- Joined
- Aug 9, 2015
- Messages
- 355
- Reaction score
- 490
One more final to go and my motivation is pretty much gone at this point. So close!
One more final to go and my motivation is pretty much gone at this point. So close!
I'm imagining someone creating a noose and strangling the dog instead of suturing it. That would be a fatal error, right?
Damn. Did the dog make it?Well. I once took in a dog on emergency that had been spayed, and the vet had ligated both ureters and partly ligated the caudal vena cava.
That was a fatal error.....
Damn. Did the dog make it?
Well, he said it was a fatal error so... I'm guessing not?
I can't imagine scooping up a ureter and ligating it Willy nilly. I hope it's not an easy thing to do.
Good point. Don't know where my brain went.
I also hope it's not easy to ligate the ureter and the caudal vena cava. This just made spays seems more terrifying than I thought they were...
I guess I just never really thought about it that way since a huge chunk of my shadowing/volunteering experience was in shelters. They make it seem very routine!Spays are very terrifying. You're expected to do a major abdominal surgery and ligate some major vessels in a 1-3" incision...no thank you.
Damn. Did the dog make it?
Yikes, how did that even happen? I'm definitely not looking forward to spays, there's too much crap in the abdominal cavity.Well. I once took in a dog on emergency that had been spayed, and the vet had ligated both ureters and partly ligated the caudal vena cava.
That was a fatal error.....
I've seen third-year surgery residents struggle with a spay.
I'm not saying 'be terrified'. It's a common procedure we all should be able to do. But don't let the 'routine' of it get you away from remembering that it's a major abdominal procedure. I'd rather do a GDV, a FB surgery, a cystotomy .... any of those over an older fat dog spay.
Yikes, how did that even happen? I'm definitely not looking forward to spays, there's too much crap in the abdominal cavity.![]()
Oh yeah, definitely. I think horrible mistakes happen all of the time, even with great practitioners. I would be absolutely gutted to know that I had done that to an animal, so I can't imagine how he felt to know that was his fault. I mean, there's nothing you can do beyond being more careful/mindful/attentive/whatever during spays from that point forward, learning from that error, but I think for many people that would definitely be a difficult mistake to swallow and move on from in a productive way without obsessing over it.Dunno. I wasn't there. His record noted that it was a "difficult" procedure with some "bleeding" and that he felt like some tissue tore.
Hard to say what happened.... badness, I guess. I mean, it's easy in isolation to say "holy **** how did that happen?!" but with thousands upon thousands of procedures done every year ... some go very badly in ways that seem to defy explanation. Just pray it isn't you. My real point in all that (in addition to "a spay isn't necessarily 'easy' or 'routine'") is that this guy is/was a good vet and STILL had something almost baffling bad happen that was 100% his fault. Whenever I'm tempted to start judging another vet, I remember that - good vet with a ****ty mistake. There but for the grace of god go I, etc.
I mean, no doubt he screwed up. And I'm sure he knows that. But he's an all-around good vet that does a good job.
As someone who does spays...the first point doesn't work unless you're next to the body wall not just pointed at it.Helping teach vet students how to do spays, the biggest helpers I had were:
- Turn the spay hook opening toward the body wall and slide it down to where the uterus should be before you make your grab. (If I could talk them into either closing their eyes or just doing it to humor me, they got it 90%+, especially if they had been frustrated and searching for quite a while.)
- Follow both directions. Bifurcation on one side and ovary on the other before you ligate or cut.
There was a lot more, but those 2 were the ones that helped a lot of frustrated or scared students. That and breathe.
We had a similar patient and the doctor had a doctor from another location come in to assist. I think it might have actually been a mastiff, can't remember. Perhaps a tiny incision shouldn't be expected in those cases 😵The words "10 year old 115 pound lab in for spay" makes me want to run away screaming and never look back.
Personally, I think vet students should learn to spay from an actual vet.
Guys, I highly doubt LotF was singlehandedly teaching students how to spay things. A tech giving tips when a student is frustrated and the vet is otherwise occupied seems pretty darn reasonable to me.
do you mean, yes, LIS? Because you quoted him then called me out...Yes Dy, I oversimplified for posting on a forum to agree with looking for landmarks.
