Official Doctor Who WW Redux Game Thread

Veterinary Science Graduate Programs from U. of I.
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Members do not see this ad.
StartingoverVet said:
I don't think lynching the seer on total speculation is such a brilliant idea this early. There are still a lot of people left to throw darts at before we do that.

lynch swings.

cause when I don't have any ideas, might as well lynch those lynching me.
Click to expand...

We've pretty much arrived at the conclusion that WS' role wouldn't be helpful to us any longer, anyway, as she can only get role name and the remaining wolf/wolves are likely converts (aside from Cuit) whose new status wouldn't be provided.
 
eh, lynch FS. I don't really buy the people not having role abilities. Not feeling the other lynches now.
 
that redhead said:
We've pretty much arrived at the conclusion that WS' role wouldn't be helpful to us any longer, anyway, as she can only get role name and the remaining wolf/wolves are likely converts (aside from Cuit) whose new status wouldn't be provided.
Click to expand...
I see. Well in that case why would the wolves convert her. They would know if they only had converts left.... wouldn't they? Or are we assuming they didn't know her limitation (not sure if they are as clueless as I am)
 
Information on WS' role only came out in the thread today, when we were talking about FS a page or two back. She said she could only tell role title and said herself that she didn't think it would be useful anymore.
 
StartingoverVet said:
I don't think lynching the seer on total speculation is such a brilliant idea this early. There are still a lot of people left to throw darts at before we do that.

lynch swings.

cause when I don't have any ideas, might as well lynch those lynching me.
Click to expand...

I am A seer. Pretty sure that was obvious after yesterday.
 
that redhead said:
Information on WS' role only came out in the thread today, when we were talking about FS a page or two back. She said she could only tell role title and said herself that she didn't think it would be useful anymore.
Click to expand...

If you guys didn't catch on that I was a seer when I was standing up for WTF, then you all are thicker than I thought. :laugh:
 
wolfspeaker said:
If you guys didn't catch on that I was a seer when I was standing up for WTF, then you all are thicker than I thought. :laugh:
Click to expand...

Catching on that you have seeing ability is different than knowing finer details about how your ability works. I imagine if those details had been available sooner, you would have a better case against being a good conversion target.
 
I had the sonic screwdriver two nights ago which is when I found out FFM was human.
 
Just to get my vote in, I hafta agree with FFM. Seems unlikely that people don't have any abilities (whether they're menial or powerful). My ability isn't game changing at all, and yet I still have one so why wouldn't they?

Lynch FS

That being said, I'm just getting a vote in. I will easily waffle if something concrete on a person is posted before the deadline.
 
wolfspeaker said:
The only one that SHOULD answer that is @Frozenshades as we know Cuit is a wolf.
Click to expand...

Nope, I have had no discussions with SOV.

I'll stand by what I said because it's the truth. I have no abilities, just one annoyance of a requirement in all my posts.

As for who to lynch, well I feel clueless. It's rather unfortunate. For now I'll go with lynch FFM
 
lynch FS, cybermen had to be in the game before lupin. I know WS, WTF, FFM, SOV, and alors are humans. I believe TRH. Info about dyachei was passed onto me and I believe FF and her role claim. We know cuit is bad news bears but can't do anything about it yet. That leaves me with allie, samoa, swings, cyndia, and FS.
 
I'm not defending FS but I don't have any role abilities either. So if that's the only basis for your lynch, maybe you should rethink it.
 
I'm back!

I don't have investigative abilities, so my thoughts on people are based on what others have been saying and personal interactions.
My current list of people I strongly trust from actions in game/pms with me are: TRH, WTF, Swings, and Alors (I think cuits actions make that pretty clear, would have made absolutely no sense to throw up two wolves for lynch without knowing what the mods would do in that situation).

I'm also pretty sure I trust Allie (wasn't she cleared as human just before the PM vote? and she caused Lupins death with the tiebreak), FFM (if hedgie is telling the truth about the screwdriver), and possibly dyachei from her lynches/actions in the game.

I have no idea on FF, FS, Samoa, or SOV. My vote for WS is currently up as I contingency voted for whomever TRH voted for.. I'm going to keep it for now, though it does concern me that lupin must have been the latest convert (unless one happened yesterday), and while I think WS would make an excellent conversion target as a seer, I doubt she was the first convert. But I need to think more and reread the thread through again.

Btw - did I miss anything important that got deleted??
 
Okay I have to go do family stuff for a bit, haven't done a proper close reading of the thread but for now I am going to unlynch WS and lynch FS. I have actually been a bit suspicious of FS for a little while (due to not much posting and her voting history), and I also think it's a bit strange she (or are you a he? sorry haha), soniced Alors last night when I think it was fairly clear from what happened with cuit that alors was telling the truth about her role.
 
I'm not a cyberman/convert. I'm still a villager.

