Once Upon A Time WW Game Thread

[Minnerbelle]

---

Members don't see this ad.

I'm still suspicious of NStarz being resurrected as a wolf. She is apparently no longer a seer. And we were thinking that it would be helpful to have Henry back so that we can all believe in magic again. But has anything changed in the day/night cycle that makes us think that is the case (as in, something beneficial has happened for the villagers)?

If you have any info, you don't have to spill it on the forum, but just say you wouldn't recommend lynching NStarz and I'll change my vote.

Otherwise, lynch NStarz

 

[that redhead]

I find it hard to believe that Henry, who seems to be a very central/important character has been resurrected as bad or as another character. Her abilities may have changed but that doesn't mean her actual role has changed.

 

[bbeventer]

Guess I'm going to lynch devyn for trying to make me reveal sources.

 

[DVMDream]

I'm still suspicious of NStarz being resurrected as a wolf. She is apparently no longer a seer. And we were thinking that it would be helpful to have Henry back so that we can all believe in magic again. But has anything changed in the day/night cycle that makes us think that is the case (as in, something beneficial has happened for the villagers)?

If you have any info, you don't have to spill it on the forum, but just say you wouldn't recommend lynching NStarz and I'll change my vote.

Otherwise, lynch NStarz

I think it is quite risky to lynch the central character in the show. The character that believes above everything else that, "Good always wins." I am assuming there are still plenty of original wolves to be finding, maybe worry about conversions later and focus on the original we have yet to locate.

 

[thedrjojo]

I find it hard to believe that Henry, who seems to be a very central/important character has been resurrected as bad or as another character. Her abilities may have changed but that doesn't mean her actual role has changed.

often though, in WW games, someone is revived as a different character. I have no idea the means or mechanism in which the resurrection was specific to henry, or just a random resurrection.

 

[DVMDream]

Guess I'm going to lynch devyn for trying to make me reveal sources.

I have no idea of devyn's role or affiliation in this game. But I hardly saw that is making you reveal sources.

It was moreso asking how you can "vouch" for someone if you have claimed you are not 100% sure AND you have not been PMing with them. It doesn't add up.

 

[Minnerbelle]

okay then unlynch NStarz. I guess I just haven't played enough games. If I remember correctly, there were at least a couple where very important villagers were resurrected as wolves in the past.

 

[StartingoverVet]

I'm still suspicious of NStarz being resurrected as a wolf. She is apparently no longer a seer. And we were thinking that it would be helpful to have Henry back so that we can all believe in magic again. But has anything changed in the day/night cycle that makes us think that is the case (as in, something beneficial has happened for the villagers)?

If you have any info, you don't have to spill it on the forum, but just say you wouldn't recommend lynching NStarz and I'll change my vote.

Otherwise, lynch NStarz

I think those are fair points but agree with DVMD that it is too early to worry about this right now. Let's find Cora and Regina, etc. and then worry about conversions.

 

[that redhead]

I think those are fair points but agree with DVMD that it is too early to worry about this right now. Let's find Cora and Regina, etc. and then worry about conversions.

👍

 

[Minnerbelle]

I think those are fair points but agree with DVMD that it is too early to worry about this right now. Let's find Cora and Regina, etc. and then worry about conversions.

fair enough. I just dunno who else i'm suspicious of at the moment, so i'll have to go back and read through and see if my suspicion radar goes up

 

[StartingoverVet]

I think those are fair points but agree with DVMD that it is too early to worry about this right now. Let's find Cora and Regina, etc. and then worry about conversions.

And if someone good resurrected Nstarz, it would be nice if you could somehow get that info disseminated. Usually resurrectors can only do it once, so they usually let the thread know. The fact that no one has claimed responsibility does make it more fishy, but still think it is too early to worry about.

No role is kind of strange and fishy though.

 

[Minnerbelle]

And if someone good resurrected Nstarz, it would be nice if you could somehow get that info disseminated. Usually resurrectors can only do it once, so they usually let the thread know. The fact that no one has claimed responsibility does make it more fishy, but still think it is too early to worry about.

No role is kind of strange and fishy though.

yeah... something just doesn't sit well with me about the whole thing. but i do agree we have bigger fish to try at the moment. i just read back in the thread that Nstarz asked not to be lynched today because she wasn't going to be here, so there's no reason to rush into it either.

 

[Escalla]

Tallying things up.

 

[wolfspeaker]

I hate it when people say they can vouch for a player, when really they only think that player is a villager. Vouching should be done only for someone you are linked with, or has been investigated. Otherwise, state that you believe them to be a villager, and do not "vouch" for them. 👎

 

[devyn]

Guess I'm going to lynch devyn for trying to make me reveal sources.

I have no idea of devyn's role or affiliation in this game. But I hardly saw that is making you reveal sources.

It was moreso asking how you can "vouch" for someone if you have claimed you are not 100% sure AND you have not been PMing with them. It doesn't add up.

👍 what DVM said.... I was in no way asking you to reveal any source of info.... as can be clear from what I wrote... I was merely trying to ascertain how you can say you think someone is a villager if you have had no contact with them and have not investigated them... seems a bit fishy....

And if someone good resurrected Nstarz, it would be nice if you could somehow get that info disseminated. Usually resurrectors can only do it once, so they usually let the thread know. The fact that no one has claimed responsibility does make it more fishy, but still think it is too early to worry about.

No role is kind of strange and fishy though.

I have it on good authority NStarz was brought back by a good role.... and brought back in hopes that they would still be Henry.... to assist a villager win....

 

[Minnerbelle]

I can't be 100% sure, but I believe Jam is a villager.

Who says I talked to her in a PM?

So then what makes you think Jam is a villager? Was this through a PM with another player? And is that person trustworthy?

Or is it from things said in the thread itself? If that's the case, can you share your reasoning?

 

[Minnerbelle]

I have it on good authority NStarz was brought back by a good role.... and brought back in hopes that they would still be Henry.... to assist a villager win....

Thanks for clarifying that. That's really helpful

 

[Escalla]

Current lynch tally:
SOV 1 - LIS
bbeventer 3 - EC, Alors, Dwin
Alors 1 - Hedgie
Fancy 1 - tuckervet
Allie 1 - TRH
Lupin 0
FH 6 - DVMD, FF, Fancy, dyachei, allie, wld
Jam 0
Wildcat 2 - NStarz, SnS
Swings 2 - devyn, SOV
NStarz 0
devyn 1 - bbeventer

Waffles: 9

18 votes in, 8 votes missing. Deadline 4 PM EST.

 

[bbeventer]

Well, awhile back I asked if we thought any evil characters had any pairs, I could remember any famous duos, and it doesn't seem like there are any. Night 1, I was allowed to follow someone, I followed Jam and she was looking for someone. That's all I know. Since, Night 1 lots of people were searching for their pairs, I took that to mean she must be a villager. Like I said though, not 100%.

 

[wolfspeaker]

Almost forgot to vote!

Lynch FH

 

[wildcatj]

Going to stick with my vote from yesterday (or at least I think it was yesterday...)

Lynch Alors

 

[bbeventer]

Well, awhile back I asked if we thought any evil characters had any pairs, I could remember any famous duos, and it doesn't seem like there are any. Night 1, I was allowed to follow someone, I followed Jam and she was looking for someone. That's all I know. Since, Night 1 lots of people were searching for their pairs, I took that to mean she must be a villager. Like I said though, not 100%.

^ supposed to say couldn't remember any famous duos.

 

[Minnerbelle]

Well, awhile back I asked if we thought any evil characters had any pairs, I could remember any famous duos, and it doesn't seem like there are any. Night 1, I was allowed to follow someone, I followed Jam and she was looking for someone. That's all I know. Since, Night 1 lots of people were searching for their pairs, I took that to mean she must be a villager. Like I said though, not 100%.

okays, so this is just based on the fact that she was looking for someone.
as far as i'm aware, we haven't established that only villagers have pairs... so that might not mean anything.

oh hells, at this point i can't think of anyone better to lynch, so i'm going to bandwagon onto lynch FH

 

[that redhead]

Since FH is likely to get mod killed from inactivity, I'll change my vote so that hopefully we minimize our losses.

unlynch allie
lynch FH

 

[wolfspeaker]

To Hedgie and wildcat,
Rojo said this a few pages back.

Don't lynch Alors. Not Hook and I believe to be a villager.

[

 

[Escalla]

Current lynch tally:
SOV 1 - LIS
bbeventer 3 - EC, Alors, Dwin
Alors 2 - Hedgie, wildcat
Fancy 1 - tuckervet
Allie 0
Lupin 0
FH 9 - DVMD, FF, Fancy, dyachei, allie, wld, WS, Minnerbelle, TRH
Jam 0
Wildcat 2 - NStarz, SnS
Swings 2 - devyn, SOV
NStarz 0
devyn 1 - bbeventer

Waffles: 11

21 votes in, 5 votes missing. Deadline 4 PM EST.

 

[Escalla]

And mods, you told me in PM that I'd be voting for SOV because the shadow swiped my vote.... but I'm not showing up in the lynch counting. Whassupwiththat?

I wasn't sure if you had wanted to post it yourself when I tallied earlier this morning, so I left it off. It wasn't forgotten, no worries. 🙂

 

[thedrjojo]

^ supposed to say couldn't remember any famous duos.

i call bs on this, as I thought we said many evil people could be looking, although it would be a bit of a weird wolf mechanic... Regina could be looking for Cora or Henry or any number of people... Rump could have been looking for Belle or his son... Sydney could be looking for Regina... Tamara and Greg were looking for each other according to FFM... Hook was looking for someone according to FS (but never told me whom they were looking for)... so, just cause Jam was looking for someone, doesn't absolve them in the least IMO...

 

[thedrjojo]

I hate it when people say they can vouch for a player, when really they only think that player is a villager. Vouching should be done only for someone you are linked with, or has been investigated. Otherwise, state that you believe them to be a villager, and do not "vouch" for them. 👎

hence why I choose my words wisely... there is essentially 1 person in this game I can truthfully vouch for, and others I can do as I have been doing, such as with you where I know someone else who is willing to vouch for you... the same reasoning applies to Alors...

 

[thedrjojo]

And more importantly, would any of them outside of storybrooke be a wolf? Tamara is dead and doesn't matter. But what about Greg, Pinnochio, or Neal?

The anonymous message I got last night claimed that a specific player is from outside Storybrooke. I don't know what to do with the information, though, because I don't know if it's actionable.

I think the odds this person is wolf/villager is the same odds as a person picked at random is a wolf/villager (cause if we have 5 ppl or so that this could be, and if 1 of them is a wolf, that's 1/5 or 20% chance of wolf... and the usual ratio of wolves to villagers is around 20%, although who knows what is usual about this game or not) then i dunno if it gives us anything.

 

[wildcatj]

To Hedgie and wildcat,
Rojo said this a few pages back.

That must have been part of what I skimmed.
Unlynch Alors, lynch FH since she's likely to be mod killed anyways.

 

[StartingoverVet]

I have it on good authority NStarz was brought back by a good role.... and brought back in hopes that they would still be Henry.... to assist a villager win....

Great.
One less thing to obsess about.

 

[tuckervet]

unlynch fancy, lynch FH

 

[Lupin21]

i call bs on this, as I thought we said many evil people could be looking, although it would be a bit of a weird wolf mechanic... Regina could be looking for Cora or Henry or any number of people... Rump could have been looking for Belle or his son... Sydney could be looking for Regina... Tamara and Greg were looking for each other according to FFM... Hook was looking for someone according to FS (but never told me whom they were looking for)... so, just cause Jam was looking for someone, doesn't absolve them in the least IMO...

I have to agree. I would not jump to the conclusion that Jam is probably a villager based off the fact she was looking for someone.

I don't have any clue who to vote for. I hate voting for FH for lack of participation. We lost Grumpy that way. It doesn't matter anyhow now thought

lynch FH

 

[Escalla]

Voting closed, results pending

 

[Escalla]

Final lynch tally:
SOV 1 - LIS
bbeventer 3 - EC, Alors, Dwin
Alors 1 - Hedgie
Fancy 0
Allie 0
Lupin 0
FH 12 - DVMD, FF, Fancy, dyachei, allie, wld, WS, Minnerbelle, TRH, wildcat, tuckervet, Lupin
Jam 0
Wildcat 2 - NStarz, SnS
Swings 2 - devyn, SOV
NStarz 0
devyn 1 - bbeventer

 

[kaydubs]

A bandwagon forms for bbe first, then FH.

Good thing the players killed her so the mods didn't have to.

FH- Red Riding Hood/Ruby is dead.

It is now Night 6. Night deadline of 10 PM EST. We're gonna try & move this game along this weekend. Aiming for 2 lynch cycles tomorrow. Hopefully: 10 am EST for Day 7 end. Night deadline of....2 PM? and lynch again at 10 pm. (We're trying to crunch through since Escalla will be leaving July 15th).

There are 26 players remaining.

Clock Tower
1. Rojo
3. dyachei
5. Alors
6. Dwin
8. cuit

Mary Margaret's Apartment
2. Jamr0ckin
3. Allie
4. FantasyFlyer
5. Hedgie
6. Tuckervet
7. bbeventer

Sheriff's Department
2. that redhead
5. Minnerbelle
6. The LIS
7. devyn
8. NStarz

Granny's Diner
1. Lupin21
2. Swings
3. WS
6. Fancy

Mr. Gold's Pawn & Antiques Shop
1.SnS
2. Wildcatj
3. DVM
4.wldlfstdnt
5. equineconstant
6. SOV

Cemetery kayd:
Lissarae06 - Grumpy/Leroy
FFM - Tamara
nohika - Belle/Lacey
SV88 - Mad Hatter/Jefferson
Frozenshades - Captain Killian "Hook" Jones
FH - Red Riding Hood/Ruby

 

[that redhead]

Dangit, FH.

 

[wildcatj]

This is getting old real fast...

 

[DVMDream]

Dangit, FH.

Seriously.

So frustrating. Ugh.

 

[wolfspeaker]

🙁 Would have been nice if she would have PM'ed me and confided in me. Or, you know, sent in contingencies so you wouldn't be mod-killed. 🙄 Not that hard to send in a few days worth of Lynch contingencies just in case. You can always change them, if you do get a chance to come on and vote.

What if FFM and FS really weren't wolves. (but possibly their own win condition) Maybe lump Greg in there, possibly Gold? They were all out for themselves, pretty much, in the show.

Reading back through the thread(just now) on the Hook discussion, it really wasn't that hard to deduce who Hook could possibly have been. So, I could see it not being a coincidence.

Cora and King George really couldn't be anything but wolves IMO. Add in possibly Genie and Peter Pan, that's a good start to a wolf group.

Not sure where to put Regina. Maybe easily converted?

 

[tuckervet]

Has someone already mentioned James, Charming's twin brother? I think he seems like a pretty straight-forward bad guy

 

[wolfspeaker]

Has someone already mentioned James, Charming's twin brother? I think he seems like a pretty straight-forward bad guy

He's only in 1 episode(I think) and then dies. So, I'm not sure he's in the game.

 

[devyn]

For fecks sake FH! 😡

TBH I am all for a ban on players signing up for at least a few games when they have multiple "FH Rule" violations (the rule is named after her for a reason)..... this has happened way too many times especially with her.... if you are not able to participate a few times a day do not sign up... simple as that...

This is not said to be mean, but it takes away from the game when players are absent continuously.... and it is not fair to the mods either....

 

[thedrjojo]

He's only in 1 episode(I think) and then dies. So, I'm not sure he's in the game.

I thought the one known to Snow White, was James (if you follow the crazy order, the guy who meets Snow White, who claims to be named James, occurred AFTER the real prince died and after he killed the dragon, was engaged to Midas's daughter, etc...) and yeah, I doubt that the original prince that is killed by the giant in Midas's kingdom is in the game...

and even if so, why would that one be evil? unless they show back up in season 2... but still, in that one episode, he was still a good guy... so unless I'm missing something, why are we concerned about this person?

Regina, i dunno. I don't see any way they aren't a wolf.

 

[that redhead]

Especially when her role with the cloak might have been really useful 🙁

 

[that redhead]

Also, whoever would like to send me the link to the show.... 🙂

 

[tuckervet]

I thought the one known to Snow White, was James (if you follow the crazy order, the guy who meets Snow White, who claims to be named James, occurred AFTER the real prince died and after he killed the dragon, was engaged to Midas's daughter, etc...) and yeah, I doubt that the original prince that is killed by the giant in Midas's kingdom is in the game...

and even if so, why would that one be evil? unless they show back up in season 2... but still, in that one episode, he was still a good guy... so unless I'm missing something, why are we concerned about this person?

Regina, i dunno. I don't see any way they aren't a wolf.

According too Wikipedia his affiliation is villain
http://onceuponatime.wikia.com/wiki/Prince_James_(Twin)

I agree his role was small, but I was trying to brainstorm characters that were not as ambiguous and I thought of him. I have no information that he is in this game, but I do think it is possible

 

[AlorsOnDanse]

According too Wikipedia his affiliation is villain
http://onceuponatime.wikia.com/wiki/Prince_James_(Twin)

I agree his role was small, but I was trying to brainstorm characters that were not as ambiguous and I thought of him. I have no information that he is in this game, but I do think it is possible

Of all the characters to choose I wouldn't think the mods would choose it, but you never know!

 

[Jamr0ckin]

Just now caught up. Today was crazy at work, I ate lunch standing up and on the go, and never had a chance to check SDN once. Sorry I missed the lynch vote.

I am a villager, and welcome investigation if someone thinks it necessary. I've not had a lot to say because I don't know the show, so can't comment on anything linking the show to the game.

About the hooded cloak, I was told by the mods it did not protect against the poison apple.