The WWalking Dead-Game Thread

[jaboo]

---

Members do not see this ad.

On a quick lunch break. I am very confused.

First of all, wth was up with KC not being around last night for the tie? Can zoms not die in ties?

Second of all, we have 12* 10 survivors but 13 players. So that's the second day now that 1 person is not a survivor. If that was indicating zombies, that should be 2 by now. So the options in my head are: only one of KC and snowy are zoms, Mel is messing with us, or this is somehow indicative of the one person who is currently infected. There are also other possibilities but those are the only ones that make sense to me rn.*

*ETA: I dun goofed. My theory makes no sense knowing the new survivor count so pls disregard.

 

[dpmd]

On a quick lunch break. I am very confused.

First of all, wth was up with KC not being around last night for the tie? Can zoms not die in ties?

Second of all, we have 12 survivors but 13 players. So that's the second day now that 1 person is not a survivor. If that was indicating zombies, that should be 2 by now. So the options in my head are: only one of KC and snowy are zoms, Mel is messing with us, or this is somehow indicative of the one person who is currently infected. There are also other possibilities but those are the only ones that make sense to me rn.

This morning it was 10 survivors and 13 players.

 

[JustPaws]

N3
Those inside the compound felt relatively safe. The holey holy bible was thrown again at its’ previous target. However, what good does a holey bible do? So, the thrower decided to launch this lovely scottish highlander cow at the intended party, thinking the extra protection would be appreciated (look at that face, who doesn’t need that!?)

More people left the compound during the night despite what happened to the last group of poor decision-makers....

A guard saw a familiar figure walking outside the compound, but it appeared her mouth was agape and she was moving with a slight limp.

Just beyond in the tree line was...wait! What was Gabriel doing outside at this hour?? The guard’s sight, not so 20/20, took aim, and missed the first shot. Their shot veered to the left, striking Gabriel in the back, ripping through his heart! They took aim again, using his last shot only to make sure Gabriel wouldn’t be turned.

The walkers frenzied toward Gabriel's near lifeless body, the first devouring the heart served in skewer form, barely clotted blood spewing, while another gnawed on his arm. If only he had his bible...Dead is @WildZoo the village protector!

In the midst of it all, @StayingPositive2017 had cleared the compound walls, rushing to the Hilltop, but she was attacked by 4 walkers along the way.

It is now D4. Lynch close 10:30pm EST

10 survivors remain...
1. @StartingoverVet
2. @Melchizedek
3. @Crayola227
4. @PippyPony
5. @kcoughli
6. @Animal Midwife
7. @StayingPositive2017
8. @johnnaboo
9. @SnowshoeDog143
10. @SportPonies
11. @Skimble
12. @genny
13. @dpmd

Officially dead:
@allieh8607 , The Governor, and a wolf
@greeneyegal92, Glenn, and a vanillager
@WildZoo, Gabriel the village protector

Can we confirm it's ten survivors please.

Maybe because my fate hasn't been sealed yet by success or failure by medical treatment? So I'm not in the count? Or maybe AM wasn't really saved?

 

[jaboo]

At this point I think weim could have been turned...why hasn't a village rezzer claimed?(unless they have more rezzes?) It's clearly not automatic after lynches as we were afraid.

I'm not sure either why that hasn't happened either. Maybe someone still has a 2nd rez? I doubt it tho, because that should've been used by now.

Fwiw, I (formerly Weim) was rezzed as Shane again. I still have a gun.
btw would love some ammo

 

[jaboo]

This morning it was 10 survivors and 13 players.

Can we confirm it's ten survivors please.

Maybe because my fate hasn't been sealed yet by success or failure by medical treatment? So I'm not in the count? Or maybe AM wasn't really saved?

12 survivors remain...
@StartingoverVet
@Melchizedek
@Crayola227
@PippyPony
@kcoughli
@Animal Midwife
@StayingPositive2017
@johnnaboo
@SnowshoeDog143
@SportPonies
@Skimble
@genny
@WildZoo
@dpmd

I was going off of Bryn's post, mah bad! Result of skimming on a lunch break...

 

[Melchizedek]

10 Surrvivors; 13 players

• 9 Villagers
• 1 Infected

3 Players not included:

• Two turned Zombies/chaos
• 1 Wolf

In which case my money is on Snowy and KC for Zombies/Chaos and Jboo for Wolf
Alternatively it could be 1 Zombie and 2 Wolves in which case my money is Still on Snowy being the Zombie (because of the mod glitch with KC's infection) and Weim + someone else as wolf.

