- Joined
- Oct 20, 2013
- Messages
- 6,388
- Reaction score
- 6,430
I am with you 100% on this. I think this exact same conversation happened on a different thread not too long ago (maybe with the same person?). I also don't think a veterinarian is legally/morally obligated to treat any animal, especially one that presents a serious risk to staff. You are not legally/morally obligated to provide free services, either, so why would you be obligated to treat an animal that can maim your staff? Veterinarians are responsible for their staff's safety. You are considered a leader and should not lead your staff into a predictably bad situation if you can help it. I've been a 'pawn' in many appointments where the vet just didn't know when to stop trying (or didn't want to turn down revenue....) and someone would always get hurt or very close to it. I've been told that you are only legally obligated to treat an animal if it walks in as an emergency, and I'm sure that can still be trumped if the animal is going to kill someone. You have to protect yourself/staff first.If you're implying that I would only treat the "well-behaved, friendly kind" - I think that's an unfair, and unsupported, accusation to level, as well as being a bit hyperbole-laced. I treat fractious animals as best I can just like any other animal, but there are limits, and I don't feel obligated - legally OR ethically - to treat every animal that walks through the door. Human safety does come first to me. And, I don't have the authority to offer free services (other than a very limited Angel fund for a very specific subset of finance-limited cases), so if they can't pay ... I can't treat. Additionally, we have a company policy against treating certain species, so I have to turn those away.
So yes, I definitely will turn a very small number of cases away.
I said it in the other thread, but if an owner won't work with the vet when it comes to dealing with their unrestrainable animal, then they can try another clinic. I think it's pretty rare for an owner to refuse sedation, usually they know darn well that their dog/cat is pretty bad. This isn't "Oh, I just don't want to spend an extra 10 minutes restraining a stressed dog." This is "How close will my techs/assistants/myself come to losing a finger with this dog?" Muzzles fail. Rabies poles can kill the animal if a staff member gets too desperate with the pole (I've seen one tech get pretty close to killing an animal until the realized what she was doing). Brute strength won't always win out.
In my experience, some veterinarians do seem to have a hard time drawing lines. When to break up with clients, when to insist on chemical restraint, etc.
Edit:
This is highly variable dependent on the patient/situation, but I don't see anything initially wrong with recommending euthanasia of extremely aggressive animals. In some sense, I would almost expect a vet to be somehow obligated to at the very least discuss it with the owner and explain why this animal is just too dangerous, what can happen, etc.Still others (more recent) refuse clients with dangerous animals, recommend euthanasia but no hints as to where to find a place that would be willing or able to care for an aggressive large patient and announce loudly that they don't care, it's not their problem.
As long as they have recorded that that recommended euthanizing, it really shouldn't be their problem if they don't want to deal with the animal. I worked for a vet who was subpoenaed in a dog bite lawsuit. This dog was a complete d*ck and has bitten before. My boss talked euthanasia with the owner, and the owner scoffed. Once the judge learned that the owner knowingly kept an animal with a lengthy bite/attack history, it was a done deal.
Also, I wouldn't feel comfortable sending this animal to another clinic. I don't want that blood on my hands, for lack of better phrasing. It's one thing to refer to a vet who is more skilled in a surgery or whatever, it's another to say "Here, you treat this a** of a dog, you guys never turn anyone down." If you're going to do it, you should at the very least personally call the clinic and explain what you are sending them yourself.
Edit again: I just realized that the previous conversation I was referring to is in fact this exact one. Blame in on the turkey.

Last edited: