Nor'east Ski WWeekend (Basics) - Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Members don't see this ad.
Skimble said:
I would recommend looking back at any game I’ve played in the last few months. How I played prior to clinics, and how I play now are very different, mostly due to time available in the day.

Also, I don’t like the way Mel switched off zig yesterday, and I’d be willing to vote there today.
Click to expand...

So it's NAI then?
 
WildZoo said:
Just got out of an exam so my brain is a little mushy and I can't really read words correctly, but...


Feels like a wolf extra shot. Not really seeing enough good reason for a village assassin to shoot genny.


And this makes me wonder about wolf seer, because I don't really see moose being a priority target otherwise.
Click to expand...
I thought that too but I don't see the wolves wanting to seer mpm n1... She had barely said anything
 
####lynch sporty####

I was wrong about Capri and snowy and was starting to get feels for Genny and was wrong there so I’m gonna switch it up completely.

She’s been pretty quiet. I feel like she was more vocal last time she wolfed, but she was definitely more vocal the last few games i remember her playing as village in.

I got called into work last night and the clinic has picked up a lot so I’m not sure I’ll be able to stay on top of the game and might end up asking for a sub depending on how today goes. Just wanted to let you guys know.
 
Animal Midwife said:
You only have two votes and I wasn't asking for a role reveal. What do you think of dolphin so far?
Click to expand...
I can read the tea leaves pretty well. I know when my time is coming.,,

The role reveal hurts no one, so I don’t see the harm.

I think Dolphin is a villager, but I that is just an impression, don’t have a lot of evidence one way or the other. Nothing she has said to me is vaguely suspicious.
 
WildZoo said:
Just got out of an exam so my brain is a little mushy and I can't really read words correctly, but...


Feels like a wolf extra shot. Not really seeing enough good reason for a village assassin to shoot genny.


And this makes me wonder about wolf seer, because I don't really see moose being a priority target otherwise.
Click to expand...
I could see that, both had pretty solid village leans imo
 
muttmanager said:
I put my thoughts on thread, that was the reasoning for that question and solidified my vote for me, if you want clarification ask. I feel like you're tunneling on me rn and if you're village I advise you to move on and actually wolf hunt.
Click to expand...
Spicy

Melchizedek said:
I'm fast approaching the point where I want to lynch you to crack that egg so I can stop tossing and turning at night over whether you're stalking about with your wolfy teeth or not.
Click to expand...
This made me giggle

Skimble said:
Did anyone say the bj kill was to make Capri look bad?
Click to expand...
Yeah dat was me. I said it could be wolves killed bj because she was suspicious of capri (if capri is wolf village wolf) or they killed bj to make capri look bad (if capri is wolf village). Never really decided one way or the other.

CoffeeQuestionMark said:
I thought that too but I don't see the wolves wanting to seer mpm n1... She had barely said anything
Click to expand...
Fair. I'm going to go look through her posts. Have a mild tinfoil brewing.

Edit: Hello, person rereading the thread. You'll notice I edited this post rather late. Well, you see, I'm an idiot, and realized I had corrected the wrong error when I edited it the first time. I am surprised no one questioned me on it. My only conclusion is that nobody reads my posts. This is probably wise.
 
Last edited:
StartingoverVet said:
I can read the tea leaves pretty well. I know when my time is coming.,,

The role reveal hurts no one, so I don’t see the harm.

I think Dolphin is a villager, but I that is just an impression, don’t have a lot of evidence one way or the other. Nothing she has said to me is vaguely suspicious.
Click to expand...

Well, if you're both villagers, it can actually be pretty dangerous in a game with conversion. Assuming they don't want to nightkill one of you to cut off the communication.
 
Animal Midwife said:
Well, if you're both villagers, it can actually be pretty dangerous in a game with conversion. Assuming they don't want to nightkill one of you to cut off the communication.
Click to expand...
I had forgotten about conversion. Why put this in my brain 😢
 
WildZoo said:
I had forgotten about conversion. Why put this in my brain 😢
Click to expand...

It's ok. Assuming this follows a similar protocol from Pippy's other games, we should have to worry about it for a bit.
 