 

[Skimble]

10 Surrvivors; 13 players

• 9 Villagers
• 1 Infected

3 Players not included:

• Two turned Zombies/chaos
• 1 Wolf

In which case my money is on Snowy and KC for Zombies/Chaos and Jboo for Wolf
Alternatively it could be 1 Zombie and 2 Wolves in which case my money is Still on Snowy being the Zombie (because of the mod glitch with KC's infection) and Weim + someone else as wolf.

I would think the wolf/wolves would still be included in the survivor count.

 

[KCgophervet]

Really? No one shot me or seered me last night? After ALL of that?

I confess I didn't expect to be alive today. And if alive, I at least expected to be cleared by seering. Going to be far too busy at work today to put up much (any) of a defense if I end up needing to. Haven't caught up on thread today, just didn't get any "you've been deaded/seered" notification via PM.

 

[bryndiana.jones]

Official Day 4 Lynch Tally: When the Dead Come Knocking
SOV (1)- Pippy
Snowy (3)- Mel, Skimble, Paws

4/13

lynch closes in ~9 hours

 

[PippyPony]

(Yes, now knowing that Dubz was a protector who gave me the bible the second night, I understand that the bible theory was off)

Wrong, afaik.

Dubz's protection -- to my knowledge -- was not the Bible. My night results were suggestive of a heavenly presence watching over me, and it was quite obvious that it was not item-based.

 

[PippyPony]

Wow. So much false logic here,,,

Not really

1)we have to believe that you knew it was wz. Easy to say now,

Ok...so you're suggesting it would have been preferable for me to say something earlier that would out the village protector?

No one else has claimed N1 protection so that is not up for debate, and I (personally, maybe this is just me 🙄) think it is preferable to NOT shout out who I think the village power roles are.

2). We have to believe that you could have even figured that out..,wolf or villager

Do you want me to quote my comment to the mods where I listed who I thought it came from? Dubz was the heavy favorite, followed distantly by a couple of other people.

She's one of my best friends and it would actually be very easy to figure out that she protected me, thanks. I think many people here are aware of that dynamic.

3). We have to believe you wouldn’t wait a night or two...even though you might have other reasons to have to kill other people.

Going for Mel N2 was not a move I would have made. If you don't think he would have been protected that night, then I am heavily questioning your logic.

So, please explain this to me -- why would I not go for an undisclosed village PR that only I knew about over someone who was almost guaranteed to be a failed kill target?

That makes NO sense. I like to win games when I wolf.

4) we have to believe you are the sole decision maker in a wolf pack.

This is often the case, yes. I tend to heavily take charge in a wolf pack/call the shots unless there are extenuating circumstances of some kind. Anyone in here who has wolfed with me would vouch for that, I would think.

Not much of that is credible.

Actually, all of it is credible if you know me at all. You don't really know me, so I suppose you get a pass.

Although i don’t have strong sense you are a wolf, your ww logic is really poor. I find your comments distracting and ina bigger game would lynch you on principle. Can’t afford that with 10 players left sadly.

But this is straight up rude and just earned you my vote for the foreseeable future, because woofs tend to get a little antsy and treat me like I suck at this game when I actually start to figure things out and spoil some of their fun.

I think it like...bothers them to lose or something? 😛

 

[PippyPony]

I am also not buying that you didn't use the bullet you got to shoot at me N2.

Oh really? Come over here and try to attack me and find out for yourself whether I still have it 😛

 

[SportPonies]

Jboo's page 14 read on me made me laugh. People say I'm ghosting when I'm actually keeping up with the game (see: whatever the last game I played was), people say I'm more active than usual when I'm perpetually 5 pages behind...

Man guys.

I'm on page 15 right now, will be commenting on things as I read

 

[Skimble]

Testing a theory based on a conversation I had with mods earlier.
May I have more ammo please?

 

[jaboo]

Can we confirm it's ten survivors please.

Maybe because my fate hasn't been sealed yet by success or failure by medical treatment? So I'm not in the count? Or maybe AM wasn't really saved?

10 Surrvivors; 13 players

• 9 Villagers
• 1 Infected

3 Players not included:

• Two turned Zombies/chaos
• 1 Wolf

In which case my money is on Snowy and KC for Zombies/Chaos and Jboo for Wolf
Alternatively it could be 1 Zombie and 2 Wolves in which case my money is Still on Snowy being the Zombie (because of the mod glitch with KC's infection) and Weim + someone else as wolf.

