GGoats!! - An aMAAAAAHzing WW thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Doggo Labs said:
So everyone but dubz?
Click to expand...
Cray and genny aren't on there. Earlier I had mkg not on there but as I explained, I can't seem AM and Samac as compatible and it feels too narrow if I remove one of them and mkg.

But yeah my trust level has dropped exceptionally low
 
Animal Midwife said:
forums.studentdoctor.net

GGoats!! - An aMAAAAAHzing WW thread

Don't feel too bad, wasn't he going around the house howling or something? :laugh: ************************ Yes, was very into "awoooooo," weirdly, turned out not to be a wolf tell :unsure: :shrug: ************************
forums.studentdoctor.net forums.studentdoctor.net
Click to expand...
Yeah, this feels wrong. That you'd let people place a vote on a wolf for a crap reason and you wouldn't correct it. You'd have to know that the risk of right wolf wrong reason, is that they can potentially slip out of the noose because their execution isn't based on something solid.
 
Animal Midwife said:
I don't think it's cherrypicked. At worst you can argue right wolf, wrong reason but it seemed completely topical to me. I don't understand why you're expecting me to defend you anyway if I'm really your top wolfread.
Click to expand...
This last sentence, I don't think is her point. She's saying the fact you didn't defend her just confirms to her the theory you're acting wolfy.

Now I'm trying to to figure out if this means you're wolfy.
 
Zenge142 said:
Okay, so let me ask you this:

It’s clear from your limited post history, you think AM is village and April is wolf.

Why are you voting for me, over April?

Because when I asked you about your suspicions of me, your response was to ask me about my April read.

So it seems like, not all, but a lot of your suspicions of me, are based on thinking that April is a Wolf, and her and you think her and I have been buddy buddy.

So I guess if your suspicions of me are (primarily, based on your questioning of me) based on your read of April being a wolf, wouldn’t your top wolf read logically be April then?

Furthermore, AM has said she thinks I’m village, and visa versa, and we’ve defended each other in arguments on the thread. April is currently postulating that AM and I are wolfing together. If you think AM is village, she thinks I’m village, and she’s voting for April, and your suspicions of me, are primarily tied to thinking April and I are in a pack, then why are you voting for me over April?

Can you see the incongruity there? Can you reconcile that for me?
Click to expand...
In hindsight knowing he was saying what he believed, this is compelling.

Torn on an April vs Samac vs AM vs genny/sunny.
 
I think my POE for today is doggo, dina, samac. I'm less confident in my mkg read but unlikely to vote there. I believe in my AM, barks, and April reads, but less so than the cray and genny ones. I think that's everyone but I'm on mobile right now, hopefully didn't forget someone. In case it is yolo we really gotta figure out where our POEs overlap. I'd like to go for two of doggo/dina/samac but will settle for one out of that and one out my less confident reads.

I thought that yesterday was all stiff because there were two wolves on the tally but I guess now I'm thinking it was just one and wolves spread out to keep from spooking people off of one of the misyeets.

And that's my current thoughts in case I die
 
Night Four Writeup

In hopes of her migraine resolving, SAR went to sleep after some medication consumption. Sadly, she didn't know that she would be a victim of a terrible crime. During the night, someone quietly loaded up another incredibly well-loved goat and driven away. Justice must be served!

321318-3467bd62a92e00b43f3323663a024dec.jpg


Permanently goat-napped is @Crayola227 who was Watson, SAR's beloved two-toned goat, representative of the Boer breed, and an unconvertable mason.

It is now D5, Yeet close at 11pm AST

Roster:
1. @Animal Midwife
4. @Aprilthearab
6. @mkg323
7. @WildZoo
8. Sunshine --> @genny
10. @Doggo Labs
13. @Barkley13
14. @Dinashadow
23. @samac

Removed from the farm:
@PippyPony - Mountain goat, Serial Killer JOAT
@TelemarketingEnigma - Sherlock, mason
@alissa14 - Valais Blackneck, vanilla
@supershorty - Kiko, odd night watcher
@holdthemayo - Angora, vanilla
@LaineyLou - Beetal, vanilla
@Zenge142 - Nubian, jailer
@Crayola227 - Watson, mason​
 
WildZoo said:
I think my POE for today is doggo, dina, samac. I'm less confident in my mkg read but unlikely to vote there. I believe in my AM, barks, and April reads, but less so than the cray and genny ones. I think that's everyone but I'm on mobile right now, hopefully didn't forget someone. In case it is yolo we really gotta figure out where our POEs overlap. I'd like to go for two of doggo/dina/samac but will settle for one out of that and one out my less confident reads.

I thought that yesterday was all stiff because there were two wolves on the tally but I guess now I'm thinking it was just one and wolves spread out to keep from spooking people off of one of the misyeets.

And that's my current thoughts in case I die
Click to expand...
How do you feel about mkg?
 
Y'all
If I was a wolf
Why would I rather let myself die
Than to make a tie that would kill myself AND a villager
That makes no sense for a wolf to do
 
The reality of today is that the numbers are almost 50/50 w/v. Which means if the villagers don't unite the vote, the wolves will EASILY pile onto one of us and outnumber us and from the looks of it with the mod hint, it'll be game over. Since we aren't sure who the wolves are, we need to be ESPECIALLY careful that we don't start following just any united vote, because it could easily be the wolves that lead it. I was on the other side of this predicament twice in the past two games and we were all laughing in wolf chat watching the villagers scramble around and shoot down their own members.

I still wholeheartedly think AM is a wolf, and her intentional misinterpretation of what I was saying and twisting of my words is INCREDIBLY wolfy. Just go back and look at what she said to me then open the quotes she has sitting in those replies and you will see clear as day that what she was saying my argument was did NOT match what I was saying. She was repeatedly referencing old arguments that I had long since dropped instead of replying to the ones I was currently making. Cray picked up on that during her night catch up and might even be one of the reasons she wound up dead.

If you don't believe me, fine. We can go after someone else. But the rest of the people are wishy washy in our POEs which means we are more likely to not unite our vote correctly. It decreases our chances of hitting a wolf.
 
Siiigh I'm really sad about the numbers here

Also I am not wishy washy in my main POE and I won't be voting AM today :shrug: so if my other village reads are intent on (probably incorrectly) voting april today, I need the counter to be among doggo/samac/dina or I will be upsetted
 
Aprilthearab said:
@WildZoo can you enlighten me with what makes you so certain AM is village?
Click to expand...
I already talked about it yesterday. Her behavior d1 does not match how she would interact with a 3p, I 100% believe she thought pippy was a wolf. Also, the alissa push was her classic lead on an inactive villager (see previous pushes on MsP, capri, kras, and also previous ones on alissa herself). I know you guys didn't like her argument with cray but I've seen village AM get into those things out of frustration for a long time. The questions/salt balance has been on par much of the game.

I will say she didn't quite react the way I typically expect her to when she was on the board yesterday beyond talking to you (I can't remember at this moment who else was voting for her...)
So yes, possibility of conversion tickles in my brain. Which is why I hate converts and I'm sad about the numbers.
 
WildZoo said:
I already talked about it yesterday. Her behavior d1 does not match how she would interact with a 3p, I 100% believe she thought pippy was a wolf. Also, the alissa push was her classic lead on an inactive villager (see previous pushes on MsP, capri, kras, and also previous ones on alissa herself). I know you guys didn't like her argument with cray but I've seen village AM get into those things out of frustration for a long time. The questions/salt balance has been on par much of the game.

I will say she didn't quite react the way I typically expect her to when she was on the board yesterday beyond talking to you (I can't remember at this moment who else was voting for her...)
So yes, possibility of conversion tickles in my brain. Which is why I hate converts and I'm sad about the numbers.
Click to expand...
Pushing a lead on an inactive villager is all too easy to replicate as a wolf because in the end you're still yeeting a villager.

Dubz I'm starting to question how solidly I have you in my village pile. I'm not sure if you've been pocketed or if you're power wolfing with her. My POE does not feel good where it is right now and I think you might be the missing link.

Regardless, I'm not going after you today but I'm rethinking why I have people where they are.
 
Aprilthearab said:
Pushing a lead on an inactive villager is all too easy to replicate as a wolf because in the end you're still yeeting a villager.

Dubz I'm starting to question how solidly I have you in my village pile. I'm not sure if you've been pocketed or if you're power wolfing with her. My POE does not feel good where it is right now and I think you might be the missing link.

Regardless, I'm not going after you today but I'm rethinking why I have people where they are.
Click to expand...
Why would I have been trying to get people off of you if that were the case? I admit pocketing is possible here, it always is, but I stand by my interpretation of her d1 actions.
 
kaydubs said:
OFFICIAL D5 BE CAREFUL Yeet Tally

April (2) - AM, genny
Doggo (1) - DubZ
AM (1) - April
samac (1) - Barks


5/9

Leading: ---

Missing: @mkg323 @Doggo Labs @Dinashadow @samac

tenor.gif


Yeet/Vote closes at 10pm Eastern/11pm AST/9pm Central/7pm fantasyland (~12.75 HOURS)

CHECK YO VOTES
Click to expand...
This be careful is just like that stupid clock in apocalypse.
I think Kaydubs feels bad that we’ve ****ed this up so hard and is telling us we’re at yolo.
I’m pretty pissed at myself. I was convinced Zenge was a wolf and the fact that some vets agreed with me made me even more confident.
I tried to get on to review as I was getting ready for work, but SDN does daily site maintenance at the time I’m getting up which makes it hard. This afternoon hopefully things are slow enough for me to re-evaluate everything.
 
WildZoo said:
Why would I have been trying to get people off of you if that were the case? I admit pocketing is possible here, it always is, but I stand by my interpretation of her d1 actions.
Click to expand...
Because Zenge was also a misyeet and you wanted that cred that you're clearly using right now. Why are you so focused on what happened D1 and nowhere else? We have three other days of interactions behind us that have been a lot more damning than D1.
 
Aprilthearab said:
Because Zenge was also a misyeet and you wanted that cred that you're clearly using right now. Why are you so focused on what happened D1 and nowhere else? We have three other days of interactions behind us that have been a lot more damning than D1.
Click to expand...
Because d1 was the day I had time to reread. I talked about my general impressions for the rest of the game in answer to your question of why I'm village reading her, but that is the one day that I actually made it through while trying to reread and so is most detailed in my mind.

If you want to honestly, as a villager, believe that today I would still be telling people not to vote for you if I were powerwolfing, then I really can't help you. I've got an hour before I have to go, I would like to spend that time figuring out where our POEs overlap so we have at least a slight chance of voting correctly today.
 
WildZoo said:
Because d1 was the day I had time to reread. I talked about my general impressions for the rest of the game in answer to your question of why I'm village reading her, but that is the one day that I actually made it through while trying to reread and so is most detailed in my mind.

If you want to honestly, as a villager, believe that today I would still be telling people not to vote for you if I were powerwolfing, then I really can't help you. I've got an hour before I have to go, I would like to spend that time figuring out where our POEs overlap so we have at least a slight chance of voting correctly today.
Click to expand...
If you're village, then I feel like you're intentionally missing AM's wolfiness. Unfortunately I'm heading to work within the next half hour and I just don't have enough time to really shift things around the way I want but I will try.
 
Aprilthearab said:
If you're village, then I feel like you're intentionally missing AM's wolfiness. Unfortunately I'm heading to work within the next half hour and I just don't have enough time to really shift things around the way I want but I will try.
Click to expand...
Seriously? Now you're questioning the integrity of my gameplay? I already said it's possible she was converted, or that I've been pocketed (less likely because I really truly believe she thought pippy was a wolf), and now you're going to accuse me of throwing the game? Pretty low, dude.
 
WildZoo said:
Seriously? Now you're questioning the integrity of my gameplay? I already said it's possible she was converted, or that I've been pocketed (less likely because I really truly believe she thought pippy was a wolf), and now you're going to accuse me of throwing the game? Pretty low, dude.
Click to expand...
Okay, intentional was the wrong word. I really can't figure out if you're a pocketed villager or you're being a manipulative power wolf.
 
Aprilthearab said:
@samac where do you stand on your reads now?
Click to expand...
Honestly I’ve got to re-evaluate everything today. yesterday, I was convinced Zenge was going to flip wolf and I was going after AM next because I thought they were W/W. I’m not so sure anymore because I was so off base with Zenge and I’m going to have to look through her stuff.

let me finish my notes and if I don’t have any new admissions I’m spending the whole afternoon deep diving everyone that’s left.
 
Now that I'm more certain about AM wolfing, I'm moving Samac out of the POE because I don't think they're compatible. Genny is still in the clear for now. I have doggo and AM as incompatible in my notes (@vetschoolsletmeinplease would be proud, I'm actually trying to take notes this game) but can't remember why off the top of my head.

Leaves Dubz, barks, dina, mkg. Nothing's struck me wolfy about dina and I think mkg is village too. Don't want to go after dubz today, maybe tomorrow if we flip a wolf. Barks would be my preference if not AM. Willing to discuss but I have to work right now.
 
Aprilthearab said:
Y'all
If I was a wolf
Why would I rather let myself die
Than to make a tie that would kill myself AND a villager
That makes no sense for a wolf to do
Click to expand...
#1 We don't know the tie rules. It could have just killed you alone.
#2 That never happened in the final minutes.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

supershorty
GGoats ThWWee: Here It GGoats Again - GAME THREAD
93 94 95 96 97
Replies
5K
Views
54K
vampyrica
vampyrica
supershorty
Here It GGOATS Again (GGOATS ThWWee) - Sign Up Thread - Sign Ups CLOSED
2
Replies
68
Views
3K
SARdoghandler
SARdoghandler
supershorty
SHWWENANIGOATS: The Unauthorized GGOATS Sequel - GAME THREAD
28 29 30 31 32
Replies
2K
Views
45K
sheltermed
sheltermed
WildZoo
SDN Fairgrounds - 10th Annual Noob WW Game
85 86 87 88 89
Replies
4K
Views
44K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
kaydubs
Melee WW Game Thread-April 2024
27 28 29 30 31
Replies
2K
Views
31K
Sandy Dikson
Sandy Dikson
Top