Unofficial Day 3 Cat Skijoring is the New Dogsledding Lynch Tally

SOV (2) - AM, Mel
Dubz (1) - Zigzag
Sporty (1) - grebes

4/18 voting

Lynch closes at 10pm Eastern (approximately 12.5 hours)

h53srCZ.gif
 
The zig/capri wagons going back and forth at the beginning of the day is super fun. And then almost the same thing happens for a bit with capri and snowy.

Day 2 Lynch Tracker

capri (1) - dubz
snowy (1) - AM
zig (1) - skim
dubz (1) - zig
zig (2) - SOV
capri (2) - grebes
mpm (1) - dina
zig (3) - cheezit
capri (3) - killer
zig (4) - mpm
dubz (0) - zig
capri (4) - zig
mutts (1) - barks
grebes (1) - snowy
capri (3) - dubz
snowy (2) - dubz
coffee (1) - sporty
zig (3) - cheezit
SOV (1) - cheezit
snowy (3) - dolph
grebes (0) - snowy
capri (4) - snowy
snowy (4) - genny
capri (5) - mutts
zig (4) - capri
zig (3) - capri
snowy (5) - capri
capri (4) - zig
snowy (6) - zig
snowy (7) - coffee
snowy (6) - AM
SOV (2) - AM
snowy (5) - dubz
capri (5) - dubz
mutts (2) - MSU
capri (4) - dubz
snowy (6) - dubz


Day 1 Lynch Tracker

killer (1) - sobsob
grebes (1) - AM
cheezit (1) - skilary
AM (1) - capri
AM (2) - MSU
MSU (1) - barks
capri (1) - grebes
dubz (1) - sportsport
AM (3) - dubz
dubz (2) - killer
barks (1) - zig
Killer (0) - sobsob
cubs (1) - sobsob
sobsob (1) - cubs
cubs (2) - mpm
sobsob (0) - cubs
AM (2) - MSU
dubz (3) - SAR
zig (1) - cheez
AM (1) - dubz
barks (2) - dubz
sporty (1) - genny
cheez (2) - dolphin
barks (3) - mutts
cubs (3) - MJ
barks (4) - snowy
coffee? (1) - cubs
grebes (1) - AM
snowy (1) - AM
sporty (0) - genny
cubs (4) - genny
dubz (2) - SAR
coffee? (2) - SAR
coffee? (1) - cubs
barks (5) - cubs
dubz (3) - dina
dubz (2) - sport
coffee? (2) - sport
genny (1) - MSU
barks (4) - dubz
coffee (3) - dubz
mutts (1) - coffee
coffee (2) - dubz
snowy (2) - dubz
capri (2) - bj
barks (3) - mutts
capri (3) - mutts
snowy (1) - dubz
zig (2) - dubz
 
Random thoughts I had while compiling votes (sometimes I actually read things, sometimes I just skim)


Skimble - some echoing of my thoughts. I don't like it.
dolph - feels fairly villa based on posts
capri - i dunno, really could go either way here. lackadaisical attitude and the way that tie went has me leaning more villa though.


SnowshoeDog143 said:
Also what is a safe-wagon?
Click to expand...
directed at @MSUcvmHOPE who I forgot was playing, until i came across the whole jailing discussion again. not sure she ever answered but I could have missed it.
 
WildZoo said:
Random thoughts I had while compiling votes (sometimes I actually read things, sometimes I just skim)


Skimble - some echoing of my thoughts. I don't like it.
dolph - feels fairly villa based on posts
capri - i dunno, really could go either way here. lackadaisical attitude and the way that tie went has me leaning more villa though.



directed at @MSUcvmHOPE who I forgot was playing, until i came across the whole jailing discussion again. not sure she ever answered but I could have missed it.
Click to expand...
Ah nope forgot. I meant it as it seemed like joining an existing wagon that wasn't the main bandwagon. Seemed like a way to say yes I agree without drawing attention to yourself.

Side note, I have the day off, though I do have to be a productive adult, I will be going through the thread and providing input today.

Sent from my Pixel 2 using SDN mobile
 
ziggyandjazzy said:
So wtf how did they get two kills and how did they know that?
Click to expand...

