2022-2023 Meharry

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Stats do matter, some schools won’t even consider applicants if stats aren’t up to par. So I think it’s fair to ask.
Exactly. It’s an anonymous forum. No one is trying to put you on blast or find out who you are or question if you’re qualified to receive an acceptance/interview. For me, when I asked it was just to gauge what Mcat score/gpa’s they are looking at right now in order to gauge where I potentially stand with the school.
 
Exactly. Stats matter a lot in this process and they don’t have time to read 9,000 stories, lol. I do believe Meharry does more of a holistic review than most other medical schools.
I mean they do a real per-secondary screen... and their average MCAT and GPA are well bellow the national average, likely because of a true holistic review.
 
Exactly. It’s an anonymous forum. No one is trying to put you on blast or find out who you are or question if you’re qualified to receive an acceptance/interview. For me, when I asked it was just to gauge what Mcat score/gpa’s they are looking at right now in order to gauge where I potentially stand with the school.
True, that said there are some toxic people posting here and there, tho a minority these days.
 
True, that said there are some toxic people posting here and there, tho a minority these days.
I've seen the toxic posts lol. Also those students who are like omg guys I'm facing the biggest crisis of my existence I have 520 MCAT but only 3.8 GPA and 37 years of clinical experience I don't know if I should take a chance and apply this cycle -_-
 
I've seen the toxic posts lol. Also those students who are like omg guys I'm facing the biggest crisis of my existence I have 520 MCAT but only 3.8 GPA and 37 years of clinical experience I don't know if I should take a chance and apply this cycle -_-

 
I dont understand why everyone always ask what eachothers stats are. No two applications are the same and no two stories are the same
Stats can make a difference! Some schools begin by looking at applicants who scored above a certain MCAT score and/ or have a certain GPA. For example. I submitted my secondary to a school (low-tier) very late. However, I was above their MCAT and GPA average by a lot. Because of this, I earned an II almost immediately. During my interview, the prof interviewing me kept saying how great my academics are.
Now, you are correct that stats are just one component of the holistic review. Just remember that stats can be a very big part of it. So, if you are willing to share, I would appreciate your answer to your stats and if you are IS or OOS. Once again, congrats on your II! Good luck with your interview and your cycle!
 
Last edited:
Stats can make a difference! Some schools begin by looking at applicants who scored above a certain MCAT score and/ or have a certain GPA. For example. I submitted my secondary to a school (low-tier) very late. However, I was above their MCAT and GPA average by a lot. Because of this, I earned an II almost immediately. During my interview, the prof interviewing me kept saying how great my academics are.
Now, you are correct that stats are just one component of the holistic review. Just remember that stats can be a very big part of it. So, if you are willing to share, I would appreciate your answer to your stats and if you are IS or OOS. Once again, congrats on your II! Good luck with your interview and your cycle!
You are correct that that can happen. But idk i guess im just different. I feel like im not getting anything out of someone tellin me their stats when people stats be low and they still get an interview and acceptance .
 
Exactly. It’s an anonymous forum. No one is trying to put you on blast or find out who you are or question if you’re qualified to receive an acceptance/interview. For me, when I asked it was just to gauge what Mcat score/gpa’s they are looking at right now in order to gauge where I potentially stand with the school.
You already know that by looking at MSAR though.
 
I mean they do a real per-secondary screen... and their average MCAT and GPA are well bellow the national average, likely because of a true holistic review.
Stats do matter, some schools won’t even consider applicants if stats aren’t up to par. So I think it’s fair to ask.
Right and thats why they screen out.. and its also about being realistic . You know youre definitely not getting in anywhere with under 490 cause only one do schools specifically say they screens at 490. And if you look at msar you will see the minn and highest stats every accepted and their percentiles.so i really dont see the point in asking folks. If you know they got an interview or acceptance chances are their stats were good enough. I feel like its an unnecessary way to either be nosey, or some elite type thinking “ aw no way they got into xyz with these stats when i have blah blah blah”. Just know they were good enough and their story was realistic and compelling
 
Can we all collectively take a chill pill, yes, I said it, a chill pill. With a large glass of water, so large that we are at borderline hyponatremia. This process is already excruciatingly painful let’s just go back to sending only good vibes. Screw stats.
Many acceptances have been rolling in lately and I feel like everyone is getting jumpy. The emotions are running high right now. Yes everybody relax!
 