Yeah, someone's missing here. I don't think the 3rd player is a wolf, I think it's another zombie. And when there was 1 player unaccounted for before, it was probably KC (presumably a zom). So we have Snowy, KC, and an unknown third.

 

[SnowshoeDog143]

So snowy turned and AM lost her arm and what? Turned? Was saved? How did that read to people?
Also do we think that you can't lynch KC/zombies or RNG?

Do you know how confusing this write up is? I chose to live not turn, but I'm not mentioned anywhere here. Also, wondering about Kc not dying? Lynch avoidance? I mean it could just be RNG too.

Is anyone else still bothered by the fact that a wolf admitted to being seered if they weren't unseerable? Why would Allie bring it up?

And if Mel did bus her, why did Allie try to take Mel down with her by saying several times that Mel was a wolf? Does that make Mel seem more village?

Sorry this has just continued to ruminate.

Allie was probably trying to take mel out before he took her out. That was my guess.

Uhhh so I just read the write up more closely

@kcoughli afaik you're the only one stockpiling things that could skewer people

Time for some 'splaining, I think

... Now do we think that kc can be killed? Because I think we should try without a tie. I'd be down for genny if we think lynching won't work on her.

 

[bryndiana.jones]

Official Day 4 Lynch Tally: When the Dead Come Knocking
SOV (1)- Pippy
Snowy (3)- Mel, Skimble, Paws

4/13

Where is everyone?

lynch closes in ~6.25 hours

 

[JustPaws]

Uhhh so I just read the write up more closely

@kcoughli afaik you're the only one stockpiling things that could skewer people

Time for some 'splaining, I think

Don't know how I missed this today in write up and this post by pippy.

@kcoughli have you responded to this?

 

[SnowshoeDog143]

10 Surrvivors; 13 players

• 9 Villagers
• 1 Infected

3 Players not included:

• Two turned Zombies/chaos
• 1 Wolf

In which case my money is on Snowy and KC for Zombies/Chaos and Jboo for Wolf
Alternatively it could be 1 Zombie and 2 Wolves in which case my money is Still on Snowy being the Zombie (because of the mod glitch with KC's infection) and Weim + someone else as wolf.

1. I am not a zombie
2. My character does suggest that they RNG'ed the characters so that the obvious aren't always wolves (From what people have be saying and reading - I haven't gotten to this character yet in watching the show)
3. Am I missing something? Do we have mod confirmed numbers or is this just guessing?
4. I am guessing that based on kc's info she told us compared to mine when I was bit, that she is a zombie. Not sure about AM who said she didn't get a choice - I assume the amputation worked to keep her village (according to Skim that works in the show)
5. Why do you think jboo is the only wolf? Do you really think Allie started as the only wolf and then rezzed a wolf and that made the wolf team? That seems way too small.

 

[SnowshoeDog143]

Also, last game AM was a butt and didn't claim the rez until end game. Since no one has claimed the rezzed, it doesn't neccessarily mean that the rez was done by a wolf.

 

[SnowshoeDog143]

Okay not going to be around the rest of the game to defend myself. Lynch me if you need to, it won't help village numbers. But if you need to test out all the infected persons are zombies theory, I would rather see kc lynched because she's the infected one that nothing makes sense (mod error, then was healed, WZ skewered).

That being said.

Lynch kc

 

[SnowshoeDog143]

cray, pips, and dpmd are my next top suspects after genny for wolves. Maybe sporty, but she seems to be playing quieter then when she's been a wolf in the past.

 

[MixedAnimals77]

Night survivor count updated. There was some slight confusion this am. We apologize.

 

[Crayola227]

I'm really busy today, I'll try to drop a few reads and my vote

I realize that I'm a very weak player when it comes to looking past mechanics to read people when I'm really confused what's going on with mechanics, it's very hard for me

I feel like we either have to go with the "obvious" of KC, Snowy, WM, or with other "obvious" sketch targets that have come up

For reasons of logic, I've tried to come off of Mel because it's super tinfoil hat theory with Allie, and given my annoyance not just with him going after me but general gameplay, I just can't trust that I'm being impartial in reading him, so ultimately I've gotta sorta wash my hands clean of him right now.

Sorta like with Pip and WZ in the last game, once that tinfoil hat of paranoia is put on, it's basically a tunnel problem until the end.

The fact we don't know if 3rd party and what role walkers vs bullets vs arrows plays, makes it really hard for me to know what to do with AM, for example, as she was bit and then "cured." Could that happen to a wolf?

The logic surrounding SOV and Pip is also enticing. Mild feels from AM and Skimble.

dpmd and SP have been too quiet for me to get a good read. I'm leaning village on dpmd at least.

