♪ ♫ Every Day I'm Shufflin' WW Game Thread ♫ ♪

[JustPaws]

---

Members do not see this ad.

Style? Have you played WW before? And what do you mean by "unwarranted lynch"?

Seems pretty warranted to me...

Sent from my Moto E (4) using SDN mobile

 

[greeneyegal92]

Style? Have you played WW before? And what do you mean by "unwarranted lynch"?

I haven't played this is my first go, it's just my style for life
Unwarranted in a sense I don't have a good reason, just "feels"

This made me laugh out loud so hard

I'm glad to at least provide some good chuckles 😉

 

[Animal Midwife]

I haven't played this is my first go, it's just my style for life
Unwarranted in a sense I don't have a good reason, just "feels"

It's fine to have "feels", but you haven't given a single one of your lynch votes any explanation for said "feels". Can you start doing that to prove you're village?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Unofficial D4 Lynch Tally

Greeney (4) - am, paws, cray, Jil
Genny (1) - greeney

5/12
Lynch ends ~8.5 hours

 

[PippyPony]

I'm imagining what I would do myself if I were a wolf, which is come up with very believable lies, which genny may or may not be capable of, she's definitely way more experienced than I am. Mostly my intentions are to shake things up a bit. Do I have good reasons to believe genny is a wolf, not really. But depending how everyone else responds it may expose potential wolves coming out of the woodwork to defend their own, especially a good wolf (maybe) hiding in plain sight. I'm on the chopping block any way with not much to lose, the best way I see myself being useful this point of the game is to sacrifice myself to expose more wolves for the rest of the villagers.

Ok, that's lovely that you feel so altruistic, but you didn't really answer my question.

I would like some more detail about the bolded statement, please. Specifically, how you are thinking about how this would go down. Because it seems to be the fundamental basis of your vote but I don't see any well-articulated logic behind it.

 

[genny]

I'm imagining what I would do myself if I were a wolf, which is come up with very believable lies, which genny may or may not be capable of, she's definitely way more experienced than I am. Mostly my intentions are to shake things up a bit. Do I have good reasons to believe genny is a wolf, not really. But depending how everyone else responds it may expose potential wolves coming out of the woodwork to defend their own, especially a good wolf (maybe) hiding in plain sight. I'm on the chopping block any way with not much to lose, the best way I see myself being useful this point of the game is to sacrifice myself to expose more wolves for the rest of the villagers.

You’re pretty funny for a noob wolf.

 

[LetItSnow]

I'm imagining what I would do myself if I were a wolf, which is come up with very believable lies,

Maybe, but in general, when I wolf, my goal is to actually come up with as few lies as possible. Ideally, none (other than the obvious "Nope, not a wolf").

The more lies you tell the greater the likelihood you get caught in one of them.

I see we still have no explanation of why you voted for me last night despite you promising that.

This ever get a response?

I kinda want to stick with my AM vote but I also kinda don't due to the weirdness from @greeneyegal92 and @SportPonies. Would like to see explanations from both of them on their votes.

I kinda think the GreenGal weirdness is noob, but ... at the end of the day how do you tell? Probably a good break-an-egg lynch.

I need to go back and find the SportPonies weirdness. I don't know what that refers to.

Tentatively planning to stick with:

lynch Pippy

 

[WildZoo]

Lol. I'm not disappointed by the results of inviting greeney to play. That said I still want an explanation for the AM vote yesterday.

 

[WildZoo]

I need to go back and find the SportPonies weirdness. I don't know what that refers to.

It was a similar thing where she voted for AM at the end of the day and said she would explain later, but never did. Granted she hasn't been on the thread at all since then.

 

[Animal Midwife]

This ever get a response?

Not yet.

 

[LetItSnow]

I'm imagining what I would do myself if I were a wolf, which is come up with very believable lies, which genny may or may not be capable of, she's definitely way more experienced than I am. Mostly my intentions are to shake things up a bit. Do I have good reasons to believe genny is a wolf, not really. But depending how everyone else responds it may expose potential wolves coming out of the woodwork to defend their own, especially a good wolf (maybe) hiding in plain sight. I'm on the chopping block any way with not much to lose, the best way I see myself being useful this point of the game is to sacrifice myself to expose more wolves for the rest of the villagers.