My friends, can we just leave it at: if you want to know about stats, ask. If you don’t want to know about stats, don’t ask. If someone asks you and you don’t want to share, then don’t. If you want to give someone an idea, but don’t want to share exact numbers just say 49X or 50X or whatever. If you want to give an idea, but don’t want to give a number attached to you at all, then give a LizzyM. If you don’t want to share publicly, just DM them. There are so many ways that info can be shared. If you care about stats, you ARE allowed to ask questions if you want, just don’t be an dingus about it, I’ve seen at least 1 post that was like “oh you must be URM if you got in with those stats” or “I didn’t know they even interviewed people with those stats”. To those of you who don’t care and are just like “screw stats”, you are also allowed to feel that way, but don’t come at people who literally just want to ask questions and gather info because that is equally shameful. We are all stressed out, this is hard on everyone, we all have insecurities about ourselves, our apps, our numbers. I question everyday whether I’m worth it, whether I deserve to be in medical school, whether I can even compare to 99% of applicants on this forum, and I KNOW I’m not the only one. The least we can all do is treat each other with kindness and respect.
 
Hi all. I spoke with two students attending Meharry and both did not have great things to say. They also mentioned that there is a possibility for academic probation in 2023....has anyone heard any of this??
Somebody posted an article talking about Meharry being put on probation. There are a few articles online but they are very vague! What are some of the things the 2 students mentioned?
 
Hmm. Those are all important aspects that this institution should have. The letter about probation was vague and unsettled my spirit.

Also having a low match rate percentage disturbs me.
 
Disorganization, lack of transparency with grades and rankings, new curriculum issues, lack of resources and faculty support.
Meharry should move to a P/F system so students don't feel cheated when it comes to grades. Many med schools use this system and students are satisfied. I hope they can resolve these issues!
 
I don’t want to minimize the very valid concerns some of you have raised, but I’ll just share my perspective. On paper, I am not a competitive medical school applicant, however, I am capable of becoming an empathetic primary care physician. If Meharry is willing to look past my imperfections and give me an opportunity to accomplish my dream, I will look past their imperfections as well. I knew what I was getting myself into applying to an HBCU. Since their inception, these schools have never had the funding, endowments, and support their counterparts have. Meharry is taking a chance on me that other MD programs wouldn’t. Furthermore, their mission is 100% in line with my professional and personal values. I totally respect anyone who feels otherwise, just offering my perspective.
 
Anyone who recieved a II recently that submitted last week? Because isn’t the turnaround time usually quick?
 
I didn't submit last week. I submitted my secondary 10/10 and got by interview invite 10 days later. Hope that helps...
Do you think it’s a bad sign if I submitted around that time and still haven’t gotten an II? I completed MHS in 2022 so I’m not sure if that’s what the issue might be.
 
Do you think it’s a bad sign if I submitted around that time and still haven’t gotten an II? I completed MHS in 2022 so I’m not sure if that’s what the issue might be.
To be completely honest, I'm not sure how that impacts the admissions process. Have you tried reading the threads from the previous years to see when the MHS students were interviewed?
 
Do you think it’s a bad sign if I submitted around that time and still haven’t gotten an II? I completed MHS in 2022 so I’m not sure if that’s what the issue might be.
You’re Meharry alumni since you graduated the MHS program. If you have questions you should be reaching out to admissions office, they already know you and should respond. Include your M number in the email or just visit the admissions office if you’re still on campus. PM me if you have any questions about who to talk to. Im a current M2 at Meharry and also did MHS. Don’t be afraid to use your connections to try and get answers on your application status. That’s one of the perks of doing the MHS program.
 
