GGoats ThWWee: Here It GGoats Again - GAME THREAD

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
A samac kill makes absolutely no sense coming from me

It's also pretty obvious that I was not working with PSV on her skinsuit claim. Especially since you can see on thread that I probably would have just had her claim sleepwalker, or at least not made that claim for her when she'd already said things that contradicted it. That would be sloppy as hell wolf work, which anyone who has played with me knows is not my style.
I don't care about anyone's interactions with PSV on D2. genny showed her hand already by that point.

D1 is better. Show me what's unaligning on D1.
No one ever, a single time, claimed the former as a reason to village read me... If mads was a wolf everyone was saying I was too, so what are you talking about?
Is this true @Zenge142 ?
I paired Zenge and samac for a single day of PMing. There would be no reason for me to kill her AFTER that, the PM was already closed
So you can kill people in the middle of the day? I don't understand what that means.
And I would not have converted PSV while she was traveling and her activity level was low at the time and unknown in the future
Why not?
 
Manual Tallying Tickles Animal Midwife's Autism - D1 FINAL Tally

Lissa (0) -
PSV (0) -
fruit (5) - dubz, mkg, genny, samac, mads
Greedy (1) - Lissa
mads (2) - Zenge, beans
beans (1) - Sakuraaa
dubz (4) - vampy, fruit, Greedy, KJQ
Zenge () -
samac (1) - PSV
clem () -

14/15
@fruitsalad, you are in the lead!
Missing: @Clem J

Check your votes.

PSV pushed for Samac at EOD1 but would not join the same group on WZ. With bean's claim I also now know WZ's wagon was pure
 
slightly off topic, what does POE mean? I keep seeing it used and have not been able to figure out what it stands for haha
 
Is this true @Zenge142 ?
I’m not 100% sure what the question is.

People were weirdly claiming that wolf!Mad’s guaranteed Wolf!Dubz.

I don’t think anyone was giving Dubz village credit because of Mads flipping village.
 
slightly off topic, what does POE mean? I keep seeing it used and have not been able to figure out what it stands for haha
despite it being POE, i keep reading it as POI (person of interest)

man. tell me why i just realized that.
 
I’m not 100% sure what the question is.

People were weirdly claiming that wolf!Mad’s guaranteed Wolf!Dubz.

I don’t think anyone was giving Dubz village credit because of Mads flipping village.
Did you agree with that assessment? Or did you think dubz was always town in a w!mads world?
 
im going to look at my list again, is it safe to assume lissa is in the clear and it wasnt a double whammy kill to throw us off or should we still be weary?
 
im going to look at my list again, is it safe to assume lissa is in the clear and it wasnt a double whammy kill to throw us off or should we still be weary?
Lower priority but I wouldn't clear her completely just yet. I've literally seen two wolves act on the nightkill before.
 
I mean I can confirm I think that item does what Lissa says it does, as I now have it. So as a wolf claiming that it seems really risky because if its not what you did someone is probably gonna find out at some point.

And I both dont think that scum has any incentive in the game to really go for that item or use it the way she did
 
Did you agree with that assessment? Or did you think dubz was always town in a w!mads world?
I thought Mads was wolfy.

My read on Dubz was unrelated to Mads - directly. I was more inclined to read Dubz as village because the logic of the wolf!mads=wolf!Dubz made no sense and this felt Wolfy.
 
I mean I can confirm I think that item does what Lissa says it does, as I now have it. So as a wolf claiming that it seems really risky because if its not what you did someone is probably gonna find out at some point.

And I both dont think that scum has any incentive in the game to really go for that item or use it the way she did
this makes sense okay, i'll keep here where she's at for now and revisit on wednesday?
 
I thought Mads was wolfy.

My read on Dubz was unrelated to Mads - directly. I was more inclined to read Dubz as village because the logic of the wolf!mads=wolf!Dubz made no sense and this felt Wolfy.
Okay. And how do you feel about her now?
 
@Animal Midwife it has been a debated topic on this thread for a little while now if sakuraaa was wolfy or not. I know you just got here, but can you provide any evidence supporting that you/sakuraaa are in fact town?
Also, do you know what item she had that was making her claim that she knew what conversions are?
 
@Animal Midwife it has been a debated topic on this thread for a little while now if sakuraaa was wolfy or not. I know you just got here, but can you provide any evidence supporting that you/sakuraaa are in fact town?
Also, do you know what item she had that was making her claim that she knew what conversions are?
Yes.
 
did it specifically say vanilla, or vanilla villager?
oh - it said vampy is vanilla. I guess it didn't specifically say villager - I just assumed vanilla = villager. Is that incorrect?
 
Oh. Vampy is back on the menu then. Vanilla can also mean just a mafia goon without an ability.

Althought id be confused about what that item even DOES in this context. Just a red herring?
 
Okay. And how do you feel about her now?
I’ve been reading Dubz village. I’m curious to see where your read is going though.

The arguments I’ve seen against Dubz so far have lacked logic or been entirely fabricated so it’s certainly colored my perspective when so many arguments feel like they’re being made in bad faith.

It’s hard to wolf read someone when the arguments you see against them aren’t valid.

I do think her claim that she wouldn’t have killed Samac is a falsehood though. She absolutely would. She loves killing people who village read her. And she knows Samac is a strong kill choice. Especially when she was a watcher last night.
 
Oh. Vampy is back on the menu then. Vanilla can also mean just a mafia goon without an ability.

Althought id be confused about what that item even DOES in this context. Just a red herring?
That would be par for the course in a Goats game.

First one had unconvertable masons in a conversion-free game.

Second had a arsonist that could never ignite its targets.
 
Zenge can you read 25-30 again at some point where PSV under pressure goes to Samac but refuses to go to PSV without your explicit approval?

Do you think that is a bad faith argument?
 
I’ve been reading Dubz village. I’m curious to see where your read is going though.

The arguments I’ve seen against Dubz so far have lacked logic or been entirely fabricated so it’s certainly colored my perspective when so many arguments feel like they’re being made in bad faith.

It’s hard to wolf read someone when the arguments you see against them aren’t valid.
Well, I hope can see me as a Voice of Reason™.
I do think her claim that she wouldn’t have killed Samac is a falsehood though. She absolutely would. She loves killing people who village read her. And she knows Samac is a strong kill choice. Especially when she was a watcher last night.
Oh, that's absolutely diabolical information to hear.
 
Zenge can you read 25-30 again at some point where PSV under pressure goes to Samac but refuses to go to PSV without your explicit approval?

Do you think that is a bad faith argument?
Can you rewrite this so it makes sense? I don’t think this is what you mean to say 🤔
 
but she only had a 33% chance of it working or something
I know it COULD work though because if it succeeded, the target could hold a seance with their own ashes and ask the mods a question, but the only answers they would have received would have been goat facts.
 
Top