My WWittle Pony: Friendship is MMagic Game Thread

[bluestoat]

---

Members don't see this ad.

Did you play last game? Because I was village and went on and on about not yeeting LHF noobs AND despite that, ended up voting the noob wolf early on as a reaction test.

It just seems weird you got this wrong.

And your theory that you thought you would catch me if I was wolfing feels weak.

So you continue to focus very heavily on PSV today. Am I not worth the effort?

Despite that very defined tunnel and two-person POE, you don't seem to be wanting to vote for either of us.

I'm often a D1 wagon. It's become part of my play expectations. Shelty is an easy misyeet. It's something I get concerned about when she's getting wolfy pile-on. Why didn't you vote for either of us?

 

[bluestoat]

For the sake of argument, Cray/Alissa is another high compatibility pairing based on their in-thread interactions. I don't want to vote for Alissa yet, unless she's howling today. She's another easy misyeet and I don't want to sus out whether some of her posts are TWTBW or truly a wolf, this fiscal today.

 

[bluestoat]

Anyway. Based on my thoughts from yesterday:

I would look at: Cray +/- Trilt, PSV, or Alissa. REALLY wondering WHY a POE of Stoat and PSV turned into a vote on MJ.

Remember how last night, I asked Cray if she's holding her vote while waiting to see if a wagon builds on me? This really didn't help that perception. She switched to MJ at vote close and is right back to tunneling her stoat-PSV POE today. But I'm not IN any of that tunnel? It doesn't make sense. Imo it's another situation of the wolf believed too hard in the D1 stoat sus, stoat wiggled out into a wide village read, and the wolf is left empty-handed with a blatant effort to misyeet that didn't gain traction.


I felt almost okay about adding Santy to the POE, because I don't understand where the perfect Cray sus disappeared to. However, while I don't know his play style, I don't think he'd start such a big wagon on a packmate and then leave the wagon.

 

[bluestoat]

Is zenge firmly in everyone’s village reads or is there a cray/zenge possibility? Just throwing that out there because stoats posts tonight have me feeling a bit better about her.

I understand why you'd ask this because I made a note in my role PM that Zenge should be looked into (just for vote patterns etc) along with some other people.

But.

I feel so much apathy about a world with voting Zenge that I haven't looked into it yet. He doesn't seem wolfy to me. Obvs if he's around by N3 that's an astonishing lifespan for him, but I feel utterly demotivated by the idea of wolf!zenge right now.

I think efforts are better spent reviewing where Cray's attention went and the counter wagon participants last night.

I'm going to go back to work and practicing magic tricks for most of today.

 

[Zenge142]

and practicing magic tricks

Engaged

 

[SportPonies]

night 1

it is said that ponies gain a cutie mark when they come of age. This mark emphasizes their special skills, their calling in life, and everypony looks to their day with excitement and wonder.


Sometimes, this calling… doesn’t necessarily fit with somepony’s skillset. And so it is with Trixie. Despite much to be desired in outcome, her enthusiasm for illusion never faltered.

The street magician hung up her hat every night with no regrets. When the streets were eerily silent the next morning, others went to check on her and found her still in bed. Trixie had performed her last disappearing act.

Dead is @bluestoat - Trixie Lulamoon, Vanillager

The Roster:

1. @Animal Midwife
2. @Santygrass
3. @Crayola227
4. @potentialsheltervet
7. @WildZoo
8. @Zenge142
9. @Trilt
10. @alissa14

Dead:
6. @Mad Jack - Spitfire, Jailor
5. @bluestoat - Trixie, vanilla

 

[Santygrass]

Yeet Trilt

GOing to relook at stuff, I just woke up.

But @bluestoat you did really well and in Kinda after EoD managed to go from PoE to one of the most towny people , sorry for not finding you earlier!

Going to quote myself on the Cray stuff now.

 

[Santygrass]

Sad that now that I am in thread to do it Blue cant reply to me tho ;-;

 

[Zenge142]

Yeet Trilt

Why Trilt?

 

[Santygrass]

I wanted you to vote her , that way the wagons would be in two people I was interested in.

Also

Unyeet Cray

Also, rip I didnt stop them from.claiming, but the wagon formation on Cray makes me waver tbh.

Like, I dont feel there was a counterwagon to Cray all day? If they are wolf, their partner also let the wagon be and didnt care about pushing in other way?

Also that claim and approach lines up with the post about liking my mech talk from early D1 tbh

I have PSV, stoat, and MJ in my POE. Don't know the tally, not caught up, baby is awake now and maybe teething. So help me figure out where to go.

II

I just unvoted you @Crayola227 . And willing to move to either Stoat/MJ with you

Tbh Now I agree that Mj can be considered a wagon.