Last edited:
I don’t want to minimize the very valid concerns some of you have raised, but I’ll just share my perspective. On paper, I am not a competitive medical school applicant, however, I am capable of becoming an empathetic primary care physician. If Meharry is willing to look past my imperfections and give me an opportunity to accomplish my dream, I will look past their imperfections as well. I knew what I was getting myself into applying to an HBCU. Since their inception, these schools have never had the funding, endowments, and support their counterparts have. Meharry is taking a chance on me that other MD programs wouldn’t. Furthermore, their mission is 100% in line with my professional and personal values. I totally respect anyone who feels otherwise, just offering my perspective.
Sorry I’m late to this. Isn’t Meharry a private institution? So what public funding are they expecting? Also other HBCU universities aren’t on probation. I also think we should demand more quality facilities and education from HBCU. Everything don’t have to be a struggle. We shouldn’t accept mediocrity. Making excuses for them is not going to help them learn and grow. Disclaimer: I’m Canadian so I may not understand some of the issues of HBCU raised, but if after over 100 years, a school cannot offer quality education and facilities to their students or found ways to increase their endowment or solicit for funding as a private institution, then they need to step back and develop a better strategy.
 
Sorry I’m late to this. Isn’t Meharry a private institution? So what public funding are they expecting? Also other HBCU universities aren’t on probation. I also think we should demand more quality facilities and education from HBCU. Everything don’t have to be a struggle. We shouldn’t accept mediocrity. Making excuses for them is not going to help them learn and grow. Disclaimer: I’m Canadian so I may not understand some of the issues of HBCU raised, but if after over 100 years, a school cannot offer quality education and facilities to their students or found ways to increase their endowment or solicit for funding as a private institution, then they need to step back and develop a better strategy.
Its really not that simple. There is a lot to unpack on this issue, but I'll just mention a couple things.

Most HBCUs are underfunded. Established PWIs have graduated thousands of alumni who have been providing donations in the millions for over a century. HBCUs on the other hand were created because blacks were not afforded the opportunity to attend higher institutions. Most of their early graduates were not in a position to donate because they earned very little. This is why private HBCUs depend more on tuition and funding than PWI, and yes, even private institutions are eligible for grants.

I'm not making excuses but if you understand U.S. history comparing a PWI with an HBCU established at the same time is just unrealistic. Its like asking a sprinter who loses a track race why he finished last even though his competitors had a 1 minute head-start.

Also wanted to add, other HBCU institutions have been on probation before, a couple have unfortuneately closed. Also, non-HBCU residency programs have also been on probation. This isn't unique to Meharry.
 
So what does being on probation actually mean for prospective students and 3rd year students applying to residency?


How is this viewed?


I would appreciate answers from current students.


Thank you.
 
Last edited:
Copy copy.

I just want to hear the experiences of current student (specifically higher levels) who are undergoing the application process. Also, for students who are currently completing STEP studying, how much support are you receiving from faculty?

With the changes in the curriculum and the schemes established, do students find that helpful and in alignment with how STEP exams are formatted? I’ve heard that organ systems help and improve board scores.

Should I just call the school? Or ask my potential interviewer? Just don’t want them to be annoyed.
 
Its really not that simple. There is a lot to unpack on this issue, but I'll just mention a couple things.

Most HBCUs are underfunded. Established PWIs have graduated thousands of alumni who have been providing donations in the millions for over a century. HBCUs on the other hand were created because blacks were not afforded the opportunity to attend higher institutions. Most of their early graduates were not in a position to donate because they earned very little. This is why private HBCUs depend more on tuition and funding than PWI, and yes, even private institutions are eligible for grants.

I'm not making excuses but if you understand U.S. history comparing a PWI with an HBCU established at the same time is just unrealistic. Its like asking a sprinter who loses a track race why he finished last even though his competitors had a 1 minute head-start.

Also wanted to add, other HBCU institutions have been on probation before, a couple have unfortuneately closed. Also, non-HBCU residency programs have also been on probation. This isn't unique to Meharry.
Ok, thanks for the detailed explanation.
 
Copy copy.

I just want to hear the experiences of current student (specifically higher levels) who are undergoing the application process. Also, for students who are currently completing STEP studying, how much support are you receiving from faculty?

With the changes in the curriculum and the schemes established, do students find that helpful and in alignment with how STEP exams are formatted? I’ve heard that organ systems help and improve board scores.

Should I just call the school? Or ask my potential interviewer? Just don’t want them to be annoyed.
I would definitely ask about the Next Step curriculum in your interview. I did. I also asked my interviewer how effective it was etc. Totally reasonable. As far as asking about probation, maybe ask current students who have posted on this thread.
 
"Okay so about the curriculum, it’s systems based meaning we go through each body system during our m1 and m2 years. the change in curriculum happened about 6 years ago and apparently it’s been really good bc STEP scores have increased alot bc of it so that means more ppl are matching into their desired specialties. And being on probation rn isn’t affected much at all. We’re still able to sign up for board exams, do classes regularly, and apply to residency. They’re just addressing some small things that students complained of in the past such as wifi issues, lack of study spaces, etc. It’s honestly a good thing tho bc those things are being addressed very seriously and within the next 2 years, they have assured us that we will be taken off probation so it’s not really a reason to worry"

This is what a friend that goes there said to me

Hope this helps clarifies. I am also having a meeting with a different student, i will post the feedback once i hear back
 
"Okay so about the curriculum, it’s systems based meaning we go through each body system during our m1 and m2 years. the change in curriculum happened about 6 years ago and apparently it’s been really good bc STEP scores have increased alot bc of it so that means more ppl are matching into their desired specialties. And being on probation rn isn’t affected much at all. We’re still able to sign up for board exams, do classes regularly, and apply to residency. They’re just addressing some small things that students complained of in the past such as wifi issues, lack of study spaces, etc. It’s honestly a good thing tho bc those things are being addressed very seriously and within the next 2 years, they have assured us that we will be taken off probation so it’s not really a reason to worry"

This is what a friend that goes there said to me

Hope this helps clarifies. I am also having a meeting with a different student, i will post the feedback once i hear back
Wifi and study spaces got the school put on watch? I find this unlikely....
 
Wifi and study spaces got the school put on watch? I find this unlikely....
Well this isn't the first time i heard about the wifi and study space thing. I read it somewhere online. While this might not be the only reason, those are part of it for sure. Also if students have been complaining about it for a while, i want to believe it is enough to raise a flag because these things are amenities NEEDED to succeed as irrelevant it might seem to appear. The curriculum clearly isn't the issue here
 
Well this isn't the first time i heard about the wifi and study space thing. I read it somewhere online. While this might not be the only reason, those are part of it for sure. Also if students have been complaining about it for a while, i want to believe it is enough to raise a flag because these things are amenities NEEDED to succeed as irrelevant it might seem to appear. The curriculum clearly isn't the issue here
Usually being put on watch involves academics or more serious things. These first world problems such as Wifi have never been problems and I've attended community colleges and no-name universities. So it's just odd to me that the Wifi was so bad and never fixed that it rose to this level lol.
 
Hey guys, current M1 here. You can private message me or ask on here any questions and I'll do my best to respond in a timely manner. Regarding probation status, I can't speak on that because that incident occurred because of a few years' review before the current M1s time. Other than that, good luck to all who are currently applying. ( :
 
Usually being put on watch involves academics or more serious things. These first world problems such as Wifi have never been problems and I've attended community colleges and no-name universities. So it's just odd to me that the Wifi was so bad and never fixed that it rose to this level lol.
Definitely 1st world issues. I briefly read over the accrediation standards for DO schools and some of the factors included the Dean's updated CV and the square footage of specific rooms on the campus. There are a lot of technical standards, but in all fairness study space and wi-fi are very important considerations for medical students.
 
Definitely 1st world issues. I briefly read over the accrediation standards for DO schools and some of the factors included the Dean's updated CV and the square footage of specific rooms on the campus. There are a lot of technical standards, but in all fairness study space and wi-fi are very important considerations for medical students.
Tell that to Caribbean schools lol 😉
 
Talked with a friend and wanted to share this with y’all here.
I think the idea of being surrounded by more black individuals in medicine is breath taking. I hope to get the opportunity, because no matter where you go you have to be happy. My friend who goes to Emory Med, was happy because of the name. But she was very unhappy and miserable being one of 4 black students in her class. So I go to say, don’t just look at the name of the school. You don’t need anymore validation, go where makes you happy and don’t name chase. Because I promise no one will care about where you went, when your saving a patients lives. Of course every school is great, but you will be spending the next 4 years there! So be wise in your decision!
I digress
 
Top