Official Holiday WW Game Thread

[LetItSnow]

---

Members do not see this ad.

Really? I have explained this multiple times. Even the post you quoted explains it. Even SOV was able to deduce what strategy I was referring to. At this time, I am done discussing it. I have nothing else to add to it and it is time to move on.

Lots of hand-waving, yelling, and personal attacks seems to be Jdh's approach. I noticed earlier in the game where I disagreed - and clearly stated why - his response was similar; to yell at me for not explaining my reasoning even though my argument was right there in the same post to which he responded. *shrug*

 

[zanydogz]

Devyn: can we trust your source of info 100%?

 

[LetItSnow]

Haha

Looks like I was right.

What was it you were saying again??

I might shoot a bullseye with both eyes closed from 50 yards with a handgun. That doesn't mean shooting with your eyes closed is a smart approach.

... at least you and DVMD share one similarity!

 

[orcagirl]

Pre-vet. Where no- one reads the whole thread. My pleas fall on the deaf ears of those who scan just enough to see possible investigative results and go with it and the arguing of others over strategy.

I'll tell you I heard you, but I've been jipped in the past by changing just because someone says they are on the villager's side. Also we know who to look at next if you are just a villager.

 

[StartingoverVet]

Hey LIS, you getting jealous?

It seems like JDH has replaced you as the object of affection disagreement in DVMD's eye.

She has replaced you with a new model.

 

[fromthebox]

Dude. We know you're durty.

(And not in the way I like)

How do you know you wouldn't like it?

And I'm telling you, I am not this Hinkle guy.

 

[DVMDream]

Lots of hand-waving, yelling, and personal attacks seems to be Jdh's approach. I noticed earlier in the game where I disagreed - and clearly stated why - his response was similar; to yell at me for not explaining my reasoning even though my argument was right there in the same post to which he responded. *shrug*

You. just. agreed. with. me. again.

What is this world coming to?

 

[LetItSnow]

Pre-vet. Where no- one reads the whole thread. My pleas fall on the deaf ears of those who scan just enough to see possible investigative results and go with it and the arguing of others over strategy.

Eh? I think we've all read your denials, but c'mon. Investigative results versus you claiming you've been set up? The latter is obviously possible (hey, I've implemented that as a mod, too), but the likelihood that you're lying is far higher.

 

[LetItSnow]

You. just. agreed. with. me. again.

What is this world coming to?

Don't worry. I threw a barb your way in another post just to make sure the earth didn't fall off its axis.

 

[fromthebox]

Eh? I think we've all read your denials, but c'mon. Investigative results versus you claiming you've been set up? The latter is obviously possible (hey, I've implemented that as a mod, too), but the likelihood that you're lying is far higher.

I think you've read my protests. I don't think others did.

 

[zanydogz]

You. just. agreed. with. me. again.

What is this world coming to?

 

[jdh71]

Lots of hand-waving, yelling, and personal attacks seems to be Jdh's approach. I noticed earlier in the game where I disagreed - and clearly stated why - his response was similar; to yell at me for not explaining my reasoning even though my argument was right there in the same post to which he responded. *shrug*

Oh bull****. No one has actually given a solid reason why my original strategy is a bad idea. Yes I will mock you if all you can come up with is: I disagree, won't tell you specifically why - if there was this one game this one time and my anecdote over-rules the game theory.

Ok genius. If you all say so. 👍

DVM has given no real reasons for get protests.

*shrug*

Your approach seems to be one if passive aggression now??

 

[LetItSnow]

Hey LIS, you getting jealous?

It seems like JDH has replaced you as the object of affection disagreement in DVMD's eye.

She has replaced you with a new model.

Nah. She's too young for me to keep up with anyway. 🙂

I wish Jdh the best of luck.... 🙂

 

[jdh71]

I might shoot a bullseye with both eyes closed from 50 yards with a handgun. That doesn't mean shooting with your eyes closed is a smart approach.

... at least you and DVMD share one similarity!

Your bull**** example was nothing like what happened here. I didn't blindly point and shoot asshat. I have my reasons and it turns out those reasons were correct. It's nothing like your intellectually dishonest analogy.

Try again.

There was no shooting with eyes closed.

 

[zanydogz]

I think you've read my protests. I don't think others did.

