Death Nommy - Game Thread

[Zenge142]

---

Members do not see this ad.

@Zenge142 could you talk more about your genny suspicions pretty please?

Its process of elimination for feeling okay about everyone else.

Also maybe D1 voting? I’d have to go back and look, and my internet is being slow to load pages

 

[Aprilthearab]

genny's ISO took much less time. Wahoo.

Spoiler: genny of the corn

First post. I think this is a fine, funny intro.

This feels like genuine exacerbation.

An insight no one else had pointed out yet.

Spicy on JJJ, but mainly quoted for 2 because it foreshadows something later on.

Annoyed with JJJ but doesn't seem overly defensive. Pretty chill.

Despite earlier annoyance, not willing to vote JJJ.

First genny vote on the board is thrown fruit's way.

The stagg part has been discussed already but I'm more interested in the Indy bit. genny and Indy are incompatible.

This was @ DVMD. And I want to point toward the Indy sus again.

I honestly don't think a wolf would include the second sentence. The first, absolutely, but the second? Mmm...
But that's my opinion.

Okay, this is what I was talking about when I mentioned her JJJ sus foreshadowing something. This seemed weird at the time but there actually was a precedent for genny thinking this way.

I just think this is funny and encapsulates genny well.

Annoyed with fruit.

This made me hmm but it seems in line with her previous thinking.

What I've gleaned from genny's ISO is that she isn't really thinking about the game the way most other people are: and I mean that as a compliment. I think she has unique insight and approaches the setup differently which is contributing to her seeming like she might not be giving reads (but she is). I am village-reading genny.
Of note: genny is not compatible with either Indy or fruit. If genny flips wolf, I struggle to see Indy or fruit being a packmate. If Indy or fruit flip wolf, I have no interest in voting genny.

Honestly, I'm inclined to agree about not really feeling the wolf in genny atm. Genny would be more of interest to me if indy and fruit flip village. And right now I'm not very convinced either you or her are wolf, but you and her might be who I'd look at as packmates for each other, again if indy and fruit flip village. Which I doubt

 

[kaydubs]

Day 4 Yeet Tally
indy (3) - Zenge, indy, rae
fruit (3) - Dubz, April, samac
genny (1) - fruit

7/11
yeet close in ~1.5 hours

 

[DVMDream]

i think i feel most ok with samac, clem, dvmd

MY WOLF READS ARE CLEM, DVMD, PSV, AND INDY

These changes happened rather quickly back on Tuesday. They really kind of changed to match with the thread consensus at the time.

Also the bolded, screamy in the thread that multiple times particular day just didn't sit well with me, but I can admit I might just be being a sensitive nelly on that.

 

[Aprilthearab]

Ugh decisions are hard

I think that both indy and fruit need to be flipped. But I don't want village discouraged if they're w/v and we pick the villager tonight. I also don't want the pick of 3 tomorrow to be zenge/DVMD/PSV. So I think I'm gonna stay on fruit for now

 

[fruitsalad]

These changes happened rather quickly back on Tuesday. They really kind of changed to match with the thread consensus at the time.

Also the bolded, screamy in the thread that multiple times particular day just didn't sit well with me, but I can admit I might just be being a sensitive nelly on that.

Less thread consensus matching, more trying to post urgent insights after reread

 

[DVMDream]

Ugh decisions are hard

I think that both indy and fruit need to be flipped. But I don't want village discouraged if they're w/v and we pick the villager tonight. I also don't want the pick of 3 tomorrow to be zenge/DVMD/PSV. So I think I'm gonna stay on fruit for now

Honestly, I am 1000% ok with it being me, zenge and PSV. I know I am village, but not convinced on the other two, regardless of how much samac yells and screams about zenge.

But ignoring the zenge feels, I have had feels about PSV for a while so would not be upset to explore those and would not be upset if I were yeeted and got to put up my own set of peoples.

 

[fruitsalad]

Ugh decisions are hard

I think that both indy and fruit need to be flipped. But I don't want village discouraged if they're w/v and we pick the villager tonight. I also don't want the pick of 3 tomorrow to be zenge/DVMD/PSV. So I think I'm gonna stay on fruit for now

What?

 

[Aprilthearab]

Honestly, I am 1000% ok with it being me, zenge and PSV. I know I am village, but not convinced on the other two, regardless of how much samac yells and screams about zenge.

