WWhere There's a WWhisk, There's a WWay! - Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
capri1722 said:
I would have thought that all red flags by default are wolfy red flags. How are they different?
Click to expand...
Essentially they're flags that basically say that if VA is alive at end-game, it's bad. They're reminders. Because at end-game there will be one wolf, one villager, and one villager (assuming VA is village) that's been sketchy since day 1. Wolves don't like to kill sketchy people because it's easier to lynch them and save themselves for a night. Make sense?
 
bryndiana.jones said:
Okay, I already went back and forth with you yesterday so I don't have much to add if you want to vote for me today too.
Click to expand...
yeah and I already broke down your "back and forth" and there's nothing there.
cdoconn said:
Finally caught up with the thread:

Okay so @bryndiana.jones you keep saying that this is your strategy post. Of these 3 points, 2 of them are facts/ fact-like (1 and 3). Point number 2 essentially just says "well I wanted to talk to LIS but he's dead, so now I'm asking VA what he thinks". None of this is your thoughts, your opinions.
Click to expand...
 
Unofficial D3 All you Knead Lynch Tally

Paws (1) - Cray
Snowy (3) - Trilt, capri, vmh
Cray (1) - Pippy
Mel (4) - VAsp, finn, kski, nohi
capri (2) - mel, stella
skye (1) - AM
VAsp (2) - KL, Skye
bryndy (1) - cdo

Missing: @StayingPositive2017, @MixedAnimals77, @allieh8607, @SnowshoeDog143, @bryndiana.jones, @fromthebox

15/21

Deadline 12am EST (~4.5 hours)

2ae7f1264ad5752dfd18c52d4bd1e687.jpg
 
cdoconn said:
Essentially they're flags that basically say that if VA is alive at end-game, it's bad. They're reminders. Because at end-game there will be one wolf, one villager, and one villager (assuming VA is village) that's been sketchy since day 1. Wolves don't like to kill sketchy people because it's easier to lynch them and save themselves for a night. Make sense?
Click to expand...
Um what?
 
cdoconn said:
I’m confused what you’re confused about?
Click to expand...
I'm confused about:
1) why you have such a weirdly specific scenario there
2) why you're "suspicious" of someone you say in that post you think is just a sketchy villager
3) if you think he is not a sketchy villager, but is in fact wolfy, why you would wait to lynch someone who you think is wolfy
4) why "flags" for someone are contingent upon them reaching end game

Do you want me to go on?
 
fromthebox said:
***** off topic*****
SKOL!!!
If anyone is wondering what FTB is doing.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
Click to expand...

**************************************
SKOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

And I didn't even work today. Glorious.

Not thrilled with their game overall, but omg what a finish.
**************************************
 
SnowshoeDog143 said:
Quick response on my break. Will comment more later on the day after work. I'm looking at skye, mixy, and mel so far today. But I haven't iso'd many people. @Trilt I am always a hedger. You should know that's why I get lynched every single game. And yes, I would go to a coffee shop just to ww when I'm vanilla village 😛
Click to expand...
Perhaps something to work on, yanno. 😉

Just waiting for an argument from ya.
 
Sketch points to all of the following:
FTB has is still not contributing all that much substance, but has made some appearances to make little comments. She has not been too helpful overall which makes me think that maybe she is taking a backseat so as to not post with any inconsistencies or cannot come up with much about the other players (I mean no offense).

VA is a bit of an oddball, but is somewhat humorous at times. Thus far he/she has only contributed opinions on KL and Mel, and I don’t understand why if you think KL is so certain a wolf, why you wouldn’t just lynch them?

Skye you have yet to post any of your own thoughts today

Stella said she would be more active today, but has yet to really say all that much and this is D3

Killerleaf has not posted all that much content, but I am willing to vote elsewhere because others seem more sketchy to me.
 
Cray and I have briefly chatted in PMs enough for me to have cooled down over her earlier posts in response to mine. That's not to say I'm completely forgetting about her but for now there are people I find sketchier than her.

