- Joined
- Nov 16, 2010
- Messages
- 1,406
- Reaction score
- 1,944
Wait don't kill me! 
*****************
The suspense is killing me.
**************
Even when dead, she did a pretty good job figuring out who all the wolves are.
Clearly I am a genius. Or an idiot. One of those 😛Most obvious goes to: WZ
Okay, so sometimes "obvious" play becomes not obvious when you are a highly revered player. But she literally did repeatedly the most obvious thing possible. She recruited MJ right off the bat, the person you would most associate with WZ. Then when she got wind of someone who could arm people with guns only, and whose deaths would show up as guns, she recruited them, even though she knew it would be a flawed tactic. Then she ended it by recruiting the most obvious person to convert left in the game. Somehow, it all worked in the end.
I feel like going through and quoting every post from caia that made it insanely obvious she was a wolf. Maybe at some point today I will. Just a good indication if you didn't pick it up in the things she stated but the sudden and very obvious change in her game play was another massive hint.
Anyway, that is all. Good game. I didn't pay a whole lot of attention at the beginning.
I think if people want to go back and read now that they know, they are free to do that.
Obviously do what you want, but trying to make a lesson out of it I don't agree with unless someone comes to you seeking it.
Who said I'm trying to make a lesson out of anything?
And what does it matter to you anyway? The game is over. I'm not doing anything bad, rude or mean and quite honestly I find your comment to be quite rude. Pointing out things that occurred in the game once it ends is normal and happens at the end of every game.
Going through one player's posts and pointing out things that were "insanely obvious" or a "massive hint" is incredibly condescending. Why else would you put that effort in if not to try and teach the people that didn't notice like you did? I never said anything about being bad or mean, I said I disagreed with it.
It's making an analysis of my play for those that didn't pick up on it. It would be different if you were pointing out various things in the game, but you centered that on only me in that post. I'm only asking that you keep it to yourself unless someone seeks it out.
🙄
Believe it or not, it isn't all about you. It is more directed to the villagers still alive at that point. Sure it was obvious you were a wolf but you managed to make it work. It is the villagers who had the bad play of not picking up on it. It isn't about you. But forget it, you get way the hell too worked up. Besides the point that I said MAY do it, if I have time. But forget it, you're clearly way too upset over nothing.
she was way more active this game than she usually is. It's a tell. Plus there were other red flags.I think it's much more easy to figure these things out when you're dead and no longer as emotionally invested. I didn't think Caia started playing particularly obviously different, but that's quite possibly me just being obtuse.
I haven't played with her much, but to me she seemed about as active as she was vs. DocE last game.she was way more active this game than she usually is. It's a tell. Plus there were other red flags.
I'm disappointed that like 3 dying villagers said it's swin or caia and then no one lynched caia![]()
Yes, I know it was obviously directed at the villagers. If you don't understand why I (or the villagers) wouldn't appreciate you doing that then fine, I'm not going to argue about it.
Only speak for yourself. It is rude to speak for others.
Other than that, not going to say anything else related to this.
she doesn't normally post as often per day.I haven't played with her much, but to me she seemed about as active as she was vs. DocE last game.
@SummerTheLynx - was there more to druggie chat people than just being lowest rank? Curious about the nights I wasn't in it.
JFC, you are being obtuse.
You're seriously going to be intentionally insulting now? Wow, I get that you're emotional about this, but there is such a thing as taking it too far.
I'm done with this convo, if you really want to discuss further you can PM me.
Reply to this or don't, but I think our opposing views on this are important for people to consider how they want to handle end of game commentary.
I'm frustrated that you don't understand why people might not want their specific mistakes lined up in a row by you, and I'm talking from the perspective of a villager here because I'm trying to address this for games as a whole, not just this one. I think it is fine to offer for those that want to learn, but it only serves to make people feel worse about what they missed otherwise and I don't think it needs to be out there to make them feel that way unless they want it to be.
I would not like it if you took a game I had played early on as a villager and lost and systematically reviewed all of the things I missed that were so obvious to you without invitation.
That is why I said I disagreed with you posting that but that it was fine if people actually sought it out.
My default on this is that there should be demonstrated interest first as it would be a more courteous route. That is all.
So if we disagree on that level of courtesy, then OK. But I thought it was worth considering.
I'm not even going to post anything anymore because you are throwing a fit.
People post things all the time like that at game end, it isn't meant to be condescending or rude in ANY way, you are just being emotional about it.
Heck, I'm still waiting for DocE to come blazing in and tell me I was a complete idiot to kill him. And guess what, he'd be right. I was busy, not thinking clearly and acted too quickly. I was also an idiot to use cocaine on MJ, yes I may have blocked him and that would have been good, but the 50% enhancement was too high of a chance. Again, I was not thinking and really expecting that he'd be blocked since that was the result I got most often.
The point in having the commentary isn't to make people feel bad, it is to re look at the game to see what occurred that maybe shouldn't have. That is all. It isn't condescending, rude, mean or meant as an attack as you are taking it to be. You are being overly sensitive about it. I understand that you had other things going on IRL too and I'm sorry to hear that and truly hope things are going better, but I think that emotion is spilling over here.
Having said that, I won't post anything because it is clear it'll just upset you. And I don't really want to make anyone upset.
And I'm sorry for any insults. I don't have a filter when I get frustrated and that's my fault.
But wasn't the last thing you said about Caia that you were pretty sure she wasn't a wolf?I'm also frustrated that if stl hadn't thought Caia wasn't voting to lynch me the other day, she likely would have been the one I took out. That's some bad luck for the villagers.
The one from LIS dying? The extra kill was from The Torpedo, which could kill twice throughout the game. He used one of his up to take out FS, and had one remaining for Caiter.Hey @SummerTheLynx what was up with the magical extra kill or whatever that Caiter got? You may have already told us but it was post-death for me so I don't remember.
Oh, is that what happened, she inherited it from LIS? Gotcha. My ability to attempt to comprehend what was going on plummeted when I died.The one from LIS dying? The extra kill was from The Torpedo, which could kill twice throughout the game. He used one of his up to take out FS, and had one remaining for Caiter.
Yeah, she originally had submitted to take out Swin and that should have been it at that point (but then I said something that in retrospect, I shouldn't have). Then she said that she would take out Caia, but she wanted me to make it clear in write up that she really didn't want to. Then she switched back to Swin b/c she really didn't think it was Caia.But wasn't the last thing you said about Caia that you were pretty sure she wasn't a wolf?
I did think swin was the wolf of the three of us, because obviously I knew it wasn't me and Caia had agreed to let me kill her if swin didn't vote for me. There was some confusion in the pm between STL and I, and I had agreed to take Caia out instead, and he told me I couldn't because she hadn't voted to lynch me, even though she had. So if he had seen that she had voted to lynch me, the game would have been over right then.But wasn't the last thing you said about Caia that you were pretty sure she wasn't a wolf?
I haven't played with her much, but to me she seemed about as active as she was vs. DocE last game.
@SummerTheLynx - was there more to druggie chat people than just being lowest rank? Curious about the nights I wasn't in it.
If it was lowest rank, why was Rojo in the chat instead of me?Nothing more except that I got to interact with those gang members.
Because I made the mistake and it never got corrected.If it was lowest rank, why was Rojo in the chat instead of me?