Game Thread: Meats's Reading List: WWhat I Read in 2019

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
So what are your thoughts on me? And wonder and nav?
Hmm not sure about wondering. Nav is super quiet but when I played the soccer game with him he’d have periods of inactivity and then thread spew everywhere. It’s also hard for me to read him because I’ve heard he’s an expert at adapting his play style to avoid suspicion
 
I know Meats said that abilities were RNG'd but if someone can silence multiple people and de facto drive all discussion into PMs, that is a sketchy ass ability and I don't think I believe her lol
 
That's alotta hedge
:shrug: was thinking I really wanted to hear more from jboo right before I saw the "I have no internet" post, felt like I had to rationalize it both to myself as well as to anyone who would read my lynch vote and be all "how dare you lynch someone who can't defend themselves". Not sure if y'all generally consider it a faux pas to lynch someone who's claimed technical difficulties or not, so you're right, I wanted to cover my bases.
 
Hmm not sure about wondering. Nav is super quiet but when I played the soccer game with him he’d have periods of inactivity and then thread spew everywhere.
...Ok? I was asking BigKitties because those people are/were voting for Miz and she said she was suspicious of Sporty for it.

It’s also hard for me to read him because I’ve heard he’s an expert at adapting his play style to avoid suspicion
Lol is he paying for radio ads now or did you take one of the pamphlets he hands out on the street?
 
So what are your thoughts on me? And wonder and nav?
You seem fine, Wondering seems like the same old Wondering from past games (though I would like to hear more from her), Nav made a severe tone shift from last game and I usually have a village read on him pretty early on but I don't have one this time which is concerning. I was considering placing my vote there but didn't want to start a bandwagon when he's already said that he won't be around to defend himself until night- hoping he'll be back before lynch close though.
 
...Ok? I was asking BigKitties because those people are/were voting for Miz and she said she was suspicious of Sporty for it.
I don't agree with you voting for miz but I also know that my read on her is influenced by the fact that we've been talking over PM and she seems fine there, so I'm not going to hold it against people for not having the same info I have.
 
Ok but like seriously, where is everybody? Is this why PMs are open to everyone?

@Animal Midwife are you also silenced?

@Navilly @Ms Procrastinator @killerleaf @alissa14 @dolphin106258 @SARdoghandler @WonderingStudent same question
Excuse me for not arriving promptly I had to deal with a place charging my card more than the receipt and therefore overdrafting my account and making my day unpleasant.. but I think it’s fixed now. Do you have any specific questions or were you just bored?
 
...Ok? I was asking BigKitties because those people are/were voting for Miz and she said she was suspicious of Sporty for it.


Lol is he paying for radio ads now or did you take one of the pamphlets he hands out on the street?
i think it’s fun btw that you’re voting Miz while simultaneously poking some subtle shade at Nav.
 
@mizchiefmanaged @WildZoo mostly feels -- she kinda dropped off after posting right out the gate and the return posts felt insubstantial and graspy.

I also don't agree with the assertion that Nav lynching her is a better way to get rid of her vs. a night kill. Because even if he thought night killing her would make people suspicious of him like she suggested, lynching is even more high profile and would probably backfire even harder if she flipped village, especially after all of the claims about how well he reads her. Plus, I think he's perfectly capable of talking his way out of nk wifom anyways
I think I would agree with your vote more if you just took out the whole bottom bit about Nav. Because the first reasons make sense, but this whole circle of well Miz is voting Nav and Nav was voting Miz is annoying at best, and just confusing at worst. I don’t know if there’s really a lot to take from the situation.

To me if felt like Nav just hopped on made a vote that sounded a lot more confident than it was and then all this started...
 
I don't agree with you voting for miz but I also know that my read on her is influenced by the fact that we've been talking over PM and she seems fine there, so I'm not going to hold it against people for not having the same info I have.
Talking over PM, eh? Should tell her to put some of that effort into the thread instead of pocketing nooblets.
 
Not sure I like this. Is this just bc of Nav’s vote for you yesterday?
Did you see the entire thing we talked about yesterday and that I was on him yesterday. It’s not retal, it’s for a reason. Even in past games where I WAS a wolf and he was a villager he voiced a bit of suspicion early but didn’t go after me until much later. This is just weird.
 
@PippyPony I saw game started, realized I was actually in the top theee posts (which hasn’t happened ever) made the “second” post and whines about not being one of my favorite books, went to sleep, went to work, then got to check the thread. There wasn’t even any lurking involved there. I’m never a heavy poster early. That’s been consistent across all games regardless of affiliation.
 
I haven't gotten my answers yet.
Refresh my mind

I know Meats said that abilities were RNG'd but if someone can silence multiple people and de facto drive all discussion into PMs, that is a sketchy ass ability and I don't think I believe her lol
I'm not silenced.

Geez, I thought I'd be in real trouble when I got on thread, but it looks like I'm not the only one having a lazy Saturday.
 
Day 2 Official Throw the Book at Em Tally

MsP (1) - AM
Pips (1) - coop
Miz (1) - Pips
Nav (1) - Miz
Jboo (2) - BC
Alissa (1) - WZ

6/16

Lynch deadline 7 PM PST/8 PM MST/9 PM CST/10 PM EST

giphy.gif
 
Okay so yesterday my two reads were coop and doggo. I had coop as neutral and doggo as sketchy because she pinged me weird. Those two reads have been resolved.
I'm leaning coop village (of course this can change but it's where she is now)
I'm not quite sure about alissa. She's a bit sporadic and that has me leaning her wolf as she was sort of the same in that speed game.
I'm not super sure about AM but I'm leaning her village.
Bare with me I still have a few more reads to get out, but I feel like there's definitely a wolf between the older (in terms of WW) vets.
 
Do you remember who you're talking about?
He is the king of weird but honestly unless we’re pretty darn sure about the other person’s affiliation or one person is a wolf I feel like we tend to give each other a few days to declare ourselves. That’s just been the trend.

Edit: it’s hard being around someone who’s mad at you for lynching them as a villager 🤣
 
Why Alissa? I felt comfortable lynching her early yesterday but a few things she said at the end of the day seemed frustrated villager to me.
She seemed very jumpy yesterday and when asked for reads on specific people (or really on anyone) she failed to provide anything that wasn't hedgey enough to be meaningless.
 
Okay so yesterday my two reads were coop and doggo. I had coop as neutral and doggo as sketchy because she pinged me weird. Those two reads have been resolved.
I'm leaning coop village (of course this can change but it's where she is now)
I'm not quite sure about alissa. She's a bit sporadic and that has me leaning her wolf as she was sort of the same in that speed game.
I'm not super sure about AM but I'm leaning her village.
Bare with me I still have a few more reads to get out, but I feel like there's definitely a wolf between the older (in terms of WW) vets.
As for Nav, I'd have to see more but his lynch vote is undeniably interesting.
 
Top