Ice Cream WW Game Thread

[Ms Procrastinator]

---

Members do not see this ad.

I think mpm's the way we should go

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

FRACK
I’m torn.

 

[kraskadva]

If you weren't voting for me today, who would you be voting for? Or, said a different way, who do you think is the third wolf?

I'm still reading you and miz. Mizzy may well be tunnel from the last game but

 

[JustPaws]

If you weren't voting for me today, who would you be voting for? Or, said a different way, who do you think is the third wolf?

yup

If you aren't a wolf why not answer questions?
Edit:

 

[kraskadva]

Guys don't make me role reveal at the last second.

please do, thx 🙂

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

I'm still reading you and miz. Mizzy may well be tunnel from the last game but

Welcome to my tunnel buddy club. The list is lengthy

 

[Stagg737]

Dubz was like we need to lynch barks tomorrow insinuating that she thinks barks is a wolf. Bark dies and ends up flipping village...People won't really think that a wolf killed the person they were talking about lynching the next day.

Why not? Still sounds like a big WIFOM-y rabbit hole to me.

What do people think about Nyanko talking so much about kras yesterday?

I think it's the one worthwhile thing that came out of that cluster**** other than Ny flipping wolf.

I think that I'd like to know what yoooooou think MsP.

I also think that it is a little weird, but personally I find it hard to believe that she would make such a big and obvious fuss about it if kras was her wolf buddy.

Oh look, more WIFOM. Did you and Ms. P get too big of a glass and fall in or something?

 

[kraskadva]

If you aren't a wolf why not answer questions?
Edit:

 

[Stagg737]

Not in that format but I've spoken about them. Said I would be voting among MsP, kras, genny, stagg (+/- ny when she was alive). Miz and you are still in my strong village reads, mpm is another village read but less strong, still kinda neutral on stagg. MsP got a little village bump today, hence the switch to kras. Am I forgetting anyone?

Thoughts on Genny other than she's not in your village list?

Do I have to have another reason?

You don't have to, but it would certainly help your cause if you had something other than that which made you so certain.

I'm also not sure why it keeps getting said that I "hung back" during the arguments on d1. I straight up wasn't here for the coop/AM argument. And I joined the nav/AM argument, questioning AM about the tell she was proposing. Was the first person to even ask her about what the tell was, asked for clarification, and questioned her about her sample size. Not sure what part of that constitutes hanging back so if someone could explain that, I'd appreciate it.

Sporty put it pretty well, it felt stiff and fake. The content wasn't what bothered me too much (once you answered my questions), it was the tone that just felt really wrong and is still bothering me a bit. Felt like you were just going through the motions with the convo from AM and that you were just trusting her.

 

[Stagg737]

View attachment 282692

Is your IM rotation frying your brain or has residency fried mine? Because I don't get where you're coming from tonight at all...

 

[kraskadva]

Is your IM rotation frying your brain or has residency fried mine? Because I don't get where you're coming from tonight at all...

perhaps a bit of both
more a dammed if I do, dammed if I don't statement

Edit: also tired and trying to prep a presentation in between popping in here

 

[Stagg737]

I’m confused. What do you want an answer to?

I wanted an answer to why you thought Nav flipping village would make FTF village to you. Seems like it should have the opposite implications to me unless there's something I'm missing.

@Stagg737 what are your thoughts on msp after her posts

Feeling better about her, but still not great. She's in my neutral section right now, but I'd still like to hear more before I'm more comfortable with her. Won't be voting there, just trying to figure out which flip would give the most info, as all the current leaders fall into the sketchy side of my list.

 

[genny]

Why can't I make chili in reasonable quantities? I'm going to be eating this for every meal for the next week. It's delicious, so I'll do it. But I really need a chili recipe for like 2-3 people and not 18.

 

[genny]

please do, thx 🙂

I don't know that it's going to do much good, since I've basically claimed a PR, and no one has switched off me.

 

[Stagg737]

Unlynch Ms P

 

[Stagg737]

Why can't I make chili in reasonable quantities? I'm going to be eating this for every meal for the next week. It's delicious, so I'll do it. But I really need a chili recipe for like 2-3 people and not 18.

What are you talking about? Chili for 18 is a reasonable quantity...

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

Wolf Nav would make you almost certainly village. I’d remain unsure about flushy just because of how rapidly he jumped on the Nav vote after you started it. I can’t imaging a wolf jumping on a village lynch that fast but I sure as hell can see a wolf jumping on a wolf lynch that early. Does flushy bus?

ETA: sure could also make him village but it wouldn’t put him as definitively in one pile or another.

@Stagg737 this was my response to the question. AM asked at the same time you did so I responded to her and just kinda assumed you read it.

 

[JustPaws]

I don't know that it's going to do much good, since I've basically claimed a PR, and no one has switched off me.

@mizchiefmanaged does this change anything for you?

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

@mizchiefmanaged does this change anything for you?

I’ve been ****ed over a lot on both sides of this claim. We know that nyan was a blocker. There have been games where wolves have had the only PR just to **** with wolf brains while there haven’t been any village PRs. I guess I’m not 100% convinced there even ARE any other PRs. At this point if she doesn’t get lynched she’ll get NKd. @genny who all have you acted on? You don’t have to say what you are.

I’m that vein, has anyone been alerted to being blocked? If nobody was alerted to that then I guess asking the former question is irrelevant.

 

[Stagg737]

Lynch Kras

Even if she's a noob, I should have more on her at this point in the game and the Ny interactions seemed weird. Still think there was likely a wolf on the Navs lynch, but I also think there could be one between MPM and Kras, and I feel better about MPM after hearing more from her.

 

[WildZoo]

Thoughts on Genny other than she's not in your village list?

I'm having a hard time parsing out her just being busy from her being off. But in general she feels off - a few of her comments have raised my eyebrow in ways I'm not used to from her. So that's pretty much what I've got.

 

[WildZoo]

You don't have to, but it would certainly help your cause if you had something other than that which made you so certain.

Meh, sometimes I just like to throw my weight around and see what happens

 

[WildZoo]

Sporty put it pretty well, it felt stiff and fake. The content wasn't what bothered me too much (once you answered my questions), it was the tone that just felt really wrong and is still bothering me a bit. Felt like you were just going through the motions with the convo from AM and that you were just trusting her.

Well, perhaps you're both terrible at reading my tone. I wasn't just trusting her, if I was I wouldn't have bothered asking. I was evaluating her and her argument. The way she presented it made me think she actually believed it (which, who knows, she might have...I figure she was probably playing it pretty village then), and since I didn't like the other options on the board, I was ok following her onto that lynch and seeing what happened.

 

[Lawpy]

Lynch closed. Results freshly pending.

 

[Lawpy]

D3 Blueberry Frozen Yogurt Tally

Please check your votes!

MsPro () -
Pawsy (1) - kras
mpm (2) - MsPro, genny
kras (3) - WZ, Pawsy, Stagg
genny (2) - mizzy, mpm

8/8 voting

Lynch closed

 

[kraskadva]

*****
and y'all did it again... Mkay, have fun.
Here's a cat pic on the way out
*****

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

Nice one stagg

 

[Lawpy]

Gone and eaten is @kraskadva , Cookies and Cream Ice Cream and a Vanilla Townie

Spoiler: ice cream

It is now Night 3.

Player Roster
3. @Ms Procrastinator
4. @mizchiefmanaged
7. @WildZoo
8. @genny
10. @Stagg737
12. @mypetmoose
13. @StayingPositive2017 (previously Coops)

Eaten
11. Navs, cherry and vanilla townie
2. AM, chocolate chip and unjester
6. Sporty, cotton candy and vanilla townie
9. Barky, mint chocolate chip and vanilla townie
0. FTFlushy, pistachio and vanilla townie
5. nyans, chocolate and mafia blocker
1. krasky, cookies and cream and vanilla townie

 

[genny]

Well, I'm toast. LOL.

 

[WildZoo]

There I go lynching one of my favorite flavors
I give up this game tbh. Probs the wolves are my strong village reads. Someone put me out of my misery already.

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

I don’t even know where to ****ing go from this. Time to reread the whole damn thread.

 

[genny]

I'm still leaning MPM. But now also Stagg.

 

[genny]

Though Miz is quickly climbing the wolfy ladder, especially with the "I don't know" act.

 

[genny]

There I go lynching one of my favorite flavors
I give up this game tbh. Probs the wolves are my strong village reads. Someone put me out of my misery already.

I think I get to go first.

 

[genny]

So 6 vs 2 tomorrow if we're lucky. 5 vs 3 if there are more wolves than I want there to be. It's got to be 6 vs 2 since we had a 3rd party, right?

 

[Stagg737]

I'm still leaning MPM. But now also Stagg.

