I'd like to see more from alissa. I do still think popping onto the thread to ask if people had questions for her and the subsequent follow up was strange. No one other than alissa herself seemed to jump in and say "oh yeah, alissa does this all the time".
Regarding samac's theory... I will say that after some google I do think my role fits well in the North. That said, I recall DocE stating his role didn't best fit with his location and I also recall at least a few people who were very skeptical about the idea of locations being meaningful and I'm inclined to assume that at least some of those people don't fit perfectly into their starting locations either or I'd expect them to be more open to the theory.
If samac is correct then AM has to be a wolf. I've never been able to read her and think she acts relatively the same no matter what role she's playing so it wouldn't surprise me.
But I
would be surprised if a mod set up a game in which she gave strong hints about what role performed which action
and put all the roles in their correct starting location. That strikes me as an unusual set up.
Is there a reason MsP is still voting for Bobloblaw considering how weak her "I caught a wolf" ended up being?
I have several people I am feeling good about right now.
I don't expect you to post entire reads lists at all, but yes after 45 pages of posts I do expect you to have a thought or two, or a few interactions that I can actually evaluate
45 pages of posts is still a cycle and half. The fact that you guys dragged this out into 36 hours makes me want to participate less (because I'm mentally exhausted) not more. I was actually pretty active--for me--over the last cycle. I took yesterday off because of the fatique. I made it clear that I intended to contribute today.
And the high post volume makes everything more difficult for me to assess. Feels a little like a vet school lecture where they're just hitting me with a firehouse of information and then I have to determine which parts are important. Except I only get like a day to do it.
Also, this reasoning has been a common theme in almost every game that I've played so you can't just say it's about the 45 pages.
Like what I'm saying
@finnickthedog is that day 2 in a 36/12 is hardly the same as day 2 in a 12/12 unless you're strictly relying on night results. What have you done that you think I should be village reading you for?
And I think it's worse, not better. Just because you prefer it, doesn't mean I'm going to feel the same way about it.
I didn't complain about the fact that you weren't village reading me. If you want my honest opinion, I think you should be neutral reading me. I complained about the fact that you are wolf reading me
again for the same exact reasons that people
always wolf read me.
I mean if you want to talk about not contributing AMs typical play style is to aggressively question everyone else but be evasive and refuse to explain herself. I don't feel she's contributed anything of value in the last cycle and a half. But we all just go "oh, typical AM, NAI".
Should I try that strategy instead? Will that finally fix this broken record?
I like this theme, so I'd really like to keep playing but I'm taking a break. Constantly being accosted for my play style isn't fun.
I've got no response to your suspicion"
