WW: -Omitted Topic-: Game Thread

[Karabiner13]

---

Members don't see this ad.

D6 Official Lynch Tally

stagg (7) - koffee, matty, genny, grebes, dubz, Dina, MsP
capri (8) - lawpy, AM, Stagg, mutts, Paws, SOV, Pippy, pbc
AM () -
Dina (2) - jboo, kcough
pippy (1) - mel
Jboo (1) - dolphin

19/27

capri is in the lead

Missing: capri, jahboi, allieh, TG, sar, skim, trilt, miz

Deadline 11pm est (~1.5 hours)

 

[capri1722]

@capri1722

I want to hear more from you. You have added very little meaningful except staying in character. It would be pretty amusing to force a wolf to do that, or to hide behind a character as a wolf, so that does nothing for me. All I see is an attempt to be uncontroversial.

Indeed.

Lawper asks for reads and Capri dodges.

😆
Have you no concept of context?
Sir Lawper had posted that while I was typing a long post just before that. I merely said "good evening" to him to be polite, to acknowledge I had seen it, and because I did not feel that it warranted any further musings from me as I had recently laid out my thoughts.

@capri1722 Meant to ask this last night but I don't think I got around to it. Current wolf reads? And feelings on dina in particular?

Currently I believe Sir Stagg to be most likely a wolf, though I am unsure of most others. Lady Pippy had made me uneasy several days ago, such that I wished to vote for her but could not, but I have since forgotten why she made me uneasy. I am hesitant to trust her as I feel that I frequently fall prey to her pocket.
I had not previously considered Lady Dina, and thus have no thoughts on her. Is there a reason I should find her to sway one way or the other?

I think it was her trying to get more village cred by taking the easy way out (LIS rule) knowing that SAR wouldn't die with that lynch. When I flip village she can say she can say that if she were a wolf she'd have voted to lynch a villager. But now we're starting to get into WIFOM

Indeed, I did vote according to the ancient wisdom; I stated as much. I should have liked to post it earlier, but it takes longer than one would imagine to speak in a formal style while maintaining my intent.

I also looked back at the Stagg v Capri interactions that I mentioned yesterday (the one where Capri kept pushing Stagg for reads) and I'm seeing it in a different light today as a wolf who got backed into a corner and drew too much attention to themselves, had to double down, and actually came up with a decent reason for pushing a villager. This moves Capri from village to neutral on my list. I'm having a hard time coming up with which explanation is more plausible atm.

Am I the wolf in your scenario? Doth thou believe that Sir Stagg is a villager?

 

[capri1722]

Lynch Stagg
For self-preservation, but do not be fooled; I still am not fond of his evasiveness.

 

[Karabiner13]

D6 Official Lynch Tally

stagg (8) - koffee, matty, genny, grebes, dubz, Dina, MsP, capri
capri (8) - lawpy, AM, Stagg, mutts, Paws, SOV, Pippy, pbc
AM () -
Dina (2) - jboo, kcough
pippy (1) - mel
Jboo (1) - dolphin

20/27

Stagg and capri are in the lead

Missing: jahboi, allieh, TG, sar, skim, trilt, miz

Deadline 11pm est (~1.5 hours)

 

[ThoracicGuy]

For now:

Lynch Stagg

Yes, I know it breaks the tie, @WildZoo.

 

[Lawpy]

For now:

Lynch Stagg

Yes, I know it breaks the tie, @WildZoo.

 

[StartingoverVet]

I am ok with a tie. Which it looks like now...
But there is a lot of time left. I won’t make it till 11, good luck with that.

 

[WildZoo]

For now:

Lynch Stagg

Yes, I know it breaks the tie, @WildZoo.

I can't believe you've done this

 

[Stagg737]

Not nothing. It definitely leaves you as a candidate for who did the killing last night.

I'd expect a wolf to disagree with my reasons. You have no defense except to attack my logic which is nonsensical as I'm the only one so far to lead a wolf lynch.

I think you're just sad because this will only be your 2nd time getting caught as a wolf.

Lol, no. I'm attacking your logic because your logic is awful. And holy balls to the bolded. This is literally Colorado where you found us a wolf, then told us all a bunch of info that was completely false (which ironically ended up getting us another wolf), and when everyone called you out on lying to village you pulled this "but I caught us a wolf" to try and justify lying to village.

No, I haven't seen you straight up lie this game (as far as I know), but you're using the same line of thought of "just trust me, it worked out before" when there's no actual logic behind it at all.

Why ask what? Why coffee was actually voting for stagg? I went for stagg because coffee did, and I had a slight paranoid delusion that something nefarious might be going on with her. I asked her why she was going after stagg because I didn't see a ton of her reasoning. So the two were only slightly related.

