X-Files: The TWWuth is OWWt There - Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Can you explain, in the context where I agree with @SARdoghandler that Clem got a 1x kill? What kind of power would be enough to balance that 3P?

It wouldnt be balanced , lol.

Like, just compare a 3P with only a manipulative and one kill.

Against a pack of two that kills every night. Who do you think is more likely to win? Its not balanced.

3p if they are alone they *need* to have more juice or be more of a threat. Like how does it makes sense that RDR role was more focused to aliens if they were already that weak compared to having a mafia of 2?

I dont know if this is site culture difference or something but this is pretty basic mafia balance that someone is just skipping all over here
 
Never unless it's an open set up. You don't know who's lying and whether the mods have given all info. Those are dangerous assumptions at any time but now they are misleading to try too get people to sus me after I've put in enough work to likely nail down nearly the exact pack

And making flavor assumptions is okay?

And yesterday your pairing analysis was that QQ was in every pack. I directed you to a wolf, and now your analysis is that I should be on every pack.

Like sorry but doesnt feel like you are nailing every pack and more so trying to use the pairing analysis to paint as "objective" a misyeet. You are not taking game context into account, and are skipping game balance in a huge swing just to push agenda
 
Like Im sorry but voting me here is Crazy work.

And I know its highly likely I have 2 wolves on me or something but please? There is a town there that needs to wake up.

And me probably being harsh on this doesnt do me favors but I really do feel like this is basic mafia stuff and cant avoid be a little bit bewildered by this narrative
 
Also I would like to point out that SAR has been tunneling spurs since Day 2, but Fx started and suddenly Sar hasnt sussed spurs a single time, and had him at arms lenght. And now they are voting together . Qq>Clem>now me . In sync


@Animal Midwife why are you so sure that SAR is town?
 
And yesterday your pairing analysis was that QQ was in every pack. I directed you to a wolf, and now your analysis is that I should be on every pack.
Yesterday my analysis was based on packs of 3. Today it's based on a pack of two. Coupled with unpairings from yesterday, you now make more sense than QQ. I am continuously reevaluating to solve this, as I should add village to avoid a sweep.

I appreciate that your agenda right now relies on discrediting me and my arguments but I've put in the work that hopefully speaks for itself to the remaining village
 
Sigh. I should actually look at this huh?

@Santygrass why SAR over AM?

Because AM spearheaded Clem yesterday. While Sar cleared Clem based on.... *Check notes* pure vibes.

Yesterday in V!QQ scenarios Sar push was gane losing, and I know them pushing against me is game losing. So yeah Late Game Sar is just them switching on the agenda to finish the game
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Well my day is starting now so I won't be around except for brief check ins until close. I think I've made a clear argument as to why it's Santy. I hope everyone will look at our posts today and consider who sounds more like a cornered wolf

I've put in a ton of work to try to solve this and I hope everyone will take it into consideration.

Hope everyone has a good day! I'm sending good vibes in the hopes it also pays off for my already-fully-booked day 😂
 
My day is starting as well, and it's busy.

I will mull things over. But I do agree, this reminds me of Santy when I saw him cornered in Supernatural. And I agree he has good compatibility with other players. Maybe this time I'm jumping in SAR's cozy pockets.
 
*makes logical argument on why balance-wise this cant be a lone 3p*

Checks counter-arguments:

"He feels cornered"
"Cant trust mech, but the flavor points to it"



Amazing
 
And yeah , I have urgency? Lol?

If you yeet me village loses I will defend myself and will try my utmost to try to erase the scum pushing it.

Rn I think if QQ is in a pack the game is just cooked for village. So Im betting it that its SAR+ 1 in AM/Spurs . And whoever is town in that pair needs some *shaking*
 
We frequently have 3ps with no killing power at all here 🤷‍♀️

Also, to comment on this. Thats okay because 3p can always have more forgiving win conditions.

But here? Having an investigative to check if someone was alien? And another one secondary for more general purposes?

Like idk that should just scream that aliens are the main threat.

But instead y'all choosing to interpret a "there's more?" As (no more aliens, another threat) instead of (more aliens) because... And.... Yeah. Uhum. Reliable sources
 
Also I would like to point out that SAR has been tunneling spurs since Day 2, but Fx started and suddenly Sar hasnt sussed spurs a single time, and had him at arms lenght. And now they are voting together . Qq>Clem>now me . In sync


@Animal Midwife why are you so sure that SAR is town?
Shifting to Clem when she could have stayed on QQ.
 
SAR did you ever clarify what happened to you at night?
Oh no I forgot actually

I had some type of investigative type notification n2 that I was being watched. It doesn't seem to fit with any of the claimed roles so it's either another role that is being hidden or it may have been genny the night she died, pending OoO

I just got home but still have to get the kid to bed, I'll try to be around before close
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad