GGoats ThWWee: Here It GGoats Again - GAME THREAD

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
I actually don't think the action of tracking Kay was all that villagey? She was pretty widely village read. It makes sense for Lissa specifically given her stated reads.

Which is why if she is wolf, I think the tracking claim was a lie. Although i can think of a scenario where it would be true in that case too!

I think I've played too many games and seen too many things at this stage.
I think if the tracking claim was a lie then Lissa needs to have a scum teammate who has the tracking item, has used it to know what it does and hasnt spoken up about it.

Scum cant just claim an item use they don't know about because like town can get that item later and it might not do exactly what they think it does.

I have the airtag right now and from the pre use description I think Lissas description of it is correct

I guess that would be exactly clem in that scenario who is being very snug about what they are doing every night. But I don't really believe it
 
reasoning for my vote: unpaired me with everyone, removed me from POE, accepted bean's public read on me that they gave me the ice cream cone and my affiliation of vanilla was revealed, then went back when genny said affiliation did not equal role. (the below messages are not in order because when i flipped through the pages it removed one so i had to re-add it, the order is Bottom 1st, Middle 2nd and top 3rd, so bottom to top)
Vampy unpaired with both other members of my limpool is interesting. I think they get out of the limpool in general for that
Not Genny, Not Lissa, Not MKG. These all have mechanical backup.

Not AM lol. Vampy willing you yeet you EOD1. Not vampy!

Beans/Clem/Zenge I guess or you are the solo OG wolf and I need to throw all my reads away, which im not willing to do speculatively just yet
Oh. Vampy is back on the menu then. Vanilla can also mean just a mafia goon without an ability.

Althought id be confused about what that item even DOES in this context. Just a red herring?

WZ makes the vote for me today at 1:58pm
vote vampy
GB unvotes WZ and votes for me with zero explanation or reasoning at 2:41pm
Unvote
Vote Vampy

i just find it super convenient
 
it just seems like every time someone mentions something new about me, you have a comment to make about it. why didnt you say anything about moving off of dubz? just quietly went with her?

justify it.
 
So I made a naked vote and you decided rather than be curious about it you would use it as justification for a push back. Interesting.
 
It’s really amazing how much the language in these games changes over time. I can’t understand half of what you guys are saying with your lingo and abbreviations. Makes me feel my age. I’m a little lost so I’m going to go back through the next couple pages while I wait on my patient’s owner to get here for discharge.
 
So I made a naked vote and you decided rather than be curious about it you would use it as justification for a push back. Interesting.
you've been flipflopping on me all day. if im going to go down screaming that its literally not me and misyeeted, i want this documented so you can be looked into next.
 
I am curious to hear what Dubz's case on Beans is, since she said Vampy/Beans were where she was 👀 at the start of the day I believe
I don't really have a case there, just POE (see my earlier post about reasoning for my non-POE people and feel free to provide input on who I'm misclearing)
 
I like competing wagons, I wanted to see who would join yours to try and counterwagon WZ (read,nobody). I also think the fact that you forgot why Genny was so heavily unpaired with PSV shows that you arnt solving and is a reason why Genny could still be alive.
 
It’s really amazing how much the language in these games changes over time. I can’t understand half of what you guys are saying with your lingo and abbreviations. Makes me feel my age. I’m a little lost so I’m going to go back through the next couple pages while I wait on my patient’s owner to get here for discharge.
Well, you can always ask if something is unclear. I don't mind explaining.
 
you've been flipflopping on me all day. if im going to go down screaming that its literally not me and misyeeted, i want this documented so you can be looked into next.
Yeah town flip flops because they don't know the right answer and are desperately trying to find it.
 
Whoa this thread blew up while I was gone 😂
Uh not sure what to add here...thank you zenge for the feedback and thank you AM for the defense!
If this helps clear it up at all, I know that there are still other players who have not been mechanically cleared. My thought process was that anyone who hasn't been cleared should be in the running to be a wolf...which is part of why I thought dubz was a wolf. I just don't think I worded that very well (probably because of exam brain). And yeah, saying "incriminating evidence" may not have been the best way to word what I was going for. Now I know for next time!

I could go for a vote on either dubz or Clem at this point. Potentially zenge? I'm with Greedy that Lissa seems ok. And AM too.
 