But like, if cray was mafia, their partner if its online or them should've like, tried to be more vocal about W!MJ or.stoat to try to derail it imo

Yeet Mad Jack

##### vote MJ ####

Cray was lead wagon most of the day. If they are mafia, tbeir partner didnt really tried to make a significant push in other direction.
Is that assuming a lot??

Like, yeah it was at two, but no one was townreading Cray and it was kinda obvious that thread consensus was Cray > Wolfy

With this is like... I think from the vocal people maybe Zenge/AM were the only ones that maybe poked a little at other slots? And even then I Vread them both and feel tha AM hasnt good equity with Cray even then.

Then Wz, psv, stoat, alissa , MJ feels unaligned to me too.

So for Cray to be a wolf their partner is Trilt? Or I am misclearing Zenge or an interaction?

But overall I feel that looking at the bigger picture probably Cray is just town

I think it adds up with some of their earlier post tbh

Basing it in the fact that I am Vreading both of them and that neither of them strongly pushed in other direction, Plus AM having some weird interactions with Cray to be W/W , I doubt it.

Its not like, Impossible? But unlikely enough to not yeet there today

Also I think it would be positive for me to reveal this info in case i get nightkilled .

Spoiler: Hardclaim

Skill Issue

 

[Santygrass]

Why Trilt?

I'm munching between Trilt and Wz in PoE , and stoat dying makes me think that they weren fully wrong, so one in psv/cray/trilt is a hit probably

 

[Santygrass]

Also I received something in the night . Not going to say more atm

 

[Santygrass]

I kinda want to make an exercise with vote movement and see how are people place in Cray Wolf scenarios and Cray Town scenarios.

But at the same time I should get out of my bed huh. Skill Issue

 

[Santygrass]

@Crayola227 want to know how are your readlist going or something.

 

[Santygrass]

Also how is your PoE rn Zenge?

 

[bluestoat]

*********
I'm feeling saucy today so... Go wolves! Get 'em!

(Also village you got dis *disappears in a puff of smoke*)
*********

 

[Trilt]

I'm munching between Trilt and Wz in PoE , and stoat dying makes me think that they weren fully wrong, so one in psv/cray/trilt is a hit probably

Stoat leaves a contingency vote on Cray, posts constantly about thinking Cray is wolfy, then dies and your conclusion is... Trilt is sketchy?

It's an interesting conclusion to make.

 

[Santygrass]

Yes indeed

 

[Trilt]

This flip is interesting lore-wise, as Trixie is a "minor" character who is originally a villian, but eventually becomes a fairly major good guy character. So we've got a jailer who was a pretty dang minor character, and an ostensibly much less minor character who is a plain ole vanillager. Continues to put a couple iffy marks on Cray's role claim.

 

[WildZoo]

Yeet cray

 

[WildZoo]

I'm munching between Trilt and Wz in PoE , and stoat dying makes me think that they weren fully wrong, so one in psv/cray/trilt is a hit probably

You can get addicted to a certain kind of sadness
Like resignation to the end
Always the end

 

[Santygrass]

Also, I did some reassesing on the claim stuff, and I got the point of why thinking of a 3p shen getting a seer could be wolf inidicative tbfh

 

[StartingoverVet]

*************

I am not a wolf. Just saying.

***************

 

[WildZoo]

*************

I am not a wolf. Just saying.

***************

Welcome back
Your dreams were your ticket out
Welcome back
To that same old place that you laughed about

 

[Santygrass]

@Trilt where is your head at rn?

 

[Santygrass]

Rn from Villageriest to scummiest I am kinda like this:

Santygrass
Zenge - psv

Alissa - AM

Wz - Cray

Trilt

But like... I doest feel *right* so probably going to try to do reassesing this day. Specially want to have a clearer take in Cray

 

[WildZoo]

Rn from Villageriest to scummiest I am kinda like this:

Santygrass
Zenge - psv

Alissa - AM

Wz - Cray

Trilt

But like... I doest feel *right* so probably going to try to do reassesing this day. Specially want to have a clearer take in Cray

I don't understand why I'm so low

 

[Santygrass]

I think its mostly that I see other people more villagery tbh. But def unpaired with Cray to me. Which is something that is giving me pause.
Im not really happy with how my reads are rn and can def see myself being bery wrong on someone

 

[Santygrass]

I think its mostly that I see other people more villagery tbh. But def unpaired with Cray to me. Which is something that is giving me pause.
Im not really happy with how my reads are rn and can def see myself being bery wrong on someone

I say this but at the same time the moment I try to maybe do some reassessing on psv/zenge my mind gets flooded with reasons to townread there and I slap myself in the face mentally to try to doubt that read wowee.