Would really like to hear more from @Animal Midwife and @fromthebox .
I'm used to AM being a lot more aggressive on the game thread, as several other people have pointed out. Was willing to give her a pass during D1, maybe even D2 but it is now D3 and she's voted Skye both today and yesterday with minimal pressure. I'm curious who besides Skye she think may be a wolf?
FTB pops in periodically with either fluff posts or things that aren't terribly helpful or that don't contribute much...can we get some player analysis or anything from you please?
My vote is most likely going towards one of those two.
 
my thoughts about crayons is that she is consistent with past impressions of her vilkage play-- lots of comments at weird hours. so I am leaning she is villager.

Mel seems to act the same no matter which side he is on...loud, pushy, arrogant, and sometimes with off the wall references. just not sure about him. I can see him as wolf and as villager.

AM has been quieter than usual. others have said this may be because she is wolfy; I am wondering if maybe just weekend busy? maybe keep an eye in future.
 
MixedAnimals77 said:
Can I help address any of my wolfy points I've accumulated from today?

In addition to everything else.
I really feel like something is up with AM she's not being her super tunnel like self so it definitely seems weird and will be watching closely if I live. Jboo seems like wolf again, she made very silly mistakes when she was wolf last game and seems to be like that again. I don't like that Lawper came in and did all this "hi" stuff got a few lynch votes for themselves and left, it feels like greeney from last game she was wolf, so probably won't move my vote from here unless I have to for self-preservation. I didn't like bryndiana's response to LIS on her sketch list, you can determine some people you find sketchy even if you're not voting for them. Not sure how I feel about the hydra but will watch over the next few days. VA, killerleaf, and sky are all posting non helpful fluff, unsure if noobness, post restrictions, etc. so will keep on watch list.
Click to expand...

So mixy had a lot of "insightful" but not really analysis D1 and this post where she pretty much says everyone is sketchy. I don't find many original thoughts from her and so she is one of my top wolf picks.

Crayola227 said:
The casual mention of a D1 spreadsheet - I know many of you keep notes and such, but it just feels too much like "look what a helpful villager I am." I've seen a wolf give us vote tally lists. When you have something to give village, do it, fine. But the and some other stuff isn't ringing true for me. Not just tunneling, I'm just calling them as I read the posts.
Click to expand...

Hmm I think this is a good thought. cdo's long list D1 and false bandwagon vote could be wolfy, but I'm actually getting mostly village vibes from her posts (and yes I finally read them ya'll)

Trilt said:
Perhaps something to work on, yanno. 😉

Just waiting for an argument from ya.
Click to expand...

Sorry got off work and then had to find a place in my house with wifi so I could read more. Mel I have points for because AM felt like he was acting similar to games he's wolfed in, vmh made a comment about how he tries to feel out who is most sketch and start a vote against them as a wolf (which he has seemed to do by switching his votes to someone with a reasoning they typically get lynched for or someone who is already leading). I don't think him and mixy are both wolves because of something mixy said yesterday where she quoted mel a lot which I don't think a noob wolf would do. But I was totally wrong about mel/dy interaction last time mel was a wolf, so not much to that. hmmm

lynch mel
 
killerleaf said:
my thoughts about crayons is that she is consistent with past impressions of her vilkage play-- lots of comments at weird hours. so I am leaning she is villager.
Click to expand...
She did the same thing as a wolf. Wolves generally attempt to keep up their village style if it’s something that a big change from it would be noticed. Because it would be noticed. I don’t think that Crayola posting lots of comments and posting at weird hours has anything to do with her affiliation since when she was a wolf she did the same thing.
 
Unlynch Capri
Lynch Snowy

For previously stated reasons + preservation. Y'all are making weak arguments for my lynch, reevaluate if you are just lynching me on feels or if you have some concrete sketchiness.
 
ski--great point. just when I think I have something figured out I realize I dont!
 
bryndiana.jones said:
Sketch points to all of the following:
FTB has is still not contributing all that much substance, but has made some appearances to make little comments. She has not been too helpful overall which makes me think that maybe she is taking a backseat so as to not post with any inconsistencies or cannot come up with much about the other players (I mean no offense).

VA is a bit of an oddball, but is somewhat humorous at times. Thus far he/she has only contributed opinions on KL and Mel, and I don’t understand why if you think KL is so certain a wolf, why you wouldn’t just lynch them?

Skye you have yet to post any of your own thoughts today

Stella said she would be more active today, but has yet to really say all that much and this is D3

Killerleaf has not posted all that much content, but I am willing to vote elsewhere because others seem more sketchy to me.
Click to expand...
That's mainly because the people I've agreed with others on being sketch haven't responded at all. I asked Stella to explain his/her logic and got nothing.
 
