CHOOSE YOUR OWWN III - Game Thread

[supershorty]

---

Members don't see this ad.

Oh, I see what you’re saying.

But I also don’t see what you’re saying because Wonder claimed late enough that there were plenty of town options to fakeclaim that would have been entirely safe (like vanilla town) or relatively safe given how many people had already claimed.

Ow, my brain. I need caffeine.

 

[Truenamer]

My only early morning thought is that I hope both Wonder and Lumi come back so we can talk to them more.

 

[supershorty]

I do think this makes me feel more confident in my Zenge read, though. Coming up with slightly off the wall theories is something I associate with village!Zenge much more than scum!Zenge. When he’s scumming, he usually goes for low hanging fruit and picks apart their posts.

I’m saying scumming because he’s not compatible with Chaos here, so wolfing isn’t appropriate to say, but I’m specifically referring to his wolf meta. His play in the SDN game didn't fit either of these descriptions, but that makes sense with what his wincon was.

 

[Lawpy]

Like, in my mind Wonder’s only real contribution was giving village a good alternative to Chaos, at a time when the Judas claim would have made village willing to look for somewhere else to vote.

Engaged

 

[Lawpy]

W/W.

Potentially a outright lie or more likely used for ability. I would expect Wonder to know outright that Lumi was lying about about the goo.

And maybe Chaos felt safe picking it for the fake claim, knowing his packmate had it in their roles.

Engaged

 

[Lawpy]

I’m brushing my teeth hi

Sleep pls

 

[Lawpy]

@Viscernable @Lawpy @potentialsheltervet

Current POE?

Currently thinking Truey, alissa, MKG

 

[Lawpy]

unless Lumi is also packmate

Unlikely

 

[WildZoo]

Unlikely

Wolf theater is fun though

 

[Lawpy]

I think it’s pretty hard to assume it would play out in Chaos’s favor.

Chaos claims Goo.
Lumi claims Goo.
Chaos says Lumi is lying.
Who does village believe?
From my perspective, without a compelling reason not to, I’m more inclined to believe Lumi, because why on earth would a wolf!Lumi counter claim Chaos there? If Lumi was wrong and Chaos was right, then Wolf!Lumi guaranteed themselves a D2 yeet.

So if village, following that logic, is more inclined to believe Lumi over Chaos, then Chaos fighting Lumi, even knowing Lumi is lying, doesn’t end well for Chaos.

Engaged

 

[supershorty]

Wolf theater is fun though

It is, but IIRC from champs, Lumi had self-metaed that scum theater was one of their weaker points and they don’t really like to do it as a result.

Self meta, WIFOM, but they were village when they claimed that, makes me more inclined to believe it.

 

[Lawpy]

Wolf theater is fun though

Too complex and unusual here since Lumis effectively buried chaos and chaos pretty much threw his hands up and readily admitted to fakeclaim

 

[WildZoo]

Too complex and unusual here since Lumis effectively buried chaos and chaos pretty much threw his hands up and readily admitted to fakeclaim

It wasn't really a serious suggestion Lawp. Hence the italics.

 

[Truenamer]

Too complex and unusual here since Lumis effectively buried chaos and chaos pretty much threw his hands up and readily admitted to fakeclaim

I agree, they did not feel like they were on the same side to me. Especially since there wasn't really any attention or pressure on either of them until that, it just seems so risky and unnecessary

 

[Truenamer]

It wasn't really a serious suggestion Lawp. Hence the italics.

Look, some of us may have missed things like italics when trying to squint through the thousands of new pages that appeared last night after all of us normal people went to sleep 😂

 

[WildZoo]

Look, some of us may have missed things like italics when trying to squint through the thousands of new pages that appeared last night after all of us normal people went to sleep 😂

Rood 😤

 

[Truenamer]

Rood 😤

I'm very normal, everyone stays up until 1:00 a.m. sewing a backpack

 

[Lawpy]

I mean, look at alley and some of the others, who are pretty much refusing to even consider the (IMO more likely) possibility of a town 5D chess move there. alley doesn’t even want to entertain the notion of it, she just wants to bury them because “lying bad.” Without thinking about that if Lumi’s claims are true, it’s a move that makes sense for a decent town PR to make to buy themselves more time to use it.

I somehow missed this. Thinking

 

[Lawpy]

Mostly I feel worse about Dubz because it seems very unusual for her to take a strong stand on genny so early, and I don’t agree with what she’s saying about genny. I would very much expect her to give it at least another day for The Genny Way to appear with genny playing imo pretty much to her usual standards, even with more content than some games where Dubz has been like “not seeing the genny way but too early to tell”

Hmm interesting

I have both as neutral currently

 

[Lawpy]

Will statistics for treats

*sends a toy*

 

[WildZoo]

Is Woxy in there for lack of village feels or for scum feels?
Why Alissa?

Realized I missed this post last night. I think I explained alissa later, Woxy is mostly lack of village feels.

