Pangaea WW - GAME THREAD

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Blockers are always suspicious imo (unless it's me 😎 ). Just throwing it out there.

I blocked you. I find you posting plants odd so whatevs. I'm randomly blocking people. But not anyone I know has an important role.

I'm not a wolf. Thankfully cause I don't have the time to be one. But feel free to lynch or kill me. Lol.
 
posting again because my post count is at triple 6 and I'm superstitious
 
I blocked you. I find you posting plants odd so whatevs. I'm randomly blocking people. But not anyone I know has an important role.

I'm not a wolf. Thankfully cause I don't have the time to be one. But feel free to lynch or kill me. Lol.

Fair enough. Chillbo is the one posting plants though. Your mistake is excused. Too much sun probably. 😉

no-drinks.gif
 
Also, btw, FS can only post in gifs today, so he can't defend himself. He says he is a Monkey Puzzle Tree.
 
So I'm at a tossup between FS and Chillbo, I think one of them has to be a wolf with such similar restrictions. Also I always end up forgetting about the players that only post in gifs, which really comes back to haunt the villagers sometimes. Anyways, since FS has revealed, I'm going to go with lynch Chillbo for now.
 
Official Poll Count:
Gwen (0) -
VetAsh (1) - dyachei
Chillbo (3) - VetAsh, FS, Cyndia
FS (5) - STL, 98cats, rojo, Chillbo, DVMD
Swings (1) - WZ
Cyndia (1) - SnS
WZ (1)- devyn
SnS (1) - swings
STL (2) - FFM, Lissa

15/18 votes cast
Wafflemeter- 4

Feelings are being had/unhad/not at all had!
funniest-animal-gifs-scared-baby-giraffe.gif

Deadline 7:00PM EST
 
Trying to work out this Chillbo vs FS thing. Their posting restrictions didn't start out similar - Chillbo could only post in gifs, FS could only post at night (but could post in words). Now FS can post in gifs during the day, too. I'm not sure I buy that them both having posting restrictions makes either of them wolfy...
 
eh, unlynch FS, lynch lissa

still suspicious of her, and the monkey puzzle tree doesn't seem to have any negative or poisonous ability to it... and I'm about to go to dinner so I might not make a change in deadline

FFM, do you know what kind of plant Chillbo is?
 
eh, unlynch FS, lynch lissa

still suspicious of her, and the monkey puzzle tree doesn't seem to have any negative or poisonous ability to it... and I'm about to go to dinner so I might not make a change in deadline

FFM, do you know what kind of plant Chillbo is?

Chillbo says he is a fungus.
 
Official Poll Count:
Gwen (0)
Swings (0)
VetAsh (1) - dyachei
Chillbo (3) - VetAsh, FS, Cyndia
FS (4) - STL, 98cats, Chillbo, DVMD
Cyndia (1) - SnS
WZ (1)- devyn
SnS (1) - swings
STL (2) - FFM, Lissa
Lissa (1) - rojo

14/18 votes cast
Wafflemeter- 6

Feelings are being had/unhad/not at all had!
funniest-animal-gifs-scared-baby-giraffe.gif

Deadline 7:00PM EST
 
Trying to work out this Chillbo vs FS thing. Their posting restrictions didn't start out similar - Chillbo could only post in gifs, FS could only post at night (but could post in words). Now FS can post in gifs during the day, too. I'm not sure I buy that them both having posting restrictions makes either of them wolfy...

I think I know why FS is posting during the day now.... I had the flask item last night and sent it to him, so that might be why. But this is just a guess.

I did not know he could post at night, but now that I know this, I find it very odd he has not posted anything at all in this game thread then up until today. Why not say something on thread about the posting restriction? Why not say something about the game or game strategy? He has said nothing at all, all game up until today.
 
Anyone have any feelings on SnS?