Note for cray: wowee is a dog emote from MU. Imagine a smiling dog when I say it

 

[Santygrass]

Wz , who do you think could be partners with Cray rn?

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Spoiler: Quote dump

Joke or not really a joke? This made me squint for trying to maybe cast weak shade.

Joke. For the 30th time.

Who is the baby sloth?

Also what happened to your reads? How did you start here and end up on MJ? How are you reading alissa?

Trilt is the baby sloth. Reading alissa neutral to slightly village. Went with MJ because I thought maybe Zenge was onto something and because Dubz's uncertainty on him made me wary.

Is no one else concerned this was an attempt at LHF? I get that site meta has changed as far as yeeting people new to our site early on, but I still have to wonder if it was a play at LHF.

Cray, Santy is a Champs finalist. LHF he ain't, by any stretch.

What do you think now with the flip?

That MJ isn't a wolf.

Interesting. Will have to see if you explain more.

I don't remember why I quoted this.

Did you play last game? Because I was village and went on and on about not yeeting LHF noobs AND despite that, ended up voting the noob wolf early on as a reaction test.

It just seems weird you got this wrong.

And your theory that you thought you would catch me if I was wolfing feels weak.

Cray. I RAN last game.

What's your POE now?

Currently you, debating potential partners.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Also @Crayola227 you're starting to sound like Lawpy with how much you're noting things.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

I think I need to go revisit what felt like a tunnel on me from Cray in 10th ann and compare it to here.
(Cray was a wolf in that game, for those who don't know.)

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Im not really happy with how my reads are rn and can def see myself being bery wrong on someone

skill issue?

 

[WildZoo]

Wz , who do you think could be partners with Cray rn?

I find it hard to tell you
I find it hard to take
When people run in circles it's a very, very
Mad world, mad world

 

[Truenamer]

I say this but at the same time the moment I try to maybe do some reassessing on psv/zenge my mind gets flooded with reasons to townread there and I slap myself in the face mentally to try to doubt that read wowee.

Note for cray: wowee is a dog emote from MU. Imagine a smiling dog when I say it

Note to self: petition for smiling dog emoji

 

[WildZoo]

I'd love to do a vote progression thingy but I don't have that kind of time. Just interested in how the MJ wagon formed and whatnot. Relative to a 36 hour day, it did happen fairly quickly. More informative if we knew Cray's aff of course.

I need somebody
(Help) not just anybody
(Help) you know I need someone, help

 

[alissa14]

Good morning. I have thoughts.

RIP stoats. I was definitely getting more village feels by the end of close and mostly took her out of my POE.

Seems like Dubz has a post restriction? Trying to decide in my head if this might have been a wolf acting on her or a villager.

I’m really not seeing all the trilt sus that everyone else seems to be seeing. But I will have to go back and re read the thread at some point. Probably later tonight. I did not sleep well last night….

Here are what my reads look like. Lots of shift from my reads yesterday.

Santy - (if santy flips wolf I would be shooketh to my core)
Zenge
AM
PSV - feeling much better about her and thought she addressed my questions well
Dubz - I’m getting paranoid. But feeling better here than trilt
Trilt - idk what everyone else is seeing but I can’t have a POE of 1 player so….
Cray - even reading her overnight posts do not make me feel any better

yeet cray

 

[Animal Midwife]

Yeet Cray

 

[Santygrass]

AM: Yeet Santy - Post 7
Santy: Yeet Crayola - Post 50
AM: Yeet Trilt - Post 98
Alissa: Yeet Zenge - Post 201
MJ: Yeet Wz, later unyeets - Post 334 / 337
WZ: Yeet Cray - Post 364
Psv: Yeet Santy - Post 368
Psv: Yeet Alissa - Post 436
AM: Yeet Stoat - Post 499
Zenge: Yeet MJ - Post 700
Bluestoat: Yeet Cray - Post 705
Alissa: Yeet Cray - Post 807
Mad Jack: Yeet Cray - Post 810
Trilt: Yeet MJ - Post 819
Psv: Yeet MJ - Post 839
Santy: Yeet MJ - Post 886
Cray: Yeet MJ - Post 888 or close enough
Alissa: Yeet MJ - Post 920


Let me know If I forgot about a vote somewhere (Probably I did)

 

[Animal Midwife]

Good morning. I have thoughts.

RIP stoats. I was definitely getting more village feels by the end of close and mostly took her out of my POE.

Seems like Dubz has a post restriction? Trying to decide in my head if this might have been a wolf acting on her or a villager.

I’m really not seeing all the trilt sus that everyone else seems to be seeing. But I will have to go back and re read the thread at some point. Probably later tonight. I did not sleep well last night….

Here are what my reads look like. Lots of shift from my reads yesterday.

Santy - (if santy flips wolf I would be shooketh to my core)
Zenge
AM
PSV - feeling much better about her and thought she addressed my questions well
Dubz - I’m getting paranoid. But feeling better here than trilt
Trilt - idk what everyone else is seeing but I can’t have a POE of 1 player so….
Cray - even reading her overnight posts do not make me feel any better

yeet cray

Can you walk me through your Trilt read?

 

[alissa14]

@WildZoo I know it’s kind of hard, but I’d love to see an updated reads list if possible

 

[alissa14]

Can you walk me through your Trilt read?

Yesterday I liked her entrance post and I’m not really seeing where everyone else is throwing sus at her. I have to ISO her at some point. But I only had Cray left in the pool of eels so some eels had to be thrown back in

 

[Santygrass]

Final Official Tally

Day 1: Friendship is Magic?

Crayola227 (3) - WildZoo, bluestoat, MadJack
Trilt (0) -
Zenge (0) -
alissa (0) -
bluestoat (1) - AM
MadJack (6) - Zenge, Trilt, PSV, Santygrass, Crayola, alissa
10/10

Missing: None, somehow

VOTE IS CLOSED

Voting at EoD. I think there was a Typo cuz MJ had 5 in the count, but there are 6 people there

 

[Animal Midwife]

Yesterday I liked her entrance post and I’m not really seeing where everyone else is throwing sus at her. I have to ISO her at some point. But I only had Cray left in the pool of eels so some eels had to be thrown back in

Why'd she get thrown in at the very bottom of your POE specifically (outside of Cray) over other candidates if you're not seeing it?

 

[Santygrass]

AM: Yeet Santy - Post 7
Santy: Yeet Crayola - Post 50
AM: Yeet Trilt - Post 98
Alissa: Yeet Zenge - Post 201
MJ: Yeet Wz, later unyeets - Post 334 / 337
WZ: Yeet Cray - Post 364
Psv: Yeet Santy - Post 368
Psv: Yeet Alissa - Post 436
AM: Yeet Stoat - Post 499
Zenge: Yeet MJ - Post 700
Bluestoat: Yeet Cray - Post 705
Alissa: Yeet Cray - Post 807
Mad Jack: Yeet Cray - Post 810
Trilt: Yeet MJ - Post 819
Psv: Yeet MJ - Post 839
Santy: Yeet MJ - Post 886
Cray: Yeet MJ - Post 888 or close enough
Alissa: Yeet MJ - Post 920


Let me know If I forgot about a vote somewhere (Probably I did)

*Fixed a Typo , in post 499 AM voted stoat, not Trilt.


Anyways

After MJ votes Cray, wagons were like this:

Cray (5) Santy, Wz , Stoat, alissa , Bluestoat
Bluestoat (1) AM
MJ (1) Zenge


Then, Trilt and psv form MJ as a viable counterwagon. I think thats prolly important if Cray flips Wolf tbh.
Then me and Cray vote MJ together and seal the deal kindof.

I think alissa timing of votes is clearing for them if Cray is a wolf. Prolly for AM too since they never switched to MJ

 

[Santygrass]

Unpairing with Cray that I have:

Alissa : Timing of votes, the weird interaction regarding first post that Zenge also mentioned is a good look
AM: Sassy interactions between the two that looks unpartnered , the talk about 3ps and AM sussing the claim and stuff . Also AM never voted MJ to try to save Cray when the wagon gained momentum
WZ: Early vote im Cray clearing, and maintaining the sus .

Psv: This maybe the least strong one, but the focus that Cray has done in psv should be a good look. But the vote on MJ could be to help Cray so w/e

 

[Santygrass]

So I'm back at:
If Cray is a wolf, their partner is like prolly Trilt, with tinfoil in psv>Zenge , which are the slots Im more comfy with V reads tbh

 

[Santygrass]

Stoat leaves a contingency vote on Cray, posts constantly about thinking Cray is wolfy, then dies and your conclusion is... Trilt is sketchy?

It's an interesting conclusion to make.

This flip is interesting lore-wise, as Trixie is a "minor" character who is originally a villian, but eventually becomes a fairly major good guy character. So we've got a jailer who was a pretty dang minor character, and an ostensibly much less minor character who is a plain ole vanillager. Continues to put a couple iffy marks on Cray's role claim.

Also, other than throwing shade on me and Cray at SoD , Trilt post at SoD arent very focused on solving or trying to move things IMO. I see them as rand > W.
Not knowing how are their reads rn is pinging me tbh

 

[Santygrass]

Also, I think it could help me clear them if the person who sent me the thingy in the night just let me know it wss them. I dont plan on revealing what it was cuz that would be dumb, but I think it prolly always comes from town so yeh