 

[Viscernable]

Me to me: Don't mention the beginnings of a blocc, it'll just spook her more and she'll put you in the block

Me to me:

Stop being so spooky

 

[WildZoo]

I have both as neutral currently

Weak, though I guess I can't expect much else when not even the holder of the reading card has moved me out of neutral, even with almost 250 posts. Y'all need to try harder 😛

 

[WildZoo]

Stop being so spooky

Vissy pls, spooky is 50% of my personality

 

[Lawpy]

Okay, but now I’m circled back around to not understanding Chaos’ reaction there if we’re in a world where he knew Lumi was lying.

I’ve been stuck on this train of thought all night, it’s just not clicking into place for me.

The rest of Zenge’s theory makes sense to me and would explain some of the things I had questions about, but I’m really struggling to make this part make sense in my head.

I see the case where chaos and Wondy are compatible but if Lumi is scum, they aren’t compatible with either of them

 

[Lawpy]

Weak, though I guess I can't expect much else when not even the holder of the reading card has moved me out of neutral, even with almost 250 posts. Y'all need to try harder 😛

Phasing wolf nightmares

 

[Lawpy]

My only early morning thought is that I hope both Wonder and Lumi come back so we can talk to them more.

Agreed

 

[Lawpy]

I do think this makes me feel more confident in my Zenge read, though. Coming up with slightly off the wall theories is something I associate with village!Zenge much more than scum!Zenge. When he’s scumming, he usually goes for low hanging fruit and picks apart their posts.

I’m saying scumming because he’s not compatible with Chaos here, so wolfing isn’t appropriate to say, but I’m specifically referring to his wolf meta. His play in the SDN game didn't fit either of these descriptions, but that makes sense with what his wincon was.

I can agree with this

 

[holdthemayo]

Subbing in for @Stagg737 is @holdthemayo​

AM finally got ahold of me. I’ll start catching up after work.


In the meantime , yeet Lawpy

 

[Lawpy]

Rough, only ordered where there are obvious spaces

Village lean:
shorty
lawpy
PSV

Zenge

True neutrals:
Alley
Genny
True
WZ
Alissa
mkg

POE: some variation of Wonder, lumi, chaos

Missing:
Me - for obvious reasons but I stand by my bulletproof townie affiliation claim
Stagg - no posts

Engaged

 

[WildZoo]

AM finally got ahold of me. I’ll start catching up after work.


In the meantime , yeet Lawpy

Hi mayo!

 

[Lawpy]

AM finally got ahold of me. I’ll start catching up after work.


In the meantime , yeet Lawpy

What pls

 

[Lawpy]

WO2 listing himself as missing in his reads amuses me

 

[Lawpy]

How come y'all are only excited to make ties outside of my games 😡

Madagascar pls?

 

[WildZoo]

Madagascar pls?

Oof

 

[Lawpy]

Because you’ve threatened The Big Death ™️ for your games numerous times

Engaged

 

[Lawpy]

And I really think we should yeet genny

Going to think on this calmly

 

[Lawpy]

why vote chaos versus lumi? Both at least if you believe me fake claimed village and lumi to my limited reading hasn't said their affiliation card even

Vote close in 30 mins and I am no where near finished reading this thread.

What are your thoughts so far?

 

[supershorty]

Madagascar pls?

Madagascar doesn’t count because I wasn’t going to murder gently remove to the cozy afterlife everyone in a tie in my first game, then no one would have signed up for my games again. Especially not a tie that would have taken out 25% of my roster.

 

[Lawpy]

I will never forget my noob game where the tie maker was also yeeted. I will not make a tie without knowing tie rules

I’m trying to remember… i’ll take a look soon

 

[Lawpy]

Madagascar doesn’t count because I wasn’t going to murder gently remove to the cozy afterlife everyone in a tie in my first game, then no one would have signed up for my games again.

Displeased

 

[Lawpy]

Madagascar doesn’t count because I wasn’t going to murder gently remove to the cozy afterlife everyone in a tie in my first game, then no one would have signed up for my games again.

What other games of yours did I play pls

 

[supershorty]

What other games of yours did I play pls

I forced you into participating in LaWWpy by offering tots real money to yeet you from tot chat so I could put you in the game, but I think Madagascar is the only one you actually signed up for 🤔

 

[Lawpy]

I forced you into participating in LaWWpy by offering tots real money to yeet you from tot chat so I could put you in the game, but I think Madagascar is the only one you actually signed up for 🤔

Displeased

 

[supershorty]

Displeased

By which part

 

[Lawpy]

By which part

both pls

*signs up to sub in a shorty game to fulfill the tie mission*

 

[Animal Midwife]

Night closed; results pending​

 

[Animal Midwife]

Stumped is @alissa14 Village 1x Diplomat (Village Enabler + Village 1x Diplomat)

Dead is @Lawpy Village Parrot (Village Seer + Wolf Parrot)

Dead is @potentialsheltervet Village Fruit Vendor (Vanillager + Village Fruit Vendor)

Dead is @supershorty Village Parrot (Village Mason/Lover + Village Parrot)
​

Roster
2. @WonderingStudent
3. @alleycat03
4. @genny
5. @WorthlessOxygen
6. @Truenamer
7. @WildZoo
7.7 @holdthemayo
8. @Zenge142
9. @Viscernable
Twelve. @mkg323
33. @LuminousLag

 

[Animal Midwife]

It is now Day 2.​

 

[Truenamer]

What the crap