I asked yesterday about who I should seer. (This was before the abrupt winter storm). Romo (he was part of my group), messaged me saying that I should seer SnS because "she has been really quiet lately". I found that odd, because a lot of people have been really quiet this game and SnS has been quiet all game, not just lately. I told him that is normal for her. His response was, "Oh, I don't think I have played any games with SnS, so I don't know what is normal for her". I just find it very odd that out of everyone this game that has been quiet, he targeted SnS. What really makes the statement odd from him though was the "lately", she wasn't any more talkative at the beginning of the game than she was at that point. Maybe he was trying to deflect away to a non-wolf? I don't know, the whole convo was a bit strange. I could just be reading into it too much.

Still thinking on a lynch, but wanted to see if anyone had any opinions on that.

I don't think I have been more quiet than usual? I've been trying to post a couple times a day. It's just hard because this is my last trip home before grad and moving, so i'm trying to fit a lot in.

Plus, I voted for Romo early in the past two lynches. Maybe he confused me with Swings?

I love plants, if that helps you. Feel free to seer me though...i'll just be crunching on some leaves.

Flying back to Glasgow tonight btw, don't know when I can check in again. I'll be sending a contingency before I leave, just in case.
 
Also, I don't think we are going to be able to determine much about wolf/villager status from revealing character names.

We are all prehistoric creatures/plants (except rojo), so it is impossible to determine who is a wolf or not just by a name reveal.
 
I don't think I have been more quiet than usual? I've been trying to post a couple times a day. It's just hard because this is my last trip home before grad and moving, so i'm trying to fit a lot in.

Plus, I voted for Romo early in the past two lynches. Maybe he confused me with Swings?

I love plants, if that helps you. Feel free to seer me though...i'll just be crunching on some leaves.

Flying back to Glasgow tonight btw, don't know when I can check in again. I'll be sending a contingency before I leave, just in case.

I asked him to clarify SnS... he said shortnsweet.

I don't think you have been more quiet than usual, I just found it odd he picked you out of everyone that is on the quieter side, especially when he has not really played with you before... it was odd, but I am guessing he was trying to deflect away from himself to get out of seering.
 
Also, I don't think we are going to be able to determine much about wolf/villager status from revealing character names.

We are all prehistoric creatures/plants (except rojo), so it is impossible to determine who is a wolf or not just by a name reveal.
Both of the wolves have been kinda bad ass creatures.

Fungus has me intrigued...
 
Also, I don't think we are going to be able to determine much about wolf/villager status from revealing character names.

We are all prehistoric creatures/plants (except rojo), so it is impossible to determine who is a wolf or not just by a name reveal.

I dunno. Big *** scorpion and megapiranha seem pretty clear cut to me.
 
I asked him to clarify SnS... he said shortnsweet.

I don't think you have been more quiet than usual, I just found it odd he picked you out of everyone that is on the quieter side, especially when he has not really played with you before... it was odd, but I am guessing he was trying to deflect away from himself to get out of seering.
Or throw another wolf under the bus to gain credibility
 
Also, I don't think we are going to be able to determine much about wolf/villager status from revealing character names.

We are all prehistoric creatures/plants (except rojo), so it is impossible to determine who is a wolf or not just by a name reveal.
Giant scorpion and megapiranha thing are more wolfy than a plant though.

FS says his posting habits were for no good reason other than his enjoyment of causing confusion, and that he's usually pretty quiet in games anyway. He told me specifically about his restriction very early, and told our whole group pretty soon after that.
 
Giant scorpion and megapiranha thing are more wolfy than a plant though.

FS says his posting habits were for no good reason other than his enjoyment of causing confusion, and that he's usually pretty quiet in games anyway. He told me specifically about his restriction very early, and told our whole group pretty soon after that.
So I guess you is a plant too...

I mean, romeo was in the pm group with dvmd, aka both aquatic animals, so there very well could be a wolf plant mixed in too
 
I asked him to clarify SnS... he said shortnsweet.

I don't think you have been more quiet than usual, I just found it odd he picked you out of everyone that is on the quieter side, especially when he has not really played with you before... it was odd, but I am guessing he was trying to deflect away from himself to get out of seering.

Noobs :shrug:
 
I dunno. Big *** scorpion and megapiranha seem pretty clear cut to me.

Yeah and Escalla was this thing:

1909709-gorgonopsid.jpg


And yet she was a villager....

So, I don't think we are going to be able to determine anything based only on character name.

Also, I am guessing there is a group out there that are all plants, I have some doubts that everyone in that group is just excluded of wolfdom... maybe they are, but I have doubts.
 
Yup, I'm a plant (or Flora more accurately). Definitely not saying there isn't a wolf in our group...there very well might be.
Out of the two I'd be more inclined to think a fungus was dangerous than a...monkey tree? FS has also been more forthcoming with specific role info than Chillbo, unless Chillbo has told someone in our group individually.
 
Or throw another wolf under the bus to gain credibility

I was never quite clear on his ability since he lied about it, but if he stretched the truth only slightly (he said something about seer avoidance, and being able to pass on his ability certain nights?), maybe he was trying to get SnS seered the same night he could make her unseerable? I remember trying to pull the same thing off in the thomas covenant game.

But yeah. Pure conjecture for the most part since who knows what his ability actually was, but might be worthwhile to seer SnS.
 
Giant scorpion and megapiranha thing are more wolfy than a plant though.

FS says his posting habits were for no good reason other than his enjoyment of causing confusion, and that he's usually pretty quiet in games anyway. He told me specifically about his restriction very early, and told our whole group pretty soon after that.

This makes me want to lynch him more... there is no good reason to cause/create confusion unless you are wolf or chaos.
 
Yup, I'm a plant (or Flora more accurately). Definitely not saying there isn't a wolf in our group...there very well might be.
Out of the two I'd be more inclined to think a fungus was dangerous than a...monkey tree? FS has also been more forthcoming with specific role info than Chillbo, unless Chillbo has told someone in our group individually.

I agree that I find a fungus more dangerous.. And while I find FS's posting strategy strange, if he was at least forthcoming about it, that's a bit better. Btw WZ, thanks for clarifying that they weren't completely similar restrictions, definitely skimmed the first part of the game while I was traveling and had thought they were nearly identical.
 
This makes me want to lynch him more... there is no good reason to cause/create confusion unless you are wolf or chaos.
I know if it were me I would be posting like crazy at night, but that's how I play anyway. Maybe he just wanted to see how long it would be before someone noticed that he wasn't posting at all? :shrug:
 
Yup, I'm a plant (or Flora more accurately). Definitely not saying there isn't a wolf in our group...there very well might be.
Out of the two I'd be more inclined to think a fungus was dangerous than a...monkey tree? FS has also been more forthcoming with specific role info than Chillbo, unless Chillbo has told someone in our group individually.
Correction, Chillbo told us more about his role right as I was posting this
 
I know if it were me I would be posting like crazy at night, but that's how I play anyway. Maybe he just wanted to see how long it would be before someone noticed that he wasn't posting at all? :shrug:

Possibly....

I don't know, call me crazy but I have doubts that 2 plant roles with posting restrictions that while not completely the same are similar in a way are both going to be villagers. Seems like a lot of posting restriction to place onto the group of villagers, IMO. (If you also include in STL's posting restriction). Wolves have won before by villagers ignoring the player with an odd posting restriction, just assuming that there could not be anyway the mods would make a wolf not allowed to post/post only at certain times.
 
Possibly....

I don't know, call me crazy but I have doubts that 2 plant roles with posting restrictions that while not completely the same are similar in a way are both going to be villagers. Seems like a lot of posting restriction to place onto the group of villagers, IMO. (If you also include in STL's posting restriction). Wolves have won before by villagers ignoring the player with an odd posting restriction, just assuming that there could not be anyway the mods would make a wolf not allowed to post/post only at certain times.
It's a valid point, I just don't know which of the two (or the three if you include STL) is more likely to be a wolf. Does anybody know their voting history?
 
I am also not sure who to vote for though, because I have a good feeling that someone with a plant role revived me, based on what the mods said. It could have been anyone with a plant role though and it seems there are a few leafy friends around in this game....
 
I am also not sure who to vote for though, because I have a good feeling that someone with a plant role revived me, based on what the mods said. It could have been anyone with a plant role though and it seems there are a few leafy friends around in this game....

It was, but not any of them.
 
I don't think a fungus would have the ability to revive but that's just my opinion.
 
Top