There are other people on here who have read your protests but chose to not respond to them. And honestly, what can I say? I going with the investigative results over your comments and like orcagirl said, if we're wrong, then we know who to lynch next.

 

[jdh71]

How do you know you wouldn't like it?

And I'm telling you, I am not this Hinkle guy.

We shall see.

(I probably would like it)

 

[fromthebox]

There are other people on here who have read your protests but chose to not respond to them. And honestly, what can I say? I going with the investigative results over your comments and like orcagirl said, if we're wrong, then we know who to lynch next.

Oh you do? Please elaborate. Because I'm not saying lynch devyn. I'm saying something foiled her investigation.

 

[DVMDream]

I think you've read my protests. I don't think others did.

I read your protest but I know that you are able to talk your way out of lynches really well. I think you are screwed... if you do end up being a villager then devyn will have some explaining to do, we will have to figure out this krampus thing, and on a smaller scale I can tell jdh to feck off.

 

[jdh71]

I read your protest but I know that you are able to talk your way out of lynches really well. I think you are screwed... if you do end up being a villager then devyn will have some explaining to do, we will have to figure out this krampus thing, and on a smaller scale I can tell jdh to feck off.

You started it.

 

[fromthebox]

You started it.

Hers is bigger. Stop measuring 😛 it's about how you use it anyway.

 

[DVMDream]

You started it.

🙄

 

[Packen]

Oh you do? Please elaborate. Because I'm not saying lynch devyn. I'm saying something foiled her investigation.

If it was a set up, why would it be so specific a character? Wouldn't it just say something like "you were naughty"?

SOV, devyn's been talking to you- do you feel this evidence is accurate?

 

[jdh71]

Hers is bigger. Stop measuring 😛 it's about how you use it anyway.

Based on what metric?!

 

[jdh71]

🙄

You did.

You know it.

 

[fromthebox]

Based on what metric?!

Volume of posts for now. I didn't have the gumption to *actually* measure over the summer.

 

[wolfspeaker]

Oh bull****. No one has actually given a solid reason why my original strategy is a bad idea. Yes I will mock you if all you can come up with is: I disagree, won't tell you specifically why - if there was this one game this one time and my anecdote over-rules the game theory.

Ok genius. If you all say so. 👍

DVM has given no real reasons for get protests.

*shrug*

Your approach seems to be one if passive aggression now??

Perhaps your 'strategy idea' looks good on paper, but it's obviously(here in pre-vet) not worked out in actual game play. It has been stated already, multiple times in the thread, that strategy has pretty much been used in many games in the past and nearly all of those games ended in wolf victory. Evidence shows us that it hasn't worked.

Now, can we please let all this bickering back and forth stop? Let's just all agree to disagree and let it be. Not everyone will agree with a strategy, be it a good one or not.

 

[dyachei]

Perhaps your 'strategy idea' looks good on paper, but it's obviously(here in pre-vet) not worked out in actual game play. It has been stated already, multiple times in the thread, that strategy has pretty much been used in many games in the past and nearly all of those games ended in wolf victory. Evidence shows us that it hasn't worked.

Now, can we please let all this bickering back and forth stop? Let's just all agree to disagree and let it be. Not everyone will agree with a strategy, be it a good one or not.

hey remember that time you told me logic had no place in ww and the person I had pegged using logic was the last wolf, but they won?

Yeah, that.

 

[dyachei]

lynch over, results pending

 

[dyachei]

The mob is done with their sipping cider and hot chocolate. They are out for the kill. They are reeling from the death of their favorite reindeer. When they finally find FTB, she puts up her hands and says that it isn't her. She was visited by the krampus.

They boil her in a vat of hot cocoa (with appropriately sized marshmallows of course) and leave her as an offering to the Grither (look it up if you don't know).

You have killed FTB, Professor Hinkle.

Whoville:
1. lissarae - villager
2. swingnsave
3. wldlfstdnt
4. The LIS
5. Foxhunter

North Pole:
1. zany
2. DVMD
3. orcagirl
4. tropictuco
5. Krist - villager

Island of Misfit Toys:
1. kakuru - villager
2. wolfspeaker
3. equineconstant - villager
4. T4C
5. EngrSC

Polar Express:
1. jdh
2. FFM - Rudolph
3. FTB - professor hinkle
4. devyn
5. SOV

London - Muppet Version:
1. Philliab
2. nohika
3. kaydubs
4. SnS
5.hedgie
6.Packen

 

[StartingoverVet]

You have killed FTB, Professor Hinkle.Boba Fett

ftfy

 

[fromthebox]

 

[StartingoverVet]

Perhaps your 'strategy idea' looks good on paper, but it's obviously(here in pre-vet) not worked out in actual game play. It has been stated already, multiple times in the thread, that strategy has pretty much been used in many games in the past and nearly all of those games ended in wolf victory. Evidence shows us that it hasn't worked.