What. The. Hell. This is the reason I'm getting lynched. This is the type of logic people are using. Do we really not see a problem with this??? And his other reasons for voting me are "tinfoil theories". Seriously.

 

[Trilt]

D6 Official Lynch Tally

stagg (8) - koffee, matty, genny, grebes, dubz, Dina, MsP, capri
capri (8) - lawpy, AM, Stagg, mutts, Paws, SOV, Pippy, pbc
AM () -
Dina (2) - jboo, kcough
pippy (1) - mel
Jboo (1) - dolphin

20/27

Stagg and capri are in the lead

Missing: jahboi, allieh, TG, sar, skim, trilt, miz

Deadline 11pm est (~1.5 hours)

You missed my vote for TG.

 

[Stagg737]

Have you no concept of context?
Sir Lawper had posted that while I was typing a long post just before that. I merely said "good evening" to him to be polite, to acknowledge I had seen it, and because I did not feel that it warranted any further musings from me as I had recently laid out my thoughts.

Yea, a long post which said absolutely nothing. The fact that Lawpy didn't follow up on it when you have provided almost nothing of value to village is just more wolf points for him.

Indeed, I did vote according to the ancient wisdom; I stated as much. I should have liked to post it earlier, but it takes longer than one would imagine to speak in a formal style while maintaining my intent.

Really? Speaking in formal style is so time consuming that it took you that long to write out two sentences? That's crap and I don't understand how so many people are buying this.

 

[ThoracicGuy]

I can't believe you've done this

If we want a tie, I could always change the vote.

 

[PrincessButterCup]

Why ask what? Why coffee was actually voting for stagg? I went for stagg because coffee did, and I had a slight paranoid delusion that something nefarious might be going on with her. I asked her why she was going after stagg because I didn't see a ton of her reasoning. So the two were only slightly related.

This was a reply to me but I didn't catch it until Stagg responded.

Agreed with Stagg, wtf is this. Why are you parroting votes if you don't even know why they're being placed?

 

[capri1722]

Really? Speaking in formal style is so time consuming that it took you that long to write out two sentences? That's crap and I don't understand how so many people are buying this.

I invite you to attempt such a feat. I do not claim it takes hours to formulate my thoughts, but when mere minutes mean the difference between placing a vote and not, indeed it does take me a while.

 

[Skimble]

I’ve been back and forth between Capri and stagg all day, and while I normally hate ties, I do agree stagg and Capri are wolfy.

Lynch capri

 

[Stagg737]

I invite you to attempt such a feat. I do not claim it takes hours to formulate my thoughts, but when mere minutes mean the difference between placing a vote and not, indeed it does take me a while.

Lol, this doesn't even make sense.

 

[PrincessButterCup]

I invite you to attempt such a feat. I do not claim it takes hours to formulate my thoughts, but when mere minutes mean the difference between placing a vote and not, indeed it does take me a while.

You don't have to write a sonnet. If it is indeed down to the wire, why can't you just "lynch whoever" and add your purple prose after? Lynch is an old term, it should count as fulfillment of your persona

I know I've only voted in one lynch this entire game, but I can still call bs on someone missing lynch due to post flair.

 

[capri1722]

You don't have to write a sonnet. If it is indeed down to the wire, why can't you just "lynch whoever" and add your purple prose after? Lynch is an old term, it should count as fulfillment of your persona

I shall keep this in mind for the next opportunity.

I know I've only voted in one lynch this entire game, but I can still call bs on someone missing lynch due to post flair.

'Tis a good thing then that I did not miss the lynch 😉

 

[Karabiner13]

D6 Official Lynch Tally

stagg (9) - koffee, matty, genny, grebes, dubz, Dina, MsP, capri, TG
capri (9) - lawpy, AM, Stagg, mutts, Paws, SOV, Pippy, pbc, skim
AM () -
Dina (2) - jboo, kcough
TG (1) - trilt
pippy (1) - mel
Jboo (1) - dolphin

23/27

stagg and capri are in the lead

Missing: jahboi, allieh, sar, miz

Deadline 11pm est (~1 hour)

 

[Matthew9Thirtyfive]

This was a reply to me but I didn't catch it until Stagg responded.

Agreed with Stagg, wtf is this. Why are you parroting votes if you don't even know why they're being placed?

Did you not read, or did I just not make it clear? I didn't say I had no reasons. I said I wasn't totally sure why coffee voted for him. Reading comprehension. It's a thing.

 

[Stagg737]

A few points on Genny since I wanted to look into her earlier:

Hey so I got delayed n1 results. What do you guys think about a silver dude who forces role names from players?

