I don't feel particularly villagey vibes from either of them and Bread is on so infrequently that there aren't really any interactions to analyze, so I don't see a problem with that
Absolutely. I don’t agree with the read, but it does seem within her village range to sus you for emoji use.
Interesting, because I pushed a similar narrative as a wolf against Pippy in the last game
I don’t understand this, so please elaborate
@PippyPony also asked me about this post but my phone keeps breaking quotes. My ehhh was about the tone more than the content
Hmmm
Maybe this is where I was on alley.
Okay so apparently you’re not reading either, because I made my vote on you pretty clear, IMO.
Bro I was specifically *asked* about the leading wagons. JFC. I didn’t “set” anything up. And I didn’t move because bread was in danger. I moved because Bob was and I felt much worse about Genny than bob.
Yeah well I have one working eye currently so maybe.
I'm not going to get into a fight with you about it, sunny. Just saying what I see in the VCA, looking for thoughts from others. I don't find it overall productive to argue with you about my read on you lol
Okay well for the other people reading, you know, the ones you wanted thoughts from? I’m not going to let your fake narrative sit unchallenged.
Hmmm
Ah, here’s the words for what I was feeling on that Mel post, but couldn’t put into words
The difference is I didn't say it was crap, I said I didn't agree with his logic for forming his reads, AND I explained exactly what I had problems with and why
This makes me feel that alley and sunny are w/v. Hmm
So if everyone is twisty and writing fake narratives, who are your ACTUAL wolf reads?
I posted my entire reads list. The only update was Pippy insisting I twisting everything
Mods: Okay I accidentally edited this. I thought I was in reply mode. And now I don’t want to edit it a second time to edit out the edit.
What logic? The one where you guys agree that I’m sus? Or the one where she quoted alleys post only to say that she didn’t read it?
I have to go back and look at progression because I thought sunny was shading bob earlier on, and I don't currently remember when that changed
Bread defense 1
Bread defense 2 (mkg was on bread at the time)
Bob and genny actually had equal vote control since they weren't crossvoting
1. Omg we’ve literally been through this. I responded to pippy claiming i was wolf reading bob when I had him as mixed. That means some sus and some positives. I pulled all the quotes. It’s on like page 18.
I was responding to sunny (first post quoted) showing her which interaction I was referring to
I like the points she made on you and Cray and I remember nodding along with a few other things too
What does this mean and why is it AI?
Ok next time I'll say anyone but sunny 😉 I'm looking for unbiased evaluations
1. No. I never said his was being a noob. Other people did. What I said was to respond to Visc’s question about something like why he would ask about people being immune to night kills on thread instead of in wolf chat if he was a wolf, and I said so that people could literally ask that question. That’s all I said.
AtE?
Appeal to emotion.
you literally tried to capitalize on Bread's absence and my throw away vote and voted behind me to get bread out. with only 13 minutes to close. if anything yesterday reflects poorly on you, not me.
I dont agree with a lot of them, and they remind me a lot of your reads from last game when you wolfed and I pulled you out of my POE
if she was a wolf why point it out? just let people hop on the wagon and vote bread out, he was absent and I wasnt keeping up on the thread well. Also, I see the people who jumped on bread last minute to be wolfy, and sunny's actions would not help them
What if she's a wolf and Bread is a packmate? It would only be useful info if we knew Bread is village
This would be assuming bread is village, yes?
I’d love to get into the specifics of which ones and why you disagree with them.
Or like why would I make so much noise about it if I was a wolf?
This doesn’t strike me as a fair reaction. On the surface it looks like wolfhunting by pointing out sus hedging, but I don’t see Bread doing the AI kind of hedging, which I see as a) bringing up points that wolves want thread to take note of in defence of a packmate or to set up suspicion on a villager, but then hedging with a wishy-washy “oh I have no idea it could mean anything maybe they are village/wolf” or b) refusing to take a real stand on anyone and giving reads lists that actually say very little for all the hedging. Bread saying that he reads z on the sketchy side of neutral is neither. Imo villagers are as likely to read someone “sketchy side of neutral” as wolves, you need to look at context (which i haven’t done, i’m just responding to z’s post because it struck me), not just “oh look a neutral read hedgey wolfy”
Nvm i forgot AtE had already been defined
Yeah but does this really line up with his voting history?
That’s the issue. Woof reading me and voting me yesterday without much to support it. Combined with today’s post it is hedgy.
WIFOM, and with at least two villagers on the board it's not unsafe to point out
Well I’m pretty sure they aren’t w/w
So just going back over the past few pages, your reasoning to clear people jumping on the genny wagon last-minute stands out to me. It seems like you're making broad assumptions as to what people would do as wolves, including Mel, who I am pretty sure you have never played with before. Additionally, the claims you made in your read list posted at the bottom of page 14. I already brought up when and where you exaggerated what I said regarding the mayo vs you argument, and your own stretching of what I said somehow made you wolfread me more? I can probably dig up a few more posts from even earlier on, but those were the most recent examples and I am pressed for time right now.
You’re right, but do you want to explain to me the logic behind Mel or Vis moving their votes when they did, the way they did, if they were wolves?
But the WIFOM is fun