I like competing wagons, I wanted to see who would join yours to try and counterwagon WZ (read,nobody). I also think the fact that you forgot why Genny was so heavily unpaired with PSV shows that you arnt solving and is a reason why Genny could still be alive.
i think you are picking pieces of what i said to divert attention off of you. the genny comment in relation to how YOU responded to it. again, weird that you picked that out of everything i mentioned.
 
If you cant do any better at justifying your vote other than I voted you, it's not going to end well for you. I've posted a LOT in this game, some of it is probably scummy, go find it.
 
i think you are picking pieces of what i said to divert attention off of you. the genny comment in relation to how YOU responded to it. again, weird that you picked that out of everything i mentioned.
What attention is on me? I'm straight chilling. If I didn't want attention on me i'd stay parked on a pretty justifyable WZ vote.
 
Also we have like 4 hours, i'm not classifying this as a critical moment. I went through PSV>Samac>PSV>Samac>WZ in 100 minutes at EOD1
 
If you cant do any better at justifying your vote other than I voted you, it's not going to end well for you. I've posted a LOT in this game, some of it is probably scummy, go find it.
i dont need to, i like my reasons.
 
Oh it’s a lot. Like I have figured out that POE is a sus list but not what it stands for.

And someone said I was being tinfoiled? I’m just an old millennial I guess
Process of Elimination

And tinfoiled refers to those who propagate theories typically associated with those wearing tinfoil hats.

Basically, "I'm/You're a silly goose" (derogatory)
 
we're down 4 town and only 1 wolf, i would say this is higher stakes than EOD1
Of course, but day 2 was a wash for assosiatives like I said it was always going to be, and mafia is confirmed to have recruitment powers.

Look at how much i'm trying to solve with EOD1. I'm thinking about EOD4 and EOD5 here as well.
 
I picked tracker and openly claimed it. I either die tonight and force scum to shoot a sub optimal target or get potentially solving info.
 
I'm never the lim, and you will never get the votes. I am purely trying to solve your motivations here. I am entirely unconcerned with standing out
 
Potentially was my former self. I'm 100% Zenge now
Facebook factcheckers would like to have a word with you.

Screenshot_20250617-165343-164.png
 
AM how strongly do you believe WZ flips wolf more often than vampy here. My read on vampy has been deteriorating as they have been setting up on me for days but if you put your foot down i'll sheep the vote
 
(speaking of sorrys, @WildZoo ooc and oog publicly owed apology for snapping at you earlier. there was no excuse for that and it was flat out rude and made the thread weird and uncomfy. i'm very sorry for being a bitch. and apologies to anyone else who i made feel uncomfy with my comments and attitude, it wasnt right)

edit: (adding a comment to say this should have 0 factor in your decision or your reads on me and i actively discourage you doing so, no this isnt not reverse psychology either, and thats not reverse reverse psychology- you get the picture)
 
AM how strongly do you believe WZ flips wolf more often than vampy here. My read on vampy has been deteriorating as they have been setting up on me for days but if you put your foot down i'll sheep the vote
I'm not opposed to competing wagons here as they're still both in my POE. I'm not going to claim to be a godreader of dubz as I haven't voted her in literal years but I do think she has solid equity with PSV.
 
Non-POE reasoning:

genny - obvious, outted PSV and from the beginning seemed more interested in pursuing her than Lissa. 100% unpaired.

mkg - Was just based on the mayoral energy, then Zenge's reading card, and then she shot PSV so barring fancy shenanigans, she good.

Zenge - Voiced suspicion against PSV multiple times prior to the genny outting, don't see him doing that after converting her. However, idk why he is now bringing up samac being a watcher as if that is a point against me when I didn't know about it.

Greedy - for VCA purposes I don't think his vote hopping at the end of D1 makes much sense knowing that mads, fruit, samac (and myself) were all village. Was the second vote on PSV (after fruit) when there were many village options on the board and encouraged KJQ to move there as well...the movement to samac was voiced by KJQ and started by fruit so not like he was the one to push things away from PSV. I also just think he's sounded village when sus has come up about him.

