Persistence of Minecraft WW Game Thread

[Trilt]

PS: I've been lax enforcing the two post dealio because I'm mostly on mobile. Getting back to reality tomorrow so please make sure you're contributing.

---

Members don't see this ad.

 

[Filly Bay]

*****
An endless waffle buffet?? Sign me up
*****

All you can eat waffles with toppings galore!

 

[Promethean]

Unlynch hayley

Officialish Lynch Tally
Dy (1) - Kam
Hayley (2) - Promo, PBC
Finn (1) - Finn
Nyanko (1) - Mq
Mq (2) - Dvmd, Dy
Deva (1) - KC

8/13 accounted for, deadline 10PM EST.

There is no limit on waffles

Finn is not voting for Finn, right?

 

[Promethean]

Anybody notice that Crayola went back to the nether again? Like PBC went twice. This seems to support my guess that only some people go to the nether. I wonder what, if anything, they have in common?

 

[genny]

Anybody notice that Crayola went back to the nether again? Like PBC went twice. This seems to support my guess that only some people go to the nether. I wonder what, if anything, they have in common?

**********
There's a butt joke in here somewhere. But it's probably NSFSDN.

**********

 

[Promethean]

By the way... this would seem to be a Dali quote.

 

[Promethean]

Also, from the intro post:

 

[Skimble]

*******************
I was night killed?! Well that is new. Can't remember the last time that happened.
*******************

 

[finnickthedog]

Finn is not voting for Finn, right?

No, but wouldn't it be interesting if I was?

 

[KCgophervet]

Had the shoe hat. Asked if it was a villager sending people to the Nether. Answer was "many villagers." Not sure what to make of it.

 

[finnickthedog]

Had the shoe hat. Asked if it was a villager sending people to the Nether. Answer was "many villagers." Not sure what to make of it.

Sounds like an item... but I would think someone would have confirmed that by now if that were the case. Interesting.

 

[Promethean]

*******************
I was night killed?! Well that is new. Can't remember the last time that happened.
*******************

I know, right? I'm curious if maybe I did it. I directed my ability your way last night, in case it would help me be able to determine your alignment, Something happened, because the way my ability can be used tonight was modified, but I'm not sure if I had anything to do with your death.

Wolves, can you confirm? Did y'all attack Jil, or was that me?

 

[Promethean]

Had the shoe hat. Asked if it was a villager sending people to the Nether. Answer was "many villagers." Not sure what to make of it.

Maybe unsuccessful lynchees sometimes go to the nether? Has everyone who has been had at least a vote or two on them the day before?

 

[genny]

Wolves, can you confirm? Did y'all attack Jil, or was that me?

************


(forgot my stars)
************

 

[vetmedhead]

Wolves, can you confirm?

****************************************

****************************************

 

[Promethean]

I had to try, right?

 

[heyyimhayley]

lynch mq

 

[allyphoe]

lynch MQ

 

[Filly Bay]

Officialish Lynch Tally
Dy (1) - Kam
Hayley (1) - PBC
Finn (1) - Nyanko
Nyanko (1) - Mq
Mq (4) - Dvmd, Dy, Hayley, Ally
Deva (1) - KC

9/13 accounted for, deadline 10PM EST.

 

[morninqlory]

And so I have just revealed my ability to @Abney. Hopefully she can get on and verify.

 

[Abnerrs]

She told me and I tried to poke holes in it. She seems to be telling the truth

 

[allyphoe]

She told me and I tried to poke holes in it. She seems to be telling the truth

Her ability is something inherently villagery, as opposed to something that could go either way, and she was able to demonstrate it to your satisfaction? Or she told an internally consistent story in a way that didn't give you wolfy feels?

 

[Abnerrs]

Her ability is something inherently villagery, as opposed to something that could go either way, and she was able to demonstrate it to your satisfaction? Or she told an internally consistent story in a way that didn't give you wolfy feels?

It could go either way but after my follow up questions her story seems to check out and lines up with info that I had

 

[Abnerrs]

It could go either way but after my follow up questions her story seems to check out and lines up with info that I had

And when I say either way, the specific nature in this situation seems very unwolfy

 

[allyphoe]

***** unlynch MQ, lynch Ny *****

 

[Abnerrs]

I would like to hear, or someone, from ny

 

[Promethean]

Ny did lynch Genny. Like, was the deciding vote, yeah?

Do we trust Abney? Why? Abney is a great liar!

 

[Abnerrs]

Lynch ny

I don't think mq should be lynched

 

[Trilt]

Officialish Lynch Tally
Dy (1) - Kam
Hayley (1) - PBC
Finn (1) - Nyanko
Nyanko (3) - Mq, Ally, Abney
Mq (3) - Dvmd, Dy, Hayley
Deva (1) - KC

10/13 accounted for, deadline in a little over an hour. Paging @Devastating, @Promethean, @finnickthedog I think.

 

[allyphoe]

Ny did lynch Genny. Like, was the deciding vote, yeah?

Do we trust Abney? Why? Abney is a great liar!