SnowshoeDog143 said:
Mel I have points for because AM felt like he was acting similar to games he's wolfed in
Click to expand...
Can you find this? Sorry, I quickly iso'd AM and don't see it but could just be missing.
SnowshoeDog143 said:
vmh made a comment about how he tries to feel out who is most sketch and start a vote against them as a wolf
Click to expand...
...is this not what villagers do? :bored:
 
Trilt said:
100% hedge
Click to expand...
I said this because the last speed game I played with her, I had her as village right away when she was a wolf. I just am not confident about reading her correctly. Now I have her at a village lean because she is so obsessed with mel and tunneling is usually more common as village. But same thing, I don't want what happened last game where I put her in village when she's been a wolf all along.

Trilt said:
Throwaway, then no further pushing.
Click to expand...

Yeah probably should have pushed allie more, but her quote about lurking to not be lynched for something dumb made me feel bad for her because she has gotten a lot of flak and killed for one dumb D1 post in the last few games I've played with her. She sounded like a frusturated villager. The one wolfy thing I have for her at the moment is some post where she was trying to make the wolfy excuse of "I'd rather be lynched for ____ instead of what I am being lynched for"

Trilt said:
This caught my eye that day because it's... not necessarily the type of thing I think of a vanilla Snowy doing. Could be wrong, sure, but it pinged a little note in my head to consider her as wolf or PR. I'm suspicious that this game is very vanilla (as explained above), so it nudges a bit wolfy now that I'm tunneling. 😛
Click to expand...

Unlike the rest of the Dubz family, I way more prefer to village so it actually be more likely I'd do this as village then wolf but wifom to you I realize.

Trilt said:
Can you explain your nohika village lean? And precisely what pushed you to Mixy?
Click to expand...

Already explained mixy. For nohika: I feel like a villager is more likely to make a joke vote or try to make a strategy vote D1 then just a vote because they are annoyed by someone. Retalitory voting mostly makes me think village-y. But AM's comment about nohika usually getting angrier/annoyed as village being lynched is interesting.

Trilt said:
Pocket hedge?
Click to expand...

I don't even know what the hedge you saw in this post was.

Trilt said:
Hedge and a bandwagon vote...
Click to expand...

Or this. And lawper wasn't a bandwagon when I lynched them.



vetmedhead said:
I would be okay with a sky lynch, a capri lynch, or a snowy lynch.

Lynch snowy for now since of the three I think they have given the least satisfactory response to lynch pressure in terms of addressing issues that have been brought up with her play.

Also, for reference, I do want to hear more from snowy about most of what was already brought up about Snowy's play, but I also want to hear more about:

The fact that most of your reads above are related to how much you like the person or how much you agree with them rather than your interpretation of their play style thus far

And the fact that your defense for being semi-asked about it was that you're just lazy and you'll get to reading better later
Click to expand...

bryndy is the only one I said I liked on this list (but I mean I like most everyone else don't worry 😉). KL and VA I decided are more nooby then wolfy sounding. Pippy seems village to me which scares me because usually when she sounds like that she pocket wolfs me. Trilt I've got as neutral, but I'm having a hard time seeing her kill LIS off N1 especially when he thought she was likely village. Iso'ing AM's posts, I actually think she sounds normal and I'm not sure what I was sketched out about the other day. Allie is still in neutral territory. ftb and stella seem village but not much to go off. In general maybe I have to many people with village reads for a D3 analysis.
 
Also, Sky has a lot of posts that look like they are trying to sound like analysis, but are actually just stating facts. This makes them one of my top sketchy people, but I lynched lawper for the same thing yesterday and they were village, so might just be a noob thing?
 
allieh8607 said:
Would really like to hear more from @Animal Midwife and @fromthebox .
I'm used to AM being a lot more aggressive on the game thread, as several other people have pointed out. Was willing to give her a pass during D1, maybe even D2 but it is now D3 and she's voted Skye both today and yesterday with minimal pressure. I'm curious who besides Skye she think may be a wolf?
FTB pops in periodically with either fluff posts or things that aren't terribly helpful or that don't contribute much...can we get some player analysis or anything from you please?
My vote is most likely going towards one of those two.
Click to expand...

