ok I have broken out the laptop to try and articulate why that post bugs me so much. I have to acknowledge that yes, that basic info was provided by KJQ, and PSV i believe did ask why they specifically thought a cop was among the visitors. its just the consolidation of that info. if I look at this from the perspective of you are a villager - you're doing the leg work for the wolves at that point with taking that next step of thought on thread. yeah, a good wolf will think those things, but dont do it for them. and no, I dont think there are 3 noobs in a pack, but there are noobs in my POE, and we already have clem out. that's max 2 wolves left, heck if there is a 3p out there it is a very real possibility that it is just 1 wolf. and if its a noob yes that is helping them. if its someone who isn't reading thread carefully and skipping around, yes its helping them, if its someone who is starting to read thread and not going to backread, yes its helping them. solving PRs is not our job as village, we are here to find wolves. and yes, we need to find each other as villagers but if we are doing it mechanically, and on thread, guess what, the wolves are just going to kill them as soon as we find them and we are back at square one. like, I dont ****ing care that people were sussing me earlier bc ya know what, having some sus on me keeps me alive in this situation and I can help find more wolves. if you are village, i am begging you to not fish for PR info, mechanically confirming someone is village, and 100% a valuable role at that, on thread is not a good long-term option for finding village. as for zenge's question of why would a wolf specifically post that - its to try and get more info. its fishing, and hoping for engagement with maybe more new info. and yeah, again sure PSV was in it earlier and its KJQ's flavor but like, this along with how she was asking me questions earlier about my role that would ONLY help wolves is not it. vampy also had an iffy post earlier but I think she backtracked it when she was warned that it was fishing. anyways thanks for coming to my ted talk i guess, cheers