SDN WW ReneWWed Game Thread

[Animal Midwife]

---

Members do not see this ad.

still don't find dpmd too wolfy, though a role reveal of stl makes me think maybe chaos?

Isn't it a good idea to get chaos out of the game?

 

[LadyOtheFarm]

If chaos and the wolves really cut a deal, I would say we should lynch chaos sooner rather than later.

 

[Skimble]

Lynch Coopah

her ability seems sketch, its weird she role revealed to SAR on D1 and that "good job whoever got a wolf" comment today rubbed me the wrong way.

Did I miss her ability claim?

Also, I'm thinking STL may not have made himself a wolf (though that is questionable).
For now,

Unlynch dpmd

 

[Animal Midwife]

Did I miss her ability claim?

Also, I'm thinking STL may not have made himself a wolf (though that is questionable).
For now,

Unlynch dpmd

Coop's claiming silencer.

 

[Skimble]

It is passive but have (possibly if true) identified the source of the items, gotten a number of wolves (which did not match jil's), identified a player who could identify the number of wolves per group (that one was not true), identified who is playing as SOV, found out about a couple of items (one thing was true). Still hoping for a nice savant one to help identifying a wolf to counteract the idiot part (of fighting SOV's lynch)

How many wolves were you told there are and when did you find that out?

Has anyone else had the caaaarrr?

 

[Skimble]

Coop's claiming silencer.

Doh, I remember that now. I'm actually ok with getting rid of that ability. I also don't think silencing wolfy players is valuable since we can learn a lot from what wolves say, but I also don't want villagers silenced.

 

[Coopah]

I think so far, most of the roles have been quite helpful. The wolf/village/chaos affiliation makes sense for most players..

For what it's worth I'm Filly Bay, usually quiet in the beginning so I have to use that as a silencing ability every other night. I could use it every night if I wanted but I chose not to because communication helps the village. If you guys want to lynch me go ahead but all my silencing has been on the most sketchy person I could find at the time. If you want to lynch me strictly because I'm the silencer you really haven't paid too much attention to STL warning you not to do so.

 

[Coopah]

Doh, I remember that now. I'm actually ok with getting rid of that ability. I also don't think silencing wolfy players is valuable since we can learn a lot from what wolves say, but I also don't want villagers silenced.

That is an extremely stupid reason for lynching someone. If you think I'm sketch, sure, if you're just like that ability doesn't help the village then you're being critically stupid.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Has anyone else had the caaaarrr?

I have.

 

[Skimble]

That is an extremely stupid reason for lynching someone. If you think I'm sketch, sure, if you're just like that ability doesn't help the village then you're being critically stupid.

I'm not lynching you right now so cool your jets.

 

[Coopah]

Unofficial Day 10 Carnage Aftermath Tally:
dpmd (5) - DVMD, Coopah, dds, AM, TRH
Coopah (3) - Fireman, nohika, Snowy
LoTF (1) - SAR
SAR (1) - Haxx
10/14

Lynch ends in ~1.5 hours

 

[Skimble]

I have.

And?

 

[Animal Midwife]

And?

I asked how many players that were neither village nor wolf remained.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Is dpmd planning on dropping a vote?

 

[Coopah]

Players that have not voted yet:
@Jilary
@Kam325
@LadyOtheFarm
@dpmd

 

[dpmd]

I don't have a reason to lynch coopah aside from trying not to die.

 

[Coopah]

I'm not lynching you right now so cool your jets.

I'll cool nothing! I'm on FIRE

 

[Coopah]

Unofficial Day 10 Carnage Aftermath Tally:
dpmd (5) - DVMD, Coopah, dds, AM, TRH
Coopah (4) - Fireman, nohika, Snowy, dpmd
LoTF (1) - SAR
SAR (1) - Haxx
10/14

Lynch ends in ~1.5 hours

 

[dpmd]

How many wolves were you told there are and when did you find that out?

Has anyone else had the caaaarrr?

night 2 I was told 4. Seemed low to me for the number of players.

 

[Coopah]

So if dpmd is STL I could see that as chaos, but also just about anything else. What have you learned with your ability?

 

[dpmd]

So if dpmd is STL I could see that as chaos, but also just about anything else. What have you learned with your ability?

