m0larm0lar
Full Member
- Joined
- Sep 22, 2023
- Messages
- 11
- Reaction score
- 0
How many letters of recommendation are we able to submit on our application for DA? And do they need to be DA's or can they also be other professors/dentists? Thank you!
Some programs require 1-2 letters from DAs and some highly recommend you have letter(s) from DAs… It’s always a good thing to find some DAs to shadow and learn more about the profession in general and from their experience, and then go from there.How many letters of recommendation are we able to submit on our application for DA? And do they need to be DA's or can they also be other professors/dentists? Thank you!
Interesting question actually. I'd say most like it, or are neutral. Some are actually against it a bit because it counts as a PGY1 year which means if you get in their program you'd technically be a PGY2 and they have to pay you more. It's not much more but I've heard it can throw off the funding. I would recommend you reach out to each program you are interested in and ask them directly.Do programs generally prefer if applicants have a GPR/AEGD as opposed to coming straight from dental school?
Sounds like a great opportunity, but yes comes at a price. I believe there also might be a anesthesia-focused internship at Indiana. It also seems like some of the OS intern programs are trying to push that you'll get anesthesia experience if that don't fill their spots. I'm not sure how much these things will help your application, but worth asking!Any thoughts about the DA internship at UoP? I’m sure it’d boost my chance, I don’t know if I can survive living in San Francisco with $64k while having to pay $1000 towards my loan each month
Oh is this a new internship program? I've never heard of DA internships before, only heard of OMFS internships. 64k will barely cover living expenses. Would that be sorta "guaranteed" entry into DA at UoP?Any thoughts about the DA internship at UoP? I’m sure it’d boost my chance, I don’t know if I can survive living in San Francisco with $64k while having to pay $1000 towards my loan each month
The Indiana anesthesia internship no longer existsSounds like a great opportunity, but yes comes at a price. I believe there also might be an anesthesia-focused internship at Indiana. It also seems like some of the OS intern programs are trying to push that you'll get anesthesia experience if that don't fill their spots. I'm not sure how much these things will help your application, but worth asking!
UoP doesn’t have a DA programOh is this a new internship program? I've never heard of DA internships before, only heard of OMFS internships. 64k will barely cover living expenses. Would that be sorta "guaranteed" entry into DA at UoP?
Can't seem to comprehend the logic behind this if they're still planning on taking residents in post match. Does anyone know the reason?So UNLV dropped out of the match - they are doing post match now
UNLV already sent out interview invitations. Does this mean they are doing interviews after Nov 22nd? or are they starting all over again after nov 22nd?So in total it looks like:
Jacobi decisions (5): notification 09/17, virtual interview 10/28-29
UNLV decisions (3): notification 09/22-10/3, virtual or in-person 11/6
* Withdrew from the MATCH (notified via email 10/23/24) and will be conducting interview invitations following November 22nd
Pitt decisions (4): notification 10/2, virtual interview 10/25
NYU decisions (6): Phone call 10/7, in-person interview 10/29-30
UoT decisions (2): 10/7; interview 11/4
Stony Brook decisions (4): notification 10/8, virtual interview 10/31-11/1
Wykoff decisions (2): notification 10/8; in-person 11/13
St. Barnabas decisions (4): notification 10/14; in-person interview 11/4
OSU decisions (2): notification 10/15; virtual interview 11/12
Masonic decisions (2): notification 10/15
Starting over fresh. Whatever that looks like is to be determined. They haven’t shared whether they will go through ADEA or have an application that is independent just that applicants that previously were given an interview will be in consideration again should they not match. 😕UNLV already sent out interview invitations. Does this mean they are doing interviews after Nov 22nd? or are they starting all over again after nov 22nd?
Do you have more accurate info by any chance? or know of a place I can collect more info from?Current resident here. There is A LOT of misinformation in this thread about application numbers, process, CBSE scores, etc. from people who are just purely speculating without any basis for their information. So if you're reading through this thread, don't let anything you read influence you or prevent you from applying if you're interested in this field. You have to be in it to win it.
There’s no place where you can collect more info from. The CBSE has only been a requirement for 3 application cycles (including this one). It is still very new and thus some programs aren’t sure how much value or weight to place on it. You can match with good numbers. You can match with not so good numbers. Don’t be discouraged. If you’re truly interested, put your application out there because you never know!Do you have more accurate info by any chance? or know of a place I can collect more info from?
Having said that, you should try your best to score well. I also think if you score low, you should be committed enough to retake it. It shows you are committed to anesthesia and you didn’t just take it on a whim to check a box off for your applicationThere’s no place where you can collect more info from. The CBSE has only been a requirement for 3 application cycles (including this one). It is still very new and thus some programs aren’t sure how much value or weight to place on it. You can match with good numbers. You can match with not so good numbers. Don’t be discouraged. If you’re truly interested, put your application out there because you never know!
what is post match ?So UNLV dropped out of the match - they are doing post match now
what is post match ?
What was the CBSE score you matched with?Some points of clarification
1. CBSE - scores are going up each year. There was a time when one could get into OMFS with a 40. Those days are gone. If NYU and Jacobi (Einstein) have tuition free medical school for their OMFS residents, what kind of scores do you think their OMFS candidates are achieving? Should dentist anesthesiologists be held to a lower standard? If putting in the time to study now is a deterrent, then residency is not for you.
2. Letters of rec - letters should come from people who have taught, supervised, and critiqued you. A dean's letter is a must. If you did a GPR or prior residency, that director must provide a letter. A group/practice leader in dental school for D4s is a must. These are the people who can give directors insights as to how you deal with criticism, maturity, bedside manner, team player, and are you teachable. Getting a big name DA doesn't mean much. Red flags are when your friend, colleague, etc writes you a letter. (Letters from a non-medical reference should only come if they demonstrate your qualities from a commitment or experience that was of significance in your life in scope and duration.) Letters from faculty/attendings who have been research mentors are nice too. 4 letters from different DAs that one shadowed for a handful of days are not going to provide meaningful insights and directors see through that. Some are too sweet to say no you a letter request but don't have anything substantive to say. A letter from a DA should come only with significant shadowing.
3. OMFS internships are not a great idea. In NY state you need to complete a GPR to do an OMFS internship. In other states, just do the GPR/AEGD. The GPR gives you a month of ED/Anesthesia. Also shows you have good judgement to improve your skills all around as a dentist should you not match. Some programs will also offer a GPR2 to the right candidate in which the second year GPR is getting extra time in the OR. The OMFS internship is doing scut work for OMFS and if they're a good little soldier maybe they will get to retract a 12 hour case or do a sedation or two. Unless they give you a plan, in writing, with some regular OR time with anesthesia, it is not worth it.
4. Cast a wide net. It is a big red flag when candidates apply to a few programs. The best program is the one you match in, so don't look down your nose at any place. Go see it for yourself. Not every program requires a GPR. It may be encouraged, but you have nothing to lose by externing and seeing the place for yourself.
Group/practice leader isn’t a must for some programs, neither is a dean’s letter. I agree with most everything else, I also think that doing an OMFS internship creates an appearance that anesthesia is a backup, whether that is the reality or not.Some points of clarification
1. CBSE - scores are going up each year. There was a time when one could get into OMFS with a 40. Those days are gone. If NYU and Jacobi (Einstein) have tuition free medical school for their OMFS residents, what kind of scores do you think their OMFS candidates are achieving? Should dentist anesthesiologists be held to a lower standard? If putting in the time to study now is a deterrent, then residency is not for you.
2. Letters of rec - letters should come from people who have taught, supervised, and critiqued you. A dean's letter is a must. If you did a GPR or prior residency, that director must provide a letter. A group/practice leader in dental school for D4s is a must. These are the people who can give directors insights as to how you deal with criticism, maturity, bedside manner, team player, and are you teachable. Getting a big name DA doesn't mean much. Red flags are when your friend, colleague, etc writes you a letter. (Letters from a non-medical reference should only come if they demonstrate your qualities from a commitment or experience that was of significance in your life in scope and duration.) Letters from faculty/attendings who have been research mentors are nice too. 4 letters from different DAs that one shadowed for a handful of days are not going to provide meaningful insights and directors see through that. Some are too sweet to say no you a letter request but don't have anything substantive to say. A letter from a DA should come only with significant shadowing.