And yes, if I was helping the vet was otherwise occupied and the student was getting frustrated to the point of walking away. Rather than let them just leave an education opportunity and a patient just lying on the table, I would step in. Get them to refocus and try a new approach. If they were scared, reminding them to either prove to themselves that they had things right (landmarks), or just allowing them the ability to decide (reminding them that they are the decision maker in this case) that they needed a larger incision than our doctor uses on a kitten and that it is not a competition and is ok.
There is a whole lot more advice that can be given, but that is relevant only to the student or unskilled surgeon in question at the moment it is needed, not here.
I was responding to you, and your quote of me and then went on to each of the other 2 quotes. I just didn't see a quick quote that made sense for me to quote and was just verifying I understood your point. It wasn't meant to be a call out, just letting you know I saw and understood.do you mean, yes, LIS? Because you quoted him then called me out...
Also, this post cheered me up a bit. I've been putting so much pressure on myself because I'm in the bottom half of my class and I hope to do go into zoo med. I can't exactly forget my goal in the meantime, but I need to stop obsessing over it.I don't know what specialty it is you are considering, but I've heard numerous times that who you know, references and your contacts are >> than GPA. Yes, should probably have as good of a GPA as you can to help get accepted to internships and residencies but don't downplay the importance of making connections which you are already doing. Hang in there, keep fighting the good fight and remember to have a little fun along the way. 🙂
I think like many things being able to make smaller incisions takes practice and a certain level of comfort. Some people have tons of experience with spays and aren't comfortable with smaller incisions and that's totally fine because incision size isn't exactly indicative of the skill needed to perform a spay, and on the other side of things there are probably plenty of people are very comfortable with small incisions who maybe shouldn't be based on their experience.I'm just glad to hear that practiced DVMs think it's okay to have a bigger incision. I've heard certain ex-bosses of mine crack jokes about new puppies/kittens/animals that went through a vet school surgery course, and how big their incisions are. It just kind of stuck with me that big incisions indicate lack of skill, but I'm comforted knowing that it was just a rude judgement on someone else's part.
My boyfriend's first cat had a pretty length incision. Guess what? In about two months, it was covered in fur.
To be honest, any surgery scares the bajeezus out of me. A great piece of advice I've gotten is to "never get comfortable."
Edit: Actually, anything with anesthesia scares the bajeezus out of me. I get to do a lot with the wildlife at my school, and I always get a little frustrated when people aren't paying attention or working efficiently while we've got a patient under iso for rads, IO catheters, whatever.
Yeah...I mean looking back, most of my pre-vet experience was in zoos, so I didn't get to see as many routine spays/neuters as I would have liked, so I don't know a ton about what they should look like. I think the first spay I ever saw was on a lion 😀I think like many things being able to make smaller incisions takes practice and a certain level of comfort. Some people have tons of experience with spays and aren't comfortable with smaller incisions and that's totally fine because incision size isn't exactly indicative of the skill needed to perform a spay, and on the other side of things there are probably plenty of people are very comfortable with small incisions who maybe shouldn't be based on their experience.
Honestly, as long as the patient's welfare isn't compromised and you aren't harvesting organs I think things like that come down to personal preference and people who judge based on something like that are probably quite picky.
I'm personally very used to seeing small incisions because I work in a high volume spay/neuter operation and our vet has done at least several dozen spays a week for years, so she's got that technique down and has tons of experience working from tiny incisions. Even with that I've seen her widen incisions many times for various reasons and she's always the first to tell clients that incision size doesn't say much about the quality of the surgery itself.
Yeah...I mean looking back, most of my pre-vet experience was in zoos, so I didn't get to see as many routine spays/neuters as I would have liked, so I don't know a ton about what they should look like. I think the first spay I ever saw was on a lion 😀
Guys, I highly doubt LotF was singlehandedly teaching students how to spay things.
I need to hang out with one of you guys who uses your fingers, I've just seriously had zero luck with that. Do you not use a hook in cats either?I didn't think she was. And her advice wasn't bad (though overly simplified).
But a student should learn surgery from a vet. I have heard wayyyyyyy too many bad tips (not in this case) regarding surgery from techs or non-tech, non-dvms. That's all. If a student is frustrated in surgery, the best way a tech can help is to go get a dvm. They don't have the knowledge base to know which advice is best given at which times.
This isn't some "oooo look at my degree, I'm better." I have learned a LOT from techs. I'm just saying that when it comes to something fairly serious like how to perform a surgical procedure - get your advice from someone appropriate.
