You know, according to my interview, this merger ACGME/AOA is actually detrimental to osteopathic students, because they're more likely going to take MD over DO. It increases the amount of residency spots available to MD students that were previously only held for DO students. If anything, this may make it worse.
The problem with all of this is that even in schools that aren't as new as BCOM, the curriculum is constantly changing. I know that in LECOM, the opening class for Bradenton did horribly in their boards. In the subsequent years, the students were able to excel much better because they changed their curriculum. This was even talked about during my interview there. The director of the program even said that there were a lot of hiccups in the first year. Sometimes, it isn't a good thing to be the first especially when you're paying about $200k for your education.
This is just my opinion, but if it is the only school I got into, of course I would attend.
I'm even worried about CUSOM. I heard stories about how residencies will not take students from provisionally accredited schools, and waited until they became fully accredited before accepting students. I don't remember which thread this was in, but one student had to wait a couple years before he could get into a residency because his school became fully accredited that year.