UM vs. Davis vs. Vanderbilt...

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Status
Not open for further replies.

cal2012

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Feb 15, 2010
Messages
134
Reaction score
0
Hi guys--thanks ahead of time for your advice.

Anyway, I know that these threads are getting pretty common, but I could really use some thoughts besides my own/my parents/everyone else I've talked to lately. Basically, I'm trying to decide between the University of Michigan, UC Davis and Vanderbilt. I'm a CA resident--not sure if I want to stay in the area though.

UC Davis
Pros:
-Cheapest option (~average med school debt coming out of here, ~150k)
-Close to family/friends (maybe too close, haha)
-In CA--potential bonus returning to CA for residency?
-Interview day was so-so, but my informal second look went really well, the faculty/doctors here seem incredibly friendly...
-Laid-back feel to class
Cons:
-Ranking, I guess, around mid-tier...
-Possibly less research opps. I know students do research here, but I'm not sure about how easy it is to get involved in a substantial sort of way.
-Location: Sacramento's ok, but the med school and undergrad aren't on the same campus (only about a mile apart though)
-Didn't get that "wow" feeling here

University of Michigan
Pros:
-Top-ranked school/good rep with residency directors
-Tons of research/mentoring opps
-Impressive facilities/right on undergrad campus
-Very very impressed on interview day--was my top choice (after ucsf/ucla...) before I got my financial aid package. All else being equal, I probably would've gone here...
Cons:
-Very expensive (I'd be paying full sticker price as OOS, though I can borrow some $ from family interest-free...I'd probably come out with >200k in debt)
-Location: Not sure if I really want to return to ca for residency, but going oos might make it hard for me to do so if I wanted to
-Far from family/friends
-Big class size/intense students (possibly)

Vanderbilt
Pros
-Top-ranked school/good rep
-Tons of research/mentoring opps
-Impressive facilities/right on undergrad campus
-Like Michigan, got blown away on interview day
Cons:
-Expensive, but not quite as much as UM (~170-190k coming out of here, w/ scholarship)
-Far from family/friends
-Location: same issue as with UM above, but everyone keeps telling me to stay out of the south :laugh:
-Not really a con, but I haven't met many students, and the ones I did seemed pretty intense.

Any thoughts would be appreciated! I'll also add that I'm not sure what my goals in medicine are, other than to just be a great doctor. I'd like to teach one day, but I'm not interested in super-high-powered academic medicine (at the moment...). But I'm not interested in primary care, surgery/anaesthesia/em are my top interests right now.

So...what do?

Members don't see this ad.
 
Hi guys--thanks ahead of time for your advice.

Anyway, I know that these threads are getting pretty common, but I could really use some thoughts besides my own/my parents/everyone else I've talked to lately. Basically, I'm trying to decide between the University of Michigan, UC Davis and Vanderbilt. I'm a CA resident--not sure if I want to stay in the area though.

UC Davis
Pros:
-Cheapest option (~average med school debt coming out of here, ~150k)
-Close to family/friends (maybe too close, haha)
-In CA--potential bonus returning to CA for residency?
-Interview day was so-so, but my informal second look went really well, the faculty/doctors here seem incredibly friendly...
-Laid-back feel to class
Cons:
-Ranking, I guess, around mid-tier...
-Possibly less research opps. I know students do research here, but I'm not sure about how easy it is to get involved in a substantial sort of way.
-Location: Sacramento's ok, but the med school and undergrad aren't on the same campus (only about a mile apart though)
-Didn't get that "wow" feeling here

University of Michigan
Pros:
-Top-ranked school/good rep with residency directors
-Tons of research/mentoring opps
-Impressive facilities/right on undergrad campus
-Very very impressed on interview day--was my top choice (after ucsf/ucla...) before I got my financial aid package. All else being equal, I probably would've gone here...
Cons:
-Very expensive (I'd be paying full sticker price as OOS, though I can borrow some $ from family interest-free...I'd probably come out with >200k in debt)
-Location: Not sure if I really want to return to ca for residency, but going oos might make it hard for me to do so if I wanted to
-Far from family/friends
-Big class size/intense students (possibly)

Vanderbilt
Pros
-Top-ranked school/good rep
-Tons of research/mentoring opps
-Impressive facilities/right on undergrad campus
-Like Michigan, got blown away on interview day
Cons:
-Expensive, but not quite as much as UM (~170-190k coming out of here, w/ scholarship)
-Far from family/friends
-Location: same issue as with UM above, but everyone keeps telling me to stay out of the south :laugh:
-Not really a con, but I haven't met many students, and the ones I did seemed pretty intense.

Any thoughts would be appreciated! I'll also add that I'm not sure what my goals in medicine are, other than to just be a great doctor. I'd like to teach one day, but I'm not interested in super-high-powered academic medicine (at the moment...). But I'm not interested in primary care, surgery/anaesthesia/em are my top interests right now.

So...what do?

I'm guessing you didn't go to the second look, but the current and prospective students all seemed fantastic.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top