Of course LoTF wasn't single handedly trying to teach anyone how to do a spay. And the actual advice - in this case - wasn't horrible.
(Though I still think spay hooks are a waste of time, but lots of vets love 'em.)
I need to hang out with one of you guys who uses your fingers, I've just seriously had zero luck with that. Do you not use a hook in cats either?
I guess I just can't get worked up about a tech telling students to breath and reiterating the normal tips that the dvm gives them. I would have appreciated that for sure when I started out. Yeah ideally there would be a dvm standing over the shoulder of every student but that wasn't even reality in our surgery class...
I didn't say you were worked up, or mean to imply. Just a figure of speech I use to mean "it doesn't really bug me." I coached lots of students along in surgery when I was barely more experienced because the vet running the show was, well... running the show. I can imagine it being a similar thing with LotF since I know she worked in a high volume place. Giving tips to scared students seems reasonable to me. That's all. I understand your point but think my tolerance is just higher. 🙂I don't use a hook in cats either, right. But I also don't do keyhole spays like those rock star high-volume vets. I mean, my incisions aren't huge (I usually close with two cruciates in a cat), but they are big enough that I can see easily.
I do resort to a hook sometimes if it just isn't working by feel/sight. I just don't like it, yanno?
I suspect if you want that keyhole spay that you can close with a single loop / one cruciate / one interrupted / whatever, you're going to have to use a hook. Maybe not. Dunno.
I don't think I was "worked up," Trilt. You're overreacting. I was just pointing out that hey, taking advice about how to do surgery from a non-validated, non-credentialed source ... is probably not a good plan in the Big Picture. This wasn't about LoTF or anything, and her specific advice was fine. You're making a bigger deal of it than I was. I would just be very, very, very cautious about taking surgical tips from someone who isn't an appropriate teaching source - it's that much harder to know if it's good or bad advice.
I didn't say you were worked up, or mean to imply. Just a figure of speech I use to mean "it doesn't really bug me." I coached lots of students along in surgery when I was barely more experienced because the vet running the show was, well... running the show. I can imagine it being a similar thing with LotF since I know she worked in a high volume place. Giving tips to scared students seems reasonable to me. That's all. I understand your point but think my tolerance is just higher. 🙂
I usually close cats with two cruciates also. Mayhaps my fingers are just defective. 😛
I just played around with every technique someone taught me for spaying while in vet school trying to find what I liked best. Saw lots on VIN about people using their fingers instead of the hook, but never had someone who actually did it to mimic, and my own attempts were fruitless. Guess my point is just that I'm curious because I found it so unrewarding, but I get the benefit of not somewhat blindly hooking stuff with a metal instrument deep in a belly.I guess I tend to play the "how will this play in the newspaper the next day" game a lot in my head. So if I were a student struggling with a spay and uncertain about how to proceed, the way my brain works would be "how's it going to look if I pushed ahead with the procedure when I'm uncertain, something went wrong, and then I had to say 'well, the technician told me to do......'". So I'd stop and go get an expert source of advice so that whatever I did was defensible. Because the first thing anyone is going to ask is "why didn't you get help from a doctor??"
Just the way I work. If you want to learn how to do something, you learn from people who are appropriate to teach it.
I don't think telling someone to "stay calm" is inappropriate ever from anyone. That's different. That's just generalized, non-specific advice. God knows I've had techs tell me to relax in surgery. But a tech standing there telling a student how to use a spay hook? Ok, how's that going to play when they rip something with the hook and THEN go get the dvm and have to explain "so the tech was trying to tell me ....." It won't matter how good the tech's advice was, it's going to look bad. Part of a tech not giving specific surgical advice is protecting the tech, not just the student and patient.
I make my cat incisions more caudal than I was taught, because I cut the suspensory in cats instead of digitally breaking it down (so I don't need much exteriorization). The uterus is easy to find/see that way. But if you like a hook - why change? You gotta go with what works for you. I don't think it's "superior" to not use a hook - there's a reason that instrument is in every spay pack. 🙂
Lucky! Only 10% of my DVM is fully loaded 😉wheelin2vetmed 12.5%-DVM
I can put that in my email signature and my business cards, yes?
Lucky! Only 10% of my DVM is fully loaded 😉
Just kidding, vmh. You're totally honorary c/o 2020. You're just crazier than the rest of us and decided 5 years in grad school sounded like more fun😛