Why? Because I picked wrong with Kras? Should I have voted for you instead? I don't think I ever caught your reason for voting for MPM, can you clarify?

 

[JustPaws]

@Stagg737 do you prefer to be wolf or village?

 

[Lawpy]

Night closed. Results pending.

 

[JustPaws]

Day 3 progression
MsP (1) - FTF
MsP (2) - FTF, WZ
MsP (1) - FTF, WZ
WZ (1) - FTF
Paws (1) - kras
FTF and Ny Modkilled
WZ () - FTF modkilled
MsP (2) - WZ, stagg
MPM (1) - MsP
MsP (1) - WZ, stagg
kras (1) - WZ
genny (1) - miz
kras (2) - WZ, Paws
genny (2) - miz, MPM
MPM (2) - MsP, genny
MsP () - stagg
kras (3) - WZ, Paws, stagg

Day 3 Final

MsP () -
Paws (1) - kras
mpm (2) - MsP, genny
kras (3) - WZ, Paws, Stagg
genny (2) - miz, mpm

8/8 voting

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

Why? Because I picked wrong with Kras? Should I have voted for you instead? I don't think I ever caught your reason for voting for MPM, can you clarify?

I was really surprised at your vote yesterday stagg. It's got me wondering

 

[Lawpy]

Gone and eaten is @mypetmoose , Pumpkin Ice Cream and a Vanilla Townie

Spoiler: ice cream

It is now Day 4 and *YLO.

Player Roster
3. @Ms Procrastinator
4. @mizchiefmanaged
7. @WildZoo
8. @genny
10. @Stagg737
13. @StayingPositive2017 (previously Coops)

Eaten
11. Navs, cherry and vanilla townie
2. AM, chocolate chip and unjester
6. Sporty, cotton candy and vanilla townie
9. Barky, mint chocolate chip and vanilla townie
0. FTFlushy, pistachio and vanilla townie
5. nyans, chocolate and mafia blocker
1. krasky, cookies and cream and vanilla townie
12. mpm/petmoosy, pumpkin and vanilla townie

 

[JustPaws]

i do not get these kill choices. When I iso'd barks, he was looking harder at mpm and neutral on Miz. gonna go iso mpm. why would you kill mpm and not try for the lynch today. so weird

 

[JustPaws]

also i will update all the tallies with colors if anyone besides myself gives a ****

Official D1 FINAL

Coops () -
Mizzy () -
WZ (2) - kras, mpm
Stagg (1) - genny
mpm () -
FTF (2) - Barky, Sporty
AM (2) - nyans, Nav
Nav (4) - AM, FTF, WZ, mizzy
Barky (1) - Coops
Sporty (1) - Stagg

13/14 voting missing MsP

D2 FINAL TALLY

Coops (1) - nyans
MsPro (1) - FTF
Sporty (4) - barky, Staggs, mpm, mizzy
WZ () -
mpm (3) - genny, Coops, Sporty
mizzy () -
Barky (1) - WZ

10/12 voting missing MsP and kras

Day 3 Final

MsP () -
Paws (1) - kras
mpm (2) - MsP, genny
kras (3) - WZ, Paws, Stagg
genny (2) - miz, mpm

8/8 voting

 

[JustPaws]

also for now

lynch miz

while i iso MPM. I talked myself out of it yesterday, but maybe that was a mistake

 

[JustPaws]

It is now Day 4 and *YLO

quoting for those in the back.
Think this means that there must be 2 wolves left.
would be willing to vote "no lynch" to buy us another day too.
@Lawper are you allowing this?

unlynch miz
lynch "no lynch"

 

[Lawpy]

quoting for those in the back.
Think this means that there must be 2 wolves left.
would be willing to vote "no lynch" to buy us another day too.
@Lawper are you allowing this?

unlynch miz
lynch "no lynch"

Yep

 

[WildZoo]

I'd be willing to go no lynch as well though I think I'm at the point where I can't see a scenario where stagg is not a wolf

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

also for now

lynch miz

while i iso MPM. I talked myself out of it yesterday, but maybe that was a mistake

You’re barking up the wrong tree with me.

******no lynch******

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

I'd be willing to go no lynch as well though I think I'm at the point where I can't see a scenario where stagg is not a wolf

Why are you thinking stagg? I’ve had his as one of my strongest village reads for the last few days.

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

Although I’ve been wrong about everything else so far so I’m probably wrong about that too.