But ignoring the zenge feels, I have had feels about PSV for a while so would not be upset to explore those and would not be upset if I were yeeted and got to put up my own set of peoples.

I mainly just want indy to be an option again tomorrow, at the very least. It's okay if the others are options in the other two slots but I want indy to be up again

 

[SARdoghandler]

Ope I think I have a contrarian view on Indy now having looked at her posts in a vacuum. Gonna pull some quotes and try to explain my thoughts but I don't think I'll be voting Indy today

 

[Aprilthearab]

What?

Indy said that those are the three she'd pick for tomorrow if she got yeeted today

 

[genny]

Its process of elimination for feeling okay about everyone else.

uh oh. and this means stagg and i were the only wolves, yet i didn't bus him into the ground? no? who's my other packmate?

 

[fruitsalad]

Indy said that those are the three she'd pick for tomorrow if she got yeeted today

Indy said they had a feeling but wasn’t sure

 

[fruitsalad]

I think the best course of action is to bury me today

 

[fruitsalad]

the issue is the stagg defense and the shouty caps and sudden read reversals, i tried to overcome that but unfortunately in a classic fruit fashion, i dug myself into a hole d1 too deep to climb out of

 

[Aprilthearab]

Indy said they had a feeling but wasn’t sure

Last I saw was "I'm submitting names and going to bed" so I think it's safe to assume that's what we're most likely to get

 

[fruitsalad]

Idk, had a feeling about DVMD, PSV, Zenge

Zenge seems so concerned about “misyeet” to the point of suspicion IMO.

Sorry if I've missed this (I probably have) but what are your reads on fruit and genny?

Maybe? Definitely sketchier than some but I didn’t know if you could name others already up

You can put up whatever 3 you want. DVMD, PSV and Zenge is definitely an interesting choice

Okay, giving peeps 5 min before I send in my names and go back to sleep to convince me otherwise……

I mean..

 

[fruitsalad]

Indy sort of acknowledged the suspicions on me and genny…

 

[fruitsalad]

So i dont think we can certainly say dvmd, zenge, and psv are the three we’ll get with their flip

 

[Aprilthearab]

Indy sort of acknowledged the suspicions on me and genny…

Yeah but never said that those were the picks they'd submit. They also didn't know that people could be re-submitted. So those three are the last we've heard and what I'll be assuming they submitted in that moment unless they come back to thread and say otherwise

 

[genny]

Yeah but never said that those were the picks she'd submit. She also didn't know that people could be re-submitted. So those three are the last we've heard and what I'll be assuming she submitted in that moment unless she comes back to thread and says otherwise

*they

 

[DVMDream]

I went back through the Stagg yeet and by doing that, fruit looks "worse" than Indy. Indy actually voted for Stagg, but that could have easily been them being told to vote that way to not look suspicious.

Fruit voted on the person with the next highest votes. So I need to have some deep thoughts on this.

 

[_rae_]

I could be convinced on a fruit flip. I think I agree with the statement that if indy or fruit flip wolf, genny is unlikely.

I am concerned for a misyeet and what tomorrow looks like if that's the case.

 

[fruitsalad]

I went back through the Stagg yeet and by doing that, fruit looks "worse" than Indy. Indy actually voted for Stagg, but that could have easily been them being told to vote that way to not look suspicious.

Fruit voted on the person with the next highest votes. So I need to have some deep thoughts on this.

I ended the day by voting PSV

Final Day 1 Yeet Tally
Clem (2) - Clem, genny
Zenge () -
genny () -
JJJ (2) - PSV, April
Dubz () -
Stagg (7) - SAR, rae, Indy, Dubz, samac, JJJ, Zenge
Indy (1) - DMVD
fruit () -
PSV (1) - fruit
April (1) - Stagg

14/14

 

[DVMDream]

But also Indy has been my suspicion all along and having a bit of a hard time letting it go.

 

[_rae_]

^Same

 

[DVMDream]

I ended the day by voting PSV

Damn it I thought I got to the last yeet count. Regardless most of that yeet you were on Clem and actively avoiding Stagg.

 

[samac]

unyeet fruit
Yeet indy

 

[Aprilthearab]

But also Indy has been my suspicion all along and having a bit of a hard time letting it go.

If you have a more convincing argument than fruit, I'm all ears and still willing to switch. Right now the two are equally wolfy to me in different ways and I'm mostly picking fruit for tomorrow's logistics

 

[_rae_]

We're one away from hammer I think!