How did they know what?

muttmanager said:
SAR flagging that she changed her mind about zig was weird bc reads change esp d1 reads - that's not wolfy imo
Click to expand...

I disagree. Wolves know who all the villagers are. Therefore they have to find and/or manufacture sketch to help push village lynche without having to worry about who actually is village or wolf. So, it is well within wolf possibility to read someone village one day and wolf another day because they can scent blood in the water and want to take advantage of it. Villagers can do this too, yes. However, I tend to find that villagers keep closer track of their reads and will usually justify them when they change. Clearly in this case it was not a wolf move, but I still would have liked to know from mpm what changed her feels as it wasn't really stated on thread.

Melchizedek said:
perfect example of good wolf hunting (even though it didn't pan out):
Click to expand...

Awwww shucks

grebes4lyfe said:
I was wrong about Capri and snowy and was starting to get feels for Genny and was wrong there so I’m gonna switch it up completely.
Click to expand...

??? How were you wrong about Capri?
 
I'd be happy with a mutts or dubs lynch today I think
 
SARdoghandler said:
How did they know what?



I disagree. Wolves know who all the villagers are. Therefore they have to find and/or manufacture sketch to help push village lynche without having to worry about who actually is village or wolf. So, it is well within wolf possibility to read someone village one day and wolf another day because they can scent blood in the water and want to take advantage of it. Villagers can do this too, yes. However, I tend to find that villagers keep closer track of their reads and will usually justify them when they change. Clearly in this case it was not a wolf move, but I still would have liked to know from mpm what changed her feels as it wasn't really stated on thread.



Awwww shucks



??? How were you wrong about Capri?
Click to expand...
I was wondering how they knew mpm was tracker. I mean they may or may not have known but it feels like a weird kill otherwise I guess
 
Day 3 Cat Skijoring is the New Dogsledding Lynch Tally

SOV (2) - AM, Mel
Dubz (1) - Zigzag
Sporty (2) - grebes, Dubz

5/18 voting

Lynch closes at 10pm Eastern (approximately 10 hours)

h53srCZ.gif
 
Lawper said:
Day 3 Cat Skijoring is the New Dogsledding Lynch Tally

SOV (2) - AM, Mel
Dubz (1) - Zigzag
Sporty (2) - grebes, Dubz

5/18 voting

Lynch closes at 10pm Eastern (approximately 10 hours)

h53srCZ.gif
Click to expand...
Having seen this GIF alone makes me feel like having played was worthwhile. If I am lynched, I am content.
 
Animal Midwife said:
How do you feel above the Skim votes?
Click to expand...
I will go back to her at lunch but as far as there being a good case there hasnt been one that I've seen, other than just to get her to post more, which is fine.

I'm more interested in the reasons these wagons are starting.
Why are you so inclined to follow Mel on SOV?
 
CoffeeQuestionMark said:
I will go back to her at lunch but as far as there being a good case there hasnt been one that I've seen, other than just to get her to post more, which is fine.

I'm more interested in the reasons these wagons are starting.
Why are you so inclined to follow Mel on SOV?
Click to expand...

So who are you suspecting at this point? Why wouldn't I be inclined?
 
SARdoghandler said:
How did they know what?



I disagree. Wolves know who all the villagers are. Therefore they have to find and/or manufacture sketch to help push village lynche without having to worry about who actually is village or wolf. So, it is well within wolf possibility to read someone village one day and wolf another day because they can scent blood in the water and want to take advantage of it. Villagers can do this too, yes. However, I tend to find that villagers keep closer track of their reads and will usually justify them when they change. Clearly in this case it was not a wolf move, but I still would have liked to know from mpm what changed her feels as it wasn't really stated on thread.



Awwww shucks



??? How were you wrong about Capri?
Click to expand...
Not sure if this poor logic is due to ignorance or trying to misguide.
No self respecting wolf has anything to do with starting anything at the beginning of the game, they just try to skirt by. Villagers are gonna lynch themselves, all you do as a wolf is let them do the heavy lifting. If anything, throw out a lynch vote on fellow wolf for CRED, even better start a lynch vote for a good reason on a fellow wolf, and best get them lynched.

