?

 

[_rae_]

Did beans call you out specifically? This feels really reactive

well, me and kitzs both.

 

[_rae_]

Some morning thoughts b4 I have to leave for school: I'm taking fruit and Clem off of today's yeet list bc I really don't think either of them is scum currently.
Kitz and rae both have my interest atm - kitz bc of her reaction to shorty's aff exercise (I don't know if that was confusion or slight scum panic). Rae because I'm mildly suspicious of her claim that she used vanillager for aff. This may be a "beans not understanding CYO strategy" thing so if it is feel free to smack me but literally so many people have either discarded vanillager OR claimed to use it as aff - how likely is it that that many players were offered it as a role?

 

[supershorty]

ONEDRIVE IS THE BANE OF MY EXISTENCE

 

[potentialsheltervet]

It’s fine there are three other Rachels in the c/o 2028 at UMN, and at three or four others spread out throughout the other classes. I could be any of them.

There are four in my class, I think lol

 

[GoSpursGo]

Here's a list if you need to make something up real quick:

Greater Idea Mafia/RolePMs

wiki.mafiascum.net

@supershorty is interrupting my re-reads by asking me relevant questions.

But this is the kind of pokey that I had gotten used to from genny and seemed missing last game.

 

[apoptosis09]

So in summary: Zenge is wolfy, beans is villagey, and everyone else is some shade of neutral?

Some are darker shades of neutral, if that helps. More "kinda maybe pretty sure but not going to label it yet" which is about as sure as I feel like I've ever gotten D1 lol

 

[potentialsheltervet]

I can't reply to rae's post since it's a naked quote but that actually makes me interested in why beans singled out rae, specifically, for the vanillager aff claim when there were many others who'd claimed it at that point.

 

[apoptosis09]

ONEDRIVE IS THE BANE OF MY EXISTENCE

One drive stores your files in the bad place

 

[GoSpursGo]

Why am I immune to your vote today lol

I think I forgot to reply to this--because I went after you hard all game last game and it doesn't feel nice to go after the same person repeatedly.

 

[supershorty]

Clem - N. Clem is clem is clem. IDK. Doesn't seem very wolfy but who knows.

I feel like to this point, Clem has posted a lot more content than rae. Given that you say you're historically not good at reading rae, I'm a little surprised that you're already leaning rae a specific way and have this super wishy-washy take on Clem.

Dubz - NW. Not giving anything very villagey and play feels similar to the last game.

Dubz has posted super minimally for her to this point. What feels similar?

Zenge - W. For above reasons of general tone and a couple things sticking here and there, and just hasn't given town zenge very strongly.

What is town!Zenge in your eyes?

PSV - NV. I'm historically not great at reading PSV but I think I got better during Hallowws, and this is giving more villagey PSV.

Again, PSV hadn't really posted that much to this point, so I'm curious about why this is the second person who you say you're not great at reading, but then give a read on when there are so many players on your list that you didn't?

 

[GoSpursGo]

If I forgot to reply to any quotes/mentions, please re-tag me. I've been bouncing between re-reading and replying and probably missed several someones

 

[supershorty]

I was actually trying to get off here for a while and do some data collection, but OneDrive keeps hanging up when I'm trying to get to the spreadsheet with the criteria for this retrospective, so here we are.

 

[supershorty]

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Some are darker shades of neutral, if that helps. More "kinda maybe pretty sure but not going to label it yet" which is about as sure as I feel like I've ever gotten D1 lol

I'm a little confused on why you made the post in the first place with a full reads list of the roster when so many boiled down to basically neutral? Shades of neutral, okay, but still neutral enough that you called them as such in your list.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

I'm only loosely listening to my therio lecture and I just heard something about "baby diaper on the scrotum"

 

[apoptosis09]

I feel like to this point, Clem has posted a lot more content than rae. Given that you say you're historically not good at reading rae, I'm a little surprised that you're already leaning rae a specific way and have this super wishy-washy take on Clem.