This is just what I've got without being more thorough and looking through the whole roster like I usually do. Just gotta drop this off the top of my head and go for now.

 

[JustPaws]

Welp, survivor count has been updated to 11 of 13 so my thought is two zombie/chaos not included. I believe that is Snowy and KC, neither were saved by the medical treatment per write ups
@johnnaboo @dpmd @Melchizedek

Cray: if we think wolves can get bitten, then yes AM might be a wolf. Maybe the medical treatment is RNG or maybe the medic picked between snowy and AM and didn't know. I think WZ was talking about this in a post a day ago in response to a question I asked

 

[bryndiana.jones]

Official Day 4 Lynch Tally: When the Dead Come Knocking
SOV (1)- Pippy
Snowy (3)- Mel, Skimble, Paws
KC (1)- Snowy

5/13

Where is everyone?

lynch closes in ~5.25 hours

 

[genny]

Testing a theory based on a conversation I had with mods earlier.
May I have more ammo please?

Does it work? Because if so, I'd love a metric crapton of ammo.

 

[dpmd]

Welp, survivor count has been updated to 11 of 13 so my thought is two zombie/chaos not included. I believe that is Snowy and KC, neither were saved by the medical treatment per write ups
@johnnaboo @dpmd @Melchizedek

Cray: if we think wolves can get bitten, then yes AM might be a wolf. Maybe the medical treatment is RNG or maybe the medic picked between snowy and AM and didn't know. I think WZ was talking about this in a post a day ago in response to a question I asked

When it was 10 i think i figured snowy, kc, and the newly infected were in that number though that wouldn't make sense now that i went back and looked at the prior writeups. now with it corrected it seems to clearly be correlating to zombie formation. so the wolf or wolves number is part of the survivors presumably (unless we think we staryed with no wolves somehow)

 

[JustPaws]

When it was 10 i think i figured snowy, kc, and the newly infected were in that number though that wouldn't make sense now that i went back and looked at the prior writeups. now with it corrected it seems to clearly be correlating to zombie formation. so the wolf or wolves number is part of the survivors presumably (unless we think we staryed with no wolves somehow)

I'm guessing they are part of the survivors which also makes me think that wolves can indeed become zombies

 

[dpmd]

I'm guessing they are part of the survivors which also makes me think that wolves can indeed become zombies

Yeah, i think they are a separate thing but i don't know how they factor in to winning.

 

[Skimble]

Does it work? Because if so, I'd love a metric crapton of ammo.

It didn’t work the way I had hoped, though it did do something.

 

[JustPaws]

Yeah, i think they are a separate thing but i don't know how they factor in to winning.

Well if we Lynch snowy tonight and she comes back chaos, then I'm guessing the zombies have their own win condition separate from the wolves

 

[StartingoverVet]

So taxes took all freaking day, old grumpy man is grumpy, no time to re read whole thread.
I have read today’s discussion,

Stop lynching the dead/infected. They do not count as players it appears. Shoot the crap out of them overnight. Or ignore them (but I think that is a mistake),

Let’s lynch wolves. Some people trying to distract us with lynch8ng the dead are probably wolves.

Therefore...

Lynch Skimble

 

[dpmd]

Well if we Lynch snowy tonight and she comes back chaos, then I'm guessing the zombies have their own win condition separate from the wolves

I can get behind that i suppose since they apparently lied about their choice
Lynch snowy

 

[JustPaws]

So taxes took all freaking day, old grumpy man is grumpy, no time to re read whole thread.
I have read today’s discussion,

Stop lynching the dead/infected. They do not count as players it appears. Shoot the crap out of them overnight. Or ignore them (but I think that is a mistake),

Let’s lynch wolves. Some people trying to distract us with lynch8ng the dead are probably wolves.

Therefore...

Lynch Skimble

If snowy doesn't come back chaos I will happily Lynch either mel or skimble tomorrow

 

[StartingoverVet]

10 Surrvivors; 13 players

• 9 Villagers
• 1 Infected

3 Players not included:

• Two turned Zombies/chaos
• 1 Wolf

In which case my money is on Snowy and KC for Zombies/Chaos and Jboo for Wolf
Alternatively it could be 1 Zombie and 2 Wolves in which case my money is Still on Snowy being the Zombie (because of the mod glitch with KC's infection) and Weim + someone else as wolf.

Makes more sense that infected is not a player,, so 10 players, unknown n7mber of wolves. Where did you get your 1 wolf theory?
zombies chaos infected all non players.