I'm getting a dodgey vibe from Skye and it's really bothering me. I'd also like to hear more from FTB, Aspargaus, and nokia.
 
Trilt said:
Can you find this? Sorry, I quickly iso'd AM and don't see it but could just be missing.

...is this not what villagers do? :bored:
Click to expand...

vetmedhead said:
Having wolfed with you in the last game I know you like to spend some time finding other players who are suspicious enough for you to draw up lynches on later in the game when you or another wolf are under fire. This post feels a little bit too much like suspicion farming and I'm keeping my eye on you
Click to expand...

This is what I meant... It seems like he's been doing a lot of this this game.

Animal Midwife said:
It scares me when you say stuff like this Mel.
Click to expand...

Animal Midwife said:
It feels similar to what you said in TLM and MI game.
Click to expand...

And these are the AM quotes I remembered.

Maybe I'm just bitter and tunnelling because mel called something I said a blatant wolf tell and voted me but then changed his vote when no one else was voting me yesterday, which is like a repeat of what he did in the MI game.
 
Melchizedek said:
Unlynch Capri
Lynch Snowy

For previously stated reasons + preservation. Y'all are making weak arguments for my lynch, reevaluate if you are just lynching me on feels or if you have some concrete sketchiness.
Click to expand...

The thing is whenever it's you being lynched, all the reasons are "weak" and when it's someone you want to lynch your reasons are always "strong and reasonable"...🙄🙄🙄
 
SnowshoeDog143 said:
The thing is whenever it's you being lynched, all the reasons are "weak" and when it's someone you want to lynch your reasons are always "strong and reasonable"...🙄🙄🙄
Click to expand...
Except for your and Meats point that I cultivate mislynches as a wolf, I haven't heard any good case. And here's the thing thats also what wolf-hunting looks like.
 
SnowshoeDog143 said:
And these are the AM quotes I remembered.

Maybe I'm just bitter and tunnelling because mel called something I said a blatant wolf tell and voted me but then changed his vote when no one else was voting me yesterday, which is like a repeat of what he did in the MI game.
Click to expand...

I was half-joking when I said that. Mel seems pretty normal to me otherwise in PMs.
 
Last edited:
Karabiner13 said:
About 2 hours remaining. Make sure to meet minimum requirements
My lightning bolt throwing hand is getting mighty itchy. I might forget to send you a warning first before a replacement or smiting
(unless you've already been warned. Then all bets are off)
Click to expand...

***********
Why would you warn people??? Isn't that what the rules of the game were for?
***********
 
OK trying to catch up on thread.
Mel has mentioned previously that he has a background theory he is working on in PM. Have him at village lean currently. It would seem he is working through that rather than just waffling.
 
Melchizedek said:
Except for your and Meats point that I cultivate mislynches as a wolf, I haven't heard any good case. And here's the thing thats also what wolf-hunting looks like.
Click to expand...

Sigh. Okay I went back to point out you jumping from one easy vote everyday to another and found you were the first person to point out (or at least lynch) bryndy for unoriginal thoughts. Though I think bryndy is more neutral-village leaning right now, I think that was a good point people were lynching her for. And if AM and trilt have you village maybe I'm just tunnelling.

unlynch mel
lynch mixy
 
ugh. Something feels off though. There's a good chance I'll come back to mel. (look at me hedging trilt - would you rather have me tunnel him?)
 
SnowshoeDog143 said:
Sigh. Okay I went back to point out you jumping from one easy vote everyday to another and found you were the first person to point out (or at least lynch) bryndy for unoriginal thoughts. Though I think bryndy is more neutral-village leaning right now, I think that was a good point people were lynching her for. And if AM and trilt have you village maybe I'm just tunnelling.

unlynch mel
lynch mixy
Click to expand...
You do realize you just put yourself tied for first now, right?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
40K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
32K
Clem J
Clem J
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
PokeWWon: A Wild Kanto Adventure - Champs Season 12 Practice Game Thread
87 88 89 90 91
Replies
5K
Views
46K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
supershorty
GGoats ThWWee: Here It GGoats Again - GAME THREAD
93 94 95 96 97
Replies
5K
Views
40K
vampyrica
vampyrica
Animal Midwife
Matrix - Game Thread
77 78 79 80 81
Replies
4K
Views
78K
samac
samac
Top