I also think there’s an item thief around, so keep a close eye on your stuff.

Silver armor. Rather forceful. I was shaking in my boots.

So apparently her role got seered by Coffee early in the game and she said the knight was forceful. But later on Coffee seered someone (I think Dina?) who said the silver knight was not forceful. Different results. Could be nothing, but inconsistency noted.

UGH. Just ugh.

Also, Coffee has a history of exaggerating her surety of things so I'm reluctant to take what she says at face value. Is "Dark Shuffle" seriously supposed to be SAR's role name? It doesn't sound like a name, it sounds like an ability.

lynch capri

since it seems apparent SAR is going down.

This was for the first SAR vote. Staying off the SAR lynch because her vote wasn't needed, which is fair. Then questioned SAR a bunch even though she said she didn't trust Coffee, which is also fair. Which didn't really catch my eye, but then this was her reasoning for voting for me today:

I could see anyone EXCEPT YOU getting away with posting this, and still having it be logical. If you're truly a villager, then my vote switching shouldn't bother you, since I moved the vote away from you (a villager) and onto a known wolf. If you're a villager, you should be really happy there wasn't a tie involving you, and that I had the presence of mind to switch away from you. You shouldn't be complaining about how I voted since I didn't actually vote for you. The only way your indignation makes sense is if you have a guilty wolf conscience, and you're trying to shade me for pulling the vote away from a wolf (you).

Basically saying I shouldn't be questioning her/looking into her because she voted for SAR to which saved me. I was very happy to not die, but her last minute switch from me to SAR was weird. Especially because it seemed like she switched right after I made a comment about her voting for me. This was the exchange:

lynch stagg

But the write-ups imply that SAR is working for someone else. That doesn't fit with the idea of an alpha to me.

Then why aren't you lynching her again?

Because the tie was too tempting.

And what about me is wolfy to you? If I recall you haven't said anything about me being sketchy up to this point, so why now all of a sudden?

unlynch stagg
lynch SAR

So it felt like she made a mistake and was trying to cover her tracks by ending up on the SAR lynch. She also never gave a reason for voting for me and earlier in the game she seemed to be weary of Coffee as above. It feels like she knew SAR was an alpha, so she stayed off the first day and then didn't know what to do on the second attempt so she ended up on SAR since she knew SAR wouldn't die. Also, she said she liked the tie which is why she voted for me, but if you look at the tallies from that day, switching to SAR shifted it from a tie to a 8-6 vote to lynch SAR. So she wanted a tie then suddenly didn't? And today she came up with a justification of "Stagg should be grateful I saved him, but he's not, so he's a wolf!"

This just reeks of trying to justify a lynch on me when she doesn't have an actual reason.

 

[Stagg737]

Did you not read, or did I just not make it clear? I didn't say I had no reasons. I said I wasn't totally sure why coffee voted for him. Reading comprehension. It's a thing.

You literally said, "I went for Stagg because Coffee did" and then followed it up with "I didn't see a ton of her reasoning". So you sheeped a vote for no reason other than the tinfoil you keep mentioning. Maybe you'd like to share that theory with the class since you're all over the place with your statements.

 

[Matthew9Thirtyfive]

You literally said, "I went for Stagg because Coffee did" and then followed it up with "I didn't see a ton of her reasoning". So you sheeped a vote for no reason other than the tinfoil you keep mentioning. Maybe you'd like to share that theory with the class since you're all over the place with your statements.

I'll pass. I don't think it's legit anymore.

 

[Karabiner13]

D6 Official Lynch Tally

stagg (9) - koffee, matty, genny, grebes, dubz, Dina, MsP, capri, TG
capri (9) - lawpy, AM, Stagg, mutts, Paws, SOV, Pippy, pbc, skim
AM () -
Dina (2) - jboo, kcough
TG (1) - trilt
pippy (1) - mel
Jboo (1) - dolphin

23/27

stagg and capri are in the lead

Missing: jahboi, allieh, sar, miz

Deadline 11pm est (~30 mins)

 

[genny]

 

[Stagg737]

I'll pass. I don't think it's legit anymore.

So if your tinfoil isn't legit, why exactly are you voting for me?

 

[WildZoo]

So apparently her role got seered by Coffee early in the game and she said the knight was forceful. But later on Coffee seered someone (I think Dina?) who said the silver knight was not forceful. Different results. Could be nothing, but inconsistency noted.

It has already been confirmed by the mod that there was some error there so I would disregard that whole thing

 

[genny]

i feel like there's no way wolves are going to let this tie stand.

 

[genny]

Also asparagus + a cheese plate + chianti is the best GoT accompaniment.

 

[WildZoo]

i feel like there's no way wolves are going to let this tie stand.