I'm Charles Dickens. I have the ability to do 3 write-ups over the course of the game and the mods have verified my existence by signing my name after each of my write-ups. I've used 2/3 (Dwin and jdh).

If it's true that cybermen don't have abilities, then having me write the next lynch write-up is solid proof that my claims are true and that I'm a villager.
 
hedgiehog said:
lynch FS, cybermen had to be in the game before lupin. I know WS, WTF, FFM, SOV, and alors are humans. I believe TRH. Info about dyachei was passed onto me and I believe FF and her role claim. We know cuit is bad news bears but can't do anything about it yet. That leaves me with allie, samoa, swings, cyndia, and FS.
Click to expand...

Allie, swings and FS are not originals FOR CERTAIN. (they've been seered/confirmed)
 
FantasyFlyer said:
I'm not a cyberman/convert. I'm still a villager.

I'm Charles Dickens. I have the ability to do 3 write-ups over the course of the game and the mods have verified my existence by signing my name after each of my write-ups. I've used 2/3 (Dwin and jdh).

If it's true that cybermen don't have abilities, then having me write the next lynch write-up is solid proof that my claims are true and that I'm a villager.
Click to expand...
sounds good to me
 
FantasyFlyer said:
I'm not a cyberman/convert. I'm still a villager.

I'm Charles Dickens. I have the ability to do 3 write-ups over the course of the game and the mods have verified my existence by signing my name after each of my write-ups. I've used 2/3 (Dwin and jdh).

If it's true that cybermen don't have abilities, then having me write the next lynch write-up is solid proof that my claims are true and that I'm a villager.
Click to expand...


WTF, Dyachei, TRH(can't remember who said it) are you certain that cybermen do not retain their role abilities? If this is true, then both FF and Hedgie can prove their innocence overnight.
 
wolfspeaker said:
WTF, Dyachei, TRH(can't remember who said it) are you certain that cybermen do not retain their role abilities? If this is true, then both FF and Hedgie can prove their innocence overnight.
Click to expand...
WTF said it and got it from the mods, if I remember correctly
 
Ok, we are looking for a convert from before Lupin was converted. And converts are believed to be cybermen who would turn out not human and have no abilities. Correct? Does anybody have anything to add to this list that could help narrow down.

7. @hedgiehog - can prove ability overnight
8. @FantasyFlyer - can prove ability overnight
10. @Samoa

Present Day
13. @Flim Flam Man - hedgie sonic'd N8? Human
17. @allieh8607
1. @dyachei
12. @WhtsThFrequency - ability was seered N7
6. @wolfspeaker
25. @that redhead

Sometime in the Future
16. @Cyndia
19. @swingnsave
20. @AlorsOnDanse - sonic'd N9 Human

The End of the Universe
21. @Frozenshades
23. @cuitlamiztli - WOLF
5b. @StartingoverVet
 
dyachei said:
Somebody seered me, too, WS. Wasn't it you? And I've been tracking items still
Click to expand...

Yes, i did but I only get role names. So, I did not include any of my seering, as it is completely useless for looking for converts. (see as cybermen retain thier original role names)
 
@hedgiehog you will need to prove you can still use your ability tonight. Send something to me, WTF, alors or FFM. Or all of us, if you are allowed to do more than 1 a night.
 
that redhead said:
Okay, unlynch FF[/b] if you can prove you still have your ability tonight.

@wolfspeaker, considering I gave crucial information leading to Lupin's lynch last round, I'd consider myself clear.
Click to expand...


I agree(said it multiple times already) but that list is only for confirmed.
 
Of those remaining, perhaps whoever has the screw driver tonight should use it on someone that should be human such as Samoa, allieh, WS, Swings, SOV. Assuming dyachei is still the role she started with at the beginning of the game.
 
that redhead said:
Of those remaining, perhaps whoever has the screw driver tonight should use it on someone that should be human such as Samoa, allieh, WS, Swings, SOV. Assuming dyachei is still the role she started with at the beginning of the game.
Click to expand...
I can still track items. And I will be happy to prove it
 
that redhead said:
Of those remaining, perhaps whoever has the screw driver tonight should use it on someone that should be human such as Samoa, allieh, WS, Swings, SOV. Assuming dyachei is still the role she started with at the beginning of the game.
Click to expand...

We need sonic results from N4-7. I may have time to go back later tonight to look for them, but not right now.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
Supernatural: Angels & Demons WW Game Thread
121 122 123 124 125
Replies
6K
Views
81K
GoSpursGo
GoSpursGo
WildZoo
Halloween Horrors WW Game Sign Ups [OPEN]
Replies
34
Views
373
GoSpursGo
GoSpursGo
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
66K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
SDN Fairgrounds - 10th Annual Noob WW Game
86 87 88 89 90
Replies
4K
Views
56K
katiemcat
katiemcat
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
48K
chicandtoughness
chicandtoughness
Top