Sega (WW) Genesis signups (& game thread)

[WildZoo]

---

Members do not see this ad.

Heck yeah.



Note when she voted for you. Then note when she switched to Mel. I'm only counting pre-closed as official. My voting pattern is my analysis.

Care to show your work? 😉

 

[Animal Midwife]

Care to show your work? 😉

Work for what?

 

[WildZoo]

Work for what?

I'm interested in your thought process, not just the results of your analysis

 

[Animal Midwife]

I'm interested in your thought process, not just the results of your analysis

I want FS to speak up.

 

[WildZoo]

And to follow up on my own statement...

If Jil put Sporty Spice on the board for mayor, then Sporty is likely village or unseerable in terms of affiliation. Same goes for Dubz voting for herself and Britzen voting for Dubz. If there is someone who can look into affiliation, I don't think they would be great seering targets because of that.

Probably better just to lynch them. I'd recommend starting with Sporty Spice; will probably move my vote there shortly.

I didn't put myself on the board, in case you wanted to take that into account. AM did.

 

[kaydubs]

D6 Slump Lynch Tally

mel (1) - dvmd
DVMD ()
FS (1) -AM

2/12

Deadline ~6hours

 

[PippyPony]

@WildZoo @DVMDream you said you wanted it....

Spoiler: Voting history

LIS (3) - LIS, DVMD, VMH
WZ (2) - WZ, britzen
Pippy (1) - Pippy
Sporty (5) - Jilary, Sporty, allieh, Snowy, FS
Mel (4) - Mel, Teeps, Cyndia, AM
genny (1) - genny
16/18

Missing: MJ, Crayola

Day 2 Lynch Tally:
DVMD ()
Cyndia (1) - WZ
WZ (1) - pippy
Teep (1) - Mel
britzen (12) - genny, AM, Teeps, Jilary, vmh, DVMD, allieh, LIS, Snowy, Cyndia, FS, Sporty
15/17

Missing: britzen, MJ

Day 3 Lynch Tally (pre extension)
Pippy (1) - Sporty
Jil ()
FS (1) - LIS
Teeps (4) - Pippy, Mel, Snowy, AM
VMH ()
Mel (1) - Jilary
allie () -
snowy (3) - allie, WZ, Teeps
Sporty (2) - genny, FS

12/15
Missing: Cyndia, vmh, MJ

Day 3 Lynch Tally (post time extension)
Pippy ()
Jil ()
FS (1) - LIS
Teeps (5) - Pippy, Mel, Snowy, Cyndia, WZ
VMH ()
Mel (1) - Jilary
allie ()
snowy (5) - allie, AM, Sporty, VMH, Teeps
Sporty (2) - genny, FS
AM ()

14/15

Missing: MJ

Day 4 Lynch Tally
Snowy (6) - FS, Sporty, allieh, mj, VMH, jil
WZ (2) - LIS, snowy
Mel () -
jil (6) - am, pippy, WZ, mel, genny, cyndia
mj () -

14/14

Day 5 Lynch Tally (pre genny dropping info)
Jil (6) - mel, am, dubz, genny, vmh, MJ
AM (2) - teep, jil
FS (2) - pippy, LIS

10/14

Missing: allieh, DVMD, Sporty, FS

D5 Lynch Tally (post genny dropping info)
Jil (12) - mel, am, dubz, genny, vmh, MJ, DVMD, sporty, LIS, pippy, allieh, teep
AM (1) - jil
FS () -

13/14

Missing: FS[/QUOTE]

Dubz:
- Votes cyndia in like the first post of the actual game, based on "off" posts. stays off britzen vote deliberately on D2 while making a deliberate call out of how wolves would probably be distributing votes (@LetItSnow also tried to make the argument that 1 out of me, Mel, or dubz was probably a wolf, iirc. Just noting that in case it is useful).
- Gets in early on the snowy lynch D3 -- this is the sticking point for me because I'm not sure she would do this as a wolf. But, if she was a wolf she also knew that Snowy had her lynch avoidance, so that she would be safe. BUT, then sinks Teep. Looking pretty bad here, dubz.
- D4 does exactly what she just described up there in that post of hers by getting in early on the Jil vote. I don't like this vote at all-- it gives me the creeps. Although LIS's WZ vote on that day is also hella sketch.
- Continues to vote for Jil early on D5, so again does exactly what she is calling out. Not a fan of dubz calling out her own logic repeatedly here. It smacks of something she would do as a wolf.

Sporty:
Not going to go into this right now b/c may no longer be relevant. Will edit to add my thoughts if there is more info that comes out about her.

FS:
- Votes late on the election & lynches D1 - D3
- Missing entirely from D4 & 5
- Elects sporty, but then lynches sporty repeatedly? If Sporty is village this looks really, really bad, imo.

 

[kaydubs]

I want FS to speak up.

@Frozenshades is currently with his fiancée enjoying NYC from what I could tell of social media. But we’ll page him anyways

 

[SportPonies]

I want FS to speak up.

I've been thinking this as well. I still have him(?) as neutral, mostly because I've seen basically nothing from him. How many times has he even posted during the game?

 

[PippyPony]

I've been thinking this as well. I still have him(?) as neutral, mostly because I've seen basically nothing from him. How many times has he even posted during the game?

He does this as a villager or a wolf, fwiw. Although he tends to have at least one insightful comment as a villager, at least from what I've seen. Makes it really annoying to evaluate him though.

 

[PippyPony]

I didn't put myself on the board, in case you wanted to take that into account. AM did.

Ok well then I think you are still sketchy because Britz tried to switch off of you to someone who I think she would believe to be village lol

 

[vetmedhead]

Looking back through all of the players, the following are the ones I know the least about:

Allie
LIS
DVMD (since rez)
teep (since rez)
MJ
FS

This scales from "I personally don't know much about them but others seem to" to "0 idea"

I'd personally be very interested in a FS lynch today. If only to encourage him to come on thread and defend so I can lay some questions to rest

 

[WildZoo]

@WildZoo @DVMDream you said you wanted it....

Spoiler: Voting history

LIS (3) - LIS, DVMD, VMH
WZ (2) - WZ, britzen
Pippy (1) - Pippy
Sporty (5) - Jilary, Sporty, allieh, Snowy, FS
Mel (4) - Mel, Teeps, Cyndia, AM
genny (1) - genny
16/18

Missing: MJ, Crayola

Day 2 Lynch Tally:
DVMD ()
Cyndia (1) - WZ
WZ (1) - pippy
Teep (1) - Mel
britzen (12) - genny, AM, Teeps, Jilary, vmh, DVMD, allieh, LIS, Snowy, Cyndia, FS, Sporty
15/17

Missing: britzen, MJ

Day 3 Lynch Tally (pre extension)
Pippy (1) - Sporty
Jil ()
FS (1) - LIS
Teeps (4) - Pippy, Mel, Snowy, AM
VMH ()
Mel (1) - Jilary
allie () -
snowy (3) - allie, WZ, Teeps
Sporty (2) - genny, FS

12/15
Missing: Cyndia, vmh, MJ

Day 3 Lynch Tally (post time extension)
Pippy ()
Jil ()
FS (1) - LIS
Teeps (5) - Pippy, Mel, Snowy, Cyndia, WZ
VMH ()
Mel (1) - Jilary
allie ()
snowy (5) - allie, AM, Sporty, VMH, Teeps
Sporty (2) - genny, FS
AM ()

14/15

Missing: MJ

Day 4 Lynch Tally
Snowy (6) - FS, Sporty, allieh, mj, VMH, jil
WZ (2) - LIS, snowy
Mel () -
jil (6) - am, pippy, WZ, mel, genny, cyndia
mj () -

14/14

Day 5 Lynch Tally (pre genny dropping info)
Jil (6) - mel, am, dubz, genny, vmh, MJ
AM (2) - teep, jil
FS (2) - pippy, LIS

10/14

Missing: allieh, DVMD, Sporty, FS

D5 Lynch Tally (post genny dropping info)
Jil (12) - mel, am, dubz, genny, vmh, MJ, DVMD, sporty, LIS, pippy, allieh, teep
AM (1) - jil
FS () -

13/14

Missing: FS

Dubz:
- Votes cyndia in like the first post of the actual game, based on "off" posts. stays off britzen vote deliberately on D2 while making a deliberate call out of how wolves would probably be distributing votes (@LetItSnow also tried to make the argument that 1 out of me, Mel, or dubz was probably a wolf, iirc. Just noting that in case it is useful).
- Gets in early on the snowy lynch D3 -- this is the sticking point for me because I'm not sure she would do this as a wolf. But, if she was a wolf she also knew that Snowy had her lynch avoidance, so that she would be safe. BUT, then sinks Teep. Looking pretty bad here, dubz.
- D4 does exactly what she just described up there in that post of hers by getting in early on the Jil vote. I don't like this vote at all-- it gives me the creeps. Although LIS's WZ vote on that day is also hella sketch.
- Continues to vote for Jil early on D5, so again does exactly what she is calling out. Not a fan of dubz calling out her own logic repeatedly here. It smacks of something she would do as a wolf.

Sporty:
Not going to go into this right now b/c may no longer be relevant. Will edit to add my thoughts if there is more info that comes out about her.

FS:
- Votes late on the election & lynches D1 - D3
- Missing entirely from D4 & 5
- Elects sporty, but then lynches sporty repeatedly? If Sporty is village this looks really, really bad, imo.

If you consider the idea that when I'm a wolf I follow villager logic and when I'm a villager I follow wolf logic, this all begins to make sense

Idk though. Just my honest analysis of what I think wolves would be doing. Remember that right now I'm thinking there's only one left. So, yeah I think there's a wolf in those groups, doesn't mean I think every person who fits those is one (otherwise I would nix the idea, since I know I'm not one).

Not sure why you find my cyndia vote sketchy.

Have you decided that you think I'm an original now though? I've got pretty good arguments for why that's loco.

 

[Melchizedek]

He does this as a villager or a wolf, fwiw. Although he tends to have at least one insightful comment as a villager, at least from what I've seen. Makes it really annoying to evaluate him though.

STOP READING FROM MY DIARY. like seriously though, you're now quoting my running notes word for word XD

 

[vetmedhead]

Dubz:
- Votes cyndia in like the first post of the actual game, based on "off" posts. stays off britzen vote deliberately on D2 while making a deliberate call out of how wolves would probably be distributing votes (@LetItSnow also tried to make the argument that 1 out of me, Mel, or dubz was probably a wolf, iirc. Just noting that in case it is useful).
- Gets in early on the snowy lynch D3 -- this is the sticking point for me because I'm not sure she would do this as a wolf. But, if she was a wolf she also knew that Snowy had her lynch avoidance, so that she would be safe. BUT, then sinks Teep. Looking pretty bad here, dubz.
- D4 does exactly what she just described up there in that post of hers by getting in early on the Jil vote. I don't like this vote at all-- it gives me the creeps. Although LIS's WZ vote on that day is also hella sketch.
- Continues to vote for Jil early on D5, so again does exactly what she is calling out. Not a fan of dubz calling out her own logic repeatedly here. It smacks of something she would do as a wolf.

You know, I think my main reservation about your theory that Dubz is an original is that would be a lot of lynch avoidances to stack into a wolf team of 3-4 players. Not to mention it would have been somewhat prescient of snowy (who we know was an ability thief) to steal that lynch avoidance from dubz, particularly given that she hadn't gotten a lot of heat in the lynch the day before.

 

[PippyPony]

You know, I think my main reservation about your theory that Dubz is an original is that would be a lot of lynch avoidances to stack into a wolf team of 3-4 players. Not to mention it would have been somewhat prescient of snowy (who we know was an ability thief) to steal that lynch avoidance from dubz, particularly given that she hadn't gotten a lot of heat in the lynch the day before.

Yeah that's a fair point.

I think I would most like to hear from Froyo right now.

 

[PippyPony]

Not sure why you find my cyndia vote sketchy.

Because I do 😛

Have you decided that you think I'm an original now though? I've got pretty good arguments for why that's loco.

Nope lol

I think it is probably less likely you are an original vs. convert. And I'm sure do you have good arguments, because I am probably loco lol

 

[vetmedhead]

Didn't play, but I'm mildly familiar with the GC version.

(Edit: I take it I should be looking back at some things in regards to this)

I agree with you about Mel and his play today.

Also, the Phantasy Star thing isn't from thread, it's from something snowy said to me in PM that I've been thinking about. I was looking into the games a bit more and realized the first one actually wasn't really released on the Genesis system outside of Japan (but rather released on an earlier console) and I was trying to figure out if the character she mentioned appears in all games or just that first one.

 

[SkiOtter]

STOP READING FROM MY DIARY. like seriously though, you're now quoting my running notes word for word XD

*******
Didn't someone say pippy was also part computer and it was looking like she was a mini-STL when she started? Maybe it's user error and you saved your notes onto her hard drive.....
********

 

[vetmedhead]

Yeah that's a fair point.

I think I would most like to hear from Froyo right now.

Same

Also, the Phantasy Star thing isn't from thread, it's from something snowy said to me in PM that I've been thinking about. I was looking into the games a bit more and realized the first one actually wasn't really released on the Genesis system outside of Japan (but rather released on an earlier console) and I was trying to figure out if the character she mentioned appears in all games or just that first one.

And the above Phantasy Star quest is related to why I would like to hear more from @Frozenshades

 

[WildZoo]

That feeling of discomfort when the people voting for your top two lynch candidates are your #3 and #4 candidates...

For now I'll let the cheez thing lie since people seem so insistent he shouldn't be lynched, but if the game is still going and there is not evidence that he is actually village by tomorrow I am definitely going in that direction.

lynch FS

 

[Melchizedek]

*******
Didn't someone say pippy was also part computer and it was looking like she was a mini-STL when she started? Maybe it's user error and you saved your notes onto her hard drive.....
********

Oh crap, I knew I shouldn't have accepted her snapchat friend request.....

 

[PippyPony]

For now I'll let the cheez thing lie since people seem so insistent he shouldn't be lynched

I agree with you about Mel and his play today.

That argument about how wolves-in-the-know would not be sending jil to kill genny last night also applies to him, fwiw. Unless he seriously ****ed up lol

 

[SportPonies]

I agree with you about Mel and his play today.

Also, the Phantasy Star thing isn't from thread, it's from something snowy said to me in PM that I've been thinking about. I was looking into the games a bit more and realized the first one actually wasn't really released on the Genesis system outside of Japan (but rather released on an earlier console) and I was trying to figure out if the character she mentioned appears in all games or just that first one.

To clarify: are you referring to her role (Player 6) or something else entirely? I understand this to be the latter, but wanted to make sure. I can do some research into the games.

 

[kaydubs]

D6 Slump Lynch Tally

mel (1) - dvmd
DVMD ()
FS (2) - AM, WZ

3/12

Deadline ~5.5 hours

 

[DVMDream]

And look at Mel posting mostly fluffiness today. Hmm... interesting.

Ok, I promise, I am done for now, time for a nap.

 

[vetmedhead]

That argument about how wolves-in-the-know would not be sending jil to kill genny last night also applies to him, fwiw. Unless he seriously ****ed up lol

Frankly his response to my tag earlier about 1 word or 2 made me feel better about him. He could have very easily driven a villager lynch with little effort based on how he answered

 

[PippyPony]

STOP READING FROM MY DIARY. like seriously though, you're now quoting my running notes word for word XD

*******
Didn't someone say pippy was also part computer and it was looking like she was a mini-STL when she started? Maybe it's user error and you saved your notes onto her hard drive.....
********

Oh crap, I knew I shouldn't have accepted her snapchat friend request.....

Y O U L O S T T H E S E

 

[PippyPony]

Y O U L O S T T H E S E

Error 404
Forgot to tag @SummerTheLynx

 

[vetmedhead]

To clarify: are you referring to her role (Player 6) or something else entirely? I understand this to be the latter, but wanted to make sure. I can do some research into the games.

Something else entirely. Specifically Myau - I was having a hard time figuring out how many games he's actually in from that series but know he was important in the first one

 

[DVMDream]

That argument about how wolves-in-the-know would not be sending jil to kill genny last night also applies to him, fwiw. Unless he seriously ****ed up lol

But, honestly, at some point they do need to kill genny because she was seriously impacting their game. So who would you send? The trap has been set and isn't going anywhere (at least based on the mod write up from that night, sounds like genny has been setting up the trap for days)... do you send the outed wolf? Or the wolf that has yet to be found?

 

[Melchizedek]

But, honestly, at some point they do need to kill genny because she was seriously impacting their game. So who would you send? The trap has been set and isn't going anywhere (at least based on the mod write up from that night, sounds like genny has been setting up the trap for days)... do you send the outed wolf? Or the wolf that has yet to be found?

Or if wolves knew about the reflexive kill, you do neither and just keep wolf-blocking genny and keep her suppressed.

 

[vetmedhead]

STOP READING FROM MY DIARY. like seriously though, you're now quoting my running notes word for word XD

*******
Didn't someone say pippy was also part computer and it was looking like she was a mini-STL when she started? Maybe it's user error and you saved your notes onto her hard drive.....
********

Oh crap, I knew I shouldn't have accepted her snapchat friend request.....

Y O U L O S T T H E S E

Error 404
Forgot to tag @SummerTheLynx

Wow, I can't believe they're already on @SummerTheLynx version 3.0. They barely fixed the bugs in the first version 😉

 

[SportPonies]

Something else entirely. Specifically Myau - I was having a hard time figuring out how many games he's actually in from that series but know he was important in the first one

Let me see what I can do.

 

[vetmedhead]

Meanwhile, I would love to have a vmh version 2.0. Imagine the thread fights we could start with our powers combined.

 

[PippyPony]

Wow, I can't believe they're already on @SummerTheLynx version 3.0. They barely fixed the bugs in the first version 😉

2.0 is also buggy af; they really need to push fixes more often.

 

[DVMDream]

Or if wolves knew about the reflexive kill, you do neither and just keep wolf-blocking genny and keep her suppressed.

Unless the blocking is similar to protection where you can't use it on the same player every night.

 

[SkiOtter]

Meanwhile, I would love to have a vmh version 2.0. Imagine the thread fights we could start with our powers combined.

*****
ILL FITE YOU
*****

 

[vetmedhead]

Let me see what I can do.

Thanks. Honestly it's one of those investigations that make me feel like a dog chasing its tail since there's so much WIFOM involved, but since FS isn't around on thread a whole lot it's something I've been pursuing in the hopes that I'll miraculously have one of those moments

 

[Melchizedek]

 

[SportPonies]

Thanks. Honestly it's one of those investigations that make me feel like a dog chasing its tail since there's so much WIFOM involved, but since FS isn't around on thread a whole lot it's something I've been pursuing in the hopes that I'll miraculously have one of those moments

Looks like he's only in the original and the remake of the original that was released on PS2.

 

[Melchizedek]

Unless the blocking is similar to protection where you can't use it on the same player every night.

Touche, I haven’t seen a blocking role with that restriction yet, but I know it’s a restriction that mods place on protections so the precedent is there I guess.

 

[DVMDream]

Touche, I haven’t seen a blocking role with that restriction yet, but I know it’s a restriction that mods place on protections so the precedent is there I guess.

I don't let people block the same player every night when I mod.

 

[PippyPony]

View attachment 226118

 

[WildZoo]

Was the trap permanent? For people in the know. Because my earlier thoughts were based on it being set up just for last night. If that's not the case then I'm leaning more towards DVMD's thinking.

+/- thoughts based on how long it took to set up and if people knew it was in the process of being set up before yesterday

 

[PippyPony]

Was the trap permanent? For people in the know. Because my earlier thoughts were based on it being set up just for last night. If that's not the case then I'm leaning more towards DVMD's thinking.

+/- thoughts based on how long it took to set up and if people knew it was in the process of being set up before yesterday

I knew it was being set up before yesterday. Can't speak for others.

And I figured it was probably not permanent, but since I was technically just speculating on its existence in the first place, I can't speak to how genny constructed it.

 

[DVMDream]

Was the trap permanent? For people in the know. Because my earlier thoughts were based on it being set up just for last night. If that's not the case then I'm leaning more towards DVMD's thinking.

+/- thoughts based on how long it took to set up and if people knew it was in the process of being set up before yesterday

@genny - Dinosaur Hunter from Jurassic Park and our resident item maker (villager!) who seemed to unintentionally be hoarding all of her items (thanks RNG ) was busy setting up an epic booby trap involving nerve gas. In the cave where she was spending most of her nights, she was tinkering with one of the mechanisms on the trap (she could've sworn it had worked earlier.....could she have been wrong or had it been tampered with?). She'd already asked Jilary to stop by to chat. Armed with a pistol and a grappling hook, she feels relatively safe to have her back turned for a few seconds.

Footsteps catch her attention. She looks up to see an irate @Jilary - Dr. Ivo “Eggman” Robotnik (WOLF) standing MUCH too close. "What do you take me for? An idiot? Think I'd just walk in here and you'd ambush me? I'm going to eliminate you from the game permanently!!!"

The bolded part makes it sound like she has been working on the trap for some time and perhaps even had it set up at one point but it didn't work for some reason or another.

 

[Melchizedek]

View attachment 226119

Footage of me right now

 

[Melchizedek]

Was the trap permanent? For people in the know. Because my earlier thoughts were based on it being set up just for last night. If that's not the case then I'm leaning more towards DVMD's thinking.

+/- thoughts based on how long it took to set up and if people knew it was in the process of being set up before yesterday

All I knew was that there was a reflexive kill. No idea what the trigger conditions were. Pippy do you know if it was it specifically if genny was targeted for a kill or would be set off by any night interaction period?

 

[PippyPony]

All I knew was that there was a reflexive kill. No idea what the trigger conditions were. Pippy do you know if it was it specifically if genny was targeted for a kill or would any night interaction period with her set it off?

Nope, but knowing genny I am going to put my money on it only being set off in the case of an attack.