 

[indysadventures]

Okay, I’m alive. Sorry all, horrible cold turned into sinus infection, laryngitis, with a migraine that I thought I’d gotten rid of but came back.

I had submitted the three discussed (DVMD, PSV, Zenge) based on expecting to be yeeted when I woke up and I didn’t want the mods to have to make a random choice.

I could make an alteration to fruit, PSV, Zenge but I do have some general thoughts about fruit’s sudden willingness to be yeeted to avoid my group of suggestions going up. I’m the least suspicious about DVMD so I could be convinced to resubmit.

 

[fruitsalad]

If you wanna bury me for defending stagg or failing to vote for him, i’ll fully accept it, it was a bad read on my part, and i’ve a habit of digging holes in d1, this is no different

 

[DVMDream]

If you have a more convincing argument than fruit, I'm all ears and still willing to switch. Right now the two are equally wolfy to me in different ways and I'm mostly picking fruit for tomorrow's logistics

I wouldn't worry too much about tomorrow, we need to be voting on who we think is most likely a wolf. And that wolf is not going to give us something kind to work with tomorrow.

 

[fruitsalad]

but I do have some general thoughts about fruit’s sudden willingness to be yeeted to avoid my group of suggestions going up.

Tbh i’ve been wanting to be yeeted since D1 ended

 

[_rae_]

Fruit's sudden willingness to be yeeted is interesting.

Indy's willingness to put fruit up for elimination (or so they say) is interesting.

Interesting.

 

[DVMDream]

Tbh i’ve been wanting to be yeeted since D1 ended

 

[indysadventures]

Tbh i’ve been wanting to be yeeted since D1 ended

Ha, me too.

 

[fruitsalad]

Fruit's sudden willingness to be yeeted is interesting.

Indy's willingness to put fruit up for elimination (or so they say) is interesting.

Interesting.

It isnt sudden

 

[SARdoghandler]

Ok so, thoughts on Indy based on iso-ing. Disclaimers first, I am reading them through a newbie lens, which means if they are playing at a 5D level already, it is entirely possible I may be bamboozled. Also, I think they're a similar type of player to how I am with a high amount of noise:content ratio (not a dig, it's also how I enjoy the game the most) with lots of joking and **** posting. So that may also make my read a bit biased towards villager status. That said, I think I am actually making an Indy-as-village argument.

Spoiler: Specific Quotes and Thoughts

I didn't pull any of their joking posts from early in the game, but there is a deep level of chill vibes through probably their first ~15 posts or so that I think would be a very difficult tone to pull as a wolf in your first game. Especially with a wolf on the chopping block day 1. That's a stressful situation to be in.

This is mighty eloquent for a townie.

Comment directed to Jay, who they then ended up temporarily dropping a vote for. I'm not saying a noob wolf wouldn't drop a vote for Jay, I'm just saying that the rest of the wolf pack would maybe gently push them away from that unless there is a thread consensus, which there definitely wasn't at the time. I don't think a noob wolf purposefully draws the attention of one of the more active and questioning players like that.

Wait do we submit names here or privately? Signed, Noob

Again, could this be wolf theater to ask on thread instead of in your pack? Yes. But this is still not a post I expect to see from a noob wolf because it likely doesn't occur to anyone to ask this for the cred.

Okay having heartily embarrassed myself in the first day I’m just here to say, this is good detective work above especially from JJJ and taking notes…….

I am a bit suspicious of Rae TBH, seemed pretty willing to call me out for vibez despite being the one who knows me best of all. Et tu, Rae?

Clem seems reckless to the point of performance, making me suspicious that this is evidence of trying a little too hard to make us tired of the self-yeets, so we’re bored and look instead at Samac or Rae and don’t choose to yeet.

Again, going against strong thread consensus to sus Rae. This continues to be a consistent read for Indy and they catch heat for it since most of the thread has a village read on Rae. It is, again, a very strong anti-consensus move that I don't see a noob wolf doing when there are easier pushes to make in this scenario.

It’s a quote from the book series The Expanse that didn’t land well. It’s my favorite series and I forget that it’s quite niche. I couldn’t be that inventive and eloquent if I tried.