 

[JustPaws]

Makes more sense that infected is not a player,, so 10 players, unknown n7mber of wolves. Where did you get your 1 wolf theory?
zombies chaos infected all non players.

It's been amended by the mods to 11 survivors, so his numbers are not reflecting that. Do you normally not kill chaos as village? I thought you wanted to kill them too?

 

[bryndiana.jones]

Official Day 4 Lynch Tally: When the Dead Come Knocking
SOV (1)- Pippy
Snowy (4)- Mel, Skimble, Paws, dpmd
KC (1)- Snowy
Skimble (1) - SOV

7/13

Little pig, little pig. . .

lynch closes in ~4.5 hours

 

[jaboo]

Better reads in memory of my grandmanator (RIP)


Pips has been kinda all over. I usually expect a lot more insight on her part at this point in the game. First was tunneling Mel, now seems to narrowing in on SOV. Not sure what to make of it since I don't think I've played with wolfPip, but she's creeping up my sketch list.

AM is still reading as village to me. The whole amputation thing was odd, but we already knew that could happen. But why hasn't that happened to anyone else? Running theory is that there's a healer out there somewhere, but that's just my tin foil hat talking.

I'm not down to lynch KC because she hasn't done anything to set off alarm bells for me. I'm still not sure lynching a zombie would be helpful. Does it work? We don't know. Are zombies automatically chaos? No idea. So I don't have much to go off of and the fact that she hasn't weirded me out makes a tough sell for me.

With Snowy revealed as chaos and also a supposed zombie though, I'm ok voting here. We kill a non-villager with the plus of finding out what happens when a zombie is lynched. Then we can move forward and get on with our lives.


Lynch Snowy

 

[Skimble]

So taxes took all freaking day, old grumpy man is grumpy, no time to re read whole thread.
I have read today’s discussion,

Stop lynching the dead/infected. They do not count as players it appears. Shoot the crap out of them overnight. Or ignore them (but I think that is a mistake),

Let’s lynch wolves. Some people trying to distract us with lynch8ng the dead are probably wolves.

Therefore...

Lynch Skimble

I’m all for wolf hunting, but right now we have a confirmed chaos. Why wouldn’t you want to kill a confirmed chaos?

 

[Crayola227]

Like I said before I'm not loving the whole going after those with a history of infection, but since we have some not coming up in the survivor count....

Plus there has been something off about Snowy's play to me. More aggressive?

lynch Snowy

 

[bryndiana.jones]

Official Day 4 Lynch Tally: When the Dead Come Knocking
SOV (1)- Pippy
Snowy (6)- Mel, Skimble, Paws, dpmd, Jboo, Cray
KC (1)- Snowy
Skimble (1) - SOV

9/13

Little pig, little pig. . .

lynch closes in ~4 hours

 

[Animal Midwife]

Lynch genny

for now

 

[PippyPony]

Pips has been kinda all over. I usually expect a lot more insight on her part at this point in the game. First was tunneling Mel, now seems to narrowing in on SOV. Not sure what to make of it since I don't think I've played with wolfPip, but she's creeping up my sketch list.

Please explain what you would like to see from me beyond what i have already provided, which includes:
- post analysis
- night kill/event theories
- unique info contributions regarding my night results and role
- questioning many other players to get them to engage in discussion
- voting for who I think is most wolfy, with multiple explanations provided for each vote

Seriously, you are claiming I'm the person who has not contributed enough strategy to move this game forward?

...Really?

 

[PippyPony]

Mods, can I get a couple BOXES of bullets, please?

I'd like to take a couple shots.

 

[StartingoverVet]

What the heck. I want six bullets.

 

[kaydubs]

Mods, can I get a couple BOXES of bullets, please?

I'd like to take a couple shots.

With or without alcohol?

 

[kaydubs]

Whaddup weirdos?

Too tired....keep lynching 😴

 

[PippyPony]

With or without alcohol?

How is this even a question? 😉

 

[StartingoverVet]

It's been amended by the mods to 11 survivors, so his numbers are not reflecting that. Do you normally not kill chaos as village? I thought you wanted to kill them too?

I’m all for wolf hunting, but right now we have a confirmed chaos. Why wouldn’t you want to kill a confirmed chaos?

Chaos is not wolves. Mostly they are supposed to be irrelevant to the game. I know some people have gone down the rabbit hole of chaos winning over villagers, But I have been independent chaos many many times.

Chaos is for killing at night,
Wolves are for lynching,
That is my strong opinion.