Kinda been thinking SAR was gonna break it but don't worry...I'll be watching

 

[Stagg737]

It has already been confirmed by the mod that there was some error there so I would disregard that whole thing

Forgot about that. What was the mix up again? Because I thought it was just that someone got more results than they were supposed to, not that the wording was off.

 

[WildZoo]

Forgot about that. What was the mix up again? Because I thought it was just that someone got more results than they were supposed to, not that the wording was off.

It doesn't matter whether it was the wording of the results or that she got the results at all (though it sounds like it was the latter), it should have no bearing on your analysis of her

So... just got another update from mods. Apparently I wasn’t supposed to get anything about a guy taking names. So I can’t tell you anything else about it.

I will confirm there was a minor mess up on night 1 results, which has now been rectified (aka I am confirming mod error with Genny's above post)

 

[PippyPony]

I shall keep this in mind for the next opportunity.

'Tis a good thing then that I did not miss the lynch 😉

You sure do talk fancy, lady

 

[allieh8607]

lynch capri

 

[Animal Midwife]

lynch capri

Why?

 

[allieh8607]

but if you all freak out about me breaking the tie, I am more than happy to go back to my vote from yesterday

 

[WildZoo]

Do we need to designate tie-watchers? I feel like we need someone on the stagg vote and someone on the capri vote.

Or I guess I could unvote and hold onto mine in case of shenanigans. I don't know how best to do this.

 

[ThoracicGuy]

Do we need to designate tie-watchers? I feel like we need someone on the stagg vote and someone on the capri vote.

Or I guess I could unvote and hold onto mine in case of shenanigans. I don't know how best to do this.

Do you trust other tie breaker watchers?

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

but if you all freak out about me breaking the tie, I am more than happy to go back to my vote from yesterday

Yes

 

[genny]

Do we need to designate tie-watchers? I feel like we need someone on the stagg vote and someone on the capri vote.

Or I guess I could unvote and hold onto mine in case of shenanigans. I don't know how best to do this.

I am as unreliable as Pippy for these things. Too slow.

 

[allieh8607]

unlynch capri
lynch TG

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

D6 Official Lynch Tally

stagg (9) - koffee, matty, genny, grebes, dubz, Dina, MsP, capri, TG
capri (9) - lawpy, AM, Stagg, mutts, Paws, SOV, Pippy, pbc, skim
AM () -
Dina (2) - jboo, kcough
TG (2) - trilt, allie
pippy (1) - mel
Jboo (1) - dolphin

24/27

capri and stagg are in the lead

Missing: jahboi, sar, miz

Deadline 11pm est (~13 mins)

 

[WildZoo]

Do you trust other tie breaker watchers?

I don't know. It would look pretty bad for them if they screwed up. I don't know if I want that kind of pressure myself though lol

 

[allieh8607]

Why?

personally I think it's harder for SAR's inevitable last minute vote to make much of a difference if we just freaking pick someone and go with it. Out of capri and stagg (and I knowwwww, it's not an either or situation) I have more feels for capri

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Just 10 more minutes

 

[WildZoo]

I don't know what would be funnier, the idea of SAR just sitting watching the thread this whole time, or the idea that she's not here at all lol

 

[Karabiner13]

D6 Official Lynch Tally

stagg (9) - koffee, matty, genny, grebes, dubz, Dina, MsP, capri, TG
capri (9) - lawpy, AM, Stagg, mutts, Paws, SOV, Pippy, pbc, skim
AM () -
Dina (2) - jboo, kcough
TG (2) - trilt, allie
pippy (1) - mel
Jboo (1) - dolphin
allie (1) - miz

25/27

capri is in the lead

Missing: jahboi, sar

Deadline 11pm est (~8 mins)

 

[Navilly]

D6 Official Lynch Tally

stagg (9) - koffee, matty, genny, grebes, dubz, Dina, MsP, capri, TG
capri (9) - lawpy, AM, Stagg, mutts, Paws, SOV, Pippy, pbc, skim
AM () -
Dina (2) - jboo, kcough
TG (2) - trilt, allie
pippy (1) - mel
Jboo (1) - dolphin
allieh(1) - Miz

25/27

capri and stagg are in the lead

Missing: jahboi, sar

Deadline 11pm est (~8 mins)

 

[allieh8607]

anyone else around who isn't currently voting for stagg or capri?
@johnnaboo @kcoughli @Trilt @Melchizedek @dolphin106258 @Jahboi

 

[WildZoo]

Does someone on the capri vote want to switch to stagg? Then I can unvote and allie can go back to capri. I'll hold onto mine in case SAR does show up. And hopefully beat her in the race to the last second.