They caught a whole lot of heat for the post that sparked this conversation about their book quote but responded in such a cool, collected way. Again, does a wolf make a sketchy sounding post like that was just to quote a book? I think this is noob trying to have fun and catching strays for it (I know the feels, I got sketch read a ton for the exact same things when I started playing)

I agree. I would say off of behavior, least to most towny are Rae<Samac<Clem. Samac feels like a lot of smoke and mirrors but very little substance which is hard to read.

Sticking by the Rae as scum read, and now poking at Samac. At the risk of inflating samac's ego, you don't poke at samac as a noob wolf. Hell I get scared of poking at samac even when I actually legit think she's a wolf, and I'm not even a noob

Of course I am …..why am I not surprised.

Meanwhile, Rae:

Still sticking to their read, despite strong thread pressure. This shows a commitment to their own thoughts, even when the easier thing to do would be to "reevaluate" and just go oopsie maybe she is village!

Honestly I feel like PSV, DVMD, Samac, April all seem pretty solid. At least DVMD has suspected me from the beginning and hasn’t wavered 🤣

LEAST TRUSTED JJJ FOREVER THOUGHT WE WERE COOL

Idk, had a feeling about DVMD, PSV, Zenge

Zenge seems so concerned about “misyeet” to the point of suspicion IMO.

Now these two posts together are interesting because they were village reading DVMD and PSV. However, I think in this case it's more about trying to put up names that they feel village would benefit from based on discussions and consensus today.

To more or less sum up, their overall tone through the first two days was remarkably relaxed and joking. While I'm sure it's possible for a skilled noob wolf to have that level of chill, it is absolutely not what I would expect. They also have a few times gone against thread consensus with their own reads or poked at active, questioning players. Both of these things has caused others to sus them, which is exactly why Indy-as-wolf shouldn't be making these moves, assuming they have reasonable teammates to help guide them on what kind of reads are going to get you heat. They have also stayed solid in their more controversial reads, when it would be a lot easier as a wolf to go with the flow and find arbitrary reasons to change your reads that are getting you heat.

Idk, obviously people have a different view but when looking at the overall tone and progression of their posts, I don't see a wolf here.

Edit: fixing for pronouns

 

[DVMDream]

What is the current yeet count at?

 

[Aprilthearab]

Okay, I’m alive. Sorry all, horrible cold turned into sinus infection, laryngitis, with a migraine that I thought I’d gotten rid of but came back.

I had submitted the three discussed (DVMD, PSV, Zenge) based on expecting to be yeeted when I woke up and I didn’t want the mods to have to make a random choice.

I could make an alteration to fruit, PSV, Zenge but I do have some general thoughts about fruit’s sudden willingness to be yeeted to avoid my group of suggestions going up. I’m the least suspicious about DVMD so I could be convinced to resubmit.

What are your fruit thoughts?

 

[_rae_]

If I'm counting right 5 indy, 1 fruit

 

[DVMDream]

What is hammer number?

 

[Aprilthearab]

I wouldn't worry too much about tomorrow, we need to be voting on who we think is most likely a wolf. And that wolf is not going to give us something kind to work with tomorrow.

Well that's the thing - to me right now they are equally wolfy. So what do I use to pick which one? The ability to vote the other tomorrow if we're wrong.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Okay I am quite conflicted on Indy's ISO, I'll admit.

Spoiler: Indy the Unknown

I am sad and lost and begging for an adult.

I may be in my mid-30s but I cannot be an adult. It’s not possible.

NAI intro

Currently fighting for my life in a MN DMV as well as this game thread.

also pretty NAI

I was not, direct me, kind person. 🫡

This stood out to me a bit with regard to Dubz asking if Indy had seen the noob posts at all. One would think a wolfator would help a nooblet by at least sending them to the noob stuff? Hm.

Wait do we submit names here or privately? Signed, Noob

This is really the only question that Indy asked where it feels like a nooby noob question. Interesting.

Quite convincing…….

Maybe too convincing……Giving big bad wolf vibes.

JJJ is a very strange target for a baby wolf. I struggle to believe noobwolf!Indy would so immediately go at him like that.

Purely noob vibes …..

But, alas:

zenge
Fruit
Rae
wildzoo
Samac
stagg
JJJ

others I can’t speak on yet……

@WildZoo was making a good case for Not Wolf but is lowering by the minute, a little sus

Having fruit up toward village will become relevant in a bit. Also note the rough symmetry.

You know what, have my confidence. 🤣🫡

JJJ

Yeet JJJ.