Why you would think any wolf is involved in any of these wrong lynches is nonsensical IMO.

Later in game is when vote analysis might be helpful IF wolves are desperate.
 
StartingoverVet said:
Not sure if this poor logic is due to ignorance or trying to misguide.
No self respecting wolf has anything to do with starting anything at the beginning of the game, they just try to skirt by. Villagers are gonna lynch themselves, all you do as a wolf is let them do the heavy lifting. If anything, throw out a lynch vote on fellow wolf for CRED, even better start a lynch vote for a good reason on a fellow wolf, and best get them lynched.

Why you would think any wolf is involved in any of these wrong lynches is nonsensical IMO.

Later in game is when vote analysis might be helpful IF wolves are desperate.
Click to expand...

Just because my logic doesn't line up with yours doesn't make it poor.

You are misunderstanding my argument. It has nothing to do with votes and where votes are placed. It has to do with where people put others on their reads. It's easy to manufacture sketch and look like a contributing villager through these.

You can dislike my logic, but I've caught a lot of wolves using similar, small tells and vote analysis from Day 1. :shrug:
 
StartingoverVet said:
Not sure if this poor logic is due to ignorance or trying to misguide.
No self respecting wolf has anything to do with starting anything at the beginning of the game, they just try to skirt by. Villagers are gonna lynch themselves, all you do as a wolf is let them do the heavy lifting. If anything, throw out a lynch vote on fellow wolf for CRED, even better start a lynch vote for a good reason on a fellow wolf, and best get them lynched.

Why you would think any wolf is involved in any of these wrong lynches is nonsensical IMO.

Later in game is when vote analysis might be helpful IF wolves are desperate.
Click to expand...

I feel like this is probably an individualistic posting style thing. I'm actually more inclined to lynch followers than those leading the lynch/lurking just because it looks better.
 
Animal Midwife said:
How do you feel about Skim who has a similar number of posts?
Click to expand...
50% more posts (which is misleading due to small #s).
There is a little bit of attempt at making villager help
Some fluff.
Some general statements that prove nothing, and a question that wolves probably would know,
A wasted vote and a missed vote,

All in all, not a great resume there, but not as bad as killer. Worth watching but not a compelling choice right now.
 
Next I am going to look at zig and Capri.

2 trends I often find. When people are leading and the choices completely change, sometimes that is because one or more wolves was in the original choices.

The other one which always amazes me is that often when it comes down to 2 people, a villager is lynched and somehow the village gets distracted and doesn’t come back to the person who wasn’t lynched. I don’t know why, but that person is often a wolf.

These are just general observations to give me places to look, no comment YETon current players involved here. Just trying to get all my thoughts out in case,as it appears, I may be today’s victim.
 
StartingoverVet said:
Next I am going to look at zig and Capri.

2 trends I often find. When people are leading and the choices completely change, sometimes that is because one or more wolves was in the original choices.

The other one which always amazes me is that often when it comes down to 2 people, a villager is lynched and somehow the village gets distracted and doesn’t come back to the person who wasn’t lynched. I don’t know why, but that person is often a wolf.

These are just general observations to give me places to look, no comment YETon current players involved here. Just trying to get all my thoughts out in case,as it appears, I may be today’s victim.
Click to expand...
Meh. Not enamored with either those as wolf choices right now, zig talks an awful lot, and that would be pretty good play for a wolf. I assume zig hasn’t played a ton of games from the posting, and if so seems like a poor choice, just says too much stuff that could get them in trouble

Capri leaves less of an impression, but seems like a normal mix.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
52K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
38K
Clem J
Clem J
supershorty
GGoats ThWWee: Here It GGoats Again - GAME THREAD
93 94 95 96 97
Replies
5K
Views
52K
vampyrica
vampyrica
Animal Midwife
Matrix - Game Thread
77 78 79 80 81
Replies
4K
Views
87K
samac
samac
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
PokeWWon: A Wild Kanto Adventure - Champs Season 12 Practice Game Thread
87 88 89 90 91
Replies
5K
Views
56K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
Top