Magical WW Signups and Game Thread

[WildZoo]

---

Members don't see this ad.

Oh come now, don't be so modest. 🙂

Not being modest haha
I have to discuss things with Caiter before I do much on the thread, as the mods have requested that we present a united front so things don't get too confusing. As far as defense goes, well, it is but day 1. I would reconsider your strategy of lynching the players who you think are good at the game. You tend to like to have those people around if they are villagers.

 

[kaydubs]

I was reminded again that I was MJ's mentor back when he was a newb. So long ago....

 

[allieh8607]

@Filly Bay @allieh8607
@WhtsThFrequency

Thanks for the tag! I don't know how you guys play in clinics. I feel like a shell of a person right now and adding WW to the mix would definitely put me over the edge lol

 

[Ceke2002]

Well, I managed to send him a video he hadn't seen before as a hello, so I've got that going for me!

Hmm, yes, yes you do. I shall therefore give you diamonds and most happily wish for your not death. 🙂

 

[Ceke2002]

Not being modest haha
I have to discuss things with Caiter before I do much on the thread, as the mods have requested that we present a united front so things don't get too confusing. As far as defense goes, well, it is but day 1. I would reconsider your strategy of lynching the players who you think are good at the game. You tend to like to have those people around if they are villagers.

There may be method in my madness though.

Some attempt at method at least, it appears we have no choice to pass on lynch votes, even those on a first night when an innocent may be killed. If I don't have some method to work from then I might as well play pin the random lynch on the donkey, either that or eenie, meenie, minie moe, and that seems so unfair.

 

[finnickthedog]

Lynch STL

 

[Ceke2002]

I'm still waiting for my group PM to happen as well, but I can't be up for much longer seeing as it's time for this little Gorgon to be in bed. I shall revisit the thread, and try not to theory bounce off the walls with my group, when I awake.

 

[kaydubs]

Thanks for the tag! I don't know how you guys play in clinics. I feel like a shell of a person right now and adding WW to the mix would definitely put me over the edge lol

huggggg

 

[kaydubs]

Lynch tally:
STL (1) - finnick

 

[Trilt]

There may be method in my madness though.

Some attempt at method at least, it appears we have no choice to pass on lynch votes, even those on a first night when an innocent may be killed. If I don't have some method to work from then I might as well play pin the random lynch on the donkey, either that or eenie, meenie, minie moe, and that seems so unfair.

We're going to kill innocents. Period. Not just the first night, but the whole game, and especially while looking for converts. It's really annoying to be on the receiving end as a villager, but part of the game.

Lynch STL

No, no, you have to keep STL around so that we can all flip flop to him 5 minutes before a lynch close. 😉 (I know he's just in your spot).


In any case, lynch Hayley.
Due to longevity in previous game, and to encourage a bit of chattiness from her.

 

[Lupin21]

*****************************
Did somebody call for a magical unicorn?! Here I be!!

 

[dyachei]

more discussion leads to being able to kill wolves day 1.

In that interest, I will join trilt and put pressure on a random player lynch hayley

 

[kaydubs]

Aw yes, kill the confused player in Pacific Time.

 

[kaydubs]

Lynch tally:
STL (1) - finnick
hay (2) - Trilt, dyachei

 

[dyachei]

Aw yes, kill the confused player in Pacific Time.

never said my vote would stay there. But pressure is an important tool

 

[nyanko]

everyone's a wolf but me imo

 

[nyanko]

lynch BBC because i still can't handle it

 

[genny]

lynch nyanko

She also lived a long time in the last game, and I'd like to pressure more than just Hayley to say something.

 

[Kam325]

Lynch Hayley so we're not waiting until the last minute to pile up somewhere.

 

[dyachei]

lynch nyanko

She also lived a long time in the last game, and I'd like to pressure more than just Hayley to say something.

it doesn't work to pressure them unless you have many votes there.

 

[genny]

it doesn't work to pressure them unless you have many votes there.

Yes, I am aware of that. I am hoping to attract additional pressure, as I do not have multiple votes to use. I think it's in our best interest to have more than one leading candidate while lynch deadline is still several hours away, as it puts pressure on more than one person to say something. If Hayley doesn't show up until 30 minutes before deadline with a great defense, and everyone has piled on her, then it's just a scramble to figure out who else to vote for. Maybe the last-minute craziness is unavoidable, but I'm at least trying to think about a way around it.

 

[Trilt]

Judging by likes, there are a lot of people who have checked in but not voted. We can have multiple candidates, but not if a ton of people hold back their votes all day in hope that the silent thread will somehow breathe forth information.

 

[kaydubs]

Dog pile lynch:
Hay(3) - trilt, dyachei, kam325
BBC(1)- nyanko
STL (1)- finnickthedog
nyanko(1) - genny

6/25

 

[finnickthedog]

Judging by likes, there are a lot of people who have checked in but not voted. We can have multiple candidates, but not if a ton of people hold back their votes all day in hope that the silent thread will somehow breathe forth information.

Did you know that I agree with you?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Lynch Hayley for now, but honestly I have no feels on anyone yet. So, I'll change to a better candidate later need be.

 

[Trilt]

Did you know that I agree with you?

I didn't! Are you a question-y sort, or should I have?

 

[finnickthedog]

I didn't! Are you a question-y sort, or should I have?