.

WTF?

lynch WS

night or day, I don't care. We don't need villagers who think that.

 

[fromthebox]

*****
Sorry y'all, no hard feels, m'kay?

Go wolves!
******

 

[StartingoverVet]

SOV, devyn's been talking to you- do you feel this evidence is accurate?

Sorry. Seems like that is answered now😀

 

[wolfspeaker]

hey remember that time you told me logic had no place in ww and the person I had pegged using logic was the last wolf, but they won?

Yeah, that.

When did I ever say that logic had no place in WW? (if it was Tortall, that doesn't count )Everyone always says that I have faulty logic. Why would I say that logic has no place and then try to be all logical? 😕

 

[Lissarae06]

*****
Sorry y'all, no hard feels, m'kay?

Go wolves!
******

*************
Oh there are definitely hard feels 😛 Glad you got caught wolfie!
*************

 

[tropictuco]

Yaaaay first wolf!! Sure happened a lot sooner than in the last game!

Ok am I the only seminoob here who has trouble distinguishing between FFM and FTB? I mean it's really hard to keep track of two players that have 3-letter acronyms that start with F. At least now it's easier. There's the WOLF F-player and the VILLAGER F-player.

 

[wolfspeaker]

WTF?

lynch WS

night or day, I don't care. We don't need villagers who think that.

Really, SOV? I wasn't the one who said it. 😉 It was already stated in thread. (I wouldn't have noticed those statistics, since I obviously wouldn't have been the one playing at the end of those games 😛)

 

[wolfspeaker]

Yaaaay first wolf!! Sure happened a lot sooner than in the last game!

Ok am I the only seminoob here who has trouble distinguishing between FFM and FTB? I mean it's really hard to keep track of two players that have 3-letter acronyms that start with F. At least now it's easier. There's the WOLF F-player and the VILLAGER F-player.

Just be glad that dvmdreamer isn't playing, also.

 

[dyachei]

When did I ever say that logic had no place in WW? (if it was Tortall, that doesn't count )Everyone always says that I have faulty logic. Why would I say that logic has no place and then try to be all logical? 😕

hahaha, I mixed you up with Nohika. My bad.

Logic doesn't have much of a place in WW games, though. It's quite possible that wld skated through without being investigated.

We'll see, I guess. I think it's past the lynch deadline.

 

[Packen]

Seriously, as of this moment, I am never listening to any of ftb pleas of innocence again!! You actually had me feeling bad for you!

 

[zanydogz]

Take that wolfie!!!!

 

[tropictuco]

Just be glad that dvmdreamer isn't playing, also.

That would be soooo confusing...

 

[LetItSnow]

*************
Oh there are definitely hard feels
*************

Kinky!

 

[shortnsweet]

Definitely just skated home from the library. That was mildly terrifying.

But YAY for getting a wolf! Way to go Dev! 🙂

 

[orcagirl]

Yaaaay first wolf!! Sure happened a lot sooner than in the last game!

Ok am I the only seminoob here who has trouble distinguishing between FFM and FTB? I mean it's really hard to keep track of two players that have 3-letter acronyms that start with F. At least now it's easier. There's the WOLF F-player and the VILLAGER F-player.

It was way confusing when orca2011 and I were playing in a game together. You can ask SOV about that. 😛

Oh and we got a wolf!!

 

[wldlfstdnt]

Yay! We got a wolf!

 

[swingnsave]

Missed ANOTHER lynch vote. Sorryyy I really need to get on WW schedule. But yay for getting a wolf! 😀 looks like you guys didn't need my vote anyway 😛

 

[jdh71]

Volume of posts for now. I didn't have the gumption to *actually* measure over the summer.

 

[devyn]

take that wolfie!

sorry I disappeared.... try to take breaks from SDN for my eyes.....not even close to 100% here yet... blurry vision FTW