I don't get it. How are you sacrificing yourself?

And if you're a villager, why would you do that knowing it just means lynching a villager? Makes no sense.

It's one thing for the rest of us to decide we need to lynch you to put a rest to things (classic break-an-egg strategy), but it's another for you to 'sacrifice' yourself as a villager.

 

[LetItSnow]

I could lynch greens or sporty today for the weird comments last night.

Lynch greens

For the weird lynch vote last night, plus it seems like maybe she has been getting mentorship somewhere. She's not asking nearly as many questions or making as many weird noob comments as I'd expect (except that sacrificing self comment above, that's pretty noobish sounding.)

Am I the only person that missed SportP's weird comments?

 

[Skimble]

Am I the only person that missed SportP's weird comments?

Well first greeny made this post:

Running out of time gotta visit my sick kitty but Lynch AM.
Hopefully I'll get the chance to explain before the lynch closes!

Then like an hour later (around 9:30) Sporty made this post:

Lynch AM, can explain further when I'm able

Neither one has explained their post or why they were lynching AM. It's just super sketch to me.

 

[LetItSnow]

Well first greeny made this post:

Then like an hour later (around 9:30) Sporty made this post:

Neither one has explained their post or why they were lynching AM. It's just super sketch to me.

Got it. Thx.

I'm super torn on Green. I really think it's just n00bness - they have a tendency to WAYYYYY overstate things, and her first post makes it sound like there's a SOLID reason to vote AM ... then today it's just "feels".

Not as sure what to think about SportP. Not exactly a n00b anymore.

 

[Skimble]

Got it. Thx.

I'm super torn on Green. I really think it's just n00bness - they have a tendency to WAYYYYY overstate things, and her first post makes it sound like there's a SOLID reason to vote AM ... then today it's just "feels".

Not as sure what to think about SportP. Not exactly a n00b anymore.

I'd just like them both to come explain. Without an explanation, I'm happy to vote for either of them.

 

[LetItSnow]

I'd just like them both to come explain. Without an explanation, I'm happy to vote for either of them.

Yup, I get it.

I just think they're a little different. SportP just has to explain a kinda weird vote. Green ... has made plenty of oddball weird comments PLUS the weird vote.

 

[greeneyegal92]

Not yet.

Sorry I'm a bad noob! I voted AM because the lynch before she was very persistent on what my thoughts were for my next lynch, I'm not sure if she was just trying to encourage me to participate more or simply digging to figure me out, this worried me some not knowing her intentions.

 

[greeneyegal92]

I don't get it. How are you sacrificing yourself?

And if you're a villager, why would you do that knowing it just means lynching a villager? Makes no sense.

It's one thing for the rest of us to decide we need to lynch you to put a rest to things (classic break-an-egg strategy), but it's another for you to 'sacrifice' yourself as a villager.

Sounded like a solid idea this morning, now I'm feeling dumber by the second...

 

[Animal Midwife]

Sorry I'm a bad noob! I voted AM because the lynch before she was very persistent on what my thoughts were for my next lynch, I'm not sure if she was just trying to encourage me to participate more or simply digging to figure me out, this worried me some not knowing her intentions.

You were totally absent D1. What did you want me to do? Does this mean you were lying about your feels on WZ?

 

[greeneyegal92]

You were totally absent D1. What did you want me to do. Does this mean you were lying about your feels on WZ?

Empty threat, picked someone who wasn't very active that day to buy me some time, sorry WZ

 

[Animal Midwife]

Empty threat, picked someone who wasn't very active that day to buy me some time, sorry WZ

SP was way less active than WZ was. And what do you need to buy time for?

 

[greeneyegal92]

SP was way less active than WZ was. And what do you need to buy time for?

To think of my strategy I'm frazzled 😵
I honestly forgot SP was playing...
Which reminds me
unlynch genny
lynch SP
I may some dumb things but at least I say something

 

[Animal Midwife]

To think of my strategy I'm frazzled 😵
I honestly forgot SP was playing...
Which reminds me
unlynch genny
lynch SP
I may some dumb things but at least I say something

Beyond SP, what are players are most likely to be wolves in your opinion?

 

[LetItSnow]

To think of my strategy I'm frazzled 😵

This sorta niggles at me.

I mean. On the one hand, yeah, there's villager 'strategy'. (Especially for SuperSpy.)

But I don't think of myself as "strategizing" much as a villager. I think of that more as a wolf term.

I dunno. Maybe that's my bias as a bull-in-the-china-shop player, but ...... kinda sets off alarms.

 

[genny]

I may some dumb things but at least I say something

This sounds coached to me. Not liking it at all.

 

[SummerTheLynx]

I am actually in agreement with LIS on who to lynch today, and it feels weird. almost sketches me out, but alas...

**********lynch pipppy*******

 

[PippyPony]

I am actually in agreement with LIS on who to lynch today, and it feels weird. almost sketches me out, but alas...

**********lynch pipppy*******

Dude. You feel like justifying this at all, or nah?

 

[PippyPony]

Just got home & cracked open a beer; updated & slightly tipsy reads incoming.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Just got home & cracked open a beer; updated & slightly tipsy reads incoming.

Are you tipsy or inebriated?

 

[PippyPony]

Are you tipsy or inebriated?

The answer to this is a time-dependent reaction

 

[genny]

Also not liking the flyby lynch voting that STL has been doing.

 

[Animal Midwife]

I'm going to have so much fun coloring these lynches.

 

[WildZoo]

I'm going to have so much fun coloring these lynches.

Oh yeah man, all that green

This sounds coached to me. Not liking it at all.

That line maybe but if she got coached on something small like that I'd think there would have been more time spent on developing a good reason for lynching AM as opposed to "She was questioning me, must be wolf" which really makes no sense.

There's a lot of smoke there though so I'm certainly not fighting that lynch. Anybody got a current tally?

 

[WildZoo]

Also, reasons for the pip votes? Because I think I missed them.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Unofficial D4 Lynch Tally

Greeney (4) - am, paws, cray, Jil
Genny () -
Pippy (2) - LIS, STL
SP (1) - greeney

7/12
Lynch ends ~2 hours

 

[PippyPony]

Also, reasons for the pip votes? Because I think I missed them.

So did I, so if you hear anything please keep me in the loop 😉

 

[ddstothecor]

I'm back! Magic 8 Ball says: It's a tie. Chop A) PP or Chop B) GEG92. I could go with Cray too. She seems to add a lot to the game (and by that, I mean a lot of nothing).

 

[Animal Midwife]

I'm back! Magic 8 Ball says: It's a tie. Chop A) PP or Chop B) GEG92. I could go with Cray too. She seems to add a lot to the game (and by that, I mean a lot of nothing).

What does the 8 ball say about me, dds?

 

[ddstothecor]

I'm going to stick with my hunch: Lynch PP.

 

[ddstothecor]

What does the 8 ball say about me, dds?

That you're behaving quite strangely. . .

 

[Animal Midwife]

That you're behaving quite strangely. . .

Interesting.

 

[PippyPony]

Ok, sorry in advance for the discombobulated catch up

Starting by quoting myself lol

Just quickly, though...this caught my eye.

Can you explain what kind of "clever plot" you are envisioning here? I'd like to hear you delineate that thought process, especially since Snowy flipped village.

Greenies still hasn't answered me from earlier. Everyone else got a response 🙁

@greeneyegal92 where you at

What's your original reasoning for AM?

So pippy/snowy/AM.

Today was a day where i just want able to get on here, so I am sticking with yesterday's and say before 's feels.

************lynch snowy***********

In addition to the random unexplained vote for me, this felt awfully light for STL given where we're at in the game.

I'd like a list of actual reads from him sooner rather than later. The only 2 people he had on his suspect list at the beginning of the game are now both dead and confirmed village, he hasn't actually pushed on anyone since D1, and since then he's been showing up for a lynch vote and basically has contributed nothing else.

I know this level of involvement has been more his norm recently because of school/research, and I'd like to think he would be a better wolf than this, tbh. Buuuut he's also been absent in PM. Still have him in neutral but I don't exactly love the combo.

Anybody else getting annoyed by seeing the phrase "easy lynch" or "easy vote" about 5000 times? No? Just me? Well anyway, on a related note...

I have you at neutral --> very slight village lean. However, you sometimes get preachy about things like this when you are a wolf. Noting this because it jumped out at me and I didn't want to forget about it.

 

[SportPonies]

Back. Thoughts coming soon.

 

[PippyPony]

I'm going to stick with my hunch: Lynch PP.

I have a whole separate follow up, just for you

 

[Karabiner13]

D4 Lynch Tally

Greeney (4) - am, paws, cray, Jil
Genny () -
Pippy (3) - LIS, STL, dds
SP (1) - greeney

8/12
Missing: @WildZoo , @SportPonies , @PippyPony , @genny

Lynch ends ~1.5

 

[WildZoo]

That you're behaving quite strangely. . .

Improper ellipsis formation noted...

 

[WildZoo]

Meh. That's how I kinda feel about everyone right now. Just meh. I'm keeping AM in mind because there's still a tingling there. This one is just a feeling too but for now I'm going to

Lynch Jil

 

[PippyPony]

All three on the block seem really off. I read AM a little bit differently this game, and ssd has not convinced me based on some of the above posts, however, if my overriding tingles move my needle the way it's headed to peg on full, then PP's name is at the far right of the meter. She usually has a woody to lynch me because of my gift for gifs, but I haven't ever seen her change her mind or read on me that quickly (for the stupidest of reasons - cats). Add to that her wanting to get rid of STL immediately, and that has me convinced that she's trying to sway favor by lynching a strong player (after trying to pick off the low hanging nuts). Finally, she drops by to say she'll be dropping out for the rest of the night. So I should feel really guilty now for voting to lynch a player who won't fight back, huh?

Ok there was just so much wrong with this that I like don't even know what to make of it. But for the record:

- I don't know where you're getting this idea that I have some kind of perpetual hard on to lynch you
- There is no way I would ever unlynch someone just because they posted a gif, nor did I do that in this case. I'm pretty sure it's actually reasonably well-established that I very much enjoy gifs and humor in this game, to the point where I actively try to keep those players around. But that doesn't mean that you get a free pass to not show up and contribute anything substantive.
- I didn't change my mind on you quickly. You hadn't posted virtually anything yet -- I voted for you to get you on the thread and saying stuff. You said some stuff (in addition to the cat picture). I moved you down a notch or two on my wolf list. For the record, you are still sitting at slight wolf lean.
- There are very few scenarios where I would lynch STL early, and this clearly is not one of them because I haven't voted for him once during this game.
- I mentioned like 600 times -- including in sign ups -- that I had a lot of **** going on this week. I was concerned about acquiring votes while I was offline...which then is what happened...so I don't know why it is weird to you that I would try to head that off at the pass.

She said that my cat picture swayed her and she backed off of me, but why bother reading the thread, right?

- That is significantly misrepresenting what happened.

Oh! My bad. I meant snowy (who I've now confused with snowshoedog). She didn't vote for STL.

- Truth!

Wait. I'm confused. She voted for snowshoedog and not LIS?!!!
Unlynch PP.

- 🙄

Yes, you're one to get out of the way too.

- This is an interesting comment (referring to STL) considering you had literally just talked about how you thought this would be a good tactic for a wolf. You're also now voting with him, which I find even more intriguing.

Maybe it was yesterday, that she voted LIS? That is suspect.

- Why?

 

[Karabiner13]

D4 Lynch Tally

Greeney (4) - am, paws, cray, Jil
Genny () -
Pippy (3) - LIS, STL, dds
SP (1) - greeney
Jil (1) - dubz

9/12
Missing: sp, pippy, genny

Lynch ends ~1

 

[WildZoo]

Nobody else feeling my AM feels anymore though (I'm not counting the weird voted from greeney and sporty)? I tunnel on at least one person per game so maybe this is that one. Just felt like I usually read her pretty well and something this time feels...off.