Ny's vote broke the tie between genny and Abs, so yeah.

***** Unlynch Ny ******

Back to re-reading.

 

[PrincessButterCup]

Unlynch Hayley

 

[Abnerrs]

Ny's vote broke the tie between genny and Abs, so yeah.

***** Unlynch Ny ******

Back to re-reading.

You can vote wolves when a wolf

 

[PrincessButterCup]

Ny's vote broke the tie between genny and Abs, so yeah.

***** Unlynch Ny ******

Back to re-reading.

Wolves vote for wolves. A wolf might have jumped that bandwagon especially because it would seem to exonerate them. Now, if they'd started the lynch and argued for it all along, that might be something.

I'll be rereading, but in the meantime:
Lynch NY

 

[Abnerrs]

It's actually pretty effective at making you look good. I'm not saying she is one. I'm saying it's a possibility

 

[Trilt]

The jukebox was left lonely all day, so Trilt's mix started playing:



You feel a little sad.

 

[Promethean]

Wolves vote for wolves. A wolf might have jumped that bandwagon especially because it would seem to exonerate them. Now, if they'd started the lynch and argued for it all along, that might be something.

I'll be rereading, but in the meantime:
Lynch NY

It is a good point. And if the choice was maybe between two of your wolfy friends, why not go for one or the other, yeah?

 

[Promethean]

I'll go @nyanko sure.

Lynch Ny.

There's time to defend.

(edited to bold)

 

[Filly Bay]

Officialish Lynch Tally
Dy (1) - Kam
Hayley (0) -
Finn (1) - Nyanko
Nyanko (4) - Mq, Abney, PBC, Promo
Mq (3) - Dvmd, Dy, Hayley
Deva (1) - KC

10/13 accounted for, deadline in a little over an hour.

 

[finnickthedog]

lynch nyanko

At least until we hear something this sounds like the best bet. I've got to walk my dogs but I think I'll be back before deadline to waffle if need be.

 

[PrincessButterCup]

Looking back . . . I'm not feeling nyanko anymore. Dunno who to wafffle to though, but the things that I thought were red flags to me before don't seem that way upon reading back through.

 

[allyphoe]

It is a good point. And if the choice was maybe between two of your wolfy friends, why not go for one or the other, yeah?

That would make Abs (guis) a wolf, too, because that was the tie and no one else was even on the radar. And Abs being early on the bandwagon for Ny is taking out an awful lot of assumed wolves in that interpretation.

I'd like to hear from Ny, but there's no way a 4-deep bandwagon with no second-best candidate in the wings is going to turn out well, unless Ny is a wolf. (I don't see it turning around no matter what defense appears in the next 50 minutes.)

So who's the second-best candidate that we want to switch to (and have an even more last minute bandwagon with no time to defend against), should Ny have a believable defense?

I just don't like the feel of this.

 

[Kam325]

I know Nyanko's role. While it could conceivably be chaos/neutral it could also certainly be villager, and I'd be more surprised to see it as wolf.

Genny's plea to find a way to circumvent Nyanko and get a message to DVMD gives me pause too. I know it could be a set-up, but it seems like it would be easier and would draw less attention to pretend they had opened the convo if they needed to pass something along.

Add on the deciding vote for Genny and I don't love this lynch, would rather she was looked into.

 

[Promethean]

I'd rather see Nyanko defend. I'm willing to hold off on pushing that wagon, but who instead? Time is getting short. You got a recommendation, Kam?

 

[allyphoe]

I actually would be okay with lynching Ny as SOV's "other." (Anyone have a feel for whether we had one chaos and one other, or multiples?)

 

[LetItSnow]

I actually would be okay with lynching Ny as SOV's "other."

********
This is so funny on so many (not-game-related) levels.
********

 

[KCgophervet]

WZ started as neutral, according to what she told me. She could be the other.

 

[allyphoe]

Kam's got a vote in for dy. Am I missing something, or was her defense basically "I'm playing differently because I'm paying more attention?" I'm not feeling dy as much as I had been earlier, but that's true of everyone else I was earlier suspicious of, too.

 

[allyphoe]

WZ started as neutral, according to what she told me. She could be the other.

That makes sense. I really am not feeling Ny, then.

 

[Devastating]

I know Nyanko's role. While it could conceivably be chaos/neutral it could also certainly be villager, and I'd be more surprised to see it as wolf.

Genny's plea to find a way to circumvent Nyanko and get a message to DVMD gives me pause too. I know it could be a set-up, but it seems like it would be easier and would draw less attention to pretend they had opened the convo if they needed to pass something along.

Add on the deciding vote for Genny and I don't love this lynch, would rather she was looked into.

To be fair, we've already had a few people die villagers who had roles that would have been surefire wolfy (creeper?) and so have established that roles on their own don't indicate much. I do agree on the feel of this lynch though.--these kind of late-day mini-wagons always seem so....convenient? Once they happen, if I don't feel the leader(s) then I don't know where to put a vote where it'd actually be "useful".

 

[allyphoe]

KC, since you're around, why Dev?