It is passive but have (possibly if true) identified the source of the items, gotten a number of wolves (which did not match jil's), identified a player who could identify the number of wolves per group (that one was not true), identified who is playing as SOV, found out about a couple of items (one thing was true). Still hoping for a nice savant one to help identifying a wolf to counteract the idiot part (of fighting SOV's lynch)

 

[Coopah]

Thanks! I missed that.

 

[kaydubs]

Day 10 Carnage Aftermath Tally:
dpmd (5) - DVMD, Coopah, dds, AM, TRH
Coopah (4) - Fireman, nohika, Snowy, dpmd
LoTF (1) - SAR
SAR (1) - Haxx
11/14

@dpmd - you in the lead. But @Coopah , you are not far behind.

Lynch ends in ~1 hour

 

[nohika]

night 2 I was told 4. Seemed low to me for the number of players.

There could be an autoconversion if they started with a lower number. Dunno if that's been a thing in recent games, though.

 

[ddstothecor]

I believe Coopah's role, and while it's not useful, it's not completely nondescript, random, and full of useless information like somebody else's role.

 

[LadyOtheFarm]

Has anyone else had the caaaarrr?

I had it twice in a row.

The first was right after I had the dildo I used on Coop and all I got was along the lines of "hope she enjoyed it." Since that told me nothing about how it worked or how someone figured out a wolf by using the dildo, I asked if all item results just went to the user or if they went elsewhere. I was told to the user.

Then I asked how many possible win conditions were left. When asked for clarification, I said I was trying to see how many factions were left, but including if there were lone wolves or multiple types of chaos. I got 3.

 

[Coopah]

I had it twice in a row.

The first was right after I had the dildo I used on Coop and all I got was along the lines of "hope she enjoyed it." Since that told me nothing about how it worked or how someone figured out a wolf by using the dildo, I asked if all item results just went to the user or if they went elsewhere. I was told to the user.

Then I asked how many possible win conditions were left. When asked for clarification, I said I was trying to see how many factions were left, but including if there were lone wolves or multiple types of chaos. I got 3.

The dildo gave me great pleasure . I could silence 2 people in one night, I chose to do nothing.

 

[ddstothecor]

Snowdog, I see you liking posts that make sense, but I don't see you changing your vote.

 

[Fireman]

I believe Coopah's role, and while it's not useful, it's not completely nondescript, random, and full of useless information like somebody else's role.

It's definitely a role I've seen assigned to both sides over the years

 

[Coopah]

It's definitely a role I've seen assigned to both sides over the years

But look at the way I've used it. I haven't silenced anyone that was villagery, and I have used it as little as possible. Why do you think I'm a wolf based on that evidence?

 

[SnowshoeDog143]

Okay I'll take it for now.

unlynch coopah

 

[SnowshoeDog143]

so dpmd is claiming STL? I don't like passive abilities - easy for wolves to claim, but ability does makes sense to me. Chances stl would be village this game?

for now because she is my next choice

lynch trh

 

[Skimble]

I asked how many players that were neither village nor wolf remained.

And what answer did you get? There is NO reason to keep that info to yourself.

There could be an autoconversion if they started with a lower number. Dunno if that's been a thing in recent games, though.

If we can trust the caaaarrr, there was only one conversion possibility in this game and MJ was a convert.

 

[Fireman]

But look at the way I've used it. I haven't silenced anyone that was villagery, and I have used it as little as possible. Why do you think I'm a wolf based on that evidence?

That isn't why I think you're a wolf. I have no evidence for DPMD, and you're phrasing has rubbed me wrong on more than one occasion.

 

[Animal Midwife]

And what answer did you get? There is NO reason to keep that info to yourself.

"1"

 

[Coopah]

That isn't why I think you're a wolf. I have no evidence for DPMD, and you're phrasing has rubbed me wrong on more than one occasion.

Lynching for phrasing? Ok I haven't seen that before. If dds is chaos I'd prefer to go that way sooner rather than later. Someone I think is a wolf would be Jilary though. If people want to swing that way.

 

[kaydubs]

Day 10 Carnage Aftermath Tally:
dpmd (5) - DVMD, Coopah, dds, AM, TRH
Coopah (3) - Fireman, nohika, dpmd
LoTF (1) - SAR
SAR (1) - Haxx
TRH (1) - Snowy
11/14

@dpmd - you in the lead. But @Coopah , you are not far behind.

Lynch ends in 33 minutes

 

[LadyOtheFarm]

The AM and Jilary conversation has me suspecting both of them.

Coop I still kinda go both ways on, but tonight she seems to be leaning more village.

Dpmd... I want to believe village but my feelz keep leaning wolfy. Why isn't STL chaos? Especially a wolf leaning god of chaos?

If dds is chaos, they should go. Especially if there really was a deal struck with the wolves. But if dpmd is STL, who is dds?

 

[Haxx]

I don't feel strongly about either dpmd or Coopah, so I'm going to keep my vote where it is today.

 

[dpmd]

The AM and Jilary conversation has me suspecting both of them.

Coop I still kinda go both ways on, but tonight she seems to be leaning more village.

Dpmd... I want to believe village but my feelz keep leaning wolfy. Why isn't STL chaos? Especially a wolf leaning god of chaos?

If dds is chaos, they should go. Especially if there really was a deal struck with the wolves. But if dpmd is STL, who is dds?

The whole still idiot savant thing has to do with his ability to on occasion brilliantly find a wolf. Why would that be wolf or chaos?

 

[Coopah]

The whole still idiot savant thing has to do with his ability to on occasion brilliantly find a wolf. Why would that be wolf or chaos?

It's not based on your ability, but on your role of STL. STL has the capability to be a brilliant wolf or chaos. The idiot savant thing tends to come from his villager side where he draws the right conclusions from the totally wrong information. I.E. Jilary is always a wolf when happy and using emojis. Probably not true but he netted her as a wolf that one time anyways.

 

[SummerTheLynx]

8 MINUTES REMAINING!

 

[dpmd]

It's not based on your ability, but on your role of STL. STL has the capability to be a brilliant wolf or chaos. The idiot savant thing tends to come from his villager side where he draws the right conclusions from the totally wrong information. I.E. Jilary is always a wolf when happy and using emojis. Probably not true but he netted her as a wolf that one time anyways.

Yeah but I don't play prevet ww so how would I know about that idiot savant thing if not my role description.

 

[that redhead]

While I think the silencer role is more annoying, we're behind on the wolves and I think STL character is more likely to be trouble versus fillybay. I haven't played pre vet in a while so maybe I'm off, but I'm keeping my vote on dpmd.

 

[SARdoghandler]

Sorry guys, been super busy today and only just got on and caught up. Looks like no one is going to join me on LotF so I'll

unlynch LotF, Lynch Coops

Sorry Coops, I had you as village early but going back and re-reading has made me question that a lot. I believe dpmd's claim of STL and I have a hard time seeing the idiot savant being a wolf role since he is that because of his propensity for catching wolves. So between the two, more wolfy feels for Coops

 

[LadyOtheFarm]

8 MINUTES REMAINING!

Crap. Gotta make a decision.

Here's guessing you would make yourself wolf or chaos:

Lynch dpmd

 

[Coopah]

Yeah but I don't play prevet ww so how would I know about that idiot savant thing if not my role description.

I'm not saying you're making it up I'm just saying how STL can be viewed as wolf or chaos too.

 

[SummerTheLynx]

Day 10 Carnage Aftermath Tally:
dpmd (6) - DVMD, Coopah, dds, AM, TRH, LoTF
Coopah (4) - Fireman, nohika, dpmd, SAR
LoTF (0)
SAR (1) - Haxx
TRH (1) - Snowy
11/14

@dpmd - you in the lead. But @Coopah , you are not far behind.

Lynch ends in 4 minutes

 

[SummerTheLynx]

2 MINUTES REMAINING!

 

[Coopah]

Sorry guys, been super busy today and only just got on and caught up. Looks like no one is going to join me on LotF so I'll

unlynch LotF, Lynch Coops

Sorry Coops, I had you as village early but going back and re-reading has made me question that a lot. I believe dpmd's claim of STL and I have a hard time seeing the idiot savant being a wolf role since he is that because of his propensity for catching wolves. So between the two, more wolfy feels for Coops

I'm not really surprised by this but you are wrong in this regard. I'm hoping dpmd is wolfy, but either way, tomorrow I'm pushing for Jilary or Fireman. They're the two that are giving me the most feels right now.