3. OMFS internships are not a great idea. In NY state you need to complete a GPR to do an OMFS internship. In other states, just do the GPR/AEGD. The GPR gives you a month of ED/Anesthesia. Also shows you have good judgement to improve your skills all around as a dentist should you not match. Some programs will also offer a GPR2 to the right candidate in which the second year GPR is getting extra time in the OR. The OMFS internship is doing scut work for OMFS and if they're a good little soldier maybe they will get to retract a 12 hour case or do a sedation or two. Unless they give you a plan, in writing, with some regular OR time with anesthesia, it is not worth it.
4. Cast a wide net. It is a big red flag when candidates apply to a few programs. The best program is the one you match in, so don't look down your nose at any place. Go see it for yourself. Not every program requires a GPR. It may be encouraged, but you have nothing to lose by externing and seeing the place for yourself.
An institutional evaluation form (IEF) is the deans letter. Just curious, which program told you they won't need an IEF?Group/practice leader isn’t a must for some programs, neither is a dean’s letter. I agree with most everything else, I also think that doing an OMFS internship creates an appearance that anesthesia is a backup, whether that is the reality or not.
Oh I misunderstood. I thought it was meant an additional letter of rec from the dean. I’ve always known it as the IEFAn institutional evaluation form (IEF) is the deans letter. Just curious, which program told you they won't need an IEF?
Yes, I’m not sure what program treesandsteeps is at, but mine could care less what your dental faculty has to say about you. A letter from a DA weighs heaviest. I also haven’t seen a trend of increasing CBSE scores. I’m sure they will steadily climb, but it’s definitely not there yet. People match with low scores across ALL programs. That being said, truly do your best to put yourself in the best position. There are some PDs that see the CBSE as the great equalizer since some schools are P/F and others inflate grades.Group/practice leader isn’t a must for some programs, neither is a dean’s letter. I agree with most everything else, I also think that doing an OMFS internship creates an appearance that anesthesia is a backup, whether that is the reality or not.
Nah, that’s no longer a thing. It helps if you can show a commitment to the field by doing IV placements, intubations, etc. during your GPR but Wykoff and St. B dropped that requirement last year or the year before.Does anyone know which programs require a GPR before enrolling in the program? is it just a few schools or majority?
It seems like these are still on their website as requirements. like St. B's requirement is GPR or AEGD or 2 years of post-doctoral experience Dental Anesthesiology Residency Program - SBH Health System . These are now dropped?Nah, that’s no longer a thing. It helps if you can show a commitment to the field by doing IV placements, intubations, etc. during your GPR but Wykoff and St. B dropped that requirement last year or the year before.
No one has ever asked me about my research or publications during interviews or externships, but mine was more general dental focused. I imagine if you were to do some anesthesia focused research that it would be well received, but you may have to highlight it during interviews or in your personal statement. With programs now having a research and publishing component, it would be good to have some prior experience.How important is research/publications to schools? Do they prefer a certain # of publications etc?
According to my last cycle yes. This is my second round of applying to DA and that’s what I was told last year.It seems like these are still on their website as requirements. like St. B's requirement is GPR or AEGD or 2 years of post-doctoral experience Dental Anesthesiology Residency Program - SBH Health System . These are now dropped?
Thank you!According to my last cycle yes. This is my second round of applying to DA and that’s what I was told last year.
UNLV wasn’t supposed to be in the match? What happened?Emails went out around 9am EST. Matched with UNLV!
They were able to rectify the situation faster than expected and sent out an email that they would be able to be in the match. Perhaps it was sent out to just the applicants they intended to interview initially.UNLV wasn’t supposed to be in the match? What happened?
When did they sent the email they’d be reentering the match?They were able to rectify the situation faster than expected and sent out an email that they would be able to be in the match. Perhaps it was sent out to just the applicants they intended to interview initially.
They sent it the 13th.When did they sent the email they’d be reentering the match?
Wasn’t that two days before rank lists were due? I’m assuming they already held interviews then? Very strange….They sent it the 13th.
You are correct. It was two days before the list was due but they did not hold any interviews. The interviews were scheduled for Nov 7th and due to them pulling out they could not have them. They informed their top candidates via email that they were back in the matchWasn’t that two days before rank lists were due? I’m assuming they already held interviews then? Very strange….