He's posted a lot more words, at least. Idk about content. Rae I could go W on, but hence I'm usually wrong, so I went V instead. Given a heat map she'd be closer to room temp than my other NV reads.

Dubz has posted super minimally for her to this point. What feels similar?

Vibes. Tone. My gut said wolfy last time and it's saying it again.

What is town!Zenge in your eyes?

More forward and ****posty from what I've seen. technically have only seen village zenge once? Maybe twice

Again, PSV hadn't really posted that much to this point, so I'm curious about why this is the second person who you say you're not great at reading, but then give a read on when there are so many players on your list that you didn't?

Very little to go off at this point but the tea leaves feel villagier

I'm a little confused on why you made the post in the first place with a full reads list of the roster when so many boiled down to basically neutral? Shades of neutral, okay, but still neutral enough that you called them as such in your list.

Bc I said I was going to and I'm not going to have time later 😅

 

[apoptosis09]

Okay I really will need to leave now. If you have any more questions, ask them to the void

 

[supershorty]

I'm just struggling to understand why you felt compelled to say you were going to post a reads list when the gist of it is that you don't have much resembling reads of most of the roster.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

apop is making my insides buzz with confusion and befuddlement. But that's how she always makes me feel and last game I led her misyeet D1, so I guess I'm just going to... set that aside for now.

 

[apoptosis09]

I'm just struggling to understand why you felt compelled to say you were going to post a reads list when the gist of it is that you don't have much resembling reads of most of the roster.

Bc I said I was going to and I'm not going to have time later 😅

I'm going to be MIA the rest of the day and wanted my thoughts out there now, even if there's not much. given it's D1.

 

[supershorty]

I'm going to be MIA the rest of the day and wanted my thoughts out there now, even if there's not much. given it's D1.

Hmmm. Okay.

I won't be voting here D1 regardless, but I have some thoughts and feelings.

 

[supershorty]

One eternity later, I have finally downloaded the spreadsheet I've been trying to get at for the last 10 minutes, so I'm gonna go dig around in records trying to find anything about carotid artery embolizations.

 

[WildZoo]

One eternity later, I have finally downloaded the spreadsheet I've been trying to get at for the last 10 minutes, so I'm gonna go dig around in records trying to find anything about carotid artery embolizations.

Those sound bad

 

[SARdoghandler]

Hmmm. Okay.

I won't be voting here D1 regardless, but I have some thoughts and feelings.

Thoughts > feelings or feelings > thoughts? 😂

 

[GoSpursGo]

I'm willing to give kitz and rae the benefit of the doubt for now. Other than what I previously mentioned, neither of them have done anything particularly scummy. Spurs feels okay? I think I've shrunk my pool down to the following (mostly because I don't think I can say that any of these people have done something to make me certain they're village):
CG, genny, Dubz, samac, zenge

I feel like someone else may have said this while I'm reviewing, but this is weird. Backtracking on kitz and rae, after initially planting those as your only real reads?

Also, hi @fruitsalad 🙂

 

[SARdoghandler]

Those sound bad

Agree 😱

 

[supershorty]

Those sound bad

Gonna be real hard to find them in our records system, but such is my life sometimes.

 

[GoSpursGo]

I don't feel like I'm vibing with Spurs right now, but I also don't know why I have a slight feeling of unease there.

Probably cuz I'm re-reading and posting things that are now way out of context?

 

[Clem J]

lol I guess you all get to know my full name now whoopsie

Oh my god who would use their real name on the internet?????

 

[GoSpursGo]

In fairness, this is a busy time and a lot of people have work/school. Sometimes you gotta crack a few eggs to make a last minute scramble.

Yeah that's fine. I more mean players who are present all day but actively choose not to make a read until the last minute. Peak sheep-opportunity

 

[WildZoo]

I am back at my desk

In my limited real-time interactions I feel okay about Spurs and checks notes okay I may have only usefully talked to Spurs