Maybe that’s just me? 🙃 I’ll explain my logic - you got a hearty chuckle outta me earlier, so I decided to not be so hard on my new friend JJJ. Then, you questioned me like it was a bad idea………then I went to a Japanese brush painting class and forgot that I didn’t ask you this…….

SO FINE, have your unyeet JJJ and yeet Stagg.

The JJJ reads whiplash is... well, definitely tough to follow. I'm not sure what they mean with the "questioned me like it was a bad idea" bit, either. The Stagg switch was at least a change consistent with their previous read.

No stunning revelations from fruit regarding Clem is sus. Obviously this is based on my storied history of fruit.

I believe this is a joke but something about the tone struck me. Unsure.

So, with no skin the game whatsoever, obviously I think fruit has bad takes.

So now fruit has moved down. I'm not sure if it's just because fruit has been suspecting Indy, but even so I pointed out before that fruit has been hopping all over on Indy. So it's interesting.

Wow, wolfy vibes from you JJJ. Is it because I spotted you first?? 🤔

I am always deeply uncomfortable don’t worry about me.

The "I spotted you first" doesn't quite land giving the ping-pong read, but at the same time it isn't quite a wolfy-type brag, eh? Hm.

Honestly I feel like PSV, DVMD, Samac, April all seem pretty solid. At least DVMD has suspected me from the beginning and hasn’t wavered 🤣

LEAST TRUSTED JJJ FOREVER THOUGHT WE WERE COOL

And now I thought this was interesting because me, DVMD, and April are, in part, the least solid village reads. So Indy choosing us is interesting.

Honestly I don’t know anyone, and I’ve been just trying to get a feel for everyone’s game style. It’s also honestly very hard to keep up and I initially played the way that I have played this type of game in person.

So, alas, I can’t give you much besides “vibes,” though I have offered some opinions on a few people, probably not great takes though.

I’m just here for a good time not a long time at this point. I do think that those putting a lot of energy into me - fruit, Rae, JJJ - are VERY likely to have real benefit of killing a villager and distracting everyone for so long.

I think the first couple sentences are likely very true, that Indy has been struggling to keep up and is trying to adjust to forum mafia. That's NAI but I sympathize with the fatigue.

Because he recruited me into this game and deserves some modicum of punishment for my suffering.

Regarding why Indy included Zenge in the POE. I think this is a joke, but I also feel bad Indy has been suffering. And it strikes me potentially as grasping at straws regarding who to scumread.

Feel this, I’m just confused and tired and still not 100% feeling better, so I think this is for the better ….

yeet Indy

I think this is just exhaustion, which is NAI. I think Indy wants to be out of the game.

Idk, had a feeling about DVMD, PSV, Zenge

Zenge seems so concerned about “misyeet” to the point of suspicion IMO.

I'm not sure what moved me and DVMD into the bottom of the POE from our earlier "solid" status.

My impression of Indy is that they could be a struggling noobwolf or a villager who's out of their depth. I'm having some difficulty figuring out which one it is, because I can see points to both sides. What I can tell is Indy seems to want to be done with the game. There are some points for wolfiness. So I do think I'll be voting for Indy today to free them from their self-described suffering in addition to thinking they could be a hit.

 

[fruitsalad]

If I'm counting right 5 indy, 1 fruit

I’m voting genny and there’s three votes on me i think

 

[_rae_]

What is hammer number?

6. We're down to 11.

 

[samac]

Okay, I’m alive. Sorry all, horrible cold turned into sinus infection, laryngitis, with a migraine that I thought I’d gotten rid of but came back.

I had submitted the three discussed (DVMD, PSV, Zenge) based on expecting to be yeeted when I woke up and I didn’t want the mods to have to make a random choice.

I could make an alteration to fruit, PSV, Zenge but I do have some general thoughts about fruit’s sudden willingness to be yeeted to avoid my group of suggestions going up. I’m the least suspicious about DVMD so I could be convinced to resubmit.

Why would Fruit want to avoid it if not a wolf trying to protect a pack mate?

 

[DVMDream]

Well that's the thing - to me right now they are equally wolfy. So what do I use to pick which one? The ability to vote the other tomorrow if we're wrong.

Meh I have fairly equal wolfy feels on PSV and zenge so fruit not being in there while not an ideal, isn't a deal-breaker for me. Plus then I might have a chance to be yeeted.

 

[_rae_]

I figure we'll know soon. I think we'll probably get a tally an hour to close which is in a few minutes.