Sakuraaaaa - no need to bring up the conversion thing as a wolf. AM is in her village meta, I'm just not used to her turning the vulpix gaze on me lol

Clem - he probably should be in my POE I just don't feel like putting him there. His energy is very village!Clem and I don't think he goes "wow surprised there are any vanilla town" as a wolf, that's some rookie wolf slippage that I know he is better than.

Lissa - on the weaker end of things, but it would just be strange for OH HOLD ON A MINUTE*******

I'm torn because part of my brain wants to be like "Ooo Lissa epiphany!!" but idk if it's too convoluted?

Like the item and usage makes sense, but we have no way to confirm that KJQ did act on samac, other than it seeming to make sense from the thread, and if we can come to that conclusion then a wolf can surely come to the same conclusion for a fake tracking claim.

Likewise it would seem strange for two wolves to act on the same player, but if Lissa wasn't tracking then...maybe not so strange?

And the big thought I had that ultimately is probably insane, is like...what if PSV wasn't lying about the item, and she was converted n1, because she used the item and ended up in the presence of a wolf and somehow that converted her? Or something?

All of this was triggered by PSV saying she believed Lissa and that there must have been some ~other~ person present for KJQ's death, which is a weird thing for a wolf to do when a Lissa vote was the only way she was gonna live.

Hard though, outted wolves do be doing stuff.

At any rate I have no reason to remove Lissa from the POE other than occam's razor.
@Zenge142

I admittedly have not looked at beans super closely so if someone wants to like, make a case for or against them I'm happy to read it. My own deep dive time for the day has been used up.
 
(speaking of sorrys, @WildZoo ooc and oog publicly owed apology for snapping at you earlier. there was no excuse for that and it was flat out rude and made the thread weird and uncomfy. i'm very sorry for being a bitch. and apologies to anyone else who i made feel uncomfy with my comments and attitude, it wasnt right)

edit: (adding a comment to say this should have 0 factor in your decision or your reads on me and i actively discourage you doing so, no this isnt not reverse psychology either, and thats not reverse reverse psychology- you get the picture)
We are good, thank you <3
 
well hate to break it to you, but i am infact vanilla villager. idk about mkg, but after i was elected mayor, i wasnt told my role updated, only that i received extra items each day. some are useful, some are useless. like one time i got a jelly bean and i can do whatever i want with it
can confirm, I also got a stale jelly bean yesterday

did i ever tell you about the time i attempted to poison another player with a jellybean?
I'm glad mine wasn't poisoned but it did taste like robitussin so close enough 🙁
 
Manual Playing Tickles Animal Midwife's Autism - Day 3 Tally

Dubz (1) - AM
vampy (2) - Dubz, Greedy
Greedy (1) - vampy

4/10 voting
@vampyrica, you are ever so slightly in the lead!

Missing: @Zenge142, @genny, @mkg323, @Clem J, @beans2020, @Lissarae06

Vote closes today, 6/17 at 9 PM (~3.5 hours).
 
It’s not an invalid point, but playing devil’s advocate, she also didn’t move to Fruit to try and save Dubz
Im pretty sure PSV had already claimed she was village reading fruit at that point, moving there at EOD would have been pretty sus
 
so no one panics, I won't be on at EOD because I have a meeting tonight. I will submit a vote before then. If anyone wants to try and convince me to swing one way or the other you have the next couple hours or so
 
She needs to stop doing that. Imagine if everyone voted for the first time when she did. Everything would always a bandwagon. I'm serious @vampyrica . I welcome playstyle difference but for this you need to start voting way earlier even if you change it later.


Two nks and one conversion. Regardless, my points are not just exclusively hinged on mads. It's just another part of the puzzle that fails to clear you.


I don't know how I can be considered tunneled when I just got here and it hasn't even been a single cycle.


I was asking a serious question and it was deflected to ATE. Which I don't understand if you see me as town and thus my questions as genuinely trying to solve you.


Show of hands here.

Who will vote dubz today with little to no ambivalence?

Not just "scumread." Actually vote.

Say "yes" or "no." There is no "maybe."

If you say "maybe," I'm putting you under "no."

@mkg323 @Clem J @vampyrica @beans2020 @Lissarae06
Put me under no
 
I'm taking dad to a baseball game so I won't be thinking about this
 
Top