Which do you think is the more likely explanation?

 

[Caiter92]

lynch kam

Cause I promised to lynch her first from now on after the Peter Pan game. Can't break those promises 😉

 

[Trilt]

Which do you think is the more likely explanation?

Yeah, that's what I thought. 🙂

 

[SummerTheLynx]

Top o' the mornin' (I guess afternoon) to ye laddies. It's time the rest of ya pull yer socks up and get ta lynchin'. Lads like crayola may be throwing shapes but at least their heart be in it. To those that last game treated favorably, I send me lot to PBC.

**********lynch PBC********

 

[Abnerrs]

***********************
I love this game already
******************************

 

[heyyimhayley]

I don't know why, but in almost every recent game I seem to be a Day1 lynch target. 🙁

Tough to defend when I don't have any posts or votes to defend yet, but I am a villager! My role name is literally a "villager gnome" so please don't lynch me.

lynch PBC

 

[dyachei]

unlynch hayley, lynch PBC

 

[Kam325]

Unlynch Hayley, lynch PBC.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Unlynch Hayley
Lynch BBC

 

[Mad Jack]

Lol
@Mad Jack, she thinks we're good at this game 🤣

She seems unaware that we're not actually not good at WW, but rather so bad it's notorious 🤣

 

[Mad Jack]

I was reminded again that I was MJ's mentor back when he was a newb. So long ago....

 

[Mad Jack]

Lynch AM

 

[LadyOtheFarm]

Lynch PBC

 

[DVMDream]

Can I Lynch the noob for suggesting some of those players as the most experienced and strategic?

 

[vetmedhead]

I'm going to lynch PBC for being next to all of the other BCs on roster. Obviously open to waffles. Or lucky charms, Crayola? 😉

 

[DVMDream]

I know it is only day 1, but I really do hate the randomly lynching people until they say something then moving on to someone else and repeat and repeat.

I'd rather see some thought even if it is completely off the rocker than the random BS

 

[Trilt]

unlynch Hayley, lynch BBC

Not opposed to the PBC lynch, but she often doesn't show up until quite late in the day when she's working, so we may wait for a response for a while.

 

[hazelmoo]

Dog pile lynch:
Hay(0)
BBC(3)- nyanko, AM, Trilt
STL (1)- finnickthedog
nyanko(1) - genny
kam(1) - caiter
PBC(6) - STL, Hayley, dy, Kam, LoTF, vmh
AM(1) - MJ

13/25

 

[DVMDream]

Sorry, finn but

Lynch finn
You just stand out as having said the least of those who have posted in my quick read through.

 

[nyanko]

finn seems to have a posting restriction where she has to post in questions maybe?

 

[Trilt]

On this note:

I'd rather see some thought even if it is completely off the rocker than the random BS

I'm a little weirded out by:

Sorry, finn

Just because I don't feel like DVMD's usually the apologetic sort about lynching someone. Now, considering the last game I can perhaps understand it, but that pings me ever so slightly. Probably off the rocker.

@PrincessButterCup, come celebrate your biochem test being done with us. 😉

 

[DVMDream]

On this note:


I'm a little weirded out by:

Just because I don't feel like DVMD's usually the apologetic sort about lynching someone. Now, considering the last game I can perhaps understand it, but that pings me ever so slightly. Probably off the rocker.

@PrincessButterCup, come celebrate your biochem test being done with us. 😉

Yup, off the rocker but hey I at least appreciate the analysis better than random IMO, even if it is against me.

Just apologetic because of last game and being adamant about lynching her.

 

[LetItSnow]

Lynch Hayley so we're not waiting until the last minute to pile up somewhere.

Meh. I am all in favor of leaning on people - we all know that - but this is PARTLY how we end up with the stupid "omg there are five minutes to go and we don't know who to lynch situations" when everyone piles up on someone, and then that person defends and everyone jumps to someone else, and they defend, etc.

At some point it's better just to decide who you think is scummy and go with it.

The pre-vet gang is too NICE. As soon as someone says "oh please don't lynch me I promise I'm not a wolf" everyone is all "oops! sorry! sorry! *unlynch unlynch unlynch*!"

 

[LetItSnow]

Can I Lynch the noob for suggesting some of those players as the most experienced and strategic?

I just about did it. For two reasons: First, the idea of "hey, let's lynch the experienced players" is so dumb that even a n00b should understand why that's a REALLY bad idea. Second .... the list itself was very .... odd. In the end, I chalked both up to n00bness and decided to let it go. Hard to learn when you get lynched Day 1. But the n00b is on my list for mid-game for sure if I'm still around.

I know it is only day 1, but I really do hate the randomly lynching people until they say something then moving on to someone else and repeat and repeat.

I'd rather see some thought even if it is completely off the rocker than the random BS

Agreed. It isn't effective if we just mob someone until they say "hey I'm not a wolf!" or force a role reveal.

Sorry, finn but

Lynch finn
You just stand out as having said the least of those who have posted in my quick read through.

Agreed. I really, really dislike the players who jump in, vote to lynch someone with no explanation, and bamf out again. That is incredibly not useful. If Finn has some posting restriction, Finn should work around it.

Caveat: Maybe Finn explained her vote and I just didn't see